9 ms·
Men should abstain from drinking at least three months prior to conceiving
- bell-cot 3y ago> He also noted that it doesn’t take excessive alcohol use ... > “In the models we’re using, even drinking three to four beers after work several days a week can induce [bad stuff for sperm],” Golding said. “You may not feel inebriated, but your body is going through chemical changes.” Vs. the CDC's current upper limit for "moderate" male drinking is 2 drinks/day, and they're very quick to specify that "a" beer is at most 12 oz. of 5% ABV (or 8 oz. of 7% ABV, or ...). One 16 oz. pint of 7.5% is two drinks. That said, with how many acres of "skin in the game" it is to become a father - I'd say to abstain for 6 months. If nothing else, it sends a loud "I'm taking daddyhood d*mned seriously" signal to your wife.
- whoomp12341 3y agoin northern culture, the CDC's recommendation is laughable. Excessive drinking is a regular thing where its cold
- eropple 3y agoSure, and during COVID we kept the liquor stores open--so alcoholics in withdrawal weren't a problem when we had bigger fish to fry. Do you think that's a good thing?
- syntheticnature 3y agoLess about mere "dry drunks" -- which refers to someone who is sober but still stuck in the behavioral traps that led to drinking -- and more about the medical support required for abrupt detoxing from alcohol.
- eropple 3y agoPoint taken, edited.
- hiAndrewQuinn 3y agoMaybe for you. Moving to Finland and seeing that a six pack cost as much as a month's worth of breakfast was all the motivation I needed to kick the stuff.
- vfclists 3y agoShame about the war. If not for that you could just cross the border over into Russia and obtain it much cheaper.
- Scoundreller 3y agoEstonia is still accessible (and they drink more than Russians, on average).
- hiAndrewQuinn 3y agoIt is too late my friend. I only wish to cross the itäraja to buy even cheaper breakfasts
- askonomm 3y agoPretty sure Finnish people jump on a ferry to get cheap booze from Estonia instead. Just like Estonians jump on a bus and get cheap booze from Latvia. Where Latvia goes however, I do not know.
- _3u10 3y agoSome of us live in free and warm countries with no matriarchical nanny state. Gov't doesn't take half my income, and doesn't charge me an arm and a leg to have a beer.
- hiAndrewQuinn 3y agoI moved from the US of A my man lol
- _3u10 3y agoAn excellent choice, I would have picked eastern europe, south america, or asia instead of finland tho.
- rpmisms 3y agoIt's probably some deep DNA-induced craving. In the summer I barely want to drink. When it's cold... I want to drink. Maybe it's the Slavic chunk of my DNA.
- giardini 3y agoKnew a fellow from Texas sent to manage a business in Russia for 6 months. He was in excellent cardiovascular health when he left. 6 months later he returned with 15 extra pounds of weight. His story: arriving in Moscow he found it brutally cold and began to drink under friends' advice. He later reported back that "you need to drink vodka and eat like crazy to keep warm and keep you body weight up" in that cold climate. Anyone else heard this? Does alcohol perhaps keep all the bad stuff(lipids et al) in your blood in solution better in cold weather?
- nkozyra 3y ago> Anyone else heard this? Does alcohol perhaps keep all the bad stuff(lipids et al) in your blood in solution better in cold weather? No, but it sounds like a great excuse for alcoholism.
- neaden 3y agoAlcohol makes you feel warm, but crucially it doesn't make you any warmer and by bringing blood closer to the skin makes you get colder faster.
- magicpin 3y agoAlcohol is very caloric. A single shot of vodka can have 100 calories. Also it can increase blood flow to the skin, making you seem warmer than you actually are, at the expense of your internal body temperature.
- koolba 3y ago> A single shot of vodka can have 100 calories. Using the standard 7 calories per gram of alcohol, the alcohol content of a 12 oz 5% beer (equivalent of a 1.5 oz 40% shot) is 117 calories (12oz x 28g/oz x 5% x 7 Kc/g). That’s just the alcohol and an average beer would have been more from the additional carbs. If your vodka shot has only 100 calories, that’s either a weak pour or some weak vodka!
- OkayPhysicist 3y ago
- u32480932048 3y agoSee also: the recommended 2000 calorie diet
- reliablereason 3y agoI would say that 3-4 beers several times a week is allot of alcohol. It is an amount where I would definitely start to think that ones life would be degraded in certain ways by the amount of alcohol consumed. Where I live the recommendations are that people that drink 10 or more units of alcohol per week should be provided support from the healthcare system to reduce their drinking.
- calvinmorrison 3y ago90% of alcoholic drinks are consumed by the top 10%. Something like 40% of people don't drink ANY alcohol, another 10% a few times a year, 10% maybe once a month, the last once a week, and the final group, drinks 10-20 drink per day...
- CalRobert 3y agoFor anyone curious about a source, there's https://archive.is/j3lg3 https://archive.is/j3lg3 . Though I still vaguely recall looking at the source data (now lost to linkrot) and thinking that they had misinterpreted it.
- jollyllama 3y agoAren't you missing the group in between the last two that has two a day?
- UberFly 3y agoNope. It goes from 1 a week to 20 a day. Slippery slope I guess.
- hef19898 3y agoI couldn't help by reading your comment with Seth Mayers immitating Bernie Sanders in my head. Nor could I help posting this, sorry...
- zelos 3y agoExactly. Maybe I’m just a lightweight, but 4 beers is into ‘drunk’ levels for me. Doing that 2 or 3 times a week? Of course that’s going to have health impacts.
- bwhaley 3y ago3-4 beers after work several days per week seems like a drinking problem imho.
- aswanson 3y agoIt is.
- hef19898 3y agoDepends on the beer. Measuring one beer as we donin Bavaria, in at least half litres, and meaning by multiple times a week more than three days, maybe. By measuring beer in 0.3 and 0.2 litres, ans assuming the average US beer, even doing so 5 days a week propably doesn't get into abuse territory by the alcohol amount alone.
- gowld 3y agoIn US culture/science, one "drink" or "beer" is 0.5oz of alcohol. Beer is often 12oz of 4% alcohol. Wine is 6oz of 9%. Liquor is 1oz or 50%, etc. There are stronger drinks, but in this scientific context should be considered multi-drinks. People not understanding this unit scale causes a lot of problems, like teens having 20-30oz pours of alcohol like it's (also ugh) soda or juice. I wonder if European science and US science get muddied due to different "drij" sizes.
- standardUser 3y agoThe average beer is closer to 5%, few wines are as low as 9% and nearly all mainstream liquor is exactly 40%.
- newaccount74 3y agoI can't speak for all of Europe, but in Austria no-one speaks of "drinks" when talking about alcohol consumption. This concept of a standard "drink" size is foreign to me and I know it only from US literature.
- 3y ago
- mistrial9 3y agoalcoholism is a particularly harsh curse in the North of Europe! A tourist went to Edinburgh Scotland for the holidays. So much whiskey and pub life all around. Herbal tea in hand, the tourist said "wow, its hard to get used to how much drinking there is here!" and the reply from a friendly local "hey this is nothing, you should see the Irish! they are certainly the worst drinkers". SO the tourist moved along to the big city Hamburg, where money is obvious and the ships are as large as anything in the world. In downtown bars, the working class and the financiers are all taking their fill. The tourist after going to the gym says "Germans in Hamburg seem to drink quite seriously" and a well-dressed local said "oh this is nothing, the Russians! the Russians are the worst drinkers by far" .. so the fast International train is waiting in the big Hamburg station, and the tourist goes to Copenhagen, land of the Little Mermaid and Christiana bike shops. Obviously beer is the fifth food group, and red noses are common. The tourist makes the same observation at the town square. A local replies "oh yes, Denmark loves their beer, but the Norwegians ! what a sight, they are certainly the worst alcoholics overall" The tourist walked over an empty package of cigarettes and said "they are all a bunch of tankards to me"
- InCityDreams 3y ago>Vs. the CDC's current upper limit for "moderate" male drinking is 2 drinks/day, and they're very quick to specify that "a" beer is at most 12 oz. of 5% ABV (or 8 oz. of 7% ABV, or ...). One 16 oz. pint of 7.5% is two drinks. Doing maths when drunk is fun, and the cdc be damned. Nobody understands the difference between one drink, and two drinks = one drink, as well. We all work in pints and litres. What damage/ fun is a 500ml of 9% beer costing me? Half a pint of 4.8%? Nobody asks for 8oz of beer. Do they......?
- wizardwes 3y agoYour average glass bottle or can is 12 oz. That's not some arbitrary measurement, it's literally the most likely size for you to get. Sure most people aren't asking for an (imperial) cup of beer, but the idea is to recognize how much you're actually drinking.
- bell-cot 3y ago> Your average glass bottle or can is 12 oz. True, at least in my part of the US. Though larger cans seem to be a growing trend. And "on tap" beer is very often served in other sizes. OTOH, 5% ABV seems to be anything but the norm.
- _3u10 3y ago> That said, with how many acres of "skin in the game" it is to become a father - I'd say to abstain for 6 months. If nothing else, it sends a loud "I'm taking daddyhood d*mned seriously" signal to your wife. The key is finding wife who takes having children more seriously, it's not that difficult.
- spiderice 3y agoI'm not sure what you mean. In the scenario GP is talking about, I read it as the wife already being serious about having children and not drinking is one way for husband to show he is also serious about it.
- bell-cot 3y agoCorrect...except there's also the "she is unsure, his behavior might be persuasive" scenario.
- scruple 3y agoI quit for ~5 months with our first (we had spontaneous fraternal twins) and ~4 months with our second. It would've been longer but we conceived the first month we started trying in both pregnancies. It seemed self-evident to me, at the time, that I should do everything I could to "clean" myself up. I stopped eating fried food, stopped drinking calories besides milk, ate more fruits and vegetables, etc. My wife doesn't drink so she didn't have to change her lifestyle much.
- gus_massa 3y ago> That said, with how many acres of "skin in the game" it is to become a father - I'd say to abstain for 6 months. If nothing else, it sends a loud "I'm taking daddyhood dmned seriously" signal to your wife.* I'd read that as : Instead of following sound medical advice, he is making up rules based on single study of dubious quality. He will probably make up more rules once the baby is born. Run! There is a lot of snake oil about baby care. You would get 2 or 3 different incompatible advice from different pediatrician. An interesting one, is which food the baby can eat during the first year. The common element is honey because it's difficult to pasteurize. But each doctor, nurse, magazine, ... adds a few things to the list. And it's more interesting to compare common list from different countries, that have a different additional food that are very bad for the baby.
- AlecSchueler 3y ago> If nothing else, it sends a loud "I'm taking daddyhood d*mned seriously" signal to your wife. Also to yourself, surely? Why is the wife here being framed as the judge of moral character for the other parent? Men also have agency and the ability to self-reflect.
- the_sleaze9 3y agoAm I missing something - what negative effects are there? > "I need to program the offspring to be able to adapt to that kind of environment" What does this mean?
- Baxxter 3y agoSeems to be suggesting that FAS is some kind of adaptation. I'm no expert but I'm pretty sure that FAS is an adverse effect, rather than a response.
- giardini 3y agothe_sleaze9 asks "what negative effects are there?" The partner one chooses: after 4 beers one may mate with anyone having a appropriately-matching part!
- mrkeen 3y ago> Am I missing something - what negative effects are there? Paragraph 1: > Researchers at Texas A&M University have already shown that paternal drinking habits prior to conception can have a negative effect on fetal development — with semen from men who regularly consume alcohol impacting placenta development, fetal alcohol syndrome (FAS)-associated brain and facial defects, and even IVF outcomes.
- black6 3y agoYes, but what are the impacts?
- the_sleaze9 3y agoYup, I managed to miss it. Thanks!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- caturopath 3y agoThis is a research report, and despite the recommendation being about as non-harmful as you can get, it shouldn't be used for health advice. Even systematic literature reviews are a stretch for health advice as opposed to tertiary sources, such as the CDC or Mayo Clinic websites.
- AlecSchueler 3y agoI've got a couple of questions about this. Maybe they were covered in the paper but I couldn't see the link? Let me know if I missed it. 1. What do they mean by "changes in sperm?" What are they actually measuring here? 2. Is there previous evidence that these changes in sperm are linked to FAS, or are we extrapolating from the known effects of motherly drinking? 3. They say 3-4 beers a couple times a week is enough to notice the changes, but do we know how big that change is and if heavier drinking leads to A) higher incidence of FAS or B) worse outcomes of FAS? Anyway, wish me luck. I'm expecting a baby now since 6 weeks ago after becoming an alcoholic during the Corona period. I "only" drink one to two beers per evening but I'm sure that more than covers the case of "moderate drinking." I experience withdrawl when I go even only one day so I'm sure there's some effect for sure. Right now I'm hoping for the best and hoping the power of good socialisation can trump any hopefully small damage I've already done to my child's brain.
- lm28469 3y ago> Alcohol can affect fertility by altering sperm count, size, shape, and motility. > Animal studies have provided clear evidence that offspring sired by ethanol-exposed males in the absence of maternal ethanol exposure showed more adverse behavioral development11, including increased risk of anxiety- and depression-like behaviors7,10, increased in activity and sensorimotor integration deficits, as well as decreased balance, coordination, and short-term motor learning https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-05611-2 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-05611-2 https://www.escardio.org/The-ESC/Press-Office/Press-releases/Fathers-to-be-should-avoid-alcohol-six-months-before-conception https://www.escardio.org/The-ESC/Press-Office/Press-releases...
- AlecSchueler 3y agoDamn. I was hoping the best on the basis that my own father liked a drink, and knowing that at least my own intelligence level was fine. But "anxiety- and depression-like behaviors, increases in activity and sensorimotor integration deficits, as well as decreased balance, coordination, and short-term motor learning" sadly sounds like a pretty good description of my own life's history. At least if I know this ahead of time I can coach my child with it all in mind and lean harder into self-care solutions for managing anxiety etc. in a way that I might not have done otherwise.
- lm28469 3y agoAnd not be obese, and exercise regularly, and don't smoke, and.. and ... Yeah so basically being in good shape means you're in good shape, we need more studies to prove it! Surely the 10th study will make people more serious about it
- actualhuman 3y ago[dead]
- epcoa 3y ago“Oh, we are living in an environment that has a really strong oxidative stressor in it. I need to program the offspring to be able to adapt to that kind of environment” Wow. Just wow. And people are surprised why it’s so easy to make people categorically distrust “science”. These “researchers” have no sense of academic integrity.
- u32480932048 3y ago"Something, something, Darwin" ought to be a journal
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- TrackerFF 3y agoWould be a lot less kids in the (western) world if men were to follow this advice.
- amelius 3y agoBut maybe it evens out in later generations?
- UberFly 3y agoThe US and EU already have declining fertility rates when you take immigration stats out of the equation.
- mrtksn 3y agoThats's just a natural behavior of people who are having it good. It happens everywhere, even in Turkey the fertility rates slid into the "catastrophic" range as the life quality of the people increased. When in places where tragedies are happening, the fertility skyrockets.
- karaterobot 3y agoBoth statements can be true. And I think alcohol consumption is also declining, isn't it? At least among people at the age where having children while drunk is most likely.
- jandrese 3y agoBut average alcohol consumption has also been decreasing, quite substantially compared to a century ago. Maybe we should be drinking more.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoWell ... not sure how well that would work, since I suspect that drinking often has a big part in the decision to ... er ... conceive.
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoOr rather the absence or decision to not conceive. I really hope vasalgel is going to lead somewhere, but something tells me if such a tech is available, the birth rate will be going down a lot faster.
- asylteltine 3y agoPeople should abstain from drinking forever. It’s an awful habit. Extra calories, extra money, extra body damage. For what?
- whateveracct 3y agofun, for one
- irusensei 3y agoBecause I want to.
- baud147258 3y agosome fun. Some courage (well, it's more removal of inhibitions, but that works out to the same thing). Ok, the courage might be a good or a bad thing, depending on the situation
- OJFord 3y agoYou presumably drink only water and eat only Huel (or similar just-add-water nutritionally complete powdered food), then?
- skeaker 3y agoYes to water. Unfortunately I've already been chemically addicted to foods that taste good but are bad for you. If I didn't have that addiction and didn't care about taste then it would absolutely make a ton of sense to eat a "no more hunger" capsule daily, you'd save plenty of time and money and would be a lot healthier in general.
- mp05 3y agoGood red wine is one of life's most blessed gifts.
- lgessler 3y agoIn a sense you're not wrong, but would you say the same thing about refined sugar? Both of these substances, in terms of immediate physiological effects, are known to be unambiguously bad for you past a certain low threshold. But immediate physiological effects are probably not the terms with which we ought to evaluate our lifestyles.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kaldev 3y agoNo
- AlgorithmicTime 3y agoColor me skeptical... people have been drinking for thousands of years. I would be terribly surprised if moderate drinking had a statistically significant effect. Either way, this is an irresponsible recommendation at a time when birthrates among native populations are falling precipitously. Adding yet another mental/physical hurdle to having kids is the wrong thing to do. Shit, next generation in South Korea will be 40% the size of the current generation with the way things are going.
- francisofascii 3y agoI don't see it as adding a hurdle, but rather giving people, who might be trying to conceive, a hurdle to avoid.
- tstrimple 3y agoColor me skeptical... people have lived without antibiotics for thousands of years. I would be terribly surprised if their use had a statistical effect.
- AlgorithmicTime 3y ago[dead]
- biasedestimate 3y agoPerhaps important to note that this result comes from a lab experiment done on mice, with as far as I can tell N=24 mice split in a control and two treatment conditions. I would be very careful concluding anything from that study about what human males should or should not do.
- heyoni 3y agoTell you what though, I drank more than I should have most of my adult life and now have a kid with a single point mutation that'll affect her in all sorts of ways and I will never stop thinking about whether or not this could have been avoided by not drinking.
- thehappypm 3y agoI think you can forgive yourself. Single-point mutations are just about the most random things that can go wrong. A cosmic ray can cause one.
- GuB-42 3y agoI think it is very important to mention. I don't know how accurate mouse models are for alcohol, but alcohol tolerance varies widely among animals, and even between humans. We have complex metabolic pathways for alcohol, we even get quite a lot of calories out of it. And while both mice and humans are mammals, I guess there are significant differences regarding reproduction too. So going to a study on mice to some conclusions like: you should abstain from drinking for at least 3 months, and quantitative measurements like "moderate drinking", which, at about 3 drinks/day is more than "moderate" to me. After a quick look at the paper, there is no such conclusion. When it comes to humans, there is not much more than "maybe it is something worth looking into".
- hinkley 3y agoOr the shorthand: … in mice.
- 0____0 3y agoHow does this pertain to if a male only drinks alcohol a few times a year, but consumed alcohol once within a month of conceiving? Reading the article and looking at some of the linked papers, it seems that the research more looked at males who drank regularly. I am sure zero alcohol is best, but interested to know if there is any info or research on the effect of sperm with rare alcohol consumption, but close to conception.
- JoshTko 3y agoThis is a mouse study. Seems questionable as mice would not need to adapt to regular alcohol consumption anywhere near the level humans would have. The length of impact on humans would probably be different than mice.
- jpdus 3y agoDoes nobody question how they get from a non-preregistered, 9-mouse study (where the treatment group gets only 6%-10% acoholic drinks and nothing non-alcoholic for 10 weeks) to this headline? Addtionally: > First, we did not generate offspring using the cessation males. Therefore, we do not know if the sperm noncoding RNA signature we identified correlates with changes in offspring fetoplacental growth or if the resulting offspring would develop normally. However, as significant differences in the ncRNA signature of EtOH-cessation sperm and epididymal mtDNAcn remained, we speculate that abstinence for 1 month is insufficient for the epigenetic memory of paternal alcohol exposure to abate, likely due to the ongoing stress associated with alcohol withdrawal.45, 46 Furthermore, we acknowledge that our analysis does not distinguish between changes in sperm ncRNAs that are causal drivers of altered epigenetic programming in the next generation versus abnormalities that are merely additional symptoms of alcohol-induced stress. I´m all for science on alcohol abuse and effects of moderate drinking, but this doesn't look like solid science for me (especially as afaik, there is still very few reliable, double-blind controlled evidence on epigenentic effects at all). But please correct me if I´m wrong (worked with biotech companies on admission studies for several years but no biologist myself).
- yamazakiwi 3y agoI would be interested to see how places like Korea or Australia with large drinking populations would differ from dry places.
- ghusto 3y agoSounds like an easy place to get great data for their hypothesis. Compare places like Saudi Arabia with England. Sure it's messy because of the other factors to consider (since it's not an experiment), but if there are zero cases of what you're looking for, your own experiment is probably wrong.
- u32480932048 3y ago"Stuffing half a dozen or so mice with booze and not giving them water for months gets them FUCKED UP, so forward this article to everyone whose husband drinks more than one tbsp of beer a week to prove that their child is gonna have all kinds of nasty birth defects" - The Science™
- none_to_remain 3y agoIt seems bizarre to consider the effects of maternal drinking during gestation and these postulated effects of paternal drinking prior to conception to be the same disease
- m3kw9 3y agoAlcoholics coming here to dispel the study.
- u32480932048 3y agoTeetotalers coming here to apply small-N animal study to humans.
- tedchs 3y agoOTOH, lots of babies wouldn't have been conceived at all if it weren't for a little booze! </joke>
- tshaddox 3y agoI don't follow these things particularly closely and I don't consider myself particularly concerned with health issues, but for some reason I always had it in my head that the general rule of thumb was six months of no alcohol before trying to conceive. Weirdly this article seems to be portraying this three month rule as a shockingly strict new development.
- hackernoteng 3y agoI drank regularly, so did my wife, and we had no problems conceiving (usually pregnant on one try). Both kids are healthy. Wife did NOT drink while pregnant or while breast feeding. I therefore drank enough for both of us during those times.
- ghusto 3y ago> ... (usually pregnant on one try). Both kids are healthy This word, "usually" ...
- hinkley 3y agoI know someone who got pregnant on vacation with their husband because they ran out of condoms and thought one time wouldn’t be statistically significant. I would presume “usually one the first try” with two kids to mean definitely first time on one, and we are not sure if it was the second or third attempt for the other that took.
- ghusto 3y agoOh, so it makes sense to you too?! Am I in the minority for finding it hilarious that "usually" was used to describe 100% of 2?
- bluGill 3y agoIn humans no birth control at all is about 80% successful in preventing pregnancy, so if they normally got pregnant in just one try that is amazingly higher than normal. More likely he meant first month of daily unprotected sex, which is likely to result in pregnancy, and a common plan for those trying to have kids.
- ghusto 3y agoI meant more that he said "usually", but was referring to exactly _two_ instances. Unless I misunderstood something? It made me laugh :)
- 3y ago
- joduplessis 3y agoSaid nobody in developing countries... ever.
- DoneWithAllThat 3y agoOnce again the headline should more accurately be “says one researcher in a single study”.
- ekianjo 3y agoFrom a study done on... mice.
- VoodooJuJu 3y agoArticle aside, it's very interesting to see the different attitudes toward drinking, how differently people consider what's typical and what's excessive. It seems that the American posters here are outliers in that they consider 2-3 drinks several days a week to be excessive and problematic. In many European cultures this is actually quite normal. It's been nearly 100 years since Prohibition ended, but it seems the Puritan ethos behind the movement is still going strong. It's especially pronounced when the conclusion of a mouse study aligns with that old ethos, while the data and logic supporting that conclusion remain tenuous.
- BillyTheMage 3y agoI'm curious what the percentage of pregnancies are planned? And how does it happen that way? Are people not having regular sex with their partners anymore? Like "okay honey, I got the quarterly sex paperwork ready, better make this count".