7 ms·
Carmakers Plan to Make Basic Features Subscription, Despite Widespread Backlash
- rekabis 3y agoIf purchasing is not ownership, then pirating is not theft. I think more technically-gifted people need to look into these “subscription” systems, in order to find workarounds. Because if it comes with my car, _it’s mine to do whatever the f**k I want with it._
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- francisofascii 3y ago> better gas and EV engine performance Are we talking about better fuel efficiency, acceleration or both? To lock down better fuel efficiency would be downright evil. I am okay with locking down better acceleration.
- oivey 3y agoWhy are you ok with that? Adding a software governor to the motors just to drag more money out of something you already bought is crazy.
- huijzer 3y agoIt’s very interesting to see businesses like BMW, Mercedes, Shell and Google obsess over quarterly revenues instead of the long term. I would see it as a red flag as investor, but maybe the main investor in these companies is someone who obsesses over quarterly revenue?
- xivzgrev 3y agoThat’s ideal but remember a company is made of thousands of shareholders - execs, employees, investors etc When the stock price starts going down / not growing as it “should”, everyone is unhappy. Execs can leave, key employees can leave, and investors can launch an activist campaign. If the story is spun right even “weak” financial performance can lead to strong stock - look at Amazon. There was very little profit for years but that was because they were reinvesting in growth (and seeing results). So people believed and stock price went brrr.
- dakial1 3y agoYou're mixing shareholders with stakeholders. Shareholders are only the investors. Execs would only care for stocks if their variable is tied to it. Low/mid employees don't really care.
- underseacables 3y agoThis is awful. Now we will have to jailbreak our cars just do use basic features.
- JohnFen 3y agoOr avoid buying newer cars. That's what I do to avoid surveillance by the manufacturer, and it would be equally effective for this.
- underseacables 3y agoIt would increase the value of older cars.
- maxwell 3y agoOr create the conditions for the rise of electric hotrods.
- CamperBob2 3y agoSeems likely. "We're all Cubans now."
- sickofparadox 3y agoMany states will ban the purchase of used ICE vehicles eventually just as they have deadlines for banning new ICE vehicle sales, or at least make the process so onerous they might as well have banned them.
- JohnFen 3y agoMaybe, maybe not. Right now, though, that isn't a reality.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hiatus 3y agoOh there's a way around that. Places like Lisbon and London already have time periods where older vehicles cannot enter parts of each city without paying a fee. It's only a matter of time that they're banned altogether for "the sake of the environment".
- lylejantzi3rd 3y agoWhen they outlaw non-subscription seat warmers, only outlaw hackers will have seat warmers! Fight the power!
- ctoth 3y agoAnother thing you could do is just not buy the damn things. As someone who cannot physically drive because I'm blind, the idea that you need a car is already suspect, but regardless, you certainly don't need a 2023+ car with "smart" features. Don't buy them, tell your families not to buy them, let them pile up, unpurchased, on dealer (what a silly idea a dealership is!) lots. You are still allowed to opt out. For now.
- TheNewsIsHere 3y agoI would agree that the dealership model for sales is ridiculous. When you need service from the same company that made your car, dealerships can be a life saver. (Not all of them, of course. YMMV.)
- jcranmer 3y agoYour ability to not need a car is highly dependent on where you choose to live. A coworker of mine got into a car accident a few days ago and has temporarily lost access to a car, and in the process discovered that getting from the house to the airport without a car was far less viable than they expected. (I say this as someone who is emphatically of the opinion that we should be less reliant on cars!)
- nullserver 3y agoNever mind when Covid hit all the buses in our area. Shut down through almost 2 years.
- xivzgrev 3y agoThis only works if there are some popular automakers not in on it. If everyone goes that way then consumers are screwed. Then inevitably after 10-20 years there will be enough anger that congress will do something about it, but in the mean time the original execs all lived like fat cats and danced into the sunset. Yippee!
- etrautmann 3y agoit'll also increase demand for used cars without these features.
- orwin 3y ago[flagged]
- maxwell 3y agoIf cars are computers on wheels now, seems time to buy a case and components and put it together instead of just gettin' a Dell. Ford's electric crate motor is out now: https://performanceparts.ford.com/part/M-9000-MACHE https://performanceparts.ford.com/part/M-9000-MACHE
- Tanoc 3y agoAs far as I know they still don't sell a wiring harness or battery for it, though. So you either have to yoink parts from a dead Mach-E or F-150 Lightning or adapt existing parts to poorly suit the conversion. They've been selling very few of them because of this, and Ford's legal department's too scared to actually sell battery cells that would fit in place of gas tanks or whatever.
- maxwell 3y agoWhy are they scared to do that?
- Tanoc 3y agoLiability. If someone installs the battery or wiring harness incorrectly there's any number of things that could go wrong. You don't want to be sued over a battery fire if someone shortcuts wiring or venting things properly. There's a double standard in that you can buy a Ford 532 crate engine and it'll come with the wiring harness and fuel system with an "approved for off-road use only" disclaimer simply because people have been doing engine swaps and self repair since the dawn of the automobile.
- oofta-boofta 3y ago[dead]
- eximius 3y ago"Yes, the planet got destroyed. But for a beautiful moment in time, we created a lot of value for shareholders." I wish we would stop making our lives worse for each other.
- houseatrielah 3y agoI was pumping gas and the gas pump decided it should advertise at me and clue me in on the latest celebrity gossip. We really have no concept that we shouldn't degrade the public realm.
- Tanoc 3y agoBring expanding spray foam with you and fill in the speaker grille and muffle or mute the sound. Other people will greatly appreciate it and the employees most likely won't care until it comes time for inspection from corporate or state agencies. I've seen it more than once at Speedway stations.
- callalex 3y agoIn that case I think it’s perfectly acceptable to degrade the speaker and screen that were placed in the public realm.
- gaws 3y ago"Why make others happy when I can profit (and be happy) from their misery?"
- jacobgorm 3y agoI actually think this makes some sense, based on my own experiences owning various cars. The first was a Mercedes A200 that had been imported from the Netherlands to Denmark. It did not have heated seats, something I overlooked when I bought it, supposedly not a deal breaker in NL, but a big issue during cold Danish winters. I would have gladly payed a subscription fee to activate seat heating had it been possible, but the car was originally made for another market, so there was nothing I could do except sell it and buy another one. The second is my current car, a Volvo, which came with a wifi hotspot. For some reason, the hotspot stopped working after a the car was out of warranty, and I found that I am able to live without it, by using my phone as a hotspot instead. In this case I could have stopped paying for a feature that I no longer need. As cars get more laden with tech, I think it is quite feasible that some initially "fashionable" features will get irrelevant over time, and users might like to have to option to stop paying for features that have lost their relevance. If Volvo would upgrade my current sat-nav to Apple Carplay I would gladly pay for that too. Having users pay recurring would also incentivize car makers to keep investing in updating their software, and perhaps even install hardware upgrades "free" of charge, in the hope that the user would keep paying a recurring fee to have them.
- tguvot 3y agovolvo hotspot has independent sim card for internet (different from the one that is used for volvo oncall). usually first few years of service included but after this you need to create account with internet provider in order to get service
- jacobgorm 3y agoI know, but the SIM-card reader broke.
- jocaal 3y ago> Having users pay recurring would also incentivize car makers to keep investing in updating their software... Please no. I don't want fancy software that hides essential features 4 layers deep and stops working when the internet is bad and the billing service can't be reached. I want buttons for the features and a display that works with android auto. Nothing more, nothing less.
- balozi 3y agoIf I choose to not activate their features I end up stuck with the cost of hosting their hardware. Those heated seats cost me money to transport, maintain and insure. They should be paying me.
- reaperman 3y agoIt may not be the case. The financials could be covered by the deferred revenue of expected subscription adoption. Perhaps heated car seats would normally cost an extra $1,200. If they predict a 50% adoption rate, they could charge $40/month (raised annually by inflation) and they'd get $2,400 from each subscriber over a 5-year ownership. This way the people who don't use the hardware don't pay for it, their unused hardware is paid for by those who do use it. If it functioned this way, I imagine some people would figure out how to hack the car to unlock these features without paying for them. I'd even be curious how illegal that would even be -- distributing software hacks might be prohibited by DMCA, but installing a switch that bypasses the infotainment OS entirely and directly connects the heated seats' resistive heating elements to 12V/48V rails or whatever surely wouldn't be in violation of any current laws.
- soperj 3y ago> This way the people who don't use the hardware don't pay for it OP was saying they pay to cart it around the country.
- rasz 3y ago>Perhaps heated car seats would normally cost an extra $1,200. how do you derive $1,200 from a ~$20 BOM change?
- reaperman 3y agoBecause generally, as a consumer, if I want to add a package which includes heated seats it seems to cost me about $600-1500. When I said "cost $1200" I meant "cost the consumer $1200" not "cost the manufacturer $1200".
- yohannparis 3y agoI can see the benefits, make only one car model. And then let the user decides what to use for a fee. The problem is a lot of cars will have features that will never be used and trashed. Their goal is just how to optimize their production and not their impact on their environment.
- tantalor 3y agoThey install that true coat the factory, there's nothing we can do. But I'll talk to my boss. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B2LLB9CGfLs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B2LLB9CGfLs
- lallysingh 3y agoThis article's 90% outrage and 10% material. The idea is still in its infancy so we don't see an impact in prices yet -- there aren't enough models with this function to price out a difference. Here are my questions: 1. Would this work for much more than small conveniences? Heated seats, steering wheel, wifi, etc? Where it's literally cheaper to build 1 part instead of 2. 2. If it's cheaper to always build in the feature, why wouldn't a competitor just include the feature as standard? The auto market is pretty competitive, and Brother did pretty well just by not screwing up their printers. 3. Will people get turned off at the fear of higher replacement part costs? 4. Has this grown past the small-experiment stage? Is it any more than BMW heated seats?
- criddell 3y agoGM dumping CarPlay / Android Auto fits this as well. GM thinks they can generate $20-$25 billion in annual subscription revenue within 6 years and they can't do that if you can just connect your phone and use that.
- gizmo 3y agoThe underlying issue here is that European car manufacturers are in deep financial trouble. Employees are getting more expensive. Cars are getting more complicated and contain more chips. This increases R&D expenses. Margins are getting squeezed. Asian competitors are on their tails. Lexus and Mazda are attacking the lower end of luxury cars and Chinese manufacturers are the only ones that can produce economy (electric) cars at a profit. European carmakers are looking into subscriptions, knowing it will anger their most loyal customers, because their main business is struggling. They look at sofware companies with envy. To put it in perspective, Volkswagen, Europe's largest carmaker with 675,000 employees has the same market cap as Crowdstrike and Snowflake.
- sgt101 3y agoI think that the problem is that cars are getting simpler and contain less precision engineering. Making a ICE drive chain is very very difficult, there is a long supply chain required. This moat is drying out very very fast.
- Tanoc 3y agoNo. Definitely not. The drivetrains swap has made them simpler in that regard. But ever changing and increasing safety standards mean that a single bodystyle costs hundredss of millions of dollars to develop. Mostly caused by SUVs and CUVs that make the physics of an impact much harsher. The widespread popularity of the Jeep Cherokee and Ford Explorer in the early 1990s have been detrimental to so many facets of the modern world...
- gizmo 3y agoCars are getting way more complicated. Just look at all the tech inside of modern headlights and side mirrors. Don't you think you need a complicated supply chain for all the sensors in modern cars? ICE drive trains aren't impossibly complicated. It's 200 year old technology that has been near perfected. Modern engines last 200k miles no sweat and require little more than an oil change. BEV is simpler in some ways but more complex in other ways. BEVs are much heavier and that means you need more structural components, heavier suspension, more complex crumple zone, etc. Electric cars also can't be repaired as easily. BEV aren't simpler than ICE cars, it's just a different set of costs/benefits.
- mgarfias 3y agoThis crap is why I probably won’t buy another new car, ever. I’ll find an old 72 travelall and swap the motor/trans for something modern and efficient and say screw the automakers. One exception: a new c8 z06. I might get one, if my dealer gets an allocation and I have all my ducks lined up AND I can get it with no markup. Which… isn’t happening
- taylodl 3y agoAll BMW, Mercedes, et. al. are doing is creating a market for someone to come in and eat their lunch. The way things are going BYD will be able to come in next year and make a killing.
- thegrim33 3y agoThere's too much regulatory capture for any newcomer to start up and produce anything different and not go bankrupt. Tesla was such a lucky exception; they had to raise tens of billions of dollars of investment and still were on the verge of bankruptcy multiple times. As an interesting anecdote, Ford was founded with the 2023 equivalent of less than a million dollars.
- pulse7 3y agoCar features subscription: 1) create new product (car) -> 2) Lobby for a lot of regulation so only a few companies can make a product -> 3) Abuse market position to extract money from customers (car feature subscriptions)
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 3y agoWhat are you going to do? Drive an old car? Government has a solution for that!