10 ms·
Desalination can beat batteries for excess energy
- somethoughts 3y agoIs the idea to use excess solar power to desalinate salt water instead of mine crypto currency? At a high level that seems smart. It seems like the general idea is to build out excess capacity on the desalinization side and run the desalinization plant at less than full throughput during peak consumer demand (i.e. peak of the duck curve?).
- mdale 3y agoLol. Almost like making drinking water and water that can be used to grow food is a better use of energy than boiling a small ocean of water on math designed to create artificial scarcity :)
- dragontamer 3y agoThe opposite. The various policies we have are for Aluminum Smelting plants, Desal, and other heavy-electricity industries to use excess solar (or nuclear) power during peak-energy times, and to turn off during peak-usage times to help balance the grid. On an individual level, we might be able to even do this for air-conditioning, washing machines, or car-charging (if you have a PHEV or EV). Cryptocoins then perverted the models we created to earn money from this through mining (using energy during peak-energy and turning off during peak-usage). But the "intent" for those laws has always been for industry and/or individual grid-level issues. -------------- For low-utilization machines (ex: washing machines and dryers), this makes perfect sense. The main issue is that for high-utilization machines (ie: all industry wishes to run at 100%, rather than 80% or 50%), you end up doubling or more the cost of CapEx. Ex: You'll need twice as many Desal plants if they only operate during the most efficient 50% of times during the week. Which might be worthwhile, but you have to run the math. Every hour these plants are shutdown for power-saving purposes is an hour that they are sitting away / depreciating.
- vlovich123 3y agoI can’t imagine that’s how industries could actually run. I think they can benefit from cheaper costs to absorb excess electricity or reduce capacity slightly when it gets too expensive, but shutting down an aluminum smelting plant seems like a non-starter as they need to run constantly 24/7 and require long startup/shutdown times. Same goes for desal - you’re not going to economically produce sufficient amounts of water just trying to time the energy grid. https://www.reddit.com/r/AskEngineers/comments/3g78nj/are_aluminium_smelters_switching_to_daytime/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AskEngineers/comments/3g78nj/are_al...
- dragontamer 3y agoI agree. Nonetheless, some industry are willing to give it a test to see how feasible it is. https://www.lightmetalage.com/news/industry-news/smelting/trimet-starts-trial-operation-of-its-virtual-battery/ https://www.lightmetalage.com/news/industry-news/smelting/tr... > “We have reinvented the electrolysis process for the production of aluminium. For the first time, we will be able to vary the energy supply during operation significantly. This will allow us to react to changes in the electricity supply, which will benefit the power supply to households in Essen,” says Philipp Schlüter, CEO of TRIMET. “As an aluminium producer, we are naturally an energy-intensive company. As such, however, we are also a valuable partner for the energy revolution.” > The €36 million trial installation converted a total of 120 furnaces in hall one of its Essen plant, which will be able to consume either 25% more or 25% less energy for up to 48 hours. The energy requirement can also be reduced to zero for up to an hour, if necessary. This means up to 2,000 megawatt hours of electricity can be stored for use in the energy revolution. ----------- It requires new smelters, new software, new engineers. Its all very expensive. But it might be worthwhile. Just don't go like... crazy... with the idea right? There's downsides, but the upsides are immense. Keep an eye on the costs and practicality, and give it a test. It might be worthwhile. That's my outlook anyway. Maybe Aluminum specifically is run too close to 100% utilization to be useful (we do have a very predictable amount of Aluminum...), but maybe other industries have a more start/stop and feast/famine kind of setup that would benefit from off-hours automation for energy price optimizations and/or even grid-tie stabilization. But there are _real_ Aluminum plants giving this idea a test. So this isn't "vaporware" or even "theoretical". This is a real test occurring today. ------------- We have to ask ourselves: is a 2GW-hr battery the best thing to build? What if Aluminum-smelters could instead vary their load by +/- 25% with this new software/manufacturing mechanism? What costs more, the 2GW-hr battery or this software + manufacturing change to Aluminum plants? In both cases, we get 2GW-hrs of "energy storage". EDIT: IE, varying your load each day is a form of energy storage that should be considered by members of society. It may very well be cheaper to achieve 2GW-hrs of virtual energy storage by upgrading industry, rather than trying to build impossibly huge amounts of Li-ion batteries.
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoConsuming energy productively > storing it? Well, yeah...
- tantalor 3y agoWhat's the difference
- vlovich123 3y agoStoring it lets you feed back that energy at a different time (e.g. night) but requires a lot of expensive hardware (i.e. batteries) + you have to deal with losses involved with storing & retrieving that energy. Consuming it directly doesn’t require batteries and desal plants are cheaper than battery plants + going to be fewer losses. It’s a stupid comparison though because the point of batteries is to get to net 0 and desal plants don’t help with that. But it’s not a great sign for renewables achieving net 0 at the grid level that a process that is so energy intensive for getting so little water out is a better use of electricity than batteries.
- jeffbee 3y agoDesal plants do help by giving renewables something economically valuable to do in the spring when energy output is being wasted.
- vlovich123 3y agoOnly because you have to overbuild more solar capacity than you need to with nuclear/hydro/fossil fuel plants which have a more reliable method of operation.
- toast0 3y agoIf you live somewhere that desal is the way you get your drinking / irrigation water, it makes sense that rather than storing energy to run desal continuously you can run desal intermittently and store water. You already need infrastructure to store fresh water for later use, and storing water for later use is relatively low loss (depending on the scale --- outdoor reservoirs can have a lot of loss). There's always a question of capital costs, of course: does it make more sense to have a higher capacity plant with a lower duty cycle where the duty cycle that uses mostly off-peak priced energy, or a lower capacity plant with a higher duty cycle which uses on-peak priced energy much of the time. Most energy consumers don't care about getting to net 0, they want to pay less for energy, if energy is a large part of their input costs. Intermittent operations do help get to net 0 though --- if all energy intensive uses could handle intermittent operations, it allows for more intermittent generation. It certainly doesn't get you all the way though; there's lots of uses that won't work well without continuous energy.
- governmentdude 3y agoAnother good use is making hydrogen for ammonia.
- varelse 3y ago[dead]
- brilee 3y agohttps://www.moderndescartes.com/essays/factobattery/ https://www.moderndescartes.com/essays/factobattery/ I looked at a variety of these ideas and most of them are bad. Desalination is another one I looked at quickly (did not add it to the blog post), but I recall it being at least 10-100x more expensive than just buying batteries.
- cogman10 3y agoI think the desal math changes a bit because it also produces a product beyond just batteries. For particularly arid or water poor locations where you need desal anyways, seems like this could be a win (think islands or the middle east). That said, you'd probably still want batteries to supply power to things like a desal plant when water levels are low.
- thelastgallon 3y agoThe lifetime of a Li plant is just 10 years? Batteries lose a bit of capacity at 10 years, maybe still have 80 - 90% capacity. These can run for decades.
- vlovich123 3y ago> New research shows that hybrid energy grids that rely on a mix of renewable and fossil fuel energy are up to the task, so long as the timing of freshwater production is right. In some situations, it may even be more financially and energy efficient to put that generated energy toward desalination rather than store it in batteries for use later. And this is why I remain skeptical of renewables as base load energy. The only carbon free base load energy tech remains nuclear which is also perfectly capable of performing desal during off-peak times.
- tmoertel 3y agoGeothermal also works for carbon-free base load, and newer drilling techniques made it viable in areas without high surface heat.
- barbazoo 3y ago> And this is why I remain skeptical of renewables as base load energy. Someone should tell countries like Germany then \s https://www.reuters.com/business/sustainable-business/germany-aims-get-100-energy-renewable-sources-by-2035-2022-02-28/ https://www.reuters.com/business/sustainable-business/german...
- himinlomax 3y agoGermany is currently producing nearly half of their electricyt from coal and gas right now. https://app.electricitymaps.com/zone/DE https://app.electricitymaps.com/zone/DE
- tsimionescu 3y agoYes, someone really should. Germany is currently one of, if not the, worse polluters in the EU, by far. Compare it to France, which produces most of its electricity from nuclear power, and thus produces almost half the CO2.
- barbazoo 3y agoFirst sentence from the linked article: > Germany aims to fulfill all its electricity needs with supplies from renewable sources by 2035
- DelaneyM 3y agoIt’s fascinating that this is a paper - we did the math about 20 years ago and have been using excess electricity for desalination in Cayman ever since.
- thechao 3y agoTexas tried to do this in the early 2000s; we even built a bunch of desalination plants (here's a comment about this I made recently): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38422172#38424191 Long-story–short (based on my experience with these chuckleheads): it was killed because the current political establishment didn't own the desalination plants, so there was no way they could personally profit off of them; they own oil/gas/fracking & ERCOT.
- passwordoops 3y agoSadly that's just about true for most things, whether it's city state or federal. God forbid Congress tries to tackle the health care industrial complex, it might hit their portfolio!
- m463 3y agoIsn't there an unused desalination plant in santa barbara? EDIT it seems like it may be back on? https://www.sbck.org/our-work/advocacy/water-supply/desalination/ https://www.sbck.org/our-work/advocacy/water-supply/desalina...
- huytersd 3y agoIt’s very much back on and expanding.
- atoav 3y agoTexas generally seems to have chosen an odd path politically, which to me has been strangely highlighted by their failure to supply their own people with electricity. Aside from the usual left-right dichtomy¹ one could start to consider to just elect people who at least pretend to care about the problem. Electricity has become kinda important. ¹: A divide that is seen more as a centrist — far-right divide from my european perspective.
- datadrivenangel 3y agoReally impressive simulation of using fresh-water storage tanks as energy storage in regions that use desalination. The cost of overbuilding desalination capacity is non-zero though, and energy is only about ~1/3rd of the typical cost for a cubic meter of water overall depending on the plant, so the marginal savings may not be as big as we would like here.
- p1mrx 3y ago> this economic efficiency “mostly vanishes” under scenarios with 100 percent renewable grids, says Conejo, because the cost of producing electricity is similar throughout the day. I don't understand this statement. Shouldn't the cost of consuming electricity vary as the supply of renewables changes throughout the day?
- thebruce87m 3y agoIn the UK we have cheaper energy tariffs at night for charging EVs. It’s about a quarter of the price as during the day. As I understand it this is because we overproduce on renewables at night.
- Animats 3y agoIf you only run the desalination plant when energy is cheap, plant cost per liter of water goes up. May or may not be a win. Probably a win for small, isolated plants, say for powering and watering a small island. Large grid-connected plants, don't know.
- thelastgallon 3y agoWater probably isn't grid connected like electricity. Nor does the supply need to perfectly match the demand every second. There is quite a bit of water storage in the system. There might be pumps, in addition to just gravity assisted transportation of water. When energy is cheap, we can do both desalinate + transport.
- cperciva 3y agoYou're missing the point. If you need 24 m^3/day of fresh water, you can have a desalination plant producing 1 m^3/hour and a water tank to match supply to demand. But if you only want to run the plant for 3 hours/day when electricity is cheap, you now need a plant which can produce 8 m^3/hour. There's a tradeoff -- spending more building the desalination plant makes it possible to run at a lower duty cycle so you can spend less on the electricity.
- laurencerowe 3y agoBut mainland desalination plants are connected to the electricity grid. The problem with only running them part of the time is that the fixed capital and other operational costs of the plant are now split over a smaller amount of water produced so that water is more expensive than if you ran the plant all the time paying more for electricity at other times of the day.
- morepork 3y agoThere is certainly a trade off there, does the cheaper electricity compensate for the fact that you need to add say 20% extra capacity and the accompanying costs to your desalination plants as they will now be idle during low renewable production/times of high electricity costs.
- jimnotgym 3y agoIf you electrolyze seawater, to make hydrogen when the grid is over producing...and then you burn it to produce electricity when the grid is in need....can you capture the waste water from the exhaust... and call the entire process desalination?
- loufe 3y agoThe energy conversion losses in the cycle you describe are enormous.
- thsksbd 3y agoNot enormous, but not insignificant either.
- jimnotgym 3y agoBut are they more or less than reverse osmosis?
- fbdab103 3y agoIf energy becomes "free" does it matter? If solar continues on its current trajectory, there needs to be some kind of sink to utilize the energy or it is all going to turn into bitcoins.
- cordenr 3y ago+1 The "fully charged show" sometimes have videos on this and similar topics. This [0] video goes through the pros and cons of using hydrogen in different ways My takeaway is that as much of the energy as possible should be used without converting it. This avoids the substantial losses converting to and from hydrogen. But storage is one of the viable uses. [0] https://youtu.be/MgmBkvrO0Dg?si=8c-y3naRRH65O4Lb https://youtu.be/MgmBkvrO0Dg?si=8c-y3naRRH65O4Lb
- thsksbd 3y agoI worked on this a little bit. You still need to energetically pay the entropic cost of separating salt from water, and the kinetic over-potential (on the electrodes). Also these cells hate running in reverse. Ruins their lifespan. Overall it is still not viable. Your idea to use it to iron out the economics, though, might have some merit if the price fluctuations are high enough (which is what motivated us to begin with)
- thelastgallon 3y agoAlso, we can charge EVs. Grid connected batteries may or may not use the energy, but EVs will use some portion of it every day, and can be charged again the next day when there is excess energy. Power price goes negative +200M times/year, just in the US and it is increase. It would be wonderful to get paid for charging EV. Tesla Electric customers report making as much as $150 a day[1]. Car batteries are bigger than powerwall, EV owners can make quite a bit of money by participating in VPP (Virtual Power Plant). (1) https://electrek.co/2023/07/05/tesla-electric-customers-report-making-150-day/ https://electrek.co/2023/07/05/tesla-electric-customers-repo...
- sandworm101 3y agoIt would take a great many discounted electric bills to justify the extra wear on the batteries that would result from the extra daily charge/discharges.
- led76 3y agoI'm not sure it would have much of an adverse impact. Driving the car is constantly charging / discharging it (regen braking). I think it's more about how deep the cycles go -- just don't let the grid drain below like 30-40% battery and it likely would have no meaningful impact long term.
- sandworm101 3y agoI'm not sure it a totally rational thing. This is effectively putting more miles on your battery, an item that costs tens of thousands of dollars to replace, if even possible years after purchase. There would have to be a substantial compensation for such use even if it only degraded the lifetime a few percent. But at such a compensation level, one could probably just purchase deep cycle lead acid marine batteries. They could sit in one's basement charging/discharging at a much lower cost than the lithiums in a car.
- thelastgallon 3y ago
- breischl 3y agoThis seems like a special case of the general concept that matching electricity demand to supply is important, and whereas a fossil fueled grid has enough dispatchable power sources to match supply to demand, a renewable-powered grid has to instead match demand to supply (at least to a much greater degree). So it's interesting, although at some point it seems unnecessary to enumerate that this same concept applies to every possible source of electricity demand.
- AtlasBarfed 3y agoI get this is useful for a huge overload of wind or solar power, but this doesn't address base load and offpeak generation usage. The headline reeks of oil/gas companies pushing an agenda to keep gas turbine a critical part of the baseload infrastructure and keep grid storage from developing.
- gwbas1c 3y ago> freshwater tanks are cheaper than electrical batteries, it seems appropriate to fully exploit the ability of tanks to displace energy production/consumption, and then, if needed, to use electrical batteries for the same purpose What about the cost of additional desalination equipment needed to take advantage of energy peaks? In a situation like this, is extra desalination equipment needed when renewable energy peaks? Or, do current desalination systems have periods where the equipment is idle?
- stephen_g 3y agoShould this kind of observation be especially surprising for anyone? There are some round-trip inefficiencies to any energy conversion and/or storage system, so using electricity directly if you can is always going to be better than storage - that doesn't mean storage is bad or less important, but it's a tool that we should try and reserve as much as possible for when it's really needed. It's easy to demonstrate the same thing on a small scale - at my house with hot water heating for example, I run my electric (heat pump) storage hot water heater in the middle of the day, and it almost always runs 100% from solar power (sometimes with extremely cloudy or rainy weather it uses some grid power). I don't have a battery system yet, but I'm doing the sums - and if I relied on instantaneous electric hot water heating so was heating water on demand mostly outside solar hours, even before thinking about the lower round-trip efficiency I'd need a far bigger (and therefore much more expensive) battery system than I will now for the same hot water load. If you're in an area that has less sunshine but more wind energy, the principle is basically the same, you just have to time it for when there's excess wind energy, but it just seems very obvious that if you can shift high energy use tasks to those times that's always going to be more effective than using batteries, and doing so makes the battery storage cheaper for the electricity use that you really need it for...
- hedora 3y agoI think you’ll find the kWh used by any water heater will be negligible, but that the peak kw of the on demand one would force you to buy giant batteries. We ended up getting a hybrid heat pump water heater. It is very efficient, but we have to wait for the water to warm up at the tap. If it were easy to change, I’d probably put in a recirculating system that keeps the water hot in the pipes (not sure how much electricity that wastes though).
- tlb 3y agoThe question is whether the round-trip inefficiency of storing energy is greater than the cost of having energy-consuming equipment that sits idle when the sun isn't shining and gets stopped and started frequently. For example, aluminum production is famously energy-intensive, but I've read it's not good for the equipment to start and stop it frequently because the reaction happens in molten aluminum salts and it hurts the equipment when you stop and it solidifies. And while Bitcoin is energy-intensive, it's also capital intensive for the chips so it's not cost-effective to run it only part-time. Reverse osmosis may have a good combination of high energy:capital ratio (so it doesn't waste a lot of capital on idle equipment) and not requiring complex startup/shutdown sequences.
- pxeger1 3y agoWith dynamic electricity pricing, wouldn’t this just happen anyway by market forces?
- ljlolel 3y agoThis is the same argument for bitcoin mining with excess energy!
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoThe more general headline is probably "flexible demand"/"time-shifting" is cheaper than short term storage.
- kilotaras 3y agoAn acquaintance of mine was looking into the general area of using cheap electricity. The pitch is "Instead of looking at storing energy efficiency, look at things that become profitable if energy is really cheap, but only for the fraction of the day". This demand in turn will drive building more generating capacity.
- bequanna 3y agoHmm what options are there for this? Pumping water, Bitcoin mining, what else?
- pjfin123 3y agoI think we should build giant desalination and water distillation plants in the American Southwest where there's a lot of sun for solar power. Then we can pump the water inland and reclaim enormous amounts of currently unusable land.
- Hithredin 3y agoThis is just naturally solved by capitalism, no magic. When electricity on the grid is cheaper, all intensive applications can run at that time. Just make the difference of price worth the pause of the industry when electricity is scarce.