8 ms·
95%-ile isn't that good (2020)
- CSMastermind 3y agoPrevious discussions: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22265197 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22265197 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30411160 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30411160
- dang 3y agoThanks! Macroexpanded: 95%-ile isn't that good (2020) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30411160 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30411160 - Feb 2022 (156 comments) 95th percentile isn't that hard to reach - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22265197 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22265197 - Feb 2020 (286 comments)
- maclockard 3y agoI love dan luu's blog posts. Great examples of principled thinking. Much of their writing on (computer) performance has pushed my own thinking and expectations.
- barumrho 3y agoIncidentally, I was in the top 10% in my last half-marathon. My next goal is to be in the top 5% (~1h30m). I expect this to take decent amount of effort and more structured training.
- danielh 3y agoThe easiest way to improve your relative ranking is to find a less competitive event :) I recently won my age class in a 10k (6th overall out of 147 men). In a very competitive race earlier this year, the exact same time barely put me in the upper half (242/498).
- brewdad 3y agoThe year I ran the NYC Marathon, I finished in the top 2 percent of men. The winner beat me by 45 minutes. While I wouldn't go so far as to say 95% sucks, there can be a world of difference between that level and the true elites.
- AirMax98 3y ago@dang — pretty annoying that this user is engagement farming by reposting classics. Not great behavior. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31199361 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31199361
- JCharante 3y agoWow they submit like 20 posts a day but I've never noticed their name before
- wharvle 3y ago“95%ile in HN-driven engagement, even among those trying, isn’t actually that good—most don’t even bother to set up a submission cron-job against a list of historically-upvoted classic posts”
- no1pcjfan 3y ago[flagged]
- NooneAtAll3 3y agohe's alone, tho
- eindiran 3y agoPeople post/repost the classics all the time, why are you tattling this aggressively, lol? It just needs a [2020] tag.
- OscarCunningham 3y agoThis fits pretty perfectly with the idea that the 90th percentile is crap: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sturgeon%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sturgeon%27s_law.
- forrestthewoods 3y ago> Note that when I say 95%-ile, I mean 95%-ile among people who participate, not all people (for many activities, just doing it at all makes you 99%-ile or above across all people). I'm also not referring to 95%-ile among people who practice regularly. The "one weird trick" is that, for a lot of activities, being something like 10%-ile among people who practice can make you something like 90%-ile or 99%-ile among people who participate. My probably wrong opinion is that when people discuss “Dunning Kruger” the participants aren’t clearly considering what set of people they’re being measured against. The original Dunnint Kruger study involved Ivy League students (Cornell). I would hope they have high confidence in their ability. They’re genuinely the cream of the crop!
- Jach 3y agoThe author has a great post on the Dunning Kruger paper: https://danluu.com/dunning-kruger/ https://danluu.com/dunning-kruger/ It's interesting that the original paper does not actually justify the popular meme that the phrase became.
- zlg_codes 3y ago> They’re genuinely the cream of the crop! More like the most connected and privileged, but okay.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mkl95 3y agoIt depends. A 95%-ile salary in an average country will buy you a tiny flat in a good area. The equivalent salary in a very rich country will allow you to retire in your 40s.
- ponector 3y agoI assume USA is a rich country. 95-percentile salary is 170k per year. Not sure this salary will allow you to retire in your 40s. Unless you are living alone in depressed city with low costs of living.
- Nthringas 3y agofor a while I've been counfounded by the connection between "they're really smart, they do great quality work" and the simple fact that maybe, they just spent way more time doing the work
- rglullis 3y agoThe argument from Scott Adams is about generalists being better than specialists is in regarding becoming useful/resourceful enough to the point people will pay you for your skillset. No one gets outstanding recognition for being in the 95%-ile.
- wharvle 3y agoI took it as suggesting 75% is aiming way too low for these kinds of even-people-doing-it-don’t-deliberately-practice activities, even if you’re aiming to be a generalist. Rather, that being 95%ile (among practitioners) or better in several valuable skills/areas-of-knowledge isn’t actually an unreasonable goal. I remember a piece on Donald Glover where Glover described discovering a “superpower” that went on to define his life when, after getting his ass handed to him in a casual basketball match as a kid, he simply practiced shots for a few hours that evening, and the next match went very differently. He doesn’t come out and say precisely what the superpower was but I took it as “literally try at all, and put the tiniest amount of thought/focus into how you try”. The implicit observation is similar: going up tens of percentile in skill-level isn’t that hard, because most people don’t thoughtfully try or put in any practice time at all, even those engaging in the activity. Won’t make you elite, but start applying that goal-oriented-practice attitude to several of the kinds of fuzzy activities mentioned in this piece, and you might really get somewhere.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- born2meme 3y agoThe Red Quest had a similar point on the dating scene - ie. guys just aren’t trying very hard and it seems like strange behaviour but if you commit you can get excellent results.
- antisthenes 3y agoGot any sources on this? I'm interested in the stats.
- no1pcjfan 3y agoI personally don’t. Pick-Up has shifted over the years not many people do it the old school way. If you Google up Red Quest, he moved to Substack you can probably find the article. “Most guys just don’t care” or something like that. And it’s true. People would rather get baited into online nonsensical outrage and neuter themselves by playing video games.
- Dylan16807 3y ago> neuter themselves by playing video games. What does that mean? Does trying hard at dating mean not playing video games...?
- AndyKelley 3y agoThis is my sad reality of local multiplayer games like Speedrunners, Duck Game, and Ultimate Chicken Horse. They're super fun, but I'm too good for my friends & family, and too bad for people who take it seriously online.
- wharvle 3y agoClassic “Kid who owns the only Sega in a friend group” problem. Nobody wants to play Mortal Kombat with them.
- zlg_codes 3y agoIt's a big meme in the Smash Bros world, too. Tons of people who beat their friends but get bodied at tournaments. If I could stand the BO or the competitive atmosphere I'd consider it.
- HideousKojima 3y agoI always demolished my friends as Ness (to the point where they renamed PK Fire to PK Cancer) but Ness is one of the least competitive characters in tournaments and I'd get absolutely demolished because he's so easy to counter if you know what you're doing (hint: intentionally absorb his PK thunder when he's trying to get back on stage).
- zlg_codes 3y agoSame with myself and Link. I've been devoted to him the entire series, with side characters for fun, and without fail, he falls to characters with more movement options that can escape the zone and outspeed him up close. Ultimate made him much better with the remote bombs for the mindgames, but yeah I feel it. Solidly mid-tier this time around but still next to nobody playing him at the top, so I haven't seen much pushing of his game. Izaw was big in the Smash4 era and I think T, Tea? A Japanese player still plays him in Ultimate. I keep telling myself if I ever get good at bomb-jumping to recover, my game will explode in potential. Nice to find another Ness player in the wild; one of my IRL friends is a Ness and Lucas main. He was the first I ever played against that could do more than PK Fire and yo-yo. Those matches get rough with PK Fire's angles and how quickly the stick can come out and return that arrow...
- genpfault 3y ago(2020)
- firebot 3y ago[flagged]
- madamelic 3y agoI would have to agree about 95th percentile being not that difficult. A streamer that I occasionally tune into (Asmongold) says that if you are seeking information outside of the game such as watching streams of the game, that makes you a top 10% player automatically. Most people are passive consumers and participants in their activities and that isn't exclusive to the individual. I am a passive consumer & participant in many activities: I have no interest in being more knowledgable in cars / driving, I don't want to get better at cooking, I enjoy chess but I currently have no desire past futzing around with the Chess.com app in the few moments I have. By virtue of seeking out information outside of that context, you are trying to dive deeper into the activity even if you aren't performing at that level. Most software engineers aren't listening to podcasts about software engineering. If you are religiously listening to and learning from podcasts, that makes you more suspectible to being a higher percentile performer in software engineering.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoIt's easy to be in the top 99% in a competition nobody cares about. Try being in the top 1% of basketball players if you're under 5'9". Easier said than done.
- madamelic 3y agoAbsolutely. The article hints at this problem by saying 95th percentile is easy but the grind from 95th to 99th is more difficult, requiring explicit effort and reflection on your process. To use a gaming metaphor that hopefully lands, the XP grind from level 1 to 92 in Runscape is the same XP amount as the XP needed to go from 92 to 99 [0]. It is also illustrated with the Pareto Principle and the 90/10 rule where the final portion takes the most resources. Someone can easily become top 10% basketball player given the right training. 27M people played basketball recreationally in the US in 2021 [1], you only need to be in the top 2,700,000 players to be a top 10% player. There's only about 500 people in the NBA in a given year [2] so they represent approximately the top 0.0018% of organized basketball players. If you include people who play rarely or in pick-up games, the odds of a top 10% 5'9 player jump drastically. 5'9 isn't that short either, it's roughly the median height of an American man. [0]: https://runescape.fandom.com/wiki/Experience/Table https://runescape.fandom.com/wiki/Experience/Table [1]: https://www.statista.com/statistics/191632/participants-in-basketballl-in-the-us-since-2006/#:~:text=The%20number%20of%20U.S.%20Americans,old%20participated%20in%20that%20activity https://www.statista.com/statistics/191632/participants-in-b.... [2]: https://www.hoopsbeast.com/total-nba-players/ https://www.hoopsbeast.com/total-nba-players/
- 303uru 3y agoI'm a pretty consistent top 10 amateur cyclist in Colorado. Some really get wrapped up in it and let it get to their head. The reality though is most people don't ride or race, of those who even race many are there just to participate, now of those who are there to race my percentile has dropped. On the flip side, the truly great riders are overseas and even of them there are just a handful of riders anyone will ever know by name and who are making any money.
- thefaux 3y agoEven within bike racing, defining 99% is tricky. The sport generally punishes all-arounders. In road racing, most winners either have great sprints with just enough aerobic capacity to hang on til the finish or have massive aerobic capacity and anemic sprints. I no longer follow the sport, but riders like Peter Sagan and Julian Alaphilippe were more impressive to me than, say, Chris Froome.
- alistairSH 3y agoTadej has entered the chat. That guy might be the best all-rounder in several generations. Tour wins and strong in the Classics? That doesn't happen any more.
- loeg 3y agoTop 10, or top 10%?
- alistairSH 3y ago
- dwaltrip 3y ago> Some reasons we might expect this to happen are: 1. People don't want to win or don't care about winning 2. People understand their mistakes but haven't put in enough time to fix them 3. People are untalented 4. People don't understand how to spot their mistakes and fix them —— There is another very common reason. It is often emotionally difficult to acknowledge that you’re making simple mistakes that could be fixed by a relatively small amount of dedicated practice. Relatedly, most people have a fear of putting in the actual effort to get better and then still falling short of expectations (their own or others). It’s emotionally easier to pretend that there are other reasons outside of your control and that dedicated practice wouldn’t make a difference anyways. In my experience, the solution to this to work on accepting your emotions and developing inner security such that you don’t feel that your self-worth depends on the outcome of these events. One might even discover that they don’t actually even care that much about achieving a high level of performance in activity X and that the “need” to be good at it is a manifestation of older behavioral patterns and conditioning that don’t necessarily benefit them today :)
- nlawalker 3y agoI was going to add "People want to be winners without trying because people who win without trying are cool, and tryhards are not cool."
- notyofriend 3y agoHow about I just want to win but I don’t want it enough to grind hard because the juice isn’t worth the squeeze in many competitive things with no rewards for winning except a small rush
- notahacker 3y agoThe first example makes me think if the 95th percentile players still can't figure out how to trigger the mission completed objective, the problem is probably more with the mission design being inappropriate for the game's user base than an indication of some broader truth about how add the 95th percentile person is at everything
- dang_rts 3y ago[dead]
- voxl 3y agoThis is the kind of claim that needs actual evidence, otherwise it's just a dumb feel-good sentiment about how you _could_ be 2000 ELO on lichess if you cared. I tend to agree that with enough time and _appropriate_ training anyone can become quite competent at anything, but this is a significantly different claim than thinking you can be in the 95th percentile of persons who are engaged in the activity. It becomes even worse when you realize that technical activities (such as programming) where there are cash incentives are a lot different than recreational activities where the only incentive is to have fun. There is an incentive to _not_ improve at a recreational activity and outpace your friends.
- tgv 3y ago> I tend to agree that with enough time and _appropriate_ training anyone can become quite competent at anything It's something I don't believe. There's no evidence for it, but that would also be really hard to obtain. You'll get better with training, practice, exercise, but quite competent is a level very many people won't be able to manage. Physical competence is an obvious case. Roughly half the population is too young or too old to become e.g. a "quite competent" marathon runner, has ailments, handicaps, etc. An even larger part simply is not tall enough to reach beyond than absolute amateur level in certain sports (basketball, volleyball). And the differences don't magically stop at the blood-brain barrier. I agree that more than 5% of the population could achieve the level currently held by the top 5%, but it's not a lot more.
- empath-nirvana 3y ago> how you _could_ be 2000 ELO on lichess if you cared. I would argue that being top 2000 ELO is _way_ higher than top 5% of chess players. Most chess players have _never played a competitive game_
- voxl 3y agoRapid rating 95th percentile is 2050 (info is available on lichess)
- ch4s3 3y agoI don't think I agree with this at all. I can see how you would have this impression with something like a video game or I guess public speaking where maybe a lot of people do it un-seriously and you can be better than most with some intentional effort. It's weird to choose a super mass market game like Overwatch to make that point though, if you were in the 95th percentile of Starcraft players, that would truly be something, since the skill ceiling is MILES high. For anything with a physical component I think this whole thing falls apart completely. For something like weightlifting the 95% percentile for men is around 160kg or ~352lbs. Going from sedentary to that lift could take years of effort. Musical performance is similarly something where the effort to do anything at all is quite large.
- lumost 3y agoIt probably depends on your objective. 352 lb is about the cutoff before you become a competitive weight lifter. Most people probably don't want to do that. Same thing happens in gaming, 95th percentile is probably about where you get to the point of "learned how to play the game up to the competitive level". The majority of my hobbies are non-competitive. If I get to one day be a 95th percentile hiker, I will be ecstatically happy. However I'd be willing to bet that for my (narrow) niche of software - I am well into the three 9s by virtue that while most backend engineers will have touched what I work on, they haven't done it for 10 years in a demanding environment.
- ch4s3 3y agoI see what you're saying, but my point is that even for non-competitive pursuits in the physical world many can involve deep levels of skill that take years to develop. Cooking is another great example, almost anyone can make dinner for themselves but making a really delightful meal for guests requires a lot of skills that take a lot of time to develop. You can go quite deep there, and while hard to measure become better than 95% of home cooks would be impressive.
- ndriscoll 3y agoI'm not sure what the 352 is supposed to be. strengthlevel.com claims a 352 lb bench is ~95th percentile for a 180 lb male, but I've never seen anyone in a gym that can bench anywhere near that. IME even a 225 lb squat feels like 95th percentile. I don't think I've ever seen someone else do a 100 lb shoulder press (~20th percentile on SL). Usually I see something like 75 lb (doing fixed barbells), and once I saw 95 lbs. The idea is most people who participate are probably closer to what you see at the YMCA or Planet Fitness, not a powerlifting gym. They could do a lot more with basic advice like "add weight".
- norir 3y agoI feel like implicit in this framing is the idea that one's sense of value is linked to where one measures up in some arbitrary task. Should I feel worse about myself if I'm only in the 95th percentile for some activity I enjoy rather than the 99th? Most things worth doing are more enjoyable the more skilled you are at them, but of course our lives are finite and we have to make choices that might limit our development of any skill. But the more I am worried about where I measure up, the less I am enjoying the thing for what it is. As the saying goes, comparison is the thief of joy.
- strstr 3y agoThe framing is a lot narrower, and pretty clear if you’ve ever played overwatch. In that context a lot of people claim they want to get better, but don’t even grab for the lowest hanging fruit.
- yixu34 3y ago> but of course our lives are finite and we have to make choices that might limit our development of any skill. This is a key point in Four Thousand Weeks (https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/54785515 https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/54785515). For our hobbies, it'd be totally fine (and even preferable) to not worry about percentiles at all.
- antisthenes 3y ago95%-ile isn't that good.* * The caveat of course being that you dedicate all your available waking hours (not occupied with life-sustaining activities) to training and deliberately practicing a single particular skill/game and also trying to do your best every single time, which is incredibly mentally taxing. It's even more mentally taxing as you get older, since your fluid intelligence diminishes. Also, another author's mistake is diminishing the role of talent. While we know that with deliberate practice most people can achieve a 95%-ile, the real advantage of talent is how fast you can get there. Because if it takes you half as long to get there, you are able to start reaping the rewards earlier, and getting first-mover advantage.
- mlyle 3y agoI think the author's point is really that you can outperform a huge slice of people with just a little bit of careful self-reflection and asking for help, instead of putting even more effort into grinding and hoping you'll improve. Or, even: by throwing some deliberateness in to things we're doing, we can avoid a lot of frustration.
- antisthenes 3y agoAs someone who used to be an avid gamer and reasonably competitive, "a little bit of careful self-reflection" is definitely not enough to get you in the top 5%. Top 20%, sure, because the bottom 50% doesn't even try, and the next 30% tries just enough to learn the basic mechanics. You need a certain time commitment and the ability to learn reasonably complex abstract mental models. Learning curves for many games are in the 1000s of hours. It's just not easy to fit into a busy work schedule.
- mlyle 3y agoThe author describes people who have >1000 hours but make basic mistakes that are easy to fix and hold down their rating. The author also describes the experience of people who are stuck, receive a small amount of quality coaching, and then massively increase in rating.
- brigadier132 3y agoI think the way this is phrased is weird. It should probably be rephrased as "becoming 95% percentile at a thing is not that hard". Which I might agree with. Becoming good at a lot of tasks and skills really just comes down to finding the right approach to training and then doing that training. The last 5% is much harder because that's generally filled with truly talented people that also know how to train and are diligent with it.
- tester756 3y agolast 5%? I've been top 1% and slightly below 1% at peak in video games that have milions of gamers and I wouldnt say that top 5% is filled with "truly talented people" Top 5% is just decent people, but they are very, very, very far from top 0.1, 0.5%, etc. At 1% I've been faaaaar from 0.5%, 0.1% people.
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoI'm in the top 15 bf4 tankers in the US. I run a very unique loadout that's very specific to my PTFO playstyle and the most common threats I deal with. It has glaring weaknesses that few ever exploit, but if you knew the game and actually tried to counter me, you absolutely could. Sometimes, the .001% have simply found their particular niche in the ecosystem
- hirvi74 3y agoI miss that game so much. What's the server population like these days? What is your load out? I was a Jet main.
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoAh, there's probably still 500 players still playing on PSN. Probably the same on XBL and maybe 2x that on PC I'd guess. The only problem I see is a 'dead sea' effect, where a lot of the folks still playing are very good, and the games can be lopsided and not fun for the average player. I hate to see them stomp on average dudes. I always hold back capturing the last objective, and I never shoot into deployment even if I'm taking fire. The game should be fun and fair for everyone. As I said, I'm a tanker. I run smoke screen, thermal camo, and LMG. It's an insanely fun play style because everyone relies on their minimap and thermal optics and I'm basically a 70 ton ghost on the battlefield. It's crazy how easy it is to sneak up behind enemy armor or juke incoming shells because everyone is looking for a white blob or a red marker on their map. Also, given I'm almost unspotable, aircraft tend to leave me alone unless i'm dealing with a pro jet pilot that's looking for me. Sometimes I will piss off the enemy team and by the 3rd strafing run I'm like 'wow bud, you really got nothing better to do with your day, huh?'
- netcan 3y agoI'm 70%-ile online chess player. That is average relative to players active on lichess in a given month. I'm better than most people (maybe top 10% even) that "play a little." I'm (I assume) well below average for adult tournament player. The pool matters. I think if I took lessons and dedicated a serious 100-200 hrs over some period, I might reach 85th in my online pool. 95%-ile is currently ELO 2075... just under where junior masters (CMs) seem to be on lichess. I suspect that extra 150 elo would be a difficult jump... but maybe doable for me and other average players. Chess is probably structured similar to athletics and other such pursuits. You can probably expect a similar distribution for weight lifting, for example. The average person can probably reach the level where everyone (including most over average people) is "actually trying" simply by being systematic. Where that point is varies, but weight lifting and chess have similar ranges of participation levels... like many hobbies. In any case... I think unlike chess, it's worth focusing on either strategy or technique... not tactics. Strategically defining the thing (chess is defined, but "software engineering" is malleable). Meaningfully selecting the pool. Actually deciding the value. Getting to top 10% rec chess player sounds fun. Getting to CM sounds arduous and pointless. There's not much value in being an entry level chess master... or power lifter. Techniques, like the habit of planning a training plan, creating a strategic plan with goals, timelines and such... that's a valuable asset... very transferable. The tactics... not so much. Meanwhile, you don't need great tactics to get results, and tactical advice is the easiest advice to get.
- PaulHoule 3y agoChess is an unusually good example of there being a system in place to rate people. Master of, say, CSS is not like that.
- psunavy03 3y agoSoftware engineering, much as some people don't like to hear it, is also a team sport unlike weightlifting or chess. Give me a 99th percentile team over a mythical 10x dev every day of the week and twice on Sundays.
- jeremyjh 3y agoChess has a funny distribution because there are different populations to consider. I'd guess a chess.com 1200 is better than 95% of all people who know the rules and have played a game. Yet to reach the 95% of any tournament rating pool is far more difficult. It took me nearly three years just to get to 1450 USCF, which is about 83% nationally. In that time I've done more than 50,000 tactics, played more than 15,000 total games (mostly online blitz and rapid) and at least 300 rated tournament games at a slow time control (this includes online games played at 45+45, only half that number are OTB). I've analyzed those tournament games, most of them with a coach. I've played through annotated game collections. I attend lectures at the club from an FM, and watch dozens of Youtube videos every week from streamers and instructors. I drill openings and endgames etc etc. I have a lifetime goal just to reach 1800, which is about 95% I believe. Its reasonable to expect that to take at least 5 years, and also reasonable to think I will never achieve it. This is what chess improvement looks like when you start in your 40s. Any kid who takes the game seriously can get to 1800, a lot of them will do it in just a couple of years.
- allig256 3y agoAre there any good platforms out there that people would recommend where you can have your code reviewed? Either paid for or for free. As this article points out, feedback is an essential part of learning, and open source projects would be a great opportunity to get feedback on something you have sole agency over as opposed to many workplace projects where it's harder to receive feedback for your individual decisions.
- saagarjha 3y agoSend PRs to open source projects you’re interested in?
- allig256 3y agoAnd ask them to review your own projects? That seems a little odd doesn't it? I am wanting feedback specifically for my own work.
- saagarjha 3y agoWhy does it have to be your project? You can make substantial technical decisions for someone else's project and get feedback on it.
- TehShrike 3y agoOpen source projects are flooded by low-quality PRs, they can't afford to give mentor-quality feedback to them. Better to join the project's chat server and have back-and-forth discussions.
- saagarjha 3y agoOften they will provide good feedback if your PR is legitimate.
- redblacktree 3y agoDepending on how good you are at programming, LLMs would probably have some good feedback.
- the__alchemist 3y agoShould I feel bad with this context because my ELO is 1150 in Age of Empires 2? That's like 70% percentile-ish. Oh well. Hypothesis: This dude will stagnate at gold or platium-league, or 1100-1200ish or equivalent in an RTS game's ranked ladder.
- saagarjha 3y ago95%-tile isn’t that good, and there’s a corollary that I often see, where there’s a plateau of people way past that (say 99.5%-tile) of several hundred people who are good but clearly not the best. This is people who are actually working hard at something and are in basically every context indistinguishable from being the best but they themselves know that there is still a ways left to go. I’d argue that it’s actually not super hard to get to this point in a few things (say, maybe an hour a day on it) but then the difficulty ramps up exponentially until you’re basically dedicating your life to get past that. It’s interesting to see people who pick being 99.5%-tile at a few things versus those who choose to give their all into one thing where they become, say, top 10.
- tomato-sauce 3y agoThe Overwatch example does not really make sense. The author assumes that if people are frustrated by frequently losing, it would be logical to put in effort to improve their skills. But their win rate should remain mostly constant as their skills improve since at the same time they would be moving up the ranking and would face better players. So there is not a strong incentive for the average player to put large effort into improving in the rankings. In real world activities (eg programming) your skill level is often directly tied to strong incentives such as income. I don't think it is reasonable to think that it would be as easy to move up in the "rankings" all the way up to 95% percentile.
- wlesieutre 3y agoThis is why I miss games like Unreal Tournament where they had 8 bot difficulty levels. When you were in the mood for a challenge you could turn it up, and when you were in the mood for some easy blowing stuff up you could turn it down. Now everything's skill-based matchmaking and as much as it can manage you're always up against opponents who are equally good to you. Or playing against people who are way better than you and sandbagged their rating. But you can't have an easy game unless you make a second smurf account and do the same. Which is a dick move because the people on the other end of it didn't sign up to play a much harder opponent.
- dmoy 3y agoCompetitive games is also a weird domain for measuring something like this. Optimal play can be both difficult to achieve, but have an incredible advantage. A 95th percentile player will lose to a 99th percentile player like 10 out of 10 times. I mean shit, different blizzard game, but I was on a team that was somewhere around 99.9-99.99%, and if we went up against actual pro gamers (99.999%+), we'd lose 10 out of 10 times, and half the time we'd be unaware of why we lost (analogous to dan luu's "basic mistake", from the perspective of optimal play). But on the flip side, we could literally play 2v3 and win 9.5 times out of 10 vs 97%-ile players. The advantage you get from seemingly small things in the game get amplified. For example if you just intuitively know when every ability comes off cooldown and becomes available again (both your own team and your opponents'), you can do things that seem otherwise impossible. I don't think this translates all that well into a lot of other domains where it isn't a gamified hyper competitive / meta optimized scenario.
- kristianp 3y agoPreviously: score: 166 date: 2022-02-21 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30411160 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30411160 score: 444 date: 2020-02-07 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22265197 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22265197 The Algolia search totally fails to find those: https://hn.algolia.com/?query=95%25-ile%20isn%27t%20that%20good&type=story&dateRange=all&sort=byDate&storyText=false&prefix&page=0 https://hn.algolia.com/?query=95%25-ile%20isn%27t%20that%20g...
- TuringNYC 3y agoFor some people it is good? I play video games to decompress and enjoy my time. If i want to be to 1% then i'd be grinding Leetcode, where it matters. I lost at video games all the time and it still achieves the goal of decompression and enjoyment.
- dtjohnnymonkey 3y agoThis seems similar to Ramit Sethi's "Craigslist Penis Effect", which IIRC basically says that you only need to try a little bit to have better results than most people.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 3y agoThe argument seems like a cheat, because it rules out people who don't participate, but doesn't limit itself to people who practice regularly. For video games, an analogy could be limiting to people who bought the game on steam, but not limiting to people who ever installed and played it. Or maybe a better analogy is website users, limiting to people who visited, but still including all the people who immediately bounced/closed the tab. Like, if you take basketball, I'd bet a lot of people here have shot a basketball, but don't practice regularly. The last time I held a basketball was probably 20 years ago, so should I still count? The point is that participation itself is too much of a spectrum, so the 95%ile statement is just 'most participants basically don't really participate, and there's a long tail of participation.' Which isn't super worthwhile. If you limit to people who "regularly practice" a thing, this would be an interesting argument, but it also wouldn't be true then.
- topaz0 3y agoOn the contrary I think that's the main point: that a fairly trivial amount of practice is enough to surpass almost everyone who you'll encounter in the activity. Obviously (tautologically) the average person who practices regularly will be average among the people who practice regularly -- you'd have to practice exceptionally well (or perhaps start out with exceptional talent) for practice to make you exceptional in that group. So I don't think it's a cheat, it's just about putting it into perspective.
- Dylan16807 3y ago> everyone who you'll encounter in the activity You have a far smaller chance of encountering the person who puts in 3 hours and then quits. The average encountered participator is much more skilled than the average participator.
- naniwaduni 3y agoYou can weight by frequency of activity—say, approximately "players sampled from matches selected uniformly at random"—and it'd largely still be true. The top few percentiles do practice more often, but overwhelmingly so. Glicko metrics for two-player games basically have this property, so if you want to try it out in the wild, you can pick up a game with a Glicko-rated ladder and see how hard it is to get your mean rating estimate up +2 SDs.
- danbrooks 3y agoWhen I was younger, I used to enjoy competition and climbing leaderboards. Now, parenting always comes first. Reaching the top 5% is possible for most people with sustained effort. Many participants aren't dedicated to reaching the top of the leaderboard.
- TehShrike 3y agoI aim to be a 95th percentile parent. It's not as hard as you'd think
- theoldlove 3y agoHow can you tell? Parenting isn’t exactly quantifiable.
- haizhung 3y agoYeah but there are some nearly objective truths that should easily bring you to the 95%ile. Like, spend conscious time with your kid (play with them, read to them, etc) over letting them watch YouTube or TV. Or, don’t invalidate their emotions when they share them.
- TehShrike 3y agoMost 5-year-olds are assholes. Once you realize that it is possible to train a child to not act like an asshole, you're pretty far ahead. Once you've trained your 5-year-old to not act like an asshole most of the time, you're easily in the top 5%
- a13n 3y agoGreat guide to get to top 95-99% of a video game. Completely different guide needed to get from 99% to 99.99%. Would love to read that one, as someone who's ranked top 1% in a video game (rocket league).
- godelski 3y agoThis is why I honestly don't care about a lot of elitism in things like schools, internships, places of work, etc. Because if anyone has the base knowledge you can turn them into a top 1%er really fast and easily. But what a lot of people don't understand, is that everyone needs training. The good argument against this is that those with elite credentials have gotten training through their elite status[0] (momentum is a powerful force) but I don't find this particularly convincing because it's implying that you don't need to train people. People should always be trained. I'm not sure why we often don't internalize this. Even top athletes are constantly training, arguably that's their entire job and weirdly enough you don't even need to have the trainer be a top athlete (just sufficient knowledge of the domain and more about skills in communication and deconstructing problems). Realistically people will just settle into wherever they've found some level of success because, like the article says, they're not looking for feedback or if they are, it's not straightforward or easy to come by. Are we coders/scientists/engineers/etc properly training? Do we have sufficient means? Are code reviews actually training exercises combined with quality control or are they an adversarial game where jobs need to be justified to those using poor metrics for said justification? (do you intentionally put in easy mistakes so review has something to point to but you have something easy to fix but would get something hard to fix if you submitted better code in the first place?) [0] I'll put it this way, when you look at top performers in a field (let's say ML for example, because it's hip) you'll typically find a long chain of elite statuses (plenty of exceptions, but they don't discredit the underlying premise here). Take for example the well known Andrej Karpathy. Before he was at OpenAI he was the Sr Director at Tesla, and before that OpenAI, and before that Standford, then University of British Columbia, and then University of Toronto (where he took classes and attended study sessions by Hinton). The point here is not to say he didn't work hard (there's no doubt of that) or isn't exceptionally skilled (entire premise is based on assuming this), but that there's compounding opportunities to catapult one's self to the top skill level. The truth of the matter is going into college the vast majority of people are dumb as shit and the differential in someone at a low tier school and a high tier school isn't that huge (we can even extend the argument further backwards). 4 years is not a lot of time, nor is the 8-12 for PhD (from high school). The skills gap does widen between these groups, but not nearly as much as they do between those leveraging their opportunities or even just those with better opportunities. There's a saying I like: "The harder you work, the luckier you get." The two are deeply intertwined and working hard you have the capacity to take advantage of more opportunities. The three questions here are: 1) how many additional Kaparthy level people did we miss out on due to them not having adequate opportunities? 2) Is there a cost effective solution to increase these numbers? Dramatically? 3) At which point (for which skills) is there no longer a sufficiently effective strategy that's also cost effective. (strategy selection is most certainly time and domain dependent) There's actually decent evidence that you can take low quality high school students and they will be successful at elite schools, especially after you control for dropouts due to higher rates of family issues. (This can be captured in many ways and is nuanced so it's actually deceptively hard). In high likelihood you could randomize Kindergartners into the elite path and non-elite path and find this effective but we're probably only going to be able to get natural experiments. Is this true for High School? College? Grad School? (If you think in any way I'm undermining Karpathy's success or talent, you've most certainly misread and/or I've most certainly greatly miscommunication and this line should be a verification of the former. Karpathy is without a doubt, a fucking beast)
- GuB-42 3y agoIt is all about the reference point. The article uses Overwatch as an example. - If you take the world population, 95%-ile means being able to use a keyboard and mouse and maybe have a vague idea of what a FPS is. - From the previous population, having played the game or one of a similar genre even once puts you in the 95%-ile - From the previous population, actually owning the game puts you in the 95%-ile - From the previous population, playing enough to have a meaningful ranking puts you in the 95%-ile - From the previous population, being good enough to compete in an established team puts you in the 95%-ile - From the previous population, being good enough to earn some money puts you in the 95%-ile - From the previous population, being good enough to make a living puts you in the 95%-ile - From the previous population, being good enough to be famous puts you in the 95%-ile - From the previous population, being in the 95%-ile means you are the world champion So which reference point are you using when you are saying you are 95%-ile?
- lamontcg 3y ago> This is a pretty fundamental disagreement that I have with a lot of people. Just for example, I recently got into a discussion with an authority who insisted that it wasn't possible for me to reasonably disagree with them (I suggested we agree to disagree) because they're an authority on the topic and I'm not. It happens that I worked on the formal verification of a system very similar to the system we were discussing, but I didn't mention that because I don't believe that my status as an authority on the topic matters. If someone has such a weak argument that they have to fall back on an infallible authority, that's usually a sign that they don't have a well-reasoned defense of their position. This goes double when they point to themselves as the infallible authority. That can just be a sign of someone who is tired of arguing with you and they're ending the argument. You also haven't offered the information that you have any expertise, so they're assuming that you're another not-even-10%-ile person who is probably making a basic mistake. You also still may be making a basic mistake even though you're a 95%-ile person on this subject -- for the exact reasons put out in this article. They're being a bit of a dick, but their time is finite and you probably annoyed them.
- mewpmewp2 3y agoIf you don't have time to argue then just say that, don't say that it isn't possible for someone to reasonably disagree. I agree with the sentiment that you should consider the arguments, not whether someone is an "authority". I enjoy arguing and I never start by mentioning whether I have relevant experience and if someone assumes I don't, it's clear to me that they are not really considering the arguments themselves, but assume I must have no experience. And when I'm arguing with someone I only focus on their arguments, not who they are. It's also not about them being a dick. It's about them indicating that they are not really intellectually honest.
- lamontcg 3y agoActual people rarely argue to some kind of platonic ideal. And the author of the post clearly indicates that he didn't bother to inform this person that he had expertise that he considers relevant. Elsewhere he also kind of shits on using "terms of art". But those "terms of art" are useful shorthand to experts, establishing that both sides are experts and familiar with the field, and more rapidly communicating information with less words. That strongly makes me suspect that the problem is one of communication. The author then asserts that the argument from authority makes him dismiss the expert. Well, that's just the fallacy-fallacy[1] and is no more relevant. The expert can still be 100% right and you can be 100% wrong, and they can be using a logical fallacy and all you can really conclude is that they're a bit of a dick about it. You can't ascertain truth. If you want to have productive discourse with that expert, you might ask yourself why they're being a bit of a dick about it, and if you've done anything to warrant that breakdown in communication on a /social/ level rather than intellectual-technical level. Or the person may just be a dick. And they might still be a dick and be wrong, we can't really tell. But really from reading that paragraph all I gather is that there was certainly a breakdown in communication, and that it reflects negatively on the author that he assumes he's right because of it. And there's a certain amount of hypocrisy apparent in his conclusion. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_fallacy
- throwaway22032 3y agoI guess it's a perception thing but I feel as if this becomes more intuitive if you look at it as 1 in 20. Amongst a group of 20 people you know, assuming you haven't just picked 20 people with highly correlated hobbies (e.g. 20 software devs that like to game), each person is probably going to have "their thing" and they'll be the 1 in 20 or 95th percentile in the group at it. Extrapolate out and there you go.