25 ms·
AI cannot be patent 'inventor', UK Supreme Court rules in landmark case
- pseudolus 3y agoLink to decision: https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/uksc/2023/49 https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/uksc/2023/49
- rational_indian 3y agoJust file the patent as your own self?
- olliej 3y agoThat would be perjury?
- CaptainFever 3y agoWould it?
- DonaldPShimoda 3y agoUnless the AI's training data was 100% your own material, yes, obviously.
- speedgoose 3y agoIt’s not obvious to me.
- ajhurliman 3y agoCan’t tell if this is satirical or not, but if it is: lol, good one
- jimmaswell 3y agoWhat human brain contains 100% its own material?
- onetimeuse92304 3y agoThat's absolutely not true. You can file a patent based on idea that you had that came from discussions with other people. For example, somebody came up with a wheeled cart, somebody came up with an engine and you have an idea to just combine those two ideas by putting an engine on a car. It is patentable even if the material is not 100% your own. What is patentable is a novel idea. You need to bring something new to the table, and that AI definitely can do. The fact the knowledge it uses comes from training material has nothing to do with it. Almost everything factual you know comes from other people anyway.
- olliej 3y agoWhen you file a patent based on a "novel" application or combination of existing ideas, or ideas from other sources, those ideas are not something you can patent. e.g in "somebody came up with a wheeled cart, somebody came up with an engine" your patent would not cover either sub idea (contextually, the thing the "AI" came up with), so all something needs to do is say given the non-patentable idea you got from a machine your patent covers an obvious application then your patent is invalid. A whole bunch of laws passed over the last decade to try to limit the validity of "X but on a Y" (where Y is in the theme of computer, internet, etc) style BS patents.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoThat's really not obvious; nobody trains humans on 100% their own material, but we let humans patent things.
- olliej 3y agoNo, the point of the ruling is that given an arbitrary amount of data, if a machine can generate the "invention" (in the patent sense) then you cannot patent it. Claiming that you invented the thing because you setup the AI would render the ruling meaningless. The whole point is the machine is mechanically converting a pile of data into a "invention", and it does not matter where the data comes from. When the machine does that, you personally did not, and when you claim in a patent application that you invented a thing, you're saying that you did the thinking or reasoning or whatever. Otherwise your teachers could wait for you to come up with an patentable idea and patent it claiming that it was their invention. Either the AI is conscious and alive, etc, etc in which case you're the teacher in the argument (and can't claim to be an inventor but rather a slave owner) or it's a mechanical device operating over data and producing a functionally deterministic result (the randomness in "AI" is artificially added solely to produce the appearance of non-deterministic output) in which case there's no invention: anyone could put the same data in and get the same thing out so on.
- olliej 3y agoThe patent office says "if an AI comes up with it's not patentable" so you turn around and sign a piece of paper that says you came up with it. How is that not perjury? I'm not making a statement on "should a machine generated idea" be patentable (my sense is no, but pharmaceutical corporations have plenty of patents on things that they found bacteria produced, so ???). My statement is: when you file a patent, you sign a sworn statement (federal in the US, presumably similar conceptually in other jurisdictions) that all your statements are true and accurate. If a machine came up with the patent, and you know that is not patentable under law, so you claim that _you_ came up with it, then that is an objectively false statement. You then signed and submitted to your relevant government body as a sworn statement. Again this is an objectively false statement, that you provide sworn testimony is true. That's definitionally perjury. Other people have made comments about combining ideas from others, but when you do that you have to state that those ideas come from another source that is not covered by the patent, unless those other entities are co-authors of the patent. e.g. if an "AI" comes up with an idea, and you combine it in a "novel" way with something else, the "AI" generated part is still not patentable, and cannot be covered by the patent.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- preommr 3y agoFrom the article: > But he added: "The judgment does not preclude a person using an AI to devise an invention – in such a scenario, it would be possible to apply for a patent provided that person is identified as the inventor." ------ > The patent office says "if an AI comes up with it's not patentable" Where are you getting this from?
- bell-cot 3y agoDid you just cut & paste the AI's output into the patent application? Or were you a competent expert in the area - who read through what it said, maybe did some real-world experimenting, made various changes to improve the idea, etc, etc.?
- saiya-jin 3y agoYeah a trivial bypass, anybody in say eastern Europe or Russia would immediately think about this path, that's one of million ways communism destroyed morality of whole region for generations to come. Change things a bit without affecting meaning and voila. I see some dark path in patent world, corporations are amoral by principle so they will try to milk this even if just to defend themselves from everybody else doing it.
- ubutler 3y agoThis is not surprising, the Federal Court of Australia issued a similar ruling last year for the same reason, namely that an inventor for the purposes of patent law must be a natural person and AI are not legal persons: https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=2a9508a2-d7fa-42bf-a283-9a711abddf8d https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=2a9508a2-d7fa... Also worth noting that that case involved the same plaintiff as this one, Dr Stephen Thaler, who has been on a mission to have a court recognise his AI system, DABUS, as capable of inventing patents.
- cyanydeez 3y agowhich is curious because an AI won't request a patent, so what benefit does he expect for applying on it's behalf? some infinite lifetime patent?
- ben_w 3y agoLLMs are very good at mimicking humans, so "an AI won't request a patent" is almost certainly already false regardless of any legal, moral, financial, or quality-of-output considerations.
- qayxc 3y agoLLMs don't do that unprompted, though. So prompting an AI to invent something and then file for a patent for the invention is comparable to using a template for the patent application. They don't have that kind of agency (yet).
- feanaro 3y agoSo if we package up AI into an autonomous loop, so that it can file for a patent unprompted, that is sufficient precondition to allow patents to be assigned to such a loop?
- cyanydeez 3y agoYes, the person who packages up a loop to make patents, get a patent for that loop and anything else it produces, right? Move this to the "Autonomous vehicle" line of thought. IF we accept the risks of a vehicle without a driver, how do we accomodate the _culpability_ of that risk? Same thing in patent law. Someone needs to hold that "culpability". Maybe there'll be a robust future systems of laws that assigns the correct weightings, but it's not today.
- gumballindie 3y agoOutstanding. Cant wait for a day when code written by companies that use procedural generators and it simply becomes public domain because it cant be copyrighted.
- qup 3y agoWhy? If the AI can write it, just ask for it yourself. I'm not very excited for heaps of AI code to get released. I basically consider that already happened.
- pixl97 3y agoYou're assuming most people are wizards capable of speaking the correct incantations to the AI to get working code.
- blacksmith_tb 3y agoThe optimist in me would like to say that people just keep trying incantations until the generated code works, then release it. The pessimist says people already release code that barely works, so we can hardly expect AI code generation to improve matters.
- Jensson 3y agoThen the programmers who used the AI to make the system are the authors. They added enough value for it to be recognized as their own thing. Until an AI can do these things on their own the author will continue to be the human driving them.
- dumbo-octopus 3y agoIs there any material difference between speaking the right english incantations vs speaking the right $PROGRAMMING_LANGUAGE incantations? By the time I've thought about a problem enough to be able to ask an AI to solve it for me, I'm 99.9% of the way to solving it myself.
- quickthrower2 3y ago
- notfed 3y ago(Deleted, I misunderstood the article.)
- Ekaros 3y agoYou are thinking of wrong problem. It is not about use of AI in new patent. But if the AI can be the author. Later of which would mean that AI would have some type of personhood like companies have... And currently courts consider that it should not as of now.
- notfed 3y agoYou're right. I misunderstood. I think I misunderstood it because the idea of marking an AI as a "patent inventor" seems quite silly to me and so I had some cognitive dissonance that this could possibly be what the issue was about.
- vincnetas 3y agoi think the idea of patent is to share knowledge needed to reproduce the invention. pitty that this is mostly unenforced.
- kevindamm 3y agoA significant portion of inventors, especially the employed kind, will quite intentionally not read up on patents in order to avoid the risk of triple damages. Patents serve to inform the lawyers more than the inventors, at least in the US in modern day and I suspect elsewhere too.
- quickthrower2 3y agoI find it hard to believe an AI invented something without human steering. If there was any human steering, prompting, hints etc., then would I think (as a layman) that the person invented it with AI assistance.
- smolder 3y agoMaybe this is a good test for what isn't novel. If an LLM trained on our existing creative output can be prompted invent some patentable solution to a problem, then maybe that shouldn't be patentable. Tada, a much less stupid patent system.
- jimmaswell 3y agoYou can prompt GPT to "invent" anything if you know the result you want - it's extremely suggestable. Nothing would be patentable.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- smolder 3y agoI don't think you understood me. If I ask GPT5 to "write a patent application for a method to optimize a program that does X, which is not currently patented", and it produces something that would be accepted as patentable, without that patentable idea being in its training data... that should not be patentable. If I ask GPT5 to "write a patent application for this specific method of optimizing a program that does X, described as follows: [...]" that's completely irrelevant because the LLM clearly isn't inventing anything, whether or not the idea is in the training data already. Being able to get an LLM to puke any idea back at you was not the point. If the idea is so obvious that an LLM can infer it from training data not including that specific idea, then it's not very novel. If by some good fortune LLMs start to spit out truly novel ideas, I will be blown away most of all, but those ideas probably shouldn't be patentable either, based on the principles behind the patent system. Granting temporary monopolies to people based on the output of true machine intelligence only on a 1st come 1st serve basis would hurt the whole world. Being first in line to ask isn't virtue.
- dukeofdoom 3y agoA metal detector, might detect treasure, where a human would not without its aid. But the Human is the one that get all the credit of discovery, because a metal detector is just a tool.
- peternilson 3y agoIf the A.I can not be rewarded the patent, can it therefore also not be guilty of infringement ?
- Ekaros 3y agoOn other hand it cannot own property or earn money. So it is pretty pointless to sue one...
- drtgh 3y agoset anti-marketing && anti-neolanguage on: " If the statistical database prepared by the team can not be rewarded the patent, can the team that configured the data that fed the vectorization of such database therefore also not be guilty of infringement ? " There is no Johnny5, HAL, Skynet, etc. It is not expected that it will be seen in the coming decades, probably not even in this century at the very least.
- dragoncrab 3y agoGiven how easy it would be to turn in an AI generated patent claiming that you were the inventor I think this is some legal activism and the guy doesn't actually care about these patents. I can't tell the goal, but is likely about clarifying the legal framework or even influence it by creating precedents in these clear scenarios.
- KaiserPro 3y agoThe person filing the patent has a lot of prior work in trying to get AI stuff legally recognised: https://www.wired.co.uk/article/stephen-thaler-ai-copyright-suits-is-trying-to-show-his-bot-is-sentient https://www.wired.co.uk/article/stephen-thaler-ai-copyright-...
- daniel-cussen 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Osmose 3y agoThe courts don't come to decisions like this, but it's pretty straightforward to want to prevent AIs from being able to invent patents (even as an aid) because the obvious consequence of allowing it is companies automating the generation of patents as much as possible and flooding the patent system. Anyone who's worked on spam prevention knows that as long as the profit is higher than the cost of impersonating a human, spammers will continue to hammer you until you can make the costs high enough to be no longer profitable.
- sgt101 3y agoThere is an intersting wrinkle here, I haven't seen it mentioned so far. In the UK a patent is invalid if you put an inventor on it who didn't make a significant and definable contribution to the invention. If a patent is AI generated, and then labelled with a human inventor it may be argued that it is invalidated by the humans lack of inventive input.
- jonplackett 3y agoIf the human knows this though surely than can work backwards and do some busywork that makes it look like they did it all.
- pbhjpbhj 3y agoThat sounds great to me, it means companies can create with ML but can't lock up the fruits of that. So they can't ditch their R&D people if they want to use patents -- that looks, inadvertently, like a good balance?
- alexisread 3y agoThat's a great observation. I guess the problem here is one of enforcement- with so many patents coming in, how can you a) prove that a human didn't contribute meaningfully, an act of transcription obfuscates the origin here. b) Devote enough manpower to doing this for every patent? If the contribution is opt-in then it's marginally better, but I can see that the lion's share of patents would go to whoever has the biggest LLM, thus pushing the wealth gap larger. Patents are about novelty and effort (we want to reward the inventor), who's to say that these inventions would be novel, when anyone with a large LLM can find them?
- jonplackett 3y agoDude should have just said he invented it… I imagine that’s what will happen from now on
- pnut 3y agoPossibly controversial opinion, but this'll have to be revisited within 10 years. It seems inevitable (to me) that the near future looks like a heterogeneous mixture of natural and artificial intelligences interacting on a level footing, enforced by legal protections. LLMs as an interface subcomponent of a larger system are surely already being prototyped, and it's a matter of time before agency emerges. In any case, most of our systems, and definitely how we manage intellectual property, are basically obsolete and require wholesale revisitation, so this is our institutions still protecting status quo until forced.
- sgu999 3y ago> In any case, most of our systems, and definitely how we manage intellectual property, are basically obsolete and require wholesale revisitation I completely agree, but don't underestimate the power of the ones who own most of it to lobby in their favour for the decades to come. That combined to a trend towards relocation of supply chains, more expensive energy, resources etc. makes me think that we will see the value of physical capital increase in proportion.
- tovej 3y agoPlease explain how agency is "just a matter of time". This is a pretty big statement you're just assuming to be true. I have seen no indication that current autonomous systems could achieve agency, or that anybody even considers that a development goal. Also, I think it seems clear that LLMs and other generative models are poised to strengthen the moat of status quo beneficiaries. I'm not sure if this decision weakens that impact, but generative models are not the tools of the "little guys".
- glimshe 3y agoThis is good. Like most of the protections in patent/copyright law, this would have protected large corporations with extensive AI resources, or trolls, and crush the little guy.
- blackoil 3y agoIf I understood correctly. Ruling doesn't concern with who is the actual "inventor", just that the ownership must be with a person or Corporation. So, you are free to file patents under your name that have been created by your AI. Which makes sense as AI isn't legally an autonomous entity.
- singularity2001 3y agoAI isn't legally an autonomous entity (... yet?)
- krapp 3y agoI see no reason why AI would ever be allowed legal autonomy or identity. That would] be counterproductive to the purpose of using AI to generate and capture value.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mensetmanusman 3y agoGood, AI is analogous to a point and shoot camera. Define your scene via a prompt, then push a button.