4 ms·
> I don't get it, so no company can provide a walled garden You can provide a walled garden. But that's not Apple does. Instead, Apple is a mafia that shakes
by cyberax 3y ago
> I don't get it, so no company can provide a walled garden
You can provide a walled garden. But that's not Apple does.
Instead, Apple is a mafia that shakes down all the vendors for the right to sell in their semi-open market square.
If Apple iOS were a walled garden, it would have contained only Apple applications.
- dantheman 3y agoThe mafia shakes down people who don't interact with them, apple does not.
- Wowfunhappy 3y agoHow do I develop a mobile app which a majority of people in the US will be able to use without interacting with Apple?
- spiderice 3y agoFigure it out lol. That’s what Apple had to do. Why are you expecting a free pass to do what took them decades?
- smoldesu 3y agoBecause decades ago, "figuring it out" entailed visiting a website and downloading a software installer. Why is Apple expecting everyone to forget about that and pay them the difference instead?
- CharlesW 3y agoYou create a web app or website.
- vineyardmike 3y ago> a mobile app which a majority of people in the US will be able to use Even using Apple, you can't do this, because you need a separate Android and iOS app already. Big picture though, I don't think you really have a "right" or entitlement to just access everyone. You're not entitled to use someone else's business, even if it's a good one. You can't just go and sell your product in the AT&T store, you need to agree to their terms. Even if you make a phone that only works on the AT&T network, you still need to agree to their terms. You can't sell in Target or Walmart or Costco or even Amazon just because you want to. Oh and you may be quite disappointed to discover many of them take >30% cut too. Apple thinks of the iOS App Store as another storefront, and you need their permission to put your product on their "shelves". The courts agree.
- wvenable 3y ago> Even if you make a phone that only works on the AT&T network, you still need to agree to their terms. Prior to the 1980s, AT&T, as the dominant telephone service provider in the United States, had a policy that only allowed customers to use telephones that were leased from them. This policy was rooted in the belief that non-AT&T equipment could harm the telephone network. Does that sounds familiar? Several legal cases (and the eventual breakup of AT&T) eventually opened up the AT&T network to third party phones and consumers rejoiced.
- EA-3167 3y agoPhones aren't infrastructure, the telecom network is.
- kmeisthax 3y agoPart of Epic's argument was that they wanted Apple and Google to distribute Epic Games Store, which makes your argument valid. However, the commenter you were replying to likely isn't aware of this and does not care about how they install EGS, only that they are able to do so if they do not want to deal with Apple or Google. The sneaky part of Apple's counterargument is that they try to apply your argument not to their own App Store, but to the entire OS. This is a land grab - the App Store is their service, but I own the phone, so the OS should respect my decision to circumvent Apple's curation if I so choose. If I'm not allowed to sell in Target or Walmart, I'm allowed to open my own store and people can circumvent Target to go to me directly. This is how it works for every other form of computer except phones and tablets.
- freedomben 3y ago> This is how it works for every other form of computer except phones and tablets. But only because macs existed before they were able to get away with this. I would bet a huge amount of money that if macs were invented/created after the iphone, they'd be locked down exactly the same way. And many of the same people who love it on the phone would love it on the computer, even though now they would say that it's a general purpose computing device not an appliance like the phone is.
- freejazz 3y agoDuh, develop it for Android, where the vast majority of smart phone users exist.
- NicoJuicy 3y agoNah, they shake down everyone they can. They can't shake down someone out of their reach. They can identify them though ( green icon... )
- EA-3167 3y agoI don't think stores have an obligation to carry your products, it isn't like supermarkets are breaking the law because they don't have an open-door policy on products. You don't have some intrinsic legal right to use someone else's infrastructure to sell your own stuff, on your terms. Framing this as a legal or ethical issue leaves me cold, when the reality is just... you'd PREFER higher margins. I get it! I'm not saying that's wrong, it just isn't a legally enshrined right.
- Wowfunhappy 3y ago> I don't think stores have an obligation to carry your products, it isn't like supermarkets are breaking the law because they don't have an open-door policy on products. I agree. However, consumers have the right to go to a different supermarket, without selling their house.
- nostrebored 3y agoAnd supermarkets have no obligation to build expressways to their competitors! We can take these analogy absurdities wherever — the harsh reality is that nobody is stopping someone from building an open ecosystem phone. But there isn’t enough demand. As a consumer, why should I care? As a company, unless I’m building my own walled garden for company phones, why should I care? What’s the market here?
- Wowfunhappy 3y ago> We can take these analogy absurdities wherever — the harsh reality is that nobody is stopping someone from building an open ecosystem phone. But there isn’t enough demand. I don't think there's too little demand, I think there's too much profit incentive in the other direction. Only a tiny number of companies on earth have the resources to build a successful mobile platform. If you are lucky enough to be one of those companies, you're not going to leave money on the table.
- wvenable 3y ago> the harsh reality is that nobody is stopping someone from building an open ecosystem phone. The harsh reality is that manufacturing capacity and network effects actually prevents building an open ecosystem phone. You will never be able to purchase the best chips and displays. I think we need to stop pretending that regulating competition is a bad thing. Competition is what makes capitalism work as an economic system. Without competition capitalism is inefficient and harmful. If we can inject more competition into the system as a whole, wherever possible, it's going to be good for consumers.
- 3cats-in-a-coat 3y agoWhen someone comes to your store and says "I'll wreck your store unless you cut me 30% of your revenue" that's the mafia. When someone comes to your store and says "I made the streets and regulate the power, water supply, sewer, and everything else in this place, cut me 30% of your revenue in taxes" that's the government. And you'd do well to not confuse those so haphazardly. Apple didn't come to your app and with no cause blackmail you to get your money. They created an ecosystem that did not exist before, and they have to maintain it. Paying for it is completely rational.
- cyberax 3y ago> When someone comes to your store and says "I'll wreck your store unless you cut me 30% of your revenue" that's the mafia. That's exactly what Apple does. If you make a mobile app (for example, a presentation manager) you _have_ to support iOS, or you will go out of business. As a developer, you simply don't have a choice. You have to either support iOS, or get out of mobile apps entirely.
- mcphage 3y ago> You have to either support iOS, or get out of mobile apps entirely. What? That’s not true. There are plenty of Android-only developers.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- m463 3y ago> Instead, Apple is a mafia that shakes down all the vendors for the right to sell in their semi-open market square. I think they actually have a monopsony since you can only sell to apple. If there were other app stores, you could sell to them instead. "In economics, a monopsony is a market structure in which a single buyer substantially controls the market as the major purchaser of goods and services offered by many would-be sellers. The microeconomic theory of monopsony assumes a single entity to have market power over all sellers as the only purchaser of a good or service. This is a similar power to that of a monopolist, which can influence the price for its buyers in a monopoly, where multiple buyers have only one seller of a good or service available to purchase from." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopsony https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopsony (And they probably have a monopoly wrt iphone customers)