28 ms·
Volkswagen, Porsche, and Audi say they will use Tesla's EV charging plug
- grecy 3y agoStellantis are the only remaining holdout. It seems inevitable they'll jump on board too.
- 1970-01-01 3y agoIf they are the last domino, they also have the worst negotiation position. Whatever number Tesla says will be their cost.
- JoshTko 3y agoNot really, last thing Tesla wants is antitrust oversight for monopolistic practice.
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoWould be a bit ridiculous to penalise Tesla as a monopolist given they virtually pioneered the industry in America within the last generation.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- skybrian 3y agoThis is just imagining future scenarios, but I don’t see an inherent contradiction. That’s one way to end up with a monopoly.
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoSure? It’s just weird to set the precedent that opening up your standard means you’re now a monopolist.
- bluGill 3y agoThe conversation is about what if Tesla doesn't open the standard to one company. An unlikely situation likely.
- CamperBob2 3y agoMr. Rockefeller from Standard Oil on line 2.
- evilfred 3y agowhy would Tesla be involved? NACS is an open standard
- fshbbdssbbgdd 3y agoWill every car that implements a standard be able to use the Tesla Superchargers at full speed? Or would the charger decide if it trusts the car first?
- kalleboo 3y agoTesla wants government subsidies to build superchargers, that's the reason they pushed for NACS to become a standard (the subsidies require the chargers use a standard - right now they're doing the Magic Dock but that's an ugly hack they probably want to avoid). The rules for those subsidies will require they don't play games with who can use them.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 3y agoTesla says they can get NACS to do 1MW. If Tesla can engineer a car that can handle that, would they really be obligated to run that to any crazy hackjob that asks for it? I expect there some to be some minimum standard every car can use, then a shorter list of approved models that can handle more.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 3y ago>Whatever number Tesla says will be their cost. There's no number. They won't have to pay Tesla a dime. It's an open standard now.
- formerly_proven 3y ago* in the US only, since NACS is becoming the US standard.
- SEJeff 3y ago* in north america, which also includes Canada.
- iso8859-1 3y agoWill Greenland use NACS? Probably not.
- rubyn00bie 3y agoHuh? It feels like you’re just being overly pedantic for no reason. From Wikipedia and numerous other sources: > Though a part of the continent of North America, Greenland has been politically and culturally associated with Europe.
- iso8859-1 3y agoIt's not even clear if it will prevail in México: https://mobilityportal.lat/carga-nacs-estandarizacion-norteamerica/ https://mobilityportal.lat/carga-nacs-estandarizacion-nortea...
- NewJazz 3y agoYou really think GB/T will prevail? Mexico is a very common destination for used vehicles from the US and Canada. The GB/T standard maxes out at 250kW speeds right now. I have also read that the locking mechanism is fragile.
- CaptainOfCoit 3y agoDon't forget the neighbor in the south North America too, Mexico.
- cr3ative 3y ago...in America. Europe here quite nicely standardising on CCS2.
- alsodumb 3y agoUS is standardizing quite nicely too, on Tesla's charging standard. I can't think of a company that is not planning to use Tesla's charger going forward.
- jader201 3y agoNot really. Many Tesla Superchargers are being equipped with Magic Dock, which is perpetuating CCS. More manufacturers may be moving to NACS, but it’s not like chargers are moving away from CCS. If anything, the CCS infrastructure is growing.
- InTheArena 3y agoCCS is dead with this. I expect magic dock installs to stop.
- _ea1k 3y agoI think they are still a requirement for NEVI, and Tesla has won a few contracts for NEVI sites. I do expect them to stop eventually though. IMO, part of the reason they exist is that it lets them collect real world data on supercharger and adapter usage before the bigger rollouts next year.
- eichin 3y agoHow widespread is that really? After the first deployment (where every EV youtuber east of the Mississippi converged on one tesla lot in New York :-) I haven't seen it in tech news since, and looking in the app I see 2 private ("destination") chargers in all of MA, and none in CT...
- giobox 3y ago> Many Tesla Superchargers are being equipped with Magic Dock, which is perpetuating CCS This isn't actually the case; while the tech press made a big deal about the project when announced, hardly any Super Charger sites have the Magic Dock. As of this month, it's only at ~50 Super Charger locations. I also think with widespread NACS adoption the rollout will slow down even more - what is the point of the project if almost all new EVs sold in the US will have NACS? There are over 2000 Tesla Super Charger locations in the US. I have never seen a Magic Dock in the wild personally, for what little additional it's worth. > https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-magic-dock-supercharger-intallations/ https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-magic-dock-supercharger-inta... > https://supercharge.info/data https://supercharge.info/data
- lnsru 3y agoLogical move. North American Charging Standard does not exist in Europe making car re-import much more difficult.
- m3kw9 3y agoIf it’s electrical it wouldn’t be too hard to conver from one standard to another using an adapter, since it’s standard on both sides there will be a money incentive to make one
- HPsquared 3y agoHow about voltage / current / communication? Seems quite a complicated problem, it's not just a case of different USB plug styles..
- _ea1k 3y agoIt actually is very similar to USB plug styles. NACS communicates the same way that CCS does. Converting between NACS and CCS1 or CCS2 connectors should be easy. The biggest issue is the amount of current involved.
- 0xfae 3y agoActually USB is a great example. USB C can charge at 5v, 10v, 20v, etc. When you plug in a device to the charger a hand shake happens between the charger and device and they choose the voltage and amperage that makes sense. A macbook pro can take 100W over USBC but obviously your headphones or phone aren't going to.
- bluGill 3y agoTesla is using the same communication standard, they just combine AC and DC on the same pins which means an adapter can be pretty cheap.
- kwhitefoot 3y agoThe voltage and current are determined by negotiation between the car and charger. There were plenty of US Teslas imported into Norway in the early days. They have no trouble charging here. If necessary a simple conversion can be done. Making my 2015 S70D that had a Type 2 connector work with CCS2 was a 300 USD conversion. I can't see any reason why converting from NACS to CCS2 would be any more difficult or expensive.
- clouddrover 3y ago> Volkswagen Group, which also owns Audi, Porsche, and Scout Motors, is finally doing what nearly every other automaker has already done: announce its intention to adopt Tesla’s electric vehicle charging standard. The reporting around this has been so poor. NACS is CCS with Tesla's plug on the end. What's happening is that CCS has won the EV charging protocol wars, Tesla's plug is being standardized as CCS type 3 (aka SAE J3400), and Tesla's chargers will use the CCS protocol (like they already do in Europe and elsewhere). To use NACS chargers older Teslas will need a CCS retrofit: https://electrek.co/2023/02/28/tesla-ccs-adapter-retrofit-price/ https://electrek.co/2023/02/28/tesla-ccs-adapter-retrofit-pr...
- valine 3y agoWhen people talk about standardizing the charge port they’re talking about the shape of the port not the protocol. Tesla has supported the CCS protocol for years now. The Tesla port is vastly superior to the CCS type 1 port. They should get credit for making it an open standard.
- clouddrover 3y agoYes, people aren't aware of what's happening. That's a consequence of lazy reporting. Tesla's charging standard is being dropped and CCS will be used by everyone. It's a shame North America still has years of plug incompatibilities and adapter fiddling to look forward to. Europe really got EV charging standardization right. The European EV infrastructure is much further advanced than the North American infrastructure thanks in part to sensible standardization.
- SEJeff 3y ago> It's a shame North America still has years of plug incompatibilities and adapter fiddling Not really, Tesla has over 24k charging stalls in the US. The second biggest is Electrify America, and they have only 3,800 charging stalls. There really aren't a lot of EV chargers that are non-tesla in the US, unlike the EU.
- LightBug1 3y ago[flagged]
- avalys 3y agoHuh?
- LegitShady 3y agoThe disinfectant has substance abuse issues.
- blabla1224 3y agoI won’t be surprised if Tesla becomes a platform for other automakers like android from Google in the future
- bluGill 3y agoAuto makers are used to making their own platforms, and they won't change. Making a platform is not the hard part, and there are advantages to a custom platform for each vehicle.
- newsclues 3y agoAuto makers are used to integrating technology from other companies like Bosch.
- bluGill 3y agoBut not their platforms. Automakers generally make their own platforms (though they will rebadge someone else's too), engines (again they share with each other, but most have their own), and transmissions. Everything else is outsourced to companies like Bosch.
- chrisjc 3y agoIt definitely seems like Tesla is slowly seeping into the world of other car manufactures in an ongoing manner. And I don't think they/we have given much thought to what's yet to come. Batteries, auto-pilot, training/inference, manufacturing/robotics, and so on... Do any of really think, especially given the track record, that most of the auto-industry is going to be able to do any of this alone? I imagine that eventually it will come down to a choice between partnering with a bunch of disparate tech/manufacturing companies or Tesla. We all know there is disruption to come in general, but it's going to hit the incumbent auto-manufacturers like a brick if they don't wake up soon.
- thiago_fm 3y ago[flagged]
- SEJeff 3y agoWhich countries have landed men on the moon using garbage standards? Which countries have landed men on the moon using your preferred standards?
- kataklasm 3y agoI don't know if US Space Programs is the end-all be-all argument you think it is, looking at Orion and SLS.
- mardifoufs 3y agoAs opposed to which other wildly successful space programs? Ariane? Lol. I'm not American but yes us space programs are absolutely way ahead and have been so since Apollo. They are also pretty good arguments whenever someone tries to argue that the US is backwards technologically because of... measurement units lol. Not sure why it's even worth denying that. There is tons of stuff to criticize the US for, or where the US is behind but space programs are probably not one of them lol.
- SEJeff 3y agoThe irony here is that even the not so great American space programs, like the two you mentioned, are still leagues ahead of most of the rest of world’s space programs. Also, the SLS launch that’s happened was flawless. Sure the thing is expensive, but how is it a failure? Orion and SLS will medium to long term likely both be replaced by Starship / Superheavy. The only non-American super impressive space program that I’ve seen is actually India’s ISRO. Their cost for traditional rockets price per kg to orbit is quite impressive, though Spacex dominates everyone on price due to reusability.
- thiago_fm 3y agoAny country can land on the moon after spending the same amount of money and effort as the US; intelligence and talent are abundant, existing in every nation and human being.
- InTheArena 3y agoI think people are missing the big story here. This is Tesla winning the charging network battle (it wasn't close before this). Any EV car (which will eventually be all cars) will immediately be available for Tesla's supercharger network. This gives Tesla a massive revenue stream and scale to grow that network even bigger. Anyone who wants their superchargers has to also support all Teslas.
- mupuff1234 3y agoBut it also takes away Tesla's biggest advantage, no? The charging network was a big reason to buy a tesla and now that's gone. So perhaps they will actually end up losing more revenue than gaining.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- adrianN 3y agoI would expect that in the near future EVs become commodities based on a small handful of licensed platforms. Owning the charging network is a nice hedge against losing the battle to become one of the platforms.
- mupuff1234 3y agoMaybe, but a charging network is not quite a trillion dollar business, not to mention that the charging network will also become a commodity (especially since the charging protocol is open)
- bluGill 3y agoI disagree. People like their car to look new/different, and volumes on cars are high enough that the advantages of a custom platform is worth the cost of designing it.
- adrianN 3y agoThe design of the car is only loosely related to the skateboard that contains the battery and the drivetrain.
- NelsonMinar 3y agoOther Audi EV news: "Audi puts big EV push on the back burner" https://electrek.co/2023/12/19/audi-puts-big-ev-push-on-the-back-burner/ https://electrek.co/2023/12/19/audi-puts-big-ev-push-on-the-...
- chaosprint 3y agoWill it be possible that Benz uses Nio's battery swap?
- mensetmanusman 3y agoGreat work by Tesla recognizing that infrastructure is half the equation for an EV future. They have moved the EV future forward by at least a decade.
- apexalpha 3y agoI understand the ridicule that the EU gets sometimes, and especially so when trying to regulate stuff like AI where it seems the EU wants to regulate more than to create start ups etc... But this is one thing the EU just nailed the hammer into the wood immediatly, and rightly so. I can't even remember the time it was. Maybe 2013? 2014? They just set a standard and everyone, even Tesla, adopted it. Every single EV can plug into every charger. Whether it's a public one, a private at the office, a Tesla supercharger or a home charger at your home. Plug and go! Glad to see NA finally agrees on a standard now. This can only help EV adoption. Especially given the sorry state of other chargers than Tesla's over there.
- Rebelgecko 3y agoEh, I think if NA had forced a standard quickly (which the US has actually sort of done with the infrastructure bill), it would've been CCS which has a lot of downsides
- justapassenger 3y agoAny downside other than bigger plug? And plug is bigger partially because it needs to support 3 phases, which isn’t a thing in USA houses (while common across the whole world) but is a thing at industrial locations. Tesla plug doesn’t work with 3 phases.
- evilfred 3y agothe Technology Connections video on NACS is very educational on the topic https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZJOfyMCEzjQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZJOfyMCEzjQ
- raphaelj 3y agoI don't own any electric car. What are the advantages and disadvantages of Tesla's standard vs CCS2 (pretty common in Europe as far as I know) ?
- akouri 3y agoI am the founder of Starlight Charging[1]. We are working on crazy-low-cost L2 chargers for multifamily apartments. Plug-and-charge is a sine-qua-non for us. One still major unsolved problem is the lack of agreement on a standard for payment/powerline communication from the EVSE to the vehicle. OCPP 2.0.1 and ISO 15118 is supposed to bring "Plug and Charge" capabilities -- this, in theory, would allow drivers to simply pull up to a station, plug in, and charging start right away. i.e. No more fiddling with multiple different manufacturer's apps, no more being SOL if your phone battery is dead. While we're seeing agreement on the physical standard for the shape and size of the conductors, there's still progress to be made on the protocol between vehicles and charger. Tesla refuses to implement OCPP because they have a great walled garden right now and don't want to release the stranglehold on the payments. [1] https://www.starlightcharging.com https://www.starlightcharging.com
- why_at 3y agoCan you explain why you feel plug-and-charge is so important? I have used chargers with and without it and while it is slightly more convenient to just plug in and go, it doesn't feel like such a huge improvement that I absolutely need it. I agree that having a different app for every brand of charging station would be annoying, but what about just accepting a credit card the way we do with gas stations now?
- jakewins 3y agoHave you done any road tripping in an EV? my experience of the app-based charging landscape has been complete horror; apps don’t work, chargers don’t start, payments don’t through.. Just last month was a new app at McDonalds in Sweden, that one asks me to, in the freezing cold, scan a dirty QR code sticker, which takes me to a website I’ve never heard of that wants me to manually enter credit card info, like a phishing attack smorgasbord. It’s the one thing I miss from a gas car: just let me fill up.
- afavour 3y agoIMO that would be better solved by mandating tap and pay payment at EV charging spots. Integrating payments into the charging standard feels like a wild overcomplication by comparison.
- zackmorris 3y agoThis makes me sad in a way that's a little hard to articulate. But I'll try! I plug my $9000 2013 Nissan Leaf into an ordinary 120V extension cord each night so I can commute to a neighboring city for work, and the electricity costs me $20/mo. I also have a 1986 Toyota pickup like on Back to the Future that I had to gas up every other week, using 30 gallons of gas per month and costing over $100. So the operating cost of an EV is about 3-5 times lower than a gas vehicle. My friend has an EV charging dongle that we jokingly call the octopus, which has a dozen adapters for plugging into every kind of 120/240V outlet like on ovens and dryers. So he charges his car in 4 hours out of whatever outlet is available, for the same $20/mo that I pay. So convincing the public that everyone needs to buy a $500-1000 charging station for their EV was a social engineering campaign to slow the adoption of EVs. The real engineering work to let us plug EVs into any outlet has not been done yet. But it would look like this: * Level 2 J1772 chargers have a resistor that tells the EV how much wattage to draw. But that just passes the buck to the user, who now must ensure that the outlet can provide that wattage. A better system would have a smart power manager that senses current saturation or voltage drop near the point where the circuit breaker trips. We also need smart breakers that add noise/harmonics/phase as they approach their limit, which EVs would detect to self-regulate. And we need breakers that trip for a nominal time like 1 second or shorter, or however long power supplies can continue to operate uninterrupted, so that a tripped breaker isn't a showstopper. * Nearly all US portable battery power stations come in only 120V with a 30A TT-30 plug normally used for RVs, with no 240V option unless you connect two stations for twice the price. If we want a 5000Wh/240V station so we can charge our EVs on solar power, we'll have to go to Europe or Alibaba to get it. * Battery chargers, BMSs and inverters are notoriously finicky. They often won't charge below a certain voltage threshold, causing some solar installations to spend part of the day off. We need 95% efficient 10kW rectifiers/inverters that can take any AC/DC voltage from 0-500V and output standard 12/24/48/96/120/240/480V in all phases without requiring configuration from the user, for under $1000. If we had these ubiquitous power tools, then choice of NACS/CCS/CHAdeMO would be moot. Edit: I forgot to add that before Google fell, they held their Little Box Challenge in 2014 to develop a high-efficiency low-cost 95% efficient 2 kW inverter similar to the one I mentioned, so the tech has been available for almost a decade now: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Box_Challenge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Box_Challenge
- l72 3y agoWhile this sounds good, why are we so focused on charging stations? It seems to me, it would make much more sense to have a series of batteries that can quickly be removed, and have battery exchanges. Then, if you need a charge, you pull over to a battery exchange, swap out batteries in a few seconds, and go on your way. I have seen this in China with electric scooters, and it seems like it could scale well for cars too.
- whalesalad 3y agoFor most EV's (specifically Tesla) the battery is a structural component of the vehicle (for better or for worse). Would require a complete architectural shift. Also, they would be incredibly heavy and difficult to swap. Would require multiple smaller batteries. People would abuse them. Would require huge inventory of batteries all over the place. Imagine going on a long road trip, you wouldn't bring batteries with you. You'd swap them along the way. What if a particular vendor/station is out of batteries for the day? Or doesn't have your particular flavor of battery because (like we have seen with charging ports in this exact story) manufacturers couldn't agree on the interface/size? Or the batteries they have are abused and low quality / at end of life? This is very common with scooters. It would be a shit show. On the other hand, electricity is essentially fluid. It does not require a container. As battery tech improves and as high voltage charging becomes more commonplace, plugging in to charge won't be so bad.
- sudobash1 3y agoI can think of many reasons: * Batteries are really expensive and have a limited life. If my batteries were wearing out, could I go to one of these swaps and hope for a fresher set? * Different sized cars require different battery capacities (EV Ford F150 vs Nissan Leaf). Not a problem with charging cables, but a big issue with battery swapping. * Battery swapping stations would be orders of magnitude more expensive than charging stations. * This is not really useful for many (or maybe most) users. If you are driving around town or commuting, charging overnight at home should be good enough for most people. (The main hurdle here would be convincing landlords of the importance of charging). * It is a lot easier to standardize on a charging port, than to standardize one a battery pack. A standardized battery pack would dictate how the car is structured. * It would make innovation harder on battery packs. It could make it impractical to try a new battery chemistry or capacity, whereas these are fairly easy changes to make without changing the charging port.
- ttyyzz 3y agoI work in the Volkswagen Group and will only add that Audi and Porsche have to go along just because of synergy effects, apart from the fact that they also belong to the Volkswagen Group and do what their mother wants.
- TacticalCoder 3y ago> ... apart from the fact that they also belong to the Volkswagen Group Volkswagen group with itself belongs to the Porsche SE holding. The Porsche SE holding is the biggest owner of Volkswagen shares (with 1/3rd of all the shares) and holds the majority of the shares with voting rights. And the Porsche SE holding shares are mostly held by the two Porsche and Piech families. So, in the end, Porsche the car manufacturer belongs to the VW group which itself belongs to the Porsche SE holding which itself belongs to the Porsche (and Piech) families.
- fuckyah 3y ago[dead]
- maximus-decimus 3y agoI wonder how much this will have an Osborne effect i.e. will people just stop buying their EVs until they release cars with the Tesla connector? Buying a car without that plug now is a bit like buying a Betamax player right after everybody announces they'll soon only support VHS.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- londons_explore 3y agoAnd that just leaves stellantis brands... Abarth, Alfa Romeo, Chrysler, Citroën, Dodge, DS, Fiat, Jeep, Lancia, Maserati, Opel, Peugeot, Ram, and Vauxhall.
- w4rh4wk5 3y agoDamn, I was hoping they'd adapt USB-C like the Fiat 500 Hybrid.
- merb 3y agobtw there are provider networks in Europe where you subscribe to a single provider and you can charge nearly anywhere. It’s just that other providers have a roaming fee, which sometimes is double the price, which makes it a little bit stupid. Roaming should either be free or add minimal overhead like 2cent maximum over the costs of the other provider