9 ms·
Paper vs. devices: Brain activation differences during memory retrieval (2021)
- ggm 3y agoLink is 500
- idonotknowwhy 3y agoWorked for me just now
- marttt 3y agoFor me, 500 on first try, but worked with refresh.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- LAC-Tech 3y agoAuthor should have written it down and posted it to all of us.
- ngrilly 3y agoAnyone here did see an improvement in memory retrieval after switching from taking notes by typing on their computer to taking notes on something like Remarkable?
- AshamedCaptain 3y agoNo, and frankly, the increased search and lookup time when my colleagues can simply string grep them on their computers is a a handicap. That said, I have never been able to take notes on a keyboard. I also find that physical notebooks not only are in practice much easier to search, but I also have the impression that the fact all your note pages physically still exist (and not "disappear" after you change pages) helps recollection.
- contravariant 3y agoWouldn't surprise me if linking the notes to a physical location aids memory.
- teamonkey 3y agoThat's the theory behind mind mapping. As a side note, I feel mind mapping works differently on paper than with something like Xmind. Xmind is for organising and categorising thoughts by moving them around. Paper mind maps are for helping me remember the conversation when I wrote them; I can't seem to use software for that at all.
- falling_myshkin 3y agoMe neither. Memory palaces also show that this effect can be emulated (not sure if that's the right word) in the mind. I wonder if there is a way for computers to encourage developing a 'mind map'
- drbaba 3y agoI used to take some notes on paper (if it needed math and diagrams, or for meetings that require eye contact), and some notes on a computer (programming or pure text). My iPad replaced the paper but not the computer.
- wodenokoto 3y agoI think the kind of notes you can take with pen and paper beats what you can reasonably do with a keyboard. And I think some of the diagrams and annotated equations you can easily write on paper creates a much better learning experience. But computer notes are much easier to search. So for things like meeting minutes, and daily todos etc, write it in a .txt file. But when following along a deep learning course, write the equations and diagrams on paper. Later you can write code examples in your personal cheat sheet for easy retrieval.
- ngrilly 3y agoI thought devices like Remarkable were doing automatic OCR to enable search across notes? Assuming search works, then I’d say a big advantage of pen and paper is being less constrained in the layout of your notes, and for example do diagrams. Big disadvantage is not being able to edit, for example restructure your notes by moving things around.
- pbhjpbhj 3y agoI use OneNote and do some scribbled handwriting and quite a lot of typing; mostly 'printed' in text from PDFs. I'm always amazed at how it can interpret my handwriting, a lot of people struggle with it (including me). It's not perfect, but it surprises me sometimes.
- Multicomp 3y agoThe ability to attach multimedia screenshots, videos, images, files, digital ink is what elevates OneNote to me beyond Joplin, DokuWiki, LogSeq, Obsidian (all tools I've tried and can see why they have such appeal) , and other markdown++ notetaking applications, at least for my own taste and usecases. OneNote is not only a good notetaking capture tool, it's also a great clarifying tool for general reference/project support digital filing. Whether the digital artifacts are text, handwritten doodles, embedded files like multimedia or WIP digital artifacts, screenshots of binary file hexdumps, the works can all be stored together with relevant context, all labelled and fitting into a 3-ring-binder skeuomorphism I'm used to from organizing projects back in school in the olden days. Not the tool for everyone (especially those want to go fully Linux Desktop) but its very close to having something for everyone. Just gotta be able to do mobile and linux with local notebooks.
- pringk02 3y agoAnecdata, but I've never been able to switch to using a computer for note taking because I just get no long-term memory retrieval. Typing notes seem to be like never having learnt the thing. The search doesn't help because I don't even recall what I do or don't have to search through. When I take physical notes, I don't seem to need to look at them again, because I will recall what was written well enough that their purpose isn't as an archive, its for helping me retain something in my actual brain. Another anecdata point, I have ADHD. It affects memory in all sorts of known and measured ways. I generally find if I can get something into long-term memory then I'm set. Working memory is terrible. Physically writing while working serves as a crutch there too.
- dboreham 3y agoI'm not sure about memory, but I've found that thinking through problems is easier using a pen tablet. I use a Surface Pro X mostly, but sometimes my Samsung Fold phone if that's all I have with me. If I use paper, I lose the paper.
- 6stringmerc 3y agoThe amount of mental investment to write by hand versus type is significant. Technology assists are still rather primitive for English (you can’t argue with me on this it’s the hardest language due to amalgamations) but lazy gonna lazy. My thesis paper on file from 20 years ago already set forth a curriculum to address literary learning deficiency. Oh well. Point being is I’ve practiced the hard way and if you only know assisted methods I will eviscerate you. In fiction, I will always be better than you. Hey Alexa, how do I spell schadenfreude? Note: I have 100,000 hours in literary pursuits ranging from reading to writing to critique. Often mocked for my English degree. The truth is English is a wonderful weapon far beyond the grasp of the commoner and I will use it.
- wesleychen 3y agoExcept in this study they were comparing writing on a paper to writing on a tablet so it seems that somehow the fact that the writing happened to a piece of paper makes our memory better and its not just the act of writing itself.
- amelius 3y agoMaybe because mistakes are less expensive on a tablet.
- tgv 3y agoThat's testable, but if it turns out to have a benefit, you'll have to implement that effect on all tablets and phones, and make corrections more difficult (???). However, I don't think it has a benefit: people don't correct themselves on tablet/phone, so I think the cost of a mistake is the same as on paper, namely 0, unless people are really more careful when writing.
- vasco 3y agoRight now you're using it to get downvoted on a random website comment section so perhaps take yourself a bit less seriously!
- 3y ago
- keiferski 3y agoThis study appears to focus on short term memory, but for my money, long-term memory is much more significant. As such, it would have been useful to add a third option: using a SRS system like Anki. I imagine it would significantly outcompete both hand-written notes and digital tablet notes. A bit like the famous Steve Jobs example comparing a human, a condor, and a human with a bicycle. The condor (hand-writing) may beat the human (tablet), but a human with a bicycle (SRS system) outcompetes both.
- ezequiel-garzon 3y agoWhat's an SRS system?
- fermiNitambh 3y agoSpaced Repetition Software.
- suriyaG 3y agoI think it is Space Repetition Software/System
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoSoftware that prompts you with information on some time interval that allows for embedding it deeper in your memory. I think the key was it would prompt you with the information, just as your short term memory would be about to forget it, and thus re-inforce it. So some information X you want to remember. It would prompt you with it at 5 minutes, then 20, then an hour, then 5 hours. I forget the durations, but it was based in some studies on time before short term memory fades.
- falling_myshkin 3y agoI don't understand your simile. The limitations of a bicycle are infrastructure: bicycles can go a lot of places very efficiently, but rugged mountain terrain without trails (precisely the place condors thrive) would be difficult to traverse. (this is totally off topic but now i am curious about the energy efficiency of condor flight vs bicycle travel in ideal conditions) i find SRS very useful. but i personally think it is not well suited to reference information. i'm skeptical of putting all my appointments in SRS for example (maybe birthdays would be worth it). or say I had collected a bunch of papers related to a topic I was very interested in. I don't necessarily think I'd want to memorize the list of them via SRS, but having the titles written somewhere for reference would be great. I think the point of this paper is that if that 'somewhere' is an SRS card, it is almost completely devoid of context (other than 'studying flashcards on computer' context), but if that somewhere is a notebook that contains lists of papers related to all the topics i'm interested in, it's much easier to find. (though computers are good at searching fast)
- BaculumMeumEst 3y agoI think it would be interesting to see a study on memory retrieval for completing software projects with a dumb text editor with nothing enabled, an IDE, and an IDE with copilot enabled.
- shinycode 3y agoI might also depends for how long the developer has been using the tool. At university we first learned to program with pen and paper to develop memory and thinking habits before doing everything by hand with only vim and after that using and IDE after +6 months to let the habits develop. Maybe if a developper starts learning straight with copilot, some habits will never form and things will never go into long term memory ?
- Buttons840 3y agoI learned to program using Python with Geany, no autocomplete, every single letter typed by my fingers; no auto-format either. I was doing some consulting (I got a cheap consulting gig as my first job) and wrote a daemon in Python, which ran for about a year, then hit an edge case where I had misspelled a variable. -_- After that it ran for several years, 24/7, no problem. Now to my point: I learned Python far better than any other language I've ever used, I think because it was the first language I used seriously, but maybe it was because I never used auto-complete in those early days?
- GuB-42 3y agoOr maybe because it is Python. I find Python to be a beginner friendly, easy to learn language that steers you in the "right" direction. I think it is the biggest factor that explains its popularity. It is not a perfect language, in fact, I don't like it that much, but you have to give credit when credit is due. With C++, you can have decades of experience and be considered an expert, and yet, feel like a noob (my case). Perl, a language that shares many similarities with Python is also much harder to learn well. The "there is more than one way to do it" philosophy has value, but not for learning.
- falling_myshkin 3y ago
- apienx 3y agoI tend to write with more intent when using paper because I know that editing is not really possible. Accessibility is also much more limited on paper. However, I think of my devices and PKM software as a second brain where I just offload information knowing it can be accessed anywhere and anytime. P.S. From TokyoU’s Department of Basic Science (in an allegedly predatory journal).
- criddell 3y agoWhat personal knowledge management software do you use? I’ve never noticed memory differences based on how I made a note. I have, however, noticed that the act of making notes helps me understand something (which isn’t necessarily the same as recall) and writing on paper works best for me.
- maksimur 3y agoI wish it was like that for me too. I waste a lot of paper because I have to strike or rewrite my notes over and over for mistakes and changes of mind, even though I do my best not to make them. I still didn't find a way to fix that, but maybe it's just how my brain works.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoThink that is the key/point. Once you get frustrated at the re-writing, waste of paper. That in-itself will start to train you to think through your thoughts before writing them down. It will help slow your brain down and conceptualize things more fully first.
- maksimur 3y agoI've been frustrated at it since I was a kid, but no intervention seems to have had an effect on reducing the waste. If I went through with thinking through my thoughts before writing them I'd be stuck for a very long time (potentially days) at best, else I'm back to square one.
- halayli 3y agoI am not sure I agree with their participants sampling approach. Memory and particularly short term memory is highly impacted with people that have adhd/depression/bipolar. I am surprised they went with random participants without assessing their mental states and taking that into consideration.
- HSO 3y agoNB: this is a Japanese study. The participants wrote their notes in Japanese. If you write on paper, you need to write out each character by hand. In contrast, if you write on a tablet or other device, the input system will sort of "autocomplete" for you. Therefore, more cognitive effort is required to write on paper than on device. It is fairly accepted that greater cognitive effort (either to encode or to retrieve) is associated with greater recall. So I would doubt the transferability of this result to western context.
- geniium 3y agoVery interesting difference. Thanks for pointing it out
- makeitdouble 3y agoFrom the article: > Participants in the Tablet group used a stylus pen, thereby controlling for the effects of longhand writing with a pen in the Note group. In this specific study this is not a notable effect between the Note and Tablet groups. For the phone group you're right that it's a completely different input, while also being much more painful all around due to the sheer device size.
- gwervc 3y ago> If you write on paper, you need to write out each character by hand. Exactly like English or French. You also need to remember the correct sequence of letters (see my remark below). > In contrast, if you write on a tablet or other device, the input system will sort of "autocomplete" for you. Exactly like English or French. I didn't write half of the letters used to type this comment. I think you are searching for Japanese exceptionalism where it probably doesn't apply. Remembering the correct kanji, and graphy of said kanji is pretty much the same as remembering the (wild) orthography of French or English words. I'm searching quite often if a letter is a 'a' or 'e' (doesn't help that cognates between French and English often swap those), the conjugation of a verb or if a letter is doubled or not (again often not the same for related words, for example ennemi vs enemy). Your perception of the difficulty in-between writing systems is twisted by the decades of education you got in the said system vs the few years of learning another system with a second language. When I see some soup of letters in Japan, it's clear that the question is not just about one system being more simple than the other.
- chrisweekly 3y agoOne thing I love about my reMarkable tablet is that I get all the benefits of manual handwriting and sketches, enhanced by and combined with digital flexibility (copy/paste, resize, undo/redo, tags/metadata, search, retrieval, PKB integ and interop, etc).
- geniium 3y agoThe only thing I miss is the ability to spread my papers in front of me to think with a global view and mix them and play with them with ease. This is something I never found in any digital product where paper is unbeatable.
- intrepidlemon 3y agoThis could be achieved with VR although I don’t know of anything product doing this now.
- Manouchehri 3y agoVR resolution is far too poor at the moment in my opinion. At the office, I use 7200x2560 @ 144Hz (5x 27" vertical). It'll be a few years before we see VR as a competitive alternative.
- ska 3y ago> I don’t know of anything product doing this now. I suspect there is no technology really capable of doing this well yet, let alone product.
- ClimaxGravely 3y agoBut then you have to wear a VR headset.
- geniium 3y agowhich we might all be wearing in a few decades or have it integrated in our eyes.
- makeitdouble 3y agoOne side issue on these studies is there's currently no control group who spent their life solely on electronic devices. Even as tablets are distributed in school from the primary cycle, note taking and exams are all done on paper. This is not a value judgment on wether it's good or bad, just that any further study will be on subjects that spent their formative years writing on paper, they better learn to be good at it and would fail their entry into society if they couldn't do so. Any conclusion that paper works better than electronic methods comes with that asterisk to it.
- bayindirh 3y ago> One side issue on these studies is there's currently no control group who spent their life solely on electronic devices. I’m a statistic of one, but I started my digital mobile life on PalmOS/Handspring devices. I still prefer pen and paper for deep-thinking and future planning, despite having them reflected in a digital medium later. Tactility of paper, plus not being subject to a glowing screen apparently changes something deep in my mind. No, e-paper and stylus is not the same for me, either. I finish two notebooks per year.
- eternityforest 3y agoI think everyone kind of feels like paper has some benefit, but it's mostly like excercise. Short term it's a hassle, and whatever you're doing will take time to see results, and... the phone is right there, frictionless, already in your hand. Plus, to find motivation to use pen and paper, you have to have a project, which isn't just work(That is often inherently digital) which you care about enough to use high-effort methods. I love the idea of using pen and paper.... but... pen and paper are more objects to manage that can be lost and add to the clutter which is currently one of the bigger sources of stress in my life.
- bayindirh 3y agoWhile to each is their own, I don't think so. I have spent and still spend a lot of time on digital document and task management systems. I have considerable note and project troves in Evernote and Pagico. In reality, long term memory provided by Pagico is a great complement to pen and paper workflow of me, because I bake longer term plans into Pagico, and use that tool everyday, too. The phone is not frictionless, because at the end tap/click depth is much more when using a digital device when compared to pen and paper. I always put stalls into my mind flow, because you need to at least add some keyboard shortcuts or taps while streaming your knowledge to something digital. Paper doesn't have that kind of friction. Just dump it down. Markdown provides some good middle ground, but it's not completely intrerrupt-free either. A small A5 or 17x24cm notebook doesn't take a place in your daily backpack, neither a good, run of the mill flight-safe roller. Digital organization has its perks and uses which can't be and shouldn't be ignored when the data volume one manages passes a certain threshold, but pen and paper is irreplaceable in my mind. Because the uninterrupted workflow and the pacing it provides works as a great regulatory aid for me. It doesn't run out of battery, has much faster random access, do not tax my eyes much, and last but not the least, prevents carpal tunnel.
- zone411 3y agoInteresting result, but I wish they hadn't used scheduled appointments as the content of the note. I don't write down scheduled appointments because I want to have them stored in my mind, quite the opposite. It would be much more interesting if they used something you want to learn and memorize. I expect the result to hold, but still.
- deafpolygon 3y agoI would imagine that in about 20 years, this will show a different result. I feel it has strong bias due to how many of us are raised during our formative years. When tech becomes more and more common at a younger age, our brain will be different.
- awinter-py 3y agonot obvious what app they're using to input appointments (from skimming + ctrl-F-ing for 'app', 'software'). did I miss something? not sure why you'd blanket compare 'all digital input' to all paper. surely the UX matters. like is this some cursed psych study calendar app that integrates with electrodes
- aeschenbach 3y ago"Every time you write it down, you make another copy in your head."
- willsmith72 3y agoi love studies like this, i've always found this to be intuitively true, so my confirmation bias is like "YES", but i hope there's more and more research into this. smartphones are such a new technology
- xivzgrev 3y agoI once wrote out a job hunting goal on a sheet of paper and read it 3x per day for a few months, with “crazy” salary and everything. And then, I got it. I did similar thing later with multiple goals in Google docs. Found that I’m not as consistent with it and haven’t achieved those same goals. Could be consistency, more goals vs fewer, or the paper vs digital There’s something about paper that feels more real. It also forces some focus as you only have so much room on paper
- digging 3y agoI find that any goals the exist inside my computer get downgraded subconsciously because, physically, it's like sliding them into a folder with everything else I do all day every day. I can open that folder and pull out my critical life goals or the doodles I did during a meeting or that cool article I want to learn something from, etc. However, prioritizing physical space for a goal affects your real life. Maybe this doesn't apply if your written goal was just in a notebook that is also used for other things, but if it's on your desk, (and your desk isn't cluttered,) its physical important also signals the brain.
- Tadpole9181 3y agoI'm sorry, are you saying putting "get a great job" on paper and reading it repeatedly does anything at all to actually getting the job? Could it be that such a huge goal as "be successful in my career" is just more important than the ones you put in Google docs?
- hn8305823 3y agoThis correlates with my personal experience. If I take paper notes, I rarely have to go back and look at them. Even then it's usually just to confirm my memory. If I take notes on an electronic device, I'm far more likely to have to go back and look at the device.
- Shermanium 3y agoI recently bought an inexpensive fountain pen and have been enjoying my list and note taking more.
- anthk 3y agoNow do paper vs an environment like Emacs and not a passive device.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- joveian 3y agoPersonally, I'm not convinced it is a good idea to make any conclusions about reality from any fMRI study (I'm not convinced what is being measured is all that important plus even intrepreting what is being measured relies on complex statistics). Also, for this kind of thing the outliers are very important in tring to figure out what is going on. They show individual data points and eyeballing them I don't really see a lot of difference in the accuracy, with the tablet in particular being slightly worse than nearly identical phone or notes (but they had to pop out "easy questions" to make that difference look interesting). Saying there is a difference between device and paper just because the tablet condition did worse is misleading. https://www.frontiersin.org/files/Articles/634158/fnbeh-15-634158-HTML/image_m/fnbeh-15-634158-g002.jpg https://www.frontiersin.org/files/Articles/634158/fnbeh-15-6... They mention the difference in terms of location cues in the conclusion section. I would guess UI choices affect the ability to use location sense to recall information and I could easily imagine the small menus of phones enhancing this effect (and/or larger screens in general reducing the physical location effect of the device itself). Taking a quick look on Google Scholar there is some research on this kind of thing but I'm not seeing any thing that pops out as a particularly interesting presentation. Any UI designers out there who intentionally try to trigger location sense in their design?
- westurner 3y agoAlgorithmically and physically-biologically, Spreading activation has a (constant?) decay term: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spreading_activation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spreading_activation
- daveguy 3y agoNitpick: Figure 4f is an obviously incorrect regression line.