6 ms·
People have no idea how efficient farming is. In 1260 the price of wheat was 6- 8 shillings (~1/3 pound sterling) per bushel (60 pounds). By the early 20th ce
by bryanlarsen 3y ago
People have no idea how efficient farming is. In 1260 the price of wheat was 6- 8 shillings (~1/3 pound sterling) per bushel (60 pounds). By the early 20th century, it was about 1 £/bushel. At that point the US became the efficient grower and dominant currency, and so switching from pounds sterling to dollars at the rate at the time of $5/£1 is appropriate. Today wheat is $6.50 per barrel. Put another way, the price of wheat in the dominant currency has ~tripled in 750 years. That's an inflation rate of ~0.1%.
Put another way, a typical Saskatchewan dryland wheat farm is about 5,000 - 10,000 acres per employee or operator in size. That 5,000-10,000 acres will produce enough calories to feed ~100,000 people. (Those acres will also require ~$10M in capital and ~$1M in annual operating expenses)
Put a third way, modern agriculture can provide enough grains and legumes to feed somebody for around 30 cents per day at bulk prices.
- LeafItAlone 3y agoCertain crops are certainly efficient. I’m not involved in ag-tech, but the ideas I’ve seen aren’t really going after the efficient (and government incentivized) crops, but rather the more labor and resource (human and natural) intensive ones as well as ones that benefit from proximity to consumers.
- azalemeth 3y agoYou raise some very good points – but I think that looking at the monetary price of wheat is a particularly bad example in England because of the Assize of Bread and Ale [1] which ran from about the 13th century until being repealed in 1836 (!) and later protectionist issues like the Corn laws [2] across "the empire". In many ways these laws directly tied the strength of the currency to the prevailing value of wheat – a very different sort of gold standard(!) – and occasionally caused massive economic difficulties as a result (I remember a story involving the value of silver, Isaac Newton, and shippers directly clipping or smelting coins and moving the metal to amsterdam to sell at a profit compared to the value of the coin, all indirectly powered by the very variable wheat). Your broader point about the pricing of wheat definitely stands though: in the 13th century, wheat drove the economy; as we got better at trading and ultimately the industrial agricultural revolution both served to reduce the variability of the harvest on macroeconomic climes and ever since really the black death we've been in a society where the relative power of the grain (if not its importance!) has steadily declined. [3] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assize_of_Bread_and_Ale https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assize_of_Bread_and_Ale [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corn_Laws https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corn_Laws [3] https://academic.oup.com/past/article-abstract/219/1/3/1472781?redirectedFrom=fulltext https://academic.oup.com/past/article-abstract/219/1/3/14727...
- a_cardboard_box 3y agoPut a fourth way, every second the operator works can feed about 4 people for a day.
- GeoAtreides 3y ago1 employee - 10 000 acres - 100 000 people fed We can have free unlimited food for everyone today maybe not free unlimited saffron, but flour(s), legumes and nuts, potatoes could be distributed for free (subject to some rationing, 5000Kcal per person per day). This is not utopian, this is technical possible right now.
- veddox 3y agoThere‘s no such thing as a free meal. Of course you could distribute free food to all your citizens (the Ancient Romans famously did), but somebody still needs to pay for it. It‘s not just about on-farm labour, you need big machines (and lots of diesel!), fertiliser, pesticides… And that‘s before you look at all the rest of the food system, because to put a meal on the table you need the whole supply chain (ag-tech, fertiliser production, food processing, wholesale suppliers, etc.) In modern agriculture, the farmer only gets a fraction of the money you pay for your loaf of bread, because there are so many other people involved.
- GeoAtreides 3y agoMachines and free energy (solar, for example) make free meals possible. Maybe if we can reduce the need for profit we also reduce the need for fertilizers, maybe the relation between fertilizers used and crop productivity is not linear (-20% productivity but -40% fertilizers?). Food processing won't be necessary: why have a factory for chips? or for hummus? _Most_ people can cook. The thing is, contrary to other things, like fusion, this is possible. Now more so than ever; we have everything we need to start a food UBI. The rest are just accounting details, like how less rich the 1% should be to fund all this.
- veddox 3y ago> contrary to other things, like fusion, this is possible. Of course it's possible, I'm just saying it's not (and can never be) free. "Free for consumers" simply means somebody else paid for the costs - or more likely, the consumer paid the costs through taxes rather than at the store. You will always have input costs to produce an output, and these will not be negligible. Just a few points on what you said, and these are not "accounting details": (1) Solar energy is not free - you need to build, install, and maintain panels and a power grid. (2) Of course you can reduce fertiliser, organic farming does so and takes ~20% yield decrease (depending on the crop). But then you have higher labour and machine costs to control weeds, and an overall higher per-hectare price. (3) Food processing matters because you probably don't want to spend most of your day milling your grain ration to make flour that you can then bake into bread. Ditto for other types of staple foods (you want to make your own sausages?). (On a historical side-note, here's a write-up of how ancient food systems worked: https://acoup.blog/2020/08/06/collections-bread-how-did-they-make-it-part-iii-actually-farming/ https://acoup.blog/2020/08/06/collections-bread-how-did-they...). Bottom line: Food systems are incredibly complex!
- pvaldes 3y ago> modern agriculture can provide enough grains and legumes to feed somebody for around 30 cents per day This just 30 cents for feeding are not real. Wheat is not the same as bread. It must be processed. Baking bread for 100,000 people will require also a lot of energy and water that aren't free normally. Would be 30 + X cents.
- anfilt 3y agoWhere do you think the term daily grind comes from. People used to grind their wheat everyday and then use it for cooking/baking.
- LeafItAlone 3y ago> Where do you think the term daily grind comes from. People used to grind their wheat everyday and then use it for cooking/baking. I’m confused. Are you trying to refute their statement? Or just throwing out a tangential information?
- Whoppertime 3y agoThe daily grind is you manually processing the wheat at the cost of your own labour.
- obmelvin 3y agoAlmost no one does that though, so I'm confused as to the point you are trying to make? Even the people who do make their own bread usually don't grind their own wheat.
- anfilt 3y agoI was just saying you could use a little time to get flour. It does not have to be money. An other thing I could mention is wheat berries are common ingredient in soup. Just cause it has not been processed does not mean it's useless.
- AtlasBarfed 3y agoBut modern agriculture isn't really sustainable. It wasted land that represents ecosystem destruction, wastes groundwater, wastes soil, requires pesticides, and petroleum for fertilizers. Not that any very farms fundamentally address these issues, but to say it's perfect is wrong. Yes by modern economics measures it is efficient, but modern economics still treats any environmental concern like a frivolous side issue.
- Whoppertime 3y agoIt was unsustainable during the American Dust Bowl or Ukranian Holodomor but in contemporary terms it is sustainable by judging their track record.
- LarsDu88 3y agoHey just because something is really efficient doesn't mean it can't be even more efficient. The innovation space should be more centered on turning agwaste into value added products though