7 ms·
Automakers must build cheaper, smaller EVs to spur adoption, report says
- Solvency 3y agoAll I want is a car that looks aesthetically like a 2dr Wrangler but fully electric. Is that so much to ask for? In other words: sporty looking, slightly rugged, no frills.
- mikestew 3y agoWe will see how much Jeep fancies up the electric Wrangler they allegedly have in the pipe: https://electrek.co/2023/05/12/the-all-electric-jeep-wrangler-is-coming-an-off-road-legend/ https://electrek.co/2023/05/12/the-all-electric-jeep-wrangle...
- newsclues 3y agoHybrids will spur adoption faster and cheaper than anything
- jgalt212 3y agothe good is the enemy of the perfect.
- Abroszka 3y agoHybrids doesn't make sense to me. If you need a car that runs on gas then make it a proper ICE car. Why put two engines into one? Seems super wasteful.
- nwvg_7257 3y agoConsumer report says hybrids are more reliable than ICE and EVs https://www.consumerreports.org/cars/car-reliability-owner-satisfaction/who-makes-the-most-reliable-cars-a7824554938/ https://www.consumerreports.org/cars/car-reliability-owner-s... "Overall, hybrids have 26 percent fewer problems than cars powered by internal combustion engines (ICE)."
- Abroszka 3y agoSeems fishy to me. How can a more complex device (ICE + EV) be more reliable than a pure ICE or EV? Also seems like a crap website, their chart show 79% more problems as red and then 26% fever as green.
- bombcar 3y agoBecause modern ICE cars have freaking overgrown snowmobile transmissions, and a hybrid drivetrain can replace that entirely. A hybrid can be simpler than an ICE car (by eliminating the transmission and allowing the engine to be power-banded) and cheaper than an EV (because a 10x size battery is more than the cost of the engine and generator).
- Abroszka 3y agoStill doesn't explain how the EV is less reliable. OK, it's more expensive due to the battery, but surely no ICE at all should make it more reliable.
- mlsu 3y agoMost mechanical stresses in the drivetrain are transient and happen in the transmission. In the engine, they happen in the "out of band" power regimes -- very low and very high RPM. The hybrid moves those transient "stresses," and the imparted maintenance thereof, into the electrical system. The engine never sees them. This unlocks additional efficiencies. For example, the Prius uses the more fuel efficient Atkinson cycle engine. This is not possible in a standard car, because it cannot provide enough power in those transient regimes. You also get things like regenerative braking which help prolong brake life. And, there's probably a bit of selection bias as well. I could see that the type of someone who buys a Prius is the type to not thrash it. That probably makes it appear more reliable in the statistics.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoPHEV's are significantly less reliable, though. HEV's and PHEV's should have a similar level of reliability. The difference is that HEV's are mostly Toyotas and PHEV's mostly aren't. My impression is that non-Toyota hybrids are significantly less reliable than gasoline cars, but the article doesn't give enough data to tell for sure.
- voisin 3y agoElectric for 95% of driving, gas to eliminate range anxiety for the few longer trips per year. Use the gas for charging the batteries - no connection between gas engine and electric drivetrain.
- Abroszka 3y agoBut then just rent an ICE car when you go for a long drive... better for the environment.
- oldnetguy 3y agoThat makes no financial sense. I bought a car because rentals over time exceeded the ownership of owning. Since many trips are outside the EV range.
- Abroszka 3y agoNot sure. In the comment I replied to, they mentioned that EV is good 95% of the time. In that case, renting a car, like once a month, for a long range tip would make sense imo. Better yet, public transport, then rent an EV there.
- olyjohn 3y agoOr just get a PHEV. And then you only need 1/3 of the batteries in your car, and you don't have to deal with rentals. Does it really make sense to have 300 miles worth of batteries that you haul around in your car when 90% of your trips are less than 100 miles?
- Abroszka 3y agoNo, but it makes less sense to haul around an ICE or more battery than needed for 100 miles.
- uoaei 3y agoHave you dealt with a rental agency in a population hub any time in the past 15 years? It's awful service and such a pain to do all the research anew on pricing every time you want to do a drive. Much easier to manage your own predictable resources than try to shove your use-case into another organization's framework.
- ClarityJones 3y agoA Model 3's battery is 82kWh, a Camry Hybrid's battery is 1.6kWH. In terms of battery, you could produce (82 / 1.6 = 51.25) hybrids per fully electric car. The total fuel savings of replacing 10+ ICE cars with hybrids is an order of magnitude larger than replacing 1 ICE car with a fully electric car.
- Abroszka 3y agoFor each of those 51 hybrids you need to manufacture an extra ICE engine. Which is not cheap. It's more complex to make a drive train that can seamlessly handle switching from EV to ICE. So it's more difficult to manufacture. Has there been a study that takes the whole lifecycle of a hybrid into account vs an EV or ICE? Would be super interested if there had been a research that also takes into account that we don't need SUVs that seems to be the go to car in the US.
- olyjohn 3y agoICE engines may be more complex, but batteries are still more expensive than a small ICE engine. Have you seen the cost of a replacement battery for a Tesla? $12-20k all day long. You don't need a massive, high performance ICE engine to charge up batteries on the go, or to get your car down the highway. Meanwhile I can get a high performance crate engine for less than half that cost ($5-6k all day). Less than half that for a basic, economical 4 banger.
- timbit42 3y agoA PHEV battery is 1/10th the size of an EV battery typically giving about 50 km of range. 90% of most people's daily use is less than 50 km. We could build 10 PHEVs with the battery from one EV. This means instead of an EV cutting fossil fuel use by 100%, 10 PHEVs could cut fossil fuel use by 90% x 10 = 900%. PHEVs also charge faster due to the battery being 1/10th the size but they don't require buying a 240v charger and can be charged using 120v in 1/5th the time of an EV. If you don't have anywhere to charge, you'll have to get an HEV.
- tzs 3y agoThe best you can get with current pure ICEs is about 35/43/39 mpg city/highway/combined. A non-plug-in Toyota Prius gets 57/56/57. A Hyundai Elantra hybrid gets 53/56/54.
- newsclues 3y agoIt's about getting more people using EV more often, and efficiently using the limited resources required for EVs. Please go read about Toyota's strategy. If you have enough Lithium for 1000 EV batteries, or 10,000 hybrid batteries, it seems pretty easy to see how it is better for everyone, especially given average trip distance. Not sure why hybrids don't make sense to you, have you done the research to consider all aspects of the change, or are you focused on a specific factor like reliability or wastefulness of the parts used? Don't you think it's wasteful to put a massive battery in a car to give it a long range that will be rarely used in most trips?
- notatoad 3y agoHybrids will spur adoption of EVs? A hybrid is not an EV, if your goal is to sell EVs then hybrids aren't accomplishing that.
- jabroni_salad 3y agoIsn't the upsizing of vehicles because of consumer demand, though? They can sell crossovers and trucks into the consumer base at such volume and margin that it is worthwhile to simply stop making sedans. There are people like me who just want an electric honda fit but it seems like there aren't enough of us to be worth the effort.
- sumtechguy 3y agoThat and the way the curves are made by the gov. Many small cars they just can not make because they would not fit the requirements set by the gov. So they classify them as trucks (different set of curves).
- mitthrowaway2 3y agoI think EVs would not have difficulty meeting those small car fuel economy standards, even though they are very strict. But they may not feel safe on a road surrounded by Dodge Rams and Raptors.
- Swizec 3y ago> an electric honda fit IoniQ 5 comes close. It's the first EV that made me go "omg I want that!". One of these days I'll take one for a test drive. Looks so cool, isn't super huge even though it's still big, and doesn't even try to look like a SUV. Although maybe I've been in USA too long and my perception is skewed because Wikipedia calls it a "compact crossover suv". Maybe battery size is a limiting factor here? The electric mustang looks like an SUV, but has a lower ground clearance (5.1in) than the sports car internal combustion version (5.3in)
- bombcar 3y agoSUV is also an over-abused term because it used to only refer to giant vehicles, but now all the various compacts and crossovers are just cars that ride a bit higher. And all things considered, a car with a trunk will almost always lose to the same vehicle with a more SUV-like end, because it can hold more.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoNah. People don't want small cars. Don't try to sell them yet another Bolt or Leaf they won't buy while the inventory languishes on some sad dealer lot until the model is discontinued due to anemic sales. Focus on revealed preference, not what consumers say they want. > Yes, it’s true that the Ford F-150 remained the most popular vehicle sold in America last year. No surprise. It has been for 40 years. In fact, the F-150 was the most popular new and used vehicle sold in America last year. Ford moved 726,004 F-150s out showroom doors in 2021, making it the top seller by over 150,000 units. The Ram 1500 finally moved up from third to second with 569,388 and the Chevrolet Silverado fell to third with 519,774. https://www.autoweek.com/news/trucks/a38752901/most-popular-vehicles-sold-by-state/ https://www.autoweek.com/news/trucks/a38752901/most-popular-... https://www.visualcapitalist.com/the-best-selling-vehicle-in-every-state/ https://www.visualcapitalist.com/the-best-selling-vehicle-in... https://electrek.co/2023/05/25/tesla-model-y-is-now-the-worlds-best-selling-car-first-ev-to-do-so/ https://electrek.co/2023/05/25/tesla-model-y-is-now-the-worl...
- losteric 3y agoWho's buying those F-150s and how amenable are they to EVs? It's not enough to just look at what's most popular if the underlying demographics are more resistant to EVs on an ideological basis.
- heyjamesknight 3y agoI belong to a social group of dads from my son’s school. Most of them are blue collar conservatives. They all have pickups. Not one is opposed to electric, as long as the details make sense. But these are camping, fishing, hunting folk. Even the Lightning, which is an awesome product all around, doesn’t have the range+charging network to make it useable away from the home. So for now, they’ll buy another ICE truck. But they’re absolutely open to it. Very, very few people are opposed to electric for “ideological reasons.”
- toomuchtodo 3y agoGreat questions. Insights below on the emotional component of consumers in question: https://www.thedrive.com/news/26907/you-dont-need-a-full-size-pickup-truck-you-need-a-cowboy-costume https://www.thedrive.com/news/26907/you-dont-need-a-full-siz... https://coltura.org/gasoline-superusers-2-report/ https://coltura.org/gasoline-superusers-2-report/ https://www.axios.com/2023/10/25/electric-vehicles-politics https://www.axios.com/2023/10/25/electric-vehicles-politics https://www.axios.com/2023/09/27/state-politics-electric-vehicles-2024 https://www.axios.com/2023/09/27/state-politics-electric-veh... https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20231108-three-big-reasons-americans-havent-rapidly-adopted-evs https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20231108-three-big-reas...
- rgmerk 3y agoIn much of the world you can buy a BYD Atto 3, which sits in precisely this sector of the market. But not in the USA.
- droopyEyelids 3y agoThis is interesting because it shows some complexity inherent to a government supporting a domestic industry. Naively it seems like the government would block imports of the small Chinese EVs so that domestic industry could compete BUT domestic automakers do not want the segment of a $5k tiny vehicle to exist at all, and will not 'compete' for that market! The margins and sales on such a thing would hurt the us auto industry as a whole. Even if a single US automaker stood to win the whole segment, their revenue and OI would sink because of cannabalizing their own full sized sales. So we're left with a profound market distortion, where the "government's" (scare quotes because legislation in this area is driven by automakers not citizens) work to support the industry is having a bunch of unexpected effects. Sure, the automakers stocks are doing fine, but this has shut off development of a new technology, which will end up taxing the populace & increasing impact to the environment, and throttling a new domestic industry that will have defense applications in the future.
- bombcar 3y agoYou can solve the problem "easily" if there's political will for it. You allow "golf cart" manufacturers to sell "golf carts" that are fully enclosed and meet some lower safety level because they're "limited" to 35 miles an hour, or classified as motorcycles, or whatever. Then you "officially" prohibit them from freeways, but turn a blind eye to it, until it's so common, that you can relax the laws associated.
- bryanlarsen 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neighborhood_Electric_Vehicle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neighborhood_Electric_Vehicle
- rgmerk 3y ago
- Yhippa 3y agoI was very close to buying an EV this summer but ended up not getting it. It felt like I could get an equivalent ICE car for about $20K cheaper. I did a lot of research about EV charging and the more I read the more I felt I didn't understand how it would practically work. I make a long trip every month or so and it sounds like the EV charging network isn't quite to where the point where it's as easy, quick, and cost efficient as filling up gas in an ICE car. I think I'm going to wait for another 8-10 years for the kinks and range to be worked out. PHEV or Hybrid for me until then.
- pmorici 3y agoIf you get a Tesla it is solved now. The charging is seamless and reliable pretty much everywhere except the very most out of the way places. All the rest though that can't yet use Tesla's charging network I would agree total trash if you want to do a long trip and need charging. This should change in ~2 years when manufactures start making more EVs that are compatible with NACS (aka Tesla's super charger network)
- Yhippa 3y agoThis is going to sound like a real dumb reason to avoid a Tesla but it disappoints me that they don't have Android Auto or Apple CarPlay. I tried them in rental cars over the past year and now that's a must-have in my next car.
- 2sk21 3y agoAgree - I will not buy a car without CarPlay no matter what other benefits it may offer.
- baggy_trough 3y agoI have the same feeling.
- dv_dt 3y agoAlso, a number of domestic mfrs are switching over the the Tesla charging plug, some as soon as the '24 year models. Don't know what the arrangements for using the network will look like though.
- the_crocodile 3y agoThis is a natural market progression and will happen. Most automakers built higher cost, lower volume "premium" products for less price sensitive early adopters. As the product and market matures, costs reduce and more mass market products are available at lower costs (Model S->Model 3 -> Model 2 etc). Used cars also become available over time to increase supply and lower costs for a different market segment.
- antisthenes 3y agoHow many times are we going to have to rediscover the supply/demand curve? Turns out if you steal all the savings from owning an EV in terms of fuel from the consumer, they are less likely to want to buy one. Will the mysteries of the world never cease?
- Glench 3y agoI guess what a lot of people don't understand is that if we want to keep a livable climate (within our carbon budget), basically every car anyone buys from here on out has to be electric. It's that urgent. If we started decarbonizing many years ago we wouldn't need such a breakneck speed, but alas. Realistically based on current car prices and people's budgets and lack of charging infrastructure it's not happening as fast as needed. But it is still happening fast which is excellent! I hope it keeps accelerating!
- roody15 3y agoAgree.. live north of i80 and in the winters here EV’s don’t have the range needed for rural areas. Hybrids works great and efficient ice’s do the trick. Heating your Tesla and cold’s impact on lithium ion batteries equals really reduced range (40/50 percent loss of range). It is surprising how quickly it seems people on online forums dismiss hybrids but honestly they seem to make the best sense at the right price point with our current tech. Just my two cents.