6 ms·
Ozempic could change the economy as we know it
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoI first heard of “the weight loss shot” from a morbidly obese waste management company owner friend of mine. He has steadily lost weight and kept it off with what is basically a chemically induced fast. So it clearly works. Anything that measurably reverses the insane growth rate of obesity is very welcome. If all it takes is a weekly shot to reliably improve individual decision making with consumption then that would legitimately be revolutionary. No free lunch still applies though, I’ll be interested to see what the long term externalities are.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 3y agoIt reminds me of accutane in a lot of ways. Some drugs are actually miraculous in how they solve problems, but can have some pretty nasty side effects. I wonder if Ozempic will end up like accutane as the final line of treatment when all other routes have been exhausted, or if the formulation will be refined to the point the side effects become minimal. One interesting difference between Ozempic and accutane is that the accutane treatment is pretty much permanent after a dosage round but it seems like this Ozempic needs to be continuously taken to see effects. Which is great news for pharm companies
- rblatz 3y agoSide effects are generally mild on ozempic like acid reflux and can be controlled easily with a PPI like pantoprazole. Accutane was absolute hell.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoThis is just a first step towards GLP-1 gene therapy. It works in mice and pig models so far. Piece by piece, we spellcheck the genome. Human trials are targeted for next year. https://www.fiercebiotech.com/research/fractyls-gene-therapy-obesity-outdoes-semaglutide-weight-loss-mice https://www.fiercebiotech.com/research/fractyls-gene-therapy... https://www.fractyl.com/fractyl-health-demonstrated-significant-improvement-in-weight-loss-in-head-to-head-preclinical-obesity-studies-of-its-rejuva-glp-1-based-pancreatic-gene-therapy-candidate-glp-1-pgtx-compared-to-chr/ https://www.fractyl.com/fractyl-health-demonstrated-signific... https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6812410/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6812410/
- pushedx 3y agoMy grandmother likes to tell me about how she was perscribed amphetamines for weight loss in the the 1960s, and how she struggled to escape that. I'm wary of anything in this space that seems too good to be true, and articles like this one seem like a part of a massive media push to me. Almost reads like a "9/10 doctors smoke Camels" kind of situation.
- esperent 3y agoI'm sure it's not a miracle solution. But it does seem unfair to compare it to amphetamines. For a start, it does not appear to be psychoactive to any large degree, which is a huge difference. Of course there will be psychological effects from anything that changes your weight or lifestyle rapidly, but that's not the same as being psychoactive. I think the largest issue will be sorting out the genuine side effects of the drug from the side effects that would happen from any major change in lifestyle/weight. Here's the list of side effects from wikipedia: > Possible side effects include nausea, diarrhea, vomiting, constipation, abdominal pain, headache, fatigue, indigestion/heartburn, dizziness, abdominal distension, belching, hypoglycemia (low blood glucose) in patients with type 2 diabetes, flatulence, gastroenteritis, and gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD).[26] It can also cause pancreatitis, gastroparesis, and bowel obstruction.[27] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semaglutide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semaglutide How many of the things in that list would you say a person who undergoes massive weight loss in short time without drugs would experience? Or massive changes in the amount and type of food that they eat? Especially if they also have complications with diabetes or pre-diabetes. And also, how do these compare to the inevitable health problems that long term obesity will cause the same person if they don't take the drug? These questions will not be easy question to answer. I expect to see a lot of arguments from both sides in the coming years.
- kennywinker 3y ago> And also, how do these compare to the inevitable health problems that long term obesity will cause Did you know that being in the BMI “overweight” category is healthier than any other category, including “healthy” and “underweight”? https://www.sciencealert.com/the-healthiest-weight-might-actually-be-overweight-massive-study-finds https://www.sciencealert.com/the-healthiest-weight-might-act... Now you might say well that’s interesting but i was talking about obese people taking this drug. “The study also found that those in the 'obese' category ended up having the same risk of death as those in the 'normal' range, even when factors such as age, sex, family history of disease, socio-economic status, and smoking were taken into account.” So there are plenty of justifications and reasons to take a drug like this - some good, some bad - but hand waving at the obvious dangers of being overweight or obese doesn’t hold up as well as you might think.
- mingus88 3y agoThe article suggests that when ozempic solves people’s weight loss issues, they will be happier and spend their money differently But every discussion of ozempic inevitably brings up “ozempic face” which is some apparent aging and irreversible damage done to the skin/collagen. So are we really changing the economy after obesity or are we just substituting one type of self-image issue with another, more difficult to treat one?
- wmf 3y agoObesity isn't a self-image issue; it's actually harmful.
- mingus88 3y agoThere are a lot of celebrities who are taking ozempic who aren’t obese at all. These are the before/after cases for ozempic face Weight loss body image issues often have nothing to do with obesity
- wmf 3y agoThat's fair; we shouldn't encourage some kind of drug-powered "the thinner the better" arms race.
- bandrami 3y agoIt can be, but weight fluctuation (which Ozempic deliberately causes) is also harmful and in some cases more harmful than overweight was to begin with. But also the issue isn't so much dangerously obese people taking it (on the whole probably good) but rather slightly overweight or not-even-overweight people taking it.
- autokad 3y agonot sure if it actually does damage to collagen, but in general losing weight makes you look older. its a sad reality of life over 40
- 3y ago
- evanjrowley 3y agoMy diabetic mother has a 2mg prescription for it and nobody seems to have it available. For weight loss, this is a luxury drug. For others, it's a lot more important. Unfortunately, luxury drugs get bought out by luxury people, leaving the average person in the dust... I wish ozempic's distribution was less corrupt, but that ship seems to have sailed now.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoBesides anecdotal evidence, what makes you believe that the people who are getting it need it less than your grandmother. Obesity kills people as surely, and sometimes faster, than diabetes. Are your feelings on this influenced by the notion that obesity is a moral failing or a willpower issue?
- AequitasOmnibus 3y agoObesity is curable. Diabetes is not.
- nradov 3y ago[flagged]
- leereeves 3y agoBoth can be managed (and symptoms resolved) by lifestyle changes. Both will return if someone returns to their old lifestyle. And the lifestyle changes that treat one often treat the other as well. We could argue about whether either is "cured" or just "in remission", but it's illogical to say one is cured and the other isn't.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoObesity can be a primary factor for getting type 2 diabetes.
- nradov 3y ago[flagged]
- sublinear 3y agoI can only speak for myself, but I stopped being obese and out of shape when I stopped being broke. I began to eat fewer calories of higher quality food, hit my macros, and prevented muscle loss by going to the gym a few times a week. It was a feedback loop with my social environment. Expectations of me changed when I finished school, and I didn't really think anything of it until I saw some results which only reinforced the new habits. Everyone was supportive and from there lots of other stuff in my life got cleaned up as well. I don't even drink as much as I used to. I can't be alone in feeling this way. For me it was finding good people, being happy with my career, and not being so stressed out all the time as a result.
- tired-turtle 3y agoThis is, regrettably, unattainable for many in the US (economy).
- nradov 3y agoHigh stress, poor sleep quality, alcohol abuse, and obesity all reinforce each other in a feedback loop. Breaking out of that vicious cycle often requires a complete lifestyle change including a new environment and different friends.
- sublinear 3y agoWell yeah. I moved away to a different region of the country and into a nicer neighborhood.
- maxglute 3y agoAfter 10 years of natural lifting, my maintenance calorie at sub 20% body fat is higher than when I was obese, normalized/settled at ~35% body fat around the same weight. Easier to maintain weigth and appearance than ever. And apart from hammering down some protein shakes, I eat whatever, like obesity days. That said eating clean does do wonders for my performance and energy levels. Ozempic probably has much greater gen pop appeal since it's a pill, and probably what one needs to stay on if they need to stablize below their natural setpoint. But sometimes I wonder if segments of population wouldn't be better off with a few dollars of testosterone and one day at gym a week before resorting to Ozempic. If only more longintunal research was done on moderate test usage. Arguably most slight-modest overweight people would look much better recompositing to more muscle at their current weight. That said I do have make an slight effort to be 5-10lbs shy of my setpoint weight during less active periods of winter. That few extra lbs is when I start experiencing health issues like gastric reflux and increase in blood pressure.
- hnburnsy 3y agoStudy that says these drugs could prevent 1.5 million cardiac events over 10 years... ----- We identified 3999 US adults weighted to an estimated population size of 93.0 million [M] (38% of US adults) who fit STEP 1 eligibility criteria. Applying STEP 1 treatment effects on weight loss resulted in an estimated 69.1% (64.3 M) and 50.5% (47.0 M) showing ≥ 10% and ≥ 15% weight reductions, respectively, translating to a 46.1% (43.0 M) reduction in obesity (BMI ≥ 30 kg/m2) prevalence. Among those without CVD, estimated 10-year CVD risks were 10.15% “before” and 8.34% “after” semaglutide “treatment” reflecting a 1.81% absolute (and 17.8% relative) risk reduction translating to 1.50 million preventable CVD events over 10 years. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37166206 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37166206
- empathy_m 3y agoI've lost about 33% of my body weight throughout 2023 on Wegovy (the weight loss brand of semaglutide). There were major weight related health complications I was having at 34 BMI and they're not happening now. I knew how to lose weight -- meticulously track every calorie, use diet and exercise to hit targets. I had done it before , down to -10% and -25% body mass twice in the past ten years. But it never stayed that way -- I found it incredibly hard to stick to my kcal in goal or to stay at a stable lower weight. I'd eat when I was hungry, and eat enough to stay at my long term stable weight. If I ever stopped tracking every calorie in, my default sense of "full" tended towards a caloric surplus. This drug fills exactly the gap I was struggling to fill with previous attempts at weight loss. I've felt "full" at 1500 kcal/day for months (though have had more of an appetite in the past 1-2 months) and have ended almost every day with a caloric deficit. It's a serious pharmaceutical intervention and I read the literature on GLP-1 agonists for years before starting. There were side effects, notably reflux when eating too much, "sulfur burps", and a general feeling of malaise for the day after taking a dose for the first few months. No idea what the long term consequences of staying on this drug forever will be. Haven't noticed any other behavior changes. Not particularly interested in the appearance angle (I felt like I looked okay before and look okay now, though I've needed new clothes due to dramatic changes in waist size). But the health stuff is serious and real and if we can make this drug cheaply available to people who discuss it carefully with a doctor there is potential for a serious chronic disorder to be addressed much more effectively than it used to be.
- saurik 3y ago> I've felt "full" at 1500 kcal/day for months... How are you handling nutritional requirements? Do you take a bunch of supplements? Are you loading up on protein?
- gpsx 3y agoI wonder about the same thing in general for people taking this drug. I think the reason some people are overweight is because their body is asking for that much food not for the sake of caloies but to get adequate nutrition. (I am not sure what fraction this would apply to.)
- doodlebugging 3y agoIf this drug costs $1000/month does it really put money in people's pockets that they will use to buy other things that end up boosting the economy? They first need to be able to pay for the next hit of Ozempic. I don't see the connection unless the ones producing the drug are getting all that money and buying new 3rd homes with custom furniture, new vehicles, etc. Since insurance evidently doesn't cover this for everyone there will be a lot of people paying ridiculous money to lose weight who will then be stuck on the lifetime drug treadmill as a health maintenance requirement drug. Why don't we invest the money going to this expense in health education and public facilities for health maintenance - parks, gyms, etc. I understand that many are already morbidly obese and need something like this drug to get them back in control of their own health outcomes but the overall goal should be to shed the extra weight and discontinue the drug while adopting healthy lifestyle habits.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y ago> If this drug costs $1000/month does it really put money in people's pockets that they will use to buy other things that end up boosting the economy? How much does being obese cost the average person in healthcare? I'd be surprised if it was A LOT less.
- doodlebugging 3y agoThis is probably a good take. I think though that the cost of health care only comes into play when the obese person begins to take action to try to change their situation or to manage their condition. Until that point their health care costs are minimal since they are not focused on staying healthy or becoming healthier. But yes, overcoming the consequences of obesity will be expensive, a lot more than this drug.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoI mean, how often are they getting sick and missing work compared to non-obese people? There's all kinds of opportunity costs to being unhealthy.
- deleted 3y ago
- jongjong 3y agoYou know someone has a real issue with food if they're willing to stab themselves with a needle once a week rather than just voluntarily restraining themselves. Don't think I would ever do this. Thankfully, my metabolism is not too bad. Not as good as my siblings who are all skinny but given how much I eat and given that I'm approaching middle age, I really can't complain.
- willy_k 3y agoGood for you. Are you in denial?
- jongjong 3y agoNot sure what kind of response you expect from such comment? I have all the information about my fitness level and you have 0 information about it. It would be pointless for me to post my earlier comment online, anonymously, if I was actually overweight. It's not like I'm seeking confirmation about my fitness from people who've never even seen me.
- tasty_freeze 3y agoIt sounds like you have a fear of needles more than anything else. I've probably had 100 blood draws in my life, and those needs are far fatter and more painful than drug delivery needles. It isn't a big deal for most people. I'm guessing you didn't get the covid-19 shots.
- xyst 3y agoI don’t know about you all, but I would hope people/doctors are using this as a last resort.
- rblatz 3y agoAnyone even slightly overweight can go to a clinic and get semaglutide that day.
- MacsHeadroom 3y agoYou don't actually have to be overweight. You just need to have trouble controlling your food intake. I'm a healthy weight. But it's only because I eat one meal a day and feel terribly hungry the entire day. When I eat more than once a day I balloon up into the obese category. So I am a good candidate for these treatments despite currently being in the low end of "normal" BMI.
- j0hnyl 3y agoA couple of months ago I was in the hospital for routine surgery. When I was in the pre-op area I overheard the conversation happening in the bed next to mine where a person was about to go into unplanned surgery and was consulting with an anesthesiologist. The doctor was suggesting a certain course of action that the patient wasn't in to, but the doctor explained that his suggestion came from the position that ozempic was so new that there was so little understanding of how it interacted with anesthesia and other things in general, they had to proceed with extreme caution. He kept stressing how little was know about this drug when it came to an emergency or surgery setting.
- anovikov 3y agoThat shit is real. I was never obese but somewhat overweight and lost half the excess weight in just 2 months even still being far from full dose (it escalates over 4 months to minimise side effects). Side effects so far: 3 days of bad headache close to the end of 1st month, and about two cases of 1-2 days of light to moderate headache after. Nothing else. Plus, i completely quit drinking. Was never trying to even going to, i just didn't feel like drinking at all anymore about a month into it.
- arcanemachiner 3y agoWhy do I feel like I just read an ad for Ozempic?
- maxglute 3y agoWonder about economic impact of not just people going to restaurants less, but large percent of population operating on sigificant caloric deficit, which has adverse effects on energy levels and cognition. Basically smalls scale seasonal famine, because most likely, casual users are going to cycle on before summer hits. I'm reading 1000+ calorie deficits. I don't know about others, but that amount of deficit over weeks/months impairs my daily functioning outside of just hunger.