7 ms·
NFTs died a slow, painful death in 2023 as most are now worthless
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tekla 3y agoThe only thing good about NFTs was the free alcohol and other things I got at the parties. (I've never bought NFTs just got invited to parties and was curious. The parties generally sucked ass)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- CPLX 3y agoIt’s far more likely that almost nobody ever cared about these things at all, and that nearly the entire thing was wash trading and market manipulation. Of course there were some marks mixed in somewhere, by definition, but the premise that there was ever real demand for this from anyone is pretty dubious.
- kolinko 3y agoI like a comparison of NFTs to a casino. People care (cared) about the profit, and about their number winning, not necessarily about the number itself. Having said that, I recently finally saw an art project I actually think makes sense as an NFT. Don't remember its name, but it's artist selling actual rights to their works on an auction to people that want to invest in the pieces, people trading the art NFTs, with the art piece being stored securely, and then one day if someone wants the physical piece for themselves, they can burn the NFT to request it's delivery. Speaking of art, we did a project ~6 years ago, where we released ERC20 tokens attached to physical objects - imho this makes way more sense, because it allows for a fractional ownership of art/collectibles. Ideas like this make way more sense than NFTs.
- unclebucknasty 3y ago>finally saw an art project I actually think makes sense as an NFT I feel like the idea of NFTs representing some right of redemption or ownership in the physical world was a fairly common NFT scheme / use-case back in the day. Am I missing something?
- babelchips 3y agoYes that is the actual benefit of NFTs. It's happening.
- kolinko 3y agoI've been away from blockchain for the last 3 years, but from what I checked most NFTs claimed some vague attachement to a real world asset, but no actual connection. As in "here is an NFT attached to this art piece" -> "what rights does NFT actually give to you?" -> "well, sentimental rights"
- karmakurtisaani 3y agoIt certainly sounds like a great solution for a non-problem. Why would I ever want to buy this NFT instead of the actual artwork? I guess i could speculate with the value, which, who am I kidding, is basically the only non-criminal crypto use case.
- kolinko 3y agoIt is an actual case, a plenty of people want to buy an artwork but they don't want an actual piece in their possession - sometimes they want to just hold it for investment purposes, and sometimes they don't have the space yet, but they expect to have it sooner or later. That's why you have storage houses for artworks, and artists often sell their artworks to collectors but keep it in possession for years. Also people own artworks but "rent out" to galleries - which makes it a win-win, and a free storage for them :)
- crooked-v 3y agoI feel like this was eminently predictable for anyone with, you know, sense.
- CJefferson 3y agoI would agree, except I thought they were as worthless as crypto in general — turns out I was half right.
- yunohn 3y agoWell, crypto has still not demonstrated any use cases. The coins are just pumping for another round of ponzi scamming.
- adastra22 3y agoBeing able to transfer funds internationally instantaneously (or near enough), and protection from both censorship and confiscation are not use cases?
- c0balt 3y agoMaybe in edge cases, e.g., Ukraine where the money conversion is not a primary concern. But for any real use case beyond "illegitimate" businesses, like Scams, it seems that the censorship and confiscation is not really stoppable. This starts and ends with the conversion from regional currency <> crypto where, e.g., a country may coerce exchanges to blacklist your wallet(s). This even has precedent in the US with wallets containing stolen assets being blacklisted from major exchanges making them hard to use at best.
- adastra22 3y agoIf you're using an exchange, you're missing the point ;)
- 3y ago
- dotcoma 3y agoWho would have said…
- kolinko 3y agoAs much as I hate NFTs, judging by the history of crypto since 2011, the moment people start pronouncing it dead is the moment it picks up steam again :)
- CydeWeys 3y agoNFTs are collectibles built on top of crypto, though. They're not the same thing as Bitcoin/Ethereum (which have much more utility, and crucially, are fungible). The vast, vast majority of collectibles that have ever been made are valueless, or nearly so. Just look at e.g. all the CCGs that have ever existed, vs how many of them have retained value.
- addicted 3y agoIs crypto even being used for anything? There were ATMs and a few places online I could pay with BTC even a few years ago. I don’t see any of that. It was fairly popular for international transfers but so many govts have clamped down on it in the past few years.
- ygjb 3y agoBTC ATMs are still wildly popular with scammers.
- FerretFred 3y agoI use my limited holding to buy my VPN subscription, and occasionally bung a few donations to various people. I've never considered BTC an investment.
- babelchips 3y agoYes.
- kolinko 3y ago
- deadlinermusic 3y agoHaha - Nelson
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- arlattimore 3y agotl;dr - as expected, there is nothing to see here, move along ;p
- kgbcia 3y agoKind of crazy since copyright laws says stuff expires like Mickey Mouse
- Volundr 3y agoCan you clarify how that's related?
- john_the_writer 3y agoIf the rights for Micky expire, then ownership expires. And if that holds for other things, then it holds for NFTs. However where the step misses is NFTs are a single instance, and being a single instance they're more like a Picasso painting. There is an owner of the singular object. The Micky thing refers to his likeness. Creating a copy of his image was restricted. Selling a copy of his original tableau as a real thing is still illegal.
- vrighter 3y agoownership and copyright are not the same thing. Apples and oranges.
- krapp 3y agoGreat. Now do AI.
- MBCook 3y ago“As most are now worthless” No. They were always worthless. More people were just in denial thanks to their gold fever.
- freitasm 3y agoIt was always a scam.
- lulznews 3y agoDon’t worry, always a new sucker to fleece.
- netsharc 3y agoI'd say sooner or later enough people would learn from others' misfortunes, but BTC is at 43K USD, so... maybe more later than soon?
- MBCook 3y agoI’ve been expecting “sooner” for like 10 years now. Somehow it just won’t die. Just when it looked like crypto would finally be over someone glued on the fantasy word NFT and everything was dumb again.
- hnbear 3y agoI think this was true a year ago too. They peaked in 2021, were dead in 2022. For me the most impressive part is how high it peaked. This wasn’t just a flash in the pan, fleecing people for a $1000 here and there. Beeple’s $69.3M price makes it third highest art sale by a living artist ever, for all art. This category came out of nowhere from nothing to top 3 in the space of a couple of years. Then died just as quickly. > The composite’s sale is not just a standout in the NFT world but in the broader art market, too. It is the third-most expensive work from a living artist ever sold at auction—behind only $90.3 million spent on a David Hockney painting in 2018 and the $91.1 million for Jeff Koons’ stainless-steel Rabbit sculpture in 2019.
- xnx 3y agoWas there any 3rd-party confirmation that Beeple's sale was real and not a wash trade / self-sale?
- xref 3y agoWell it sold at Christie’s, not OpenSea or something
- acdha 3y agoThe best theory I’ve seen is that it was more of an attempt to generally juice the market: https://amycastor.com/2021/03/14/metakovan-the-mystery-beeple-art-buyer-and-his-nft-defi-scheme/ https://amycastor.com/2021/03/14/metakovan-the-mystery-beepl...
- xnx 3y agoTrue, so there was probably a commission cost, though even Christie's might have been doing it to try and establish itself in this new space.
- CPLX 3y agoDepends on what you call “real” but it’s going to basically be a certainty that it was someone using money borrowed from other crypto nonsense to prop up this specific crypto nonsense in the hopes that making money off crypto nonsense in general could continue for a few more months.
- BMc2020 3y agohttps://www.investopedia.com/terms/g/greaterfooltheory.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/g/greaterfooltheory.asp What Is the Greater Fool Theory? The greater fool theory argues that prices go up because people are able to sell overpriced securities to a "greater fool," whether or not they are overvalued. That is, of course, until there are no greater fools left.
- brutalized 3y ago[dead]
- friend_and_foe 3y agoObligatory I'm a fan of cryptocurrency, and only a very, very small subset of them at that. Sturgeon's Law, 90% of everything is crap. I tried to tell some of these people. What's the value proposition? People talked about artists and all this and I'm like, OK, what's the value proposition to the buyer? Then I'd hear about how they'll be useful for something some day, so OK, they're useless now? And then something something greater fool. It really was something to watch, "metaverse real estate" and all this. I can tell you the value proposition of a handful of cryptocurrencies. You might not agree, but there's a case I can make. I can tell you Tue value proposition of ethereum. Nobody to this day has been able to give me anything concrete about NFTs or crypto gaming or any of that stuff. It's all hand wavy "this is the future" or "people are going to want this" or something like that. It was all a plainly obvious load of crap.
- tazard 3y agoUniswap V3 liquidity pools are managed as NFTs. Not your main point I know, but people often think of NFTs as simply buy and sell art on opensea. A liquidity pool has clear value.
- friend_and_foe 3y agoWhat do you mean by "managed as NFTs"? A liquidity pool is a contract where people put their coins in and the contract gives them a percentage ownership of all assets in the contract and they get a small fee off the trades done in it. Are you saying that the proof of ownership is a non fungible token? That seems like a small technical detail, it's not the token that has value, it's the assets in the pool, you could easily do it with fungible tokens or with simply a record of ownership in the contract.
- WheelsAtLarge 3y agoCrypto is coming back. NFTs will follow. The problem is that 99%+ are worthless. There's no way to figure out which are the good ones. Funny, how they are similar in that way to baseball cards. Read about a guy who was the head of a group that sold a set for over 50 mil. He cashed out and bought a mansion. The buyers just lost their money. I doubt they have any recourse to get their money back. We'll hear more of these stories again.
- brutalized 3y ago[dead]
- babelchips 3y agoIncorrect. NFTs used for pictures of monkeys etc are now effectively worthless. NFTs as a technology, for tokenizing real world assets, is the far more interesting and useful part. https://www.ledgerinsights.com/abrdn-tokenize-money-market-fund-hedera/ https://www.ledgerinsights.com/abrdn-tokenize-money-market-f... Watching NFTs from afar and thinking it’s all just JPGs means you only have 5% of the story.
- CPLX 3y agoThe headline of that article reads like Vogon poetry.
- babelchips 3y agoIndeed! On that note, if Douglas Adams were still alive he’d have cleared this entire situation up years ago. And it’s NOT that NFTs are themselves worthless… Reading below it’s clearly a perception problem. The fundamental concept of NFTs is profoundly useful. The fact a trivial use case (to represent ownership of JPGs) is all anyone here knows or talks about is the real problem.
- CPLX 3y agoI’m pretty sure the fundamental concept of NFTs is totally useless for anything other than financial speculation.
- babelchips 3y agoHow come?
- MBCook 3y agoIn multiple years despite huge amounts of hype and investment and trivial access to the technology by anyone on the internet no one has managed to find a single one besides “selling” “rare” “art”, which bombed spectacularly? NFT art didn’t work. NFTs in games didn’t work. NFT shares of things didn’t work. Enjoy your intangible beanie baby. At least those had a (small) intrinsic worth.