7 ms·
Researchers discover neuronal biomarkers of schizophrenia in the blood
- CoastalCoder 3y agoWill this help researchers better understand the schizophrenia disease process?
- autoexec 3y agoIt'd be useful and terrifying if this means we can screen people for schizophrenia. Especially if it works on people many years before symptoms show.
- booleandilemma 3y agoCreepy. I could see a good psychological horror movie about this.
- CoastalCoder 3y agoWhy terrifying?
- n8henrie 3y agoI assume referring to being an individual getting this diagnosis prior to the onset of symptoms.
- CoastalCoder 3y agoThat would make sense. I assumed GP was referring to the potential for abuse.
- MBCook 3y agoIt would have to be extremely stressful, knowing that in some short number of years (since it normally shows up in late teens/early 20s I think) your mind would start to constantly lie to you and you may lose the ability to discern reality from hallucinations.
- autoexec 3y agoImagine if children could get diagnosed, or anyone who had no idea and now has to question their own sanity knowing that if it isn't already affecting them that it's only a matter of time. Also because our blood can end up in a lot of places. People who may not even be aware it was collected/screened for schizophrenia could end up being targeted by marketers, scammers, or anyone else with an agenda who'll try to feed into their paranoia the same away advertisers target people with biopolar disorder because they know that people in a manic phase tend to buy things/travel more or how scammers use data brokers to buy up lists of people with dementia and those with low IQ/little education
- TriangleEdge 3y agoI would vote for making data brokers illegal.
- mrcode007 3y agoSame. Not sure why you got downvoted.
- toasted-subs 3y agoBecause some of the people here are corporate dogs, who just try to better themselves. Just had an interview where there was no correct answer. Remembered the equivalent leetcode problem, and my solution worked. Could not pass their test cases though.
- toomuchtodo 3y agohttps://www.consumerfinance.gov/about-us/newsroom/remarks-of-cfpb-director-rohit-chopra-at-white-house-roundtable-on-protecting-americans-from-harmful-data-broker-practices/ https://www.consumerfinance.gov/about-us/newsroom/remarks-of... https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/senate-bill/2121/text?s=1&r=14&q=%7B%22search%22%3A%22Energy%5C%5C+and%5C%5C+and%5C%5C%22%7D https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/senate-bill/212... (S.2121 - DELETE Act) CFPB is trying to rein them in. Call your congressional reps, ask them to support the DELETE Act.
- Staple_Diet 3y agoAlphabet were investing heavily into this space a while ago, with Thomas Insel leading the research. Their aim was to identify biomarkers of these more serious mental illnesses. Schizophrenia isn't like Huntington where an early predictive diagnosis does little more than inform you of an inevitable debilitating illness. Schizophrenia can be managed, and when it is managed well with early intervention the outcomes can be very good. I oversaw a program that supported sufferers of schizophrenia in the community and we had some staff working with us who were also sufferers. The main difference between those who had positive vs negative outcomes was the way in which the illness was managed at onset (typically between teens to young adulthood). Unfortunately mismanagement during that period could have a massive effect on final outcome, where for example we had 60yo patients suffering PTSD from the way they were treated 40y ago during the onset of their illness. If there's anything to fear about improved mental health diagnostics it's how this data will be used by insurance companies to exclude customers in countries that lack socialized healthcare (i.e., US).
- WoodenChair 3y ago> If there's anything to fear about improved mental health diagnostics it's how this data will be used by insurance companies to exclude customers in countries that lack socialized healthcare (i.e., US). Since the Affordable Care Act went into effect in 2014 in USA it's no longer legal to exclude people based on most pre-existing conditions. "Marketplace plans must cover treatment for pre-existing medical conditions. No insurance participating in the health insurance market place can reject you for coverage, charge more, or refuse to pay for essential health services for any prior medical condition. Moreover, once an individual is enrolled in the marketplace, insurance plans cannot deny coverage or raise rates solely based on your health." [0] 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pre-existing_Condition_Insurance_Plan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pre-existing_Condition_Insuran...
- 4death4 3y ago> No insurance participating in the health insurance market place Unfortunately, all the marketplace plans suck.
- swayvil 3y ago1. Locate individual who refuses to do what all the good, right-minded people know to be scientifically appropriate. 2. Blood test. 3. Help the unfortunate person with large doses of mandatory etc.
- getwiththeprog 3y agoScientific proof that an individuals behaviour is "bad". Not a road that I would like to see society go down again. People need to be judged on their behaviour, not their blood. Nothing more, nothing less.
- M1ch431 3y agoExactly. It's scary to think that a simple screening could dictate how you are treated for the rest of your life effectively. You're declared a "latent schizophrenic" and people start doubting your credibility, sanity, independence, safety etc. at every change or milestone in your life. You are forced into therapy for your "benefit", because you are preemptively declared "incompetent" because your illness could manifest any time. You are given "maintenance" doses of major tranquilizers and a cocktail of other poorly understood psychiatric drugs to balance the side effects out; and any spirituality, any epiphanies or sudden changes, any minute delusion is blown out of proportion and is put under a microscope. This name-calling/magnification of "bad behavior" could happen to anybody, and does every day regardless of such screenings and tests. These psychological disorders are poorly understood, with flimsy and often biased/subjective diagnostic criteria (with no measurable physical damage, only a checklist - even in schizophrenia; those bunk brain scans of people who have been treated long-term with anti-psychotics are evidence of just that - it's not the natural progression of the disease). "Wellness checks" are one way today where people can effectively send anybody to a mental hospital with no due process. Some states require that you be a threat to yourself or others, which is something that is easy to fabricate/exaggerate if you wish a person harm, or perhaps misunderstand a situation or are misguided and think you know better than the person that you want to "help". In my state though, if there is "clear and convincing evidence that somebody needs treatment and would benefit from it" during such a check, it basically gives them the right to involuntarily commit you. Imagine how devastating that could be to somebody who cannot afford to pay for the treatment/duration of stay, even if they were deemed subjectively to need treatment. It's highway robbery how much they charge. And their entire life could be upended in the 3 days they held them, if they did get out in only 3 days. They could lose their job, and it all cascades from there. Instead of worrying how bad reality can get, or is, we really just need to attack the problem at its core: Health care needs to be health care, not whatever the hell capitalism has twisted it to be. Involuntary treatment should be made illegal, and there should be a much higher bar on what criteria makes somebody incompetent. One psychiatrist and a judge who is wooed by that psychiatrist is not enough. You should be able to direct your care to another psychiatrist or facility if you have any problem whatsoever, but that usually doesn't happen. There are courts specifically called "Mental Health Courts" in the US and I can tell you that "second opinions" and even small changes to your treatment can be hell to fight for. And finally, suicide should be legal. There should be humane, detailed processes for it, and it should be done in a medical setting. If suicide were legal, then a lot of these frivolous interventions would become regulated. People shouldn't have an express ticket to the mental prison whenever they express wanting to die.
- heavyset_go 3y agoThe real terror is descending into a hell of your mind's own making and it being largely preventable.
- Log_out_ 3y ago? It's a genetic adaptation to hellish circumstances and as we head toward these circumstances somewhat OP. They really are after you, in Russia, in china, in large parts of Africa and more to come. And there are manmade Tigers in the sky and water. Seems to be misguided notion, out of a nostalgic sense for reality, to want to mis-adapt people to a ever more shrinking raft of stability. This shitty circumstances are normal.. It is what most of the species, spend most of its time in before science gifted us with temporary freedom. Better in the long run to adapt the surplus scientific society so that it can survive and thrive in shitty circumstances. Let's make chips in Mogadishu the challenge?
- local_crmdgeon 3y agoRecommend this screening for you. This is p schizoid
- heavyset_go 3y agoOlder, longer and more sustainable societies and cultures found places for some of the people we'd call schizophrenic today. I do think it's tragic that we've lost those roles and ideas surrounding those roles in modernity. However, I've seen with my own two eyes schizophrenia destroy the lives of several people I know. These people are suffering, and not just because of how society treats the neurodivergent. They are trapped in hellish prisons of their own minds, reliving and reinventing traumas no one should have to experience. It's as if their own minds have turned on themselves just to torment them in uniquely personal and unseen hells. It's utterly tragic, and largely preventable with treatment. That said, even in the past, where there were roles for those who experienced schizophrenic symptoms, those with extreme symptoms also suffered from expulsion, disownment, imprisonment and death. It's a mistake to romanticize something that torments so many.
- mistrial9 3y ago
- sylware 3y agoIt all depends on the strength of the correlation. We all know, that to link behavioral patterns to bio-chemistry is full of false-positive... and the other way around too. Correlation is not proof, and in biology, due to inherent complexity it is even more questionable. That looks like some kind of "more research is needed", "give me more money" kind of study.
- cobalt60 3y agoThis is so surreal, I just started watching the anime show "Psycho-Pass", which exactly seems to correlate with this ideology.
- murphyslab 3y agoHere's the DOI for their Science Advances paper: https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.adi4386 https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.adi4386 "miRNA cargo in circulating vesicles from neurons is altered in individuals with schizophrenia and associated with severe disease"
- ofslidingfeet 3y ago"Although medication effects, comorbidities, chronic illness, and drug use (licit and illicit) are common in SZ, these factors are difficult to accurately quantify and control, such that caution interpreting these findings is warranted."
- nightowl_games 3y agoI wonder if it's related to the medications.
- cheekibreeki2 3y agoNo its marijuana /s
- electrondood 3y agoNot sure why you're joking, cannabis use absolutely gave me schizoid symptoms like ideas of reference, etc. This is an actual thing that can happen for some people.
- teddyh 3y ago“Am I just paranoid or am I just stoned?” — Uncensored lyrics of Green Day’s Basket Case.
- toxicdevil 3y agoExactly cannabis abuse and schizophrenia often go hand in hand. There is also some evidence that cannabis use can trigger the condition, esp. in people with a predisposition.
- mcbits 3y agoI think you might mean schizotypal symptoms. Schizoid personality disorder is considered "on the spectrum" with schizophrenia but has very little similarity to it other than social withdrawal.
- maybelsyrup 3y ago[flagged]
- toasted-subs 3y agoLet's say hypothetically I hear voices every now and then. Now let's say those voice correspond to people making these publications, what does that mean?
- deely3 3y agoThat you are listening to some pop-science radios?
- soup10 3y agoPsychiatrists know mental health is mostly subjective and the institution is desperate for physical evidence to add airs of legitimacy. There's a handful of medications that make people less crazy, they prescribe them like candy to anyone for any reason(usually at dosages that are too high). Other than that all they can offer is therapy(which most of them don't want to do because the people that come to them are often heavily traumatized)
- elcritch 3y agoADHD has a half dozen or more effective treatments. Several are rather recent. There’s long term evidence that ADHD medications help those with on a wide variety of measures. Likewise cognitive behavioral therapy and similar work well for many folks. It helps give people tools to change negative behavioral patterns. There’s fMRI which can objectively show brain activity differences for various mental illnesses.
- M1ch431 3y agoWhat makes fMRI objective proof when the mental illnesses are largely subjective? One psychiatrist could see a patient completely differently from another. You either have Alzheimer's or you don't. Your arm is broken or it isn't. It's measurable. With mental illness, the line is blurred. I've never seen compelling evidence for fMRI - just circular reasoning. Psychiatrists who buy into this paradigm posit that the disease exists because in these populations of heavily medicated, subjectively diagnosed (heavily traumatized/stressed) individuals, there are similarities between them in the activity of their brain. Perhaps it's just their disease-first perspective that I take issue with when it comes to fMRI. You could validly look at these populations completely differently without subjective disease terminology and be logically sound with your findings, such as; people tested who experienced more traumatic events in their lifetime and seeing how their brain lit up vs. people who did not experience traumatic events. Or how people respond in institutionalized situations vs. less formal situations, etc. The person you are responding to shares the same general thinking that I have: medically, there is no disease if there is no measurable physical damage. As a doctor when you are arguing that somebody has a disease, especially a disease that is thought to be lifelong or perhaps genetic in nature, it's your job to prove that. A check-list of symptoms isn't enough proof. And by going through these lists you are stereotyping your patient. Studying people diagnosed in this way and forming correlations in these heavily stressed, vulnerable populations proves nothing besides perhaps how stressed they are and the different ways that stress is expressed throughout the population. But when you factor treatment into the mix, physical study of the brain frankly becomes worthless if you are applying it broadly. It could be that fMRI is more or less finding that people on Lexapro or Lithium (whatever the common prescription for an illness is) respond a certain way. Or that individuals experiencing specific types of heightened states (like mania) respond a certain way. What we are not saying is that there is not suffering, that symptoms don't exist, that symptom groupings (like ADHD) aren't bad or good, it's the disease terminology and intellectual dishonestly of the psychiatric field that we are pointing out.