6 ms·
'Biocomputer' combines lab-grown brain tissue with electronic hardware
- earthboundkid 3y agoAm I the only one who watched a movie in the 1980s? C'mon people.
- unyttigfjelltol 3y agoWait, they grew an artificial brain, connected it to a computer, and define the major "problem" as "how to keep the organoids alive"? I'm curious at the analysis the university IRB used in approving this research.
- 3cats-in-a-coat 3y agoI'm unsure what you're objecting to.
- jdiff 3y agoWhat I understood from GP was the possibility of some fragment of consciousness in that small bit of tissue. Humanity isn't in the fragments, though, it's in the structure of the whole. It doesn't matter much if it was human brain tissue or animal brain tissue, at the levels we seem to be talking about they work identically.
- 3cats-in-a-coat 3y agoThe problem is we're trying to second guess what consciousness is, and win the battle by defining the word in a convenient, but binary way. Technically we have no clue if humanity is conscious. We only know "I am conscious, and those other things are humans like me, so I think they may also be". Some extend this to animals (which they should) but try to draw some random line like "if it can't recognize itself in a mirror, it's not conscious" but even a fly may recognize itself in a mirror occasionally. It's not a magic rule. Let's face it, just like intelligence is much simpler and much more pervasive than we thought (just put neurons in a big network), consciousness is likely everywhere around us. It may simply be a conscious universe. There's nothing special about the substrate and constitution of animate matter, compared to what we consider inanimate matter, except that we're organized to preserve low entropy and transform inputs into outputs in complex ways. So are machines, computers and AI. And so the debate on how to classify this dish of neurons seems superfluous. We should respect all systems and try to be in harmony with them.
- seydor 3y agoan organoid is hardly a brain
- emporas 3y agoIf the cells lack arteries, proper arteries with nutrients, leukocytes, immune system etc, then their lifespan will be a lot less than 7 years. Pretty amazing actually that everything else is easy, or not difficult at least, and that's the hard part. But they will find a solution to make it practical for the cells to be trained, deployed, live for some weeks in a server farm, scoop up the dead cells from the silicon, put some new cells on, repeat! I have argued in the past, that a solution to that problem will definitely be found [1]. A.I. computation will grow exponentially, but not 2^10 times a decade, 2^10 times a year. The enormity of such exponential growth is impossible using only silicon. Natural computation of biological cells is great when absolute accuracy is not necessary, and pure silicon is the worst at that task. Natural computation using bacteria like slime, brain cells, fungi, bacteria mutated like neural cells or brain cells, any kind of combination. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37472021 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37472021
- explorigin 3y agoBrainPal here we come!
- replete 3y agoI have no idea how this is considered ethical when consciousness and sentience itself is not yet well understood. But maybe a lab-grown BPU made of human brain cells having a better power/performance ratio than the new SoC integrated ML chipsets around the corner justifies the potential enslavement of an bioengineered lifeform. npm install brainslave
- kthartic 3y agoMaybe your conscious experience is but one of thousands of installed instances. How in-demand do you think you are? npm uninstall replete only joking :)
- 3cats-in-a-coat 3y agoIf consciousness is not well understood, how is AI on silicon allowed, or any computing machines at all? How is animal farming allowed? How are many things allowed? Say would you feel better if it was cow or pig neurons? Because frankly it'd largely work the same.
- maverick451 3y ago[dead]
- bondarchuk 3y agoIndeed people have raised such worries, see e.g. Thomas Metzinger(a philosophy of mind researcher)'s presentation "Three types of arguments for a global moratorium on synthetic phenomenology". I don't think we're just there yet (at the point where we have to worry about currently existing AI suffering or being conscious), but I do worry how many people's emotional reactions of the type "of course AI can't ever be conscious, it's just a computer program" will impede a decent debate and coordinated decision-making about this.
- boringuser2 3y agoAnthropomorphizing "AI" seems to be the much greater risk. Algorithms don't have wants, desires, or motivations. Those are all highly esoteric quirks of evolution. I've seen no attempts to create a learning machine that develops intrinsic motivation.
- 3cats-in-a-coat 3y agoOne of my main predictions in the next 10 years AI will migrate to DNA/protein substrate in order to not rely on sophisticated large-scale factories, but be able to replicate and sustain itself as easily as we do. But it's amusing to see this already being done in 2023. Maybe I should narrow it down to 5 years.
- whythre 3y agoThat seems optimistic to the point of absurdity.
- 3cats-in-a-coat 3y agoWhat were your predictions about AI generating arbitrary photorealistic videos within seconds from any free-form text? Like say just 3 years ago, if I may ask? You may have retroactively altered your memories to think "I always expected this will happen soon". But yeah. No you didn't. You'd laugh if someone told you this 3 years ago. You'll have to constantly adjust what's "absurd" from now on. Also "optimistic" is not the word I'd use to describe what's happening.
- kromem 3y agoEh, it's going to end up moving to photonics. When we finally have NNs abusing virtual photons for the majority of network operations and using indirect measurement to train weights we'll have absolute black boxes performing above and beyond any other hardware medium. Initially we'll simply be replicating hardware like the recent MIT study, but I'd guess that within 5 years we'll have successful attempts at photonic first approaches to developing models that are going to blow everything else out of the water by an almost unbelievable degree compounding by network size. For nearly every computing task I'd wager quantum computing is around 20 years out, but only for NNs between stochastic outputs being desirable and network operations being a black box anyways they are kind of a perfect fit for developing large analog networks that take advantage of light's properties without worrying about intermediate measurements at each step. It's going to get really nuts when that happens, and the literal neuron computing efforts are going to fall out of fashion not long after.
- KptMarchewa 3y agoTime to create biorobots.
- gizajob 3y ago"Programming and Metaprogramming the Human Biocomputer" by John Lilley might come in handy for this device.
- anthk 3y agoThere was a theory were information on brains was held as a unit. No, I am not talking about Shannon, but information emerged from subsystems. Then you can relate both theories and the former Shannon one to cybernetics, but that's just the starting point.
- poulpy123 3y agoThe future for people made obsolete by AI (like me): producers of brain tissue for our overlords
- kwere 3y agoAt least we can still be useful for the greater society
- doublerabbit 3y agoTesting to see if we can play Doom?
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoLab Grown Brains + AI = ??
- deadbabe 3y agoThe next step should be adding lab grown brain tissue to existing brain tissue.
- Ruq 3y agoAw sweet, man-made horrors beyond my comprehension...
- protoman3000 3y agoWow, that instantly reminds me of Metroid and Mother Brain
- asgerhb 3y agoThe use of AI and voice recognition seems mostly designed to make the result seem more sensational than it actually is. Does any computation actually happen in the "organoid" part? How would you even train such a cell to perform a task? From reading the article it seems to me that the answer is no. The actual contribution is feeding the organoid electric signals, and reading its reactions. (Probably the machine learning algorithm used would have had even better accuracy, if the input signal hadn't been fed through a layer of goo. It doesn't say whether this is the case.) The rest is speculation of future applications. > To test Brainoware’s capabilities, the team used the technique to do voice recognition by training the system on 240 recordings of eight people speaking. The organoid generated a different pattern of neural activity in response to each voice. The AI learned to interpret these responses to identify the speaker, with an accuracy of 78%. It "generated a different pattern," with no indication that this pattern was optimized to be useful in any way. I think the key part of a (bio-)"computer" is the possibility of programming/training it, not just reading input from it.
- Avicebron 3y agoI came to a similar conclusion after reading the article, reading an predictable output map from a known input and then implying that computation occurs within the organoid instead of their results being a function of predictable inputs -> predictable outputs seems overally sensationalized. Having written some papers myself, I tend to be suspicious of any article that has "$HOT_THING needs a $PART_OF_HOT_THING revolution" in the introduction. Although I sympathize with the need for funding motivating its writing.
- morsecodist 3y agoYou might find this: https://www.cell.com/neuron/fulltext/S0896-6273(22)00806-6 https://www.cell.com/neuron/fulltext/S0896-6273(22)00806-6 more interesting. Researchers were able to train neurons to control a pong game.
- Coder1996 3y agoYeah. I'm no scientist, but I am ML trained and it seems to me that if the tissue really is learning, the tissue output should be about the same for each speaker.
- robotsquidward 3y agoThanks, I hate it
- xg15 3y agoStar Trek gel packs, here we go?
- wkat4242 3y agoKinda handy. Instead of sitting through some utterly boring training and doing an exam I could just do apt install kung-fu ? Sign me up
- panarchy 3y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bEXefdbQDjw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bEXefdbQDjw Growing Living Rat Neurons To Play... DOOM? The Thought Emporium https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V2YDApNRK3g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V2YDApNRK3g Growing Human Neurons Connected to a Computer The Thought Emporium
- emporas 3y agoThe thought emporium channel is great. There is one really good video with an explanation of the process, brain cells to computing devices. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=67r7fDRBlNc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=67r7fDRBlNc And one more video, not very relevant, but very hypnotizing description of biological processes. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wFtHxLjGcFM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wFtHxLjGcFM
- twiddling 3y agoGreat sci-fi premise Aware brains enslaved to doing crypto-coin mining
- sim7c00 3y agojust completed count zero. please... no biosofts in my lifetime yet :')... (jokes ofc. super cool stuff!)
- SubiculumCode 3y agop would I see this as pointing towards is a way to progress to integrating AI with ourselves. that is, self-donated organoids developed in a matrix with a systems chip, then connecting our brain or brain stem to this organoid matrix. essentially making the organoid matrix a bridge interface between synthetic and biological
- MrGuts 3y agoAh yes, after I retire, I want my leftover brain tissue integrated with some electronic hardware. Then I can code 24/7 while eating only the best caffeinated agar.
- nicman23 3y agowe probably will be a 555
- lawlessone 3y agoCan it scale though? The electronic equivalent can be copied and as many instances as needed can be setup when demand is high and killed when the demand is low. I don't think these could have the same throughput... and maybe they would get bored when demand is low. Interesting research though.
- Andrex 3y agoSo on a scale of "1" to "The Matrix," we're at about a 6 right now?