20 ms·
Comcast says hackers stole data of close to 36M Xfinity customers
- happytiger 3y ago0wn3d. Includes security questions and last four of social security for tens of millions. Couldn’t happen to a nicer company either. Boilerplate response from them: https://assets.xfinity.com/assets/dotcom/learn/Notice%20To%20Customers%20of%20Data%20Security%20Incident.pdf?INTCMP=dsi-12152023 https://assets.xfinity.com/assets/dotcom/learn/Notice%20To%2...
- tessierashpool 3y agoit didn't happen to a company at all. it happened to their customers. if the CEO faces criminal or civil penalties, or the company does, then it happens to the company. what makes it worse is Comcat's quasi-monopoly status as a non-optional public utility with, in many areas, no competitors. your only choice is to give away your secrets to a company which will manage them irresponsibly and then act like victims about it.
- RajT88 3y ago"Starting today" - there's no date on that notice. But the URI suggests it was authored on the 15th. Apparently not released for 4 days?
- happytiger 3y agoAdmitting they suck at security is hard for monopolies. Be sensitive to their feelings man.
- stonepresto 3y agoThe part of the prompt that suggests its the 15th of December is a GET param, which just means wherever this link was retrieved from is where that date is coming from. The PDF could have been authored at any time. Looks like the created date embedded in the metadata is as follows: 2023-12-18T21:21:19.000Z Created with MS Word. But even that isn't definitive.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- crazybLanKeT 3y agoanother reason to never answer those security questions with actual info.
- happytiger 3y agoOr put your real birth date.
- AdamJacobMuller 3y agoThe primary reason being when you have to answer the questions over the phone. "What is your mother's maiden name?" "bidah6shee8Dahkouju" "Wait, what, that is correct how ?" Every time I hear their confusion and shock, I get a bit more depressed that more people aren't doing this.
- tzs 3y agoMost people want to minimize the time it takes to resolve whatever issue has led to them being on the phone with support. Giving "bidah6shee8Dahkouju" as your mother's maiden name does not help achieve that. Using a different made up mother's maiden name at each site is a good idea, but you can use short names that are easy to pronounce and spell for that to get the security benefits without drawing out the time you have to spend with support.
- amlozano 3y agoProtip, use something like a https://diceware.rempe.us/#eff https://diceware.rempe.us/#eff password with 6 words. They never seem to mind when you just say "litmus secrecy ruckus nest reason send", they don't even skip a beat.
- mdaniel 3y agoI enjoy pointing out that 1Password has a dedicated section for generating "security answers" using this same method (they allow "horse battery staple" style with variable number of words, although a minimum of 3) https://support.1password.com/generate-security-questions/ https://support.1password.com/generate-security-questions/ Like all good Bitwarden things, feel free to spit^W vote for a similar feature request https://community.bitwarden.com/t/security-questions-track-autofill-like-a-password/14353 https://community.bitwarden.com/t/security-questions-track-a...
- teeray 3y ago> and their secret questions and answers Periodic reminder that these are just passwords too. They should be treated as such by users (generate random responses) and devs (hash and salt them).
- gruez 3y ago>They should be treated as such by users (generate random responses) and devs (hash and salt them). I agree for tech savvy users it's prudent to treat them as passwords, but it doesn't extend to the general public. If they should be treated as passwords, what's the point of having them then? They're most often used in password reset flows. If it's a random string/phrase, they're basically useless in that use case. In what situation would you have the randomly chosen string for the security question, but not the randomly chosen string for the password?
- renewiltord 3y agoThey're just recovery codes by a different name and with a built-in hint. I could reset the password of half of my friends from what I know. For a random person, I could probably just use something like this https://www.fastbackgroundcheck.com/people/gavin-newsom/san-francisco-ca https://www.fastbackgroundcheck.com/people/gavin-newsom/san-... and get almost all the way there. As a user, if you want guessable recovery codes, that's fine. It's all in the threat model. The password for this account is very guessable. It used to be 000000. I don't care about any possible threat to it.
- eli 3y agoI don't think most users care much one way or the other. But they do sometimes lose their credentials and need a password reset and if the reset flow assumes you'll be able to answer those questions anyway, you're going to have a bad time.
- ghaff 3y agoIn general, you don't want a forgotten password to be a "sucks to be you" situation or even a come to a physical office with two forms of ID situation.
- cvalka 3y agoAwesome
- electrondood 3y agoCan we just have financial penalties per compromised user for these companies already?
- gruez 3y ago*statutory penalties You can already seek financial compensation through the tort system[1]. It just sucks right now because you have to demonstrate harm, which is hard. Having a law that's like "each breach equals $50" makes lawsuits go much more smoothly. [1] eg. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_Equifax_data_breach#Litigation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_Equifax_data_breach#Litig...
- eli 3y agoAnd it should be punitive. The point isn't just to compensate me for the harm I suffered
- jen20 3y agoIndeed: if companies are to be treated as people, and we are to have a federal death penalty, corporate execution should be the result of breaches like this.
- tedunangst 3y agoAs a Comcast customer, I'd be kinda upset if I woke up one morning and my internet connection was dead.
- vaidhy 3y agoGiven these info loss from major companies, it is worthwhile to assume that your name, your phone number and last 4 digit SSN are pretty much available for any actor. For my part, I have put in a credit freeze with all three credit bureaus. I am wondering what else I should be doing.
- mattwad 3y agoactually I'm pretty sure that all our social security numbers leaked in full since the Experian/TransUnion hacks. I have kept my scores frozen ever since then. It's a minor annoyance but I don't know why this isn't required now
- chatmasta 3y agoThey've been leaked ever since they were shared with anyone other than yourself and the Social Security Administration. Any system using an SSN as a password is fundamentally broken - just the fact that a company can verify your SSN is proof that it's an authentication mechanism known to more than only yourself... (Ok, they could be hashing it, or at least the first five digits of it... but they're not.)
- SoftTalker 3y agoYes. And not just the last 4 but your entire SSN, and most or all of the data that Credit Bureaus maintain, such as date and place of birth, past places of residence, whether you own or rent, income, education, marital status, and on and on. It's all been exposed, somewhere, by someone who didn't exercise due care for protecting it. Until this data becomes a liability and not an asset that can be sold and expoited, it will continue.
- wimp 3y agoIt's all out there, tenfold. It's available to anyone who wants it enough. I've had my identity stolen. The SSA office essentially does nothing to resolve it, they place the burden upon you as the victim to fix an unfixable problem. I didn't even bother. The whole thing is fucked.
- CursedUrn 3y ago
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoWho was the threat actor?
- hoofhearted 3y agoI think based of the Citrix vulnerability alone, there is only one group to look at
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoAnd who would that be?
- hoofhearted 3y agoSame folks behind the OPM hack
- phendrenad2 3y agoTL;DR: Santa Claus, trying to finish up his naughty/nice list last-minute.
- hoofhearted 3y agoCorrect. This is just tinfoil hat speculation of course lol. When this Citrix zero day was disclosed to the public a few months ago, they mentioned nationstate actors. It seems that Santa Clause is finishing up his naughty or nice list before rejoining the little lost island of elves with the rest of mainland North Pole.
- happytiger 3y ago[flagged]
- comcast192784 3y agoNot suprising. When I worked for an Xfinity "Branded Partner" they played it fast and loose with security. During training, a trainer on equal level ranking as a national director told my class full of new hires we should all make our secure internal-use Comcast account password "E@sypassword1", and later in the class told us that if a customer forgot their phone in their car we should just bypass the 2FA completely. why? Because there is a tracker on the door that tracks how many open/closes linked to the conversion rate. The conversion rate was considered more important than properly authenticating accounts. Im pretty sure Comcast knows about this and does nothing. Needless to say, when I made my concerns known I was terminated same day for "not being a good fit".
- meepmorp 3y agoAt one point in the early 2000s, Comcast's internal network wasn't internal. IIRC, everything (workstations, servers, printers, etc.) had a 24.x.x.x address with no firewall or other mitigations in place; you could directly connect to arbitrary ports on any corporate machine, from anywhere. And they weren't exactly on top of patching.
- xyst 3y agoBack when ICANN was just giving any company /8 blocks of IPV4 addresses
- grepfru_it 3y agoComcast didn’t own 24/8, @Home did. Not sure if Comcast was part of @Home. @Home was a coalition of cable providers who didn’t have the technical knowledge or funds to implement their own cable ISP. FWIW, when Comcast finally bought out our neighborhood cable co (mid-2005ish), we never got 24/8 addresses Also throwing more water on your story, Comcast’s internal network was entirely 10/8 for a very long time. Around 2008 or so they went to ipv6 because they ran out of private addresses.
- mixdup 3y agoComcast was an @Home provider (as was AT&T Broadband, which merged with Comcast in the early days) It's entirely possible that as a Comcast customer parent OP was on @home
- jerf 3y ago"The company says for an unspecified number of customers, hackers may have also accessed names, contact information, dates of birth, the last four-digits of Social Security numbers, and their secret questions and answers." Ah, yes, it truly gives me hope for the future of humanity when these hackers break in to a corporate database like this, have total access to all this sensitive data, and then, out of a sense of fair play and comity, run "SELECT * FROM customers LIMIT UNSPECIFIED" rather than just "SELECT * FROM customers". It's so nice of them to access only an "unspecified" number of customer's data rather than all of them.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- a1369209993 3y agoTo be fair, Comcast's database software is probably crap made by Oracle or something. It's not totally implausible that it crashed partway through printing the results of "SELECT * FROM customers" so the last X% was never sent.
- grepfru_it 3y agoWe used MariaDB, Couchbase, Hadoop, etc. May not be the same system you are referring to, but Comcast isn’t some old dinosaur of a company.
- mixdup 3y ago1000% guarantee the billing system is A Very Enterprise Level database like Oracle or SAP and not postgres or MariaDB
- RajT88 3y agoLogged in just now to see if I got the prompt to change my password (I did). The only mail I had waiting in my mailbox was identity theft scam phishing email. Good job all around guys.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jerf 3y agoBut the password reset prompt was, and I quote, "As part of our commitment to you, Comcast routinely reviews and monitors account security. Please update your password to help protect you and your account." No word about a compromise or anything, just corporate bland. Also I got a kick out of their screen "obfuscating" my email to j***rf@jerf.org. Fantastic job there. (Anyone not quite sure what I'm getting at are invited to consider the domain name and my Hacker News nym and come to the obvious conclusion about the clandestine character hiding behind those three secret stars.) Now truly I am safe from those thousands of spams a year I get from spammers shoulder-surfing my email address. I really ought to do something about them. Their harsh whispers as they furtively read my email address into their phones for their accomplices to copy every time it's on the screen make it difficult to concentrate on work sometimes.
- gnicholas 3y agoYep, I remember being forced to change my password a week or two ago. It told me I had to periodically change it, which was weird because I've been with Comcast for many years and didn't remember ever being prompted before now.
- bell-cot 3y agoYet another reason to say "nope" when Yet Another Co. wants me to route my interactions with them through their app or web site, or give them answers to security questions, or ...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- robotburrito 3y agoThis might be bad for Xfinity. A lot of their customers may leave them for a variety of readily available competitors created by the dynamic free market economy.
- dmitrygr 3y agoYou might want to post an explanation for non-Americans about why this is hilarious!
- boredtofears 3y agoRegional ISP markets are usually a monopoly or duopoly. If you're on comcast, its unlikely there is another high speed option out there for you (or if there is, the option is no better than comcast).
- doubled112 3y agoCanada too. Almost every independent ISP is just a reseller anyway.
- phkahler 3y agoStarlink is everywhere Comcast is. It's not the highest speed, but it apparently pretty good.
- jcrawfordor 3y agoA lot of Comcast customers in this audience are going to be on 500Mbps or Gbps plans. Starlink just can't meaningfully compete with these speeds. Most people in US cities will have two options, cable and either bonded VDSL2 or fiber from the telco. Both will be faster and usually cheaper than Starlink. The main competitor in most cases, after the cable company and the telephone company, is LTE. Also faster and cheaper than Starlink in a suburban area, but in dense areas the speeds really suffer. I was on LTE home internet for a good while and enjoyed 100+ Mbps at night but only 20 during the day, due to living too close to downtown. Only $45/mo though!
- tky 3y agoThis on the heels of requiring bank account details to preserve auto-pay discounts, just like their security peer over in wireless, T-Mobile. What could go wrong?
- advael 3y agoComcast is a great example of a company I'd like to see antitrust law literally destroy rather than merely chastise
- orthecreedence 3y agoDo all the big telecoms. Then maybe we'd finally get a real municipal fiber movement going.
- advael 3y agoMaybe the entire class of services that can meaningfully be called "infrastructure" is a bad idea to make the exclusive purview of private, profit-motivated liability shields. Just spitballing
- orthecreedence 3y agoYeah, completely agree. Infrastructure always congeals into monopoly. It's incredibly stupid to even bother letting private industry manage it.
- advael 3y agoSometimes we skip the congealing step and just establish a government-protected but privately-operated monopoly for a regional utility as a matter of course, and this is after decades of failure on the parts of most if not all of these monopolies when compared to similar-sized government-run utilities. Something has got to give
- fuzzfactor 3y agoRemember when AT&T broadband customers across the USA had DSL modems from a mysterious company named 2wire? And besides Ethernet and DSL jacks, they had an unused coaxial connection on the back, the kind that connects to TV cables, but it was not involved with their Uverse TV offering? "You can tell a lot about a culture by its instruments." Plus right around then, almost 20 years ago now, a consortium of internet communication companies formed the Home Gateway Initiative[0] whose original manifesto[1] is a technical document that could form the basis for achieving uniformity among the hardware suppliers and their firmware, especially when DSL was the top offering from AT&T and very few cable providers were any faster. 2wire modems bumped that up a notch for a while by pushing the physical limit for AT&T's aging network of symmetrical copper wire pairs, but Comcast's aging network of coaxial TV cable is still 30 to 50 years newer, plus with its cable having the outer grounded shield surrounding the sensitive data conductor within, it's physically capable of reliably carrying more data faster. Even though the entire cable infrastructure was far from symmetrical, more like a water faucet where content just pours out more so than could be pushed back up. At least the old POTS was a two-way communication network by design. It was only a matter of time before useful cable speeds outran telco infrastructure, and back then I would expect 2wire to have focused on that coming date more so than anyone else. 2wire modems bumped performance up a notch for a while by pushing the physical limit for AT&T, but Comcast wasn't going to quit even though cable was a latecomer and missed the AOL boat that was made possible only by the old telco wiring. All you have to do is read the non-technical first 13 pages of the HGI manifesto[0] to see the way that user flexibility was to be curtailed and completely replaced by "business requirements". The final bullet point of the 13th page is what got me: >o The Home Gateway must support QoS both in the operator network and on the home network side when different simultaneous broadband services are used. In addition, the Home Gateway must support QoS on in-home flows. Different simultaneous broadband services. You mean like telco and cable at the same time? What would that be like, and who would want that anyway? I don't think customers would want to be paying two different ISP's so the initiative must have been initiated by somebody else for some other reason, not disclosed. One thing's for sure, AT&T was poised with their exceptional 2wire modems already in place, a single firmware change away from a merger with cable, not necessarily by starting out with some exchange of shares on Wall Street, but instead by connecting the networks from the bottom up, physically in your home(s). In a way that could have as significant an effect on shareholder value regardless. Now what would that be like? I can only imagine that to make the very best use of all infrastructure resources for all concerned, that sophisticated hardware/firmware could combine elements from all resources by all providers, at a price of course. If you were an AT&T customer, IOW you responded positively to their sales "person", then you would expect to be provided your on-line service over AT&T infrastructure and pay only one bill to that single vendor. But the "perks" of the future could include a special arrangement between AT&T with local cable where their cable service would be connected to the AT&T modem at no additional effort or cost to the consumer, so that on those occasions where you (or others sharing your bandwith in aggregate) might want to effectively download data way faster than the 2 wires of AT&T could provide, well the dual modem would be able to temporarily switch over to the cable source seamlessly. And likewise if you had responded favorably to the cable sales effort instead of telco, and the cable company wanted to provide you with more two-way or upload bandwidth than their infrastructure had at the time, then using the same type of modems AT&T could reciprocate by allowing cable companies to access AT&T's underutilized bandwidth, automatically on demand also. For the most rewarding customer experience? It would have to be by special arrangement like never before. How could you get more convenient than a system that could automatically, with the help of QOS and stuff, provide the best that can be delivered to your exact premises regardless of whether a "competitive" service might have better performance for some types of data compared to others? Whichever provider you have they'll just generously lease any helpful infrastructure from the competitor as needed. Automatically, involving a sophisticated modem. As you go along. And resell it to you at a profit, even if you never see any sign of this on your bill if it did take place. It's got to be rewarding to somebody. Some would say that would be like having somebody's cash register in your house that you are paying for and were not ever aware of to begin with. And it would kind of reduce to a battle of the salespeople who could duke it out after that. Well, that didn't happen. Then again the same 2wire hardware would have physically facilitated a more recognizable top-down merger if one would have materialized, and that didn't happen either. I think 2wire spent more money than the company was worth, just trying to figure out what could be accomplished using the plain old unshielded wire pairs that their network to the premisies consisted of. And was probably no slouch at more accurately determining what Comcast's infrastructure was capable of in the long run also, much more aware much earlier than Comcast itself. Not exactly "their" network, rather AT&T's network. After that Comcast started buying up everyone else. 2wire rode off into the sunset. And here we are now. Customer service worth the money has been smoothly bedamned by all providers, with consumers ending up as predicted in a certain type of hell. . [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Home_Gateway_Initiative https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Home_Gateway_Initiative [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20070124064123/http://www.homegatewayinitiative.org/publis/HGI_V1.0.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20070124064123/http://www.homega... This might be what a fly on the wall would be hearing at the hotel bar when a couple executives run into each other after an early HGI meeting almost 20 years ago; Comcast: "We have a network and streaming content to go with it, not you guys at AT&T WTF?" AT&T: "Ha, we started as a monopoly and have always had seamless operation along with our divested subsidiaries ever since. We're everywhere." Comcast: "Well, we'll get a monopoly and whacha doin' with a monopoly and not jacking up prices to the moon?" AT&T: "OK, we'll deliver some content but can't we just call this whole thing off?" 2wire, a small player hidden in AT&T's pocket silently casting a voodoo spell: "Merge, merge, merge, ca-ching, ca-ching, ca-ching . ."
- lucasjames9 3y ago[dead]
- kderbyma 3y agoComcast is incompetent and unable to handle the very infrastructure it supposedly offers.....break them up and get this shit show outta here
- DoesntMatter22 3y agoHaving worked for Comcast I can't tell you how many times I brought up security concerns and I was told that they were doing better than ever before and its a non issue. Idk which systems were hacked but I worked on thier innermost apps, and they were a dumpster fire.
- iFred 3y agoOh man, xray is just a nightmare waiting to happen.
- liquidise 3y ago> On October 10, 2023, one of Xfinity’s software providers, Citrix, announced a vulnerability in one of its products used by Xfinity and thousands of other companies worldwide. At the time Citrix made this announcement, it released a patch to fix the vulnerability. Citrix issued additional mitigation guidance on October 23, 2023. We promptly patched and mitigated our systems[1] This reads like "we didn't patch until weeks after the vulnerability and patch were provided" but it's worded intentionally unclear to differ blame. > Q: How will Comcast prevent another incident from occurring? > A: We have robust security programs in place which help us to discover criminal activity such as this one You have to love how their response to their own question is, functionally, "we won't prevent your information from being stolen, but boy howdy we'll sure know when it happens though!" As a long-time disgruntled comcast customer, i have to say none of this surprises me. But local monopolies mean my wallet doesn't really get a vote in this matter. 1. https://assets.xfinity.com/assets/dotcom/learn/Notice%20To%20Customers%20of%20Data%20Security%20Incident.pdf?INTCMP=dsi-12152023 https://assets.xfinity.com/assets/dotcom/learn/Notice%20To%2...
- advael 3y agoI wonder how many enormous breaches of so-called sensitive information it will take for infrastructural security to improve. Like I think at this point it's reasonable to assume that most SSNs are public information, and dates of birth arguably always were. Why do important services still use this as a final word authentication for any individual? Why is it legal for a person's credit score for example to affect things like mortgage applications, when these measures are permanently affected by identity theft that could happen to anyone at any time through the fault of one of any number of irresponsible companies that routinely hold enough information to impersonate someone to both the government and their bank (setting aside for a moment how fraudulent and irresponsible the practices of the aggregators of these scores are themselves).
- mensetmanusman 3y agoPass a law requiring each municipality to offer fiber isp.
- yumraj 3y agoIt seems that my info has been stolen by a variety of hackers as part of this and several prior hacks that at this point does it even matter. For all practical purposes I’m sure my info, and almost everyone’s, is out there. Genuinely curious: Does it even matter anymore. I think all one can do is freeze the credit and hope for the best.
- latchkey 3y agoHere is the PDF notice: https://assets.xfinity.com/assets/dotcom/learn/Notice%20To%20Customers%20of%20Data%20Security%20Incident.pdf https://assets.xfinity.com/assets/dotcom/learn/Notice%20To%2... I tried to go to the first fraud alert link in the document: https://equifax.com/personal/creditreport-services/credit-fraud-alerts/ https://equifax.com/personal/creditreport-services/credit-fr... 404
- technion 3y agoWhat hasn't gotten enough attention here in my view is how astoundingly basic this exploit is. https://github.com/GossiTheDog/scanning/blob/main/CitrixBleed.curl https://github.com/GossiTheDog/scanning/blob/main/CitrixBlee... You've got a single curl request to a web service that for magical reasons is running as root. There's no SELinux/jails/etc, and no logs written for this request. Remember this next time someone wants to sell you a WAF: The Netscaler isn't some wiki application, one of the things it is sold for is specifically as a WAF.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- markhahn 3y agowe need to blame the failing party (Comcast here), we need to make customer data outrageously radioactive, so companies like Comcast try hard to avoid storing it...
- ianbutler 3y agoAs a recent Xfinity customer, I am delighted by this update.
- say_it_as_it_is 3y agoIt's probably data that Comcast shouldn't have had in the first place
- chaps 3y agoHeh. Years ago I had a call with Comcast's CISO about them setting up a bug bounty program after I informed them about a leak of exposed information (sysadmin's home dir, with ssh keys and more). They told me that if they setup a bug bounty program like that, that they'd effectively go bankrupt. So here we are. Not expecting them to go bankrupt from this, but it's sad to see how their apathy turns into actual harms.
- midtake 3y agoI have yet to see a large scale hack on services hosted on Linux stacks using basic technologies like SSH. Whenever large companies get hacked and their technology stacks consist entirely of overvalued "security for midwits" enterprise software, I just groan. It irks me that my own information security is orders of magnitude more robust than a company worth many billions. It is clear to me that security is theater to these companies, and that is why companies that resell TLS tunnels with 2000s technology bolted on like Citrix get away with charging so much. It should be assumed that there was no security to begin with. If you told me in 2 years that a foreign adversary had compromised all American companies since 2012 I would not even blink. It is more or less something I expect to eventually hear.
- dangoodmanUT 3y agoThat’s just embarrassing
- sneak 3y agoThe issue with leaks like these is that for wealthy/powerful/notable people (ie targets of blackmail/extortion/threats/surveillance) their non-public residential addresses are now available, making the job much much easier for criminals who work offline. This is why my ISP account at the house where I sleep (as well as all other utilities and services for the address) is not in my name, and does not have my phone number or email address on it. You’re just one data leak away from people from the internet being able to show up at your house in the middle of the night with guns (or outsourcing same to the police with a swatting). I spend a lot of time and money protecting against this type of attack. It’s annoying. There should be real, actual, criminal liability for putting people at risk like this. Maybe if someone publishes the excerpts from these with everyone with the same residential zip code and last name as all sitting US senators, something will happen. Then again, when weev did that (with just email addresses), instead of going after AT&T who leaked the PII through simple negligence, they prosecuted the guy who downloaded it and alerted the press. It’s almost as if everyone not wealthy enough to have staff/managers/shell companies is just expected to not have any privacy.
- betaby 3y agoAll property tax bills are public in Montreal for example. My name is tied to the address literally on the city of Montreal official website.
- mixdup 3y agoThat's easy to mitigate, though, if you have money. Like the parent comment said all you have to do is buy all your property through a shell LLC (or Canadian equivalent), put all the utilities in the name of that LLC, and have your lawyer's lawyer file all the incorporation papers and it's very, very difficult to trace back the actual owner
- forward1 3y agoGood luck getting a mortgage for your shell LLC - won't happen.
- phendrenad2 3y agoUgh get ready for wall-to-wall saccharine Comcast ads crawling into every ad slot to remind us all how much we love the company.
- bsmartt 3y agoI'm not really sure what to think about this yet. I suppose comcast has the consumer customer base so when news like this breaks shade naturally gets thrown their way. But it's hard to fault comcast for having netscaler infra (which i guess was acquired by citrix at some point? dont quote me on that). 9 days to patch isn't really what I call blatant negligence (which is what i'd like to think would make me likely to terminate my contract). It's not always easy to just yank node balancers from your perimiter, especially if you have as large and probably ugly permimeter as comcast does. I'm sure that most people on this site had very little faith to lose in Citrix/Netscaler prior to this incident, so it's not a surprise there's little focus on them here, but as far as the consequences in any form, I really doubt Citrix / Netscaler will face enough punishment. It's also unclear to me exactly what the consequences of this data leaking are. last four of my social? Well, my full social is already out there, thanks to equifax (if no one else). There's also the fact that a large number of companies were and still are being popped with citrixbleed, ransomware has gotten in line for this ride, and i bet it will take 6+ months for 80% of vuln systems to be patched/purged. Again, 9 days? Ars technica's Dan Goodin has two articles about this (ive shortened them a bit): Comcast waits 9 days to patch critical vuln The latest high severity citrix vuln isn't easy to fix come on...