7 ms·
Copyright claim against Tolkien estate backfires on LOTR fanfiction author
- patrickwalton 3y agoHe was just 18 years ahead of his time...smh. 2040 is when Tolkien is slated for public domain.
- OhioMan2943 3y agoOr next year if you live in NZ or have a production studio in NZ
- johannes1234321 3y agoAnd then sell to NZ market.
- mkl 3y agoMuch of (not most of) the world has that same copyright length: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries%27_copyright_lengths https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries%27_copyright...
- sjfjsjdjwvwvc 3y agoSo where can I download a copy before it’s nuked?
- misnome 3y agoI tried all the usual vendors and second hand suppliers but couldn’t find it still listed anywhere :(
- throwaway81523 3y agoIt's on bn.com but it sounds pretty bad based on reddit comments.
- qingcharles 3y agoI can't see a copy on any of the pirate sites.
- jackhack 3y agoFor anyone that enjoyed LoTR/The Hobbit and thinks this new story might be interesting or entertaining, allow me to assure you it is not. The writing is meandering, unclear, futile expository. In a word "amateurish". Being as generous as possible, it is a poor tribute. Less generously, one might call it a lazy attempt to cash in on the legacy of JRR's universe of Middle Earth. The writing bears no resemblance whatsoever to the grand, Elizabethan style of Tolkien. See for yourself: https://play.google.com/books/reader?id=iH6iEAAAQBAJ&source=ebookstore https://play.google.com/books/reader?id=iH6iEAAAQBAJ&source=...
- duskwuff 3y agoOh my goodness. You weren't kidding -- this is awful. Even if it weren't trying to fill Tolkien's boots it'd still be bad writing; the pretension just makes it look even worse by comparison.
- mock-possum 3y agoOh wow it’s so bad I can’t get over HMS Samwise, like he’s a boat
- thecodedmessage 3y agoI am so sad there’s not more LoTR stories. Have written about this before: https://www.thecodedmessage.com/posts/tolkien/ https://www.thecodedmessage.com/posts/tolkien/
- tptacek 3y agoWhy? Write new stories.
- randombits0 3y agoJust keep them to yourself! lol! This is where free expression and intellectual property butt heads. Had our subject merely distributed his writings openly (free), it would be much harder to shut him down.
- saalweachter 3y agoEh, just 20 years to go.
- TillE 3y agoThis is always my argument with "fangames", which frequently get nuked by the copyright/trademark owner. Like, you put years of effort into making a game from scratch, the code is all original, the design is new, why ruin all that by putting in Mega Man or whatever? LOTR is great because it's a unique product of who Tolkien was, with his background in linguistics and experience in World War I and his Beowulf scholarship. Be your own interesting person and make your own stuff.
- deafpolygon 3y agoI never understood why people put so much effort into fangames, fanfiction, etc. I mean - great, they're inspired! No copyright infringement there. Share it with the world. I feel like these days, real creativity is punished, and only 'meme'-able things get rewarded.
- 3y ago
- renewiltord 3y agoWhat, why would he do that? Seems like a marketing ploy gone wrong. FWIW though I rather enjoyed The Last Ringbearer.
- DistractionRect 3y agoThere was no way they were going to make seven unlicensed books without getting sued into oblivion. It's reasonable to summize that they always intended to become an official work. They likely sent scripts/drafts in the past looking to become officially licensed and failed. So, they launched anyways, hoping to become a commercial success and resume talks. Then when they saw perceived similarity between the later released Amazon prequel they saw a chance to force deal. Ideally, Amazon/Tolkien estate settle with the book series becoming officially licensed works.
- shiroiuma 3y agoI haven't read these books of course, but we all probably would have been better off if they had become the basis of Amazon's series instead of what we got.
- metabagel 3y agoYou’re entitled to your opinion, but I absolutely love The Rings of Power.
- shiroiuma 3y agoPersonally, I think the show's creators did a good job with the resources they had and the huge limitations that were imposed on them. The production values were excellent, the costumes (particularly for the orcs) were amazing, the casting and acting seemed good, but the script was really weak. This was probably because of the Tolkein estate: they only allowed them to use the appendices from The Return of the King, and for some weird reason wouldn't let them use the material from the Silmarillion. The show could have been so much better if they had access to that.
- 3y ago
- ben0x539 3y ago> The Tolkien estate then filed a separate lawsuit against Polychron for all physical and digital copies of The Fellowship of the King to be destroyed Huh, is this a thing? You can have someone's personal copy on their hard drive destroyed even beyond stopping them from publishing it?
- readthenotes1 3y agoAnd they will take it from your kindle
- userbinator 3y ago...like they did with Orwell's 1984. Of all the books it had to happen to, it had to be that one.
- jtriangle 3y agoWell you see, you bring the copies up to a heavily fortified volcano city, and you simply throw them in. No you can't use eagles, yes you should consider the courier with much care. Good luck. (which is to say, the idea of digital eradication is imaginary).
- xeonmc 3y agohttps://xkcd.com/750/ https://xkcd.com/750/
- electriclove 3y agoHe sued the Tolkien Estate and Amazon? Why?? After doing that, I’m not surprised they want to shut him down.
- kmeisthax 3y agoBecause authors have not even the first clue about how copyright works. This is at least partially by design, because if they did, nobody would sign ownership away to a publisher. The reason why publishers want ownership is specifically because they get paid way more in the derivative works market than by selling copies of a book. Derivatives are also the reason why the plaintiff lost. Fun fact: fan fiction is not copyrightable, so if you make a derivative work without permission you own nothing. Yes this means it's legal for the original author to just resell your fan work as their own, as the plaintiff alleges (even if it didn't actually happen here).
- ronsor 3y ago> fan fiction is not copyrightable, so if you make a derivative work without permission you own nothing This is false. It's possible for both you and the original author to simultaneously infringe each other's copyrights. This is unintuitive but true due to the simple fact that you own all the original parts of your work.
- seanhunter 3y agoCertainly in the UK it seems you have to have permission from the original rights holder to create the derivative work in the first place. If they didn't have this permission they weren't entitled to create the work and therefore their claim of copyright in the original parts of that work would be moot. I'd be surprised if that were not the case elsewhere https://copyrightservice.co.uk/copyright/p22_derivative_works https://copyrightservice.co.uk/copyright/p22_derivative_work...
- jasinjames 3y agoThis aligns with what I was taught in my U.S. Intellectual property class a few years ago
- WalterBright 3y agoCopyright is about the text, not the idea. I'm not sure of the legal basis for claiming a sequel is a copyright violation.
- saalweachter 3y agoCopyright covers derivative works. There was an interesting weird area of copyright law that comes up every few years; early Sherlock Holmes are in the public domain, but not the final Sherlock Holmes stories [but maybe now? It's been a few years]. So it was legal to create a derivative work based on the early stories, like a movie or your own sequels or whatever, but if you referenced the final canon works, the estate would have you.
- ekianjo 3y ago> Copyright covers derivative works This is so dumb. If early math has been copyrighted all math would be 1000 late by now
- EnigmaFlare 3y agoCopyright only protects "unnecessary", i.e. creative work. If there's only one way to do something (eg. maths), it can't be protected by copyright. If copyright is an obstacle to somebody creating something, they always have the freedom to create something different and just as good instead.
- deafpolygon 3y agoSimilarly to how recipes can't be copyrighted, but the text prefacing it can be.
- throwaway81523 3y agoThe infringement can go in both directions though. The fanfic obviously infringes Tolkien but it's not so obvious that Amazon doesn't infringe the fanfic. That was a common scenario with unsolicited scripts for TV shows. Some Star Trek viewer writes a script where the Enterprise is turned into a pumpkin, sends it to Paramount for consideration, Paramount says no thanks. Next thing you know there is a Star Trek episode with the Enterprise being turned into a pumpkin and oops, the amateur scriptwriter sues. The script is a work derived from ST, but the episode with the pumpkin is potentially derived from the slushpile script. So now there is a fight about whether Paramount developed the idea independently. For that reason studios are very careful about exactly how and when they will accept script submissions from outside their usual stable of writers.
- throwaway81523 3y agoBook review here (March 2023): https://indiereader.com/book_review/the-fellowship-of-the-king/ https://indiereader.com/book_review/the-fellowship-of-the-ki... It was being sold commercially on amazon. What a doofus. It is gone from amazon but still on bn: https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/book/1142895065 https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/book/1142895065
- vinaypai 3y agoGlad to hear the copyright troll got his comeuppance. I just wouldn't have expected a large estate to be in the receiving end of the trolling.
- edgarvaldes 3y agoI'm totally fine with fan fiction and derivative works. Just mark it as such. If some quality stuff arises, great.
- advisedwang 3y agoWould you be fine if they were derivative of your work and their sales (in the case of a commercial project like the one in this article) cut into your bottom line?
- josefx 3y agoWe could ask JRR himself what he thinks about getting ripped of by 90% of the fantasy genre. A lot of sold works are comparable to badly written fanfiction with inly a thin pretense of originality.
- dessimus 3y agoBeyond the use of the "Hero's Journey" meta, I'm not sure what 90% of fantasy rips off from JRR. Not even Tolkien invented the concept.
- duskwuff 3y ago> I'm not sure what 90% of fantasy rips off from JRR. Popular conceptions of fantasy races (elves, dwarves, goblins, orcs, trolls, etc) are heavily indebted to Tolkien's portrayals of them in his works. While many of them were based on concepts from European (and especially Scandinavian) folklore, Tolkien's representations of those races were much more specific and different in character. For instance, folkloric "elves" ranged anywhere from midgets to fairies to demons. Tolkien's nature-attuned immortals were a substantial departure from these traditions, and have suffused popular culture to the degree that they're now the default interpretation of "elf" in most contexts outside Christmas. The "orc" is an even more extreme example; the word was attested in some Old English texts but was long extinct in English by the time he borrowed it for a race of evil creatures in The Hobbit.
- TheAtomic 3y agoThe rich stay rich, and control our culture. Tolkien has long since left this and Middle Earth.
- colechristensen 3y agoAre they rich? Regardless, something has gone wrong when a creator’s retirement aged grandchildren win lawsuits regarding rights to their grandparents creation. Most of us should earn more from the long tail benefits from our work, but the copyright situation is just ridiculous.
- Perenti 3y agoPretty sure the Tolkien Estate is managed by Saul Zaentz, and he was a fool to try to sue him. He has a _very_ long record of defending the IP very very strenuously.
- huxley 3y agoNo Saul Zaentz (who has been dead for almost 10 years) used to own Middle Earth Enterprises (previously Tolkien Enterprises) which was a division of the Saul Zaentz Company but now is owned by the Embracer Group. Zaentz bought the Worldwide Exclusive film and tv rights to the Hobbit and LotR from United Artists which bought them from Tolkien. All of which is separate from the Tolkien Estate and the Tolkien Trust which is managed by Tolkien’s family.
- melagonster 3y agocall yourself book perfect and try to shame on author's kids is very different.
- EvanAnderson 3y agoPerhaps this will provide the incentive J.R.R. Tolkien needs to write some more books.
- xref 3y agoHe’s probably happy resting on his laurels and cashing the checks.
- lproven 3y ago/me can't tell if this is parody. As, apparently, nor can this fanfic writer, with their parody of a pen-name. Just for a laugh: JRRT would be 131 if he were still alive. He published 45 books; he wasn't slacking. His son Christopher, whom I met once, spent his whole adult life editing together his late father's works, and would have been 100 next year... and he nearly made it.
- nadermx 3y agoI suppose this would sway the masses if by giving copyright many more years after death, it caused long deasceaded authors to unearth themselves in order to squeeze out one last work.
- freejazz 3y agoI get the snark, but are you seriously going to argue that an author has no interest in providing a livelihood to their family and/or offspring, even past their own lives? That seems absurd and in defiance of the economic system we live under.
- EvanAnderson 3y agoThat's a system that has been lobbied into existence in the last 100 years. I think it's a bad thing for society, and society has a lousy lobby.
- freejazz 3y agoThe term of copyright has been extended recently, yes. But copyright is in the US constitution and has existed for much longer than 100 years. As to doing well for one's offspring? I think that is a concept that is older than 100 years...
- BramLovesYams 3y agoOn does not simply take on the Tolkien Estate in a copyright lawsuit. It is folly.
- Borrible 3y agoSlightly amused, I did some research and came across the case of Marion Zimmer Bradley, who once had to defend herself against the ghosts she herself had conjured. https://fanlore.org/wiki/Marion_Zimmer_Bradley_Fanfiction_Controversy https://fanlore.org/wiki/Marion_Zimmer_Bradley_Fanfiction_Co... My precious. There must be some LotR/Darkover crossover out there somewhere.
- courseofaction 3y agoShould Tolkien sue the Danish mythologists, or should another derivative work sue Tolkien?