9 ms·
The Persistent Myth That Most Americans Are Miserable at Work
- underseacables 3y agoMiserable is not the right word. I think most Americans feel unfulfilled at their jobs. They don't feel accomplished, just another brick in the wall.
- baal80spam 3y agoWhile it may be true, I'd assume this is the case for 99% of the working people.
- taeric 3y agoI agree. My gut would be that we are able to hear of more folks that are not "fulfilled" by their job. But it is really hard to hold some thoughts in my head about how this is really new. Worse, I think, is that it sells to tell people how bad off things are. Which seems to be driving even worse moods and outlooks along the way.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoYeah, it's like 99% of people didn't grow up dreaming to file TPS reports or do landscaping for 8 hours a day, but rent has to be paid somehow and landlords don't accept payment in unrealistic hopes and dreams. It would be much cooler for al of us to be writers, musicians, painters, astronauts and F1 drivers. I remember talking to my grandad who went from WW2 trenches, to famine, to working on the farm for 16+ hours/day and raising 10 kids, about purpose and fulfilment through work, whether all that hard work made him depressed, and he said that thought never occurred to him, that he never had any time to feel depressed or unfulfilled, he just did whatever had to be done to survive without thinking about fulfillment or purpose, but that he never really felt unhappy from any kind of work. IMHO, looking at what's happening globally and what my grandad went through, it's a sign of incredible prosperity to have the luxury to think about fulfillment needing to come from work.
- johnnyworker 3y agoHow do you know we wouldn't be off even better with less alienation and exploitation? What makes you think those generate prosperity, rather than destroying it? > It would be much cooler for al of us to be musicians, painters, astronauts and F1 drivers. No, it would be cool if we were fully fledged human beings and shared some of the shitty work that needs doing more fairly, and stopped exploiting each other. Between those two things you'd quell a lot of "complaints". It's not about doing grand things, anything can be grand if you have the heart for it, and put your heart in it. > Suppose that humans happen to be so constructed that they desire the opportunity for freely undertaken productive work. Suppose that they want to be free from the meddling of technocrats and commissars, bankers and tycoons, mad bombers who engage in psychological tests of will with peasants defending their homes, behavioral scientists who can't tell a pigeon from a poet, or anyone else who tries to wish freedom and dignity out of existence or beat them into oblivion. -- Noam Chomsky But you can't put your heart into being a cog. I don't even think you can put any real heart into being powerful and using people as cogs, that's both a failure state of how to human IMO.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>How do you know we wouldn't be off even better with less alienation and exploitation? Depends who is the "we" here. Much of the lifestyle and perks of living in the developed west are dependent on other less fortunate people being exploited: cheap cocoa and cheap coffee grown in the poorest African nations, cheap bananas, asparagus and other fruits and vegs in your supermarket, cheap electronics made in China with mineral mined by kids in Africa, cheap clothes made in the poorest SE Asian countries, cheap semiconductors etched in Taiwan, etc. Entire industries and supply chains we take for granted in the west as being commodities now, depend on what is basically modern slavery and environmental destruction we intentionally turn a blind eye on. So if all those exploited people were to be be less exploited and have the prosperity to choose other careers than to work in mines, farms or sweatshops to supply the wealthy west, then those "we" would be much better off, but then the westerners "we" would be less well off as now we wouldn't be able to afford those commodities we take for granted at the new non-slavery prices. >No, it would be cool if we were fully fledged human beings and shared some of the shitty work that needs doing more fairly, and stopped exploiting each other. And who gets to fairly decide the global sharing of that shitty work? Because I don't know anyone who would like to scrub toilets for a living, or collect minerals form piles of scrap, mine uranium and lithium, etc. Do we draw straws? Or the more likely scenario for humanity, have a world war, and the victors get the nice comfy work and the losers the shitty work. Yes, it would be cool if the human race would give up on the greed driven self enrichment and exploitation of others, and reach a utopic enlightenment where all the shitty work would be done by robots instead of the desperate people of the poorest countries, but we're very far away from that. A good first step, let's start properly taxing our 1% wealth hoarding corporate elite who thrive on the human and environmental exploitation (cough Saudi Aramco, Nestle, Exxon, cough) while amassing more wealth than the 99% could spend in a lifetime, tax free in offshore heavens. But since we can't even collectively crack down on that simple thing, I don't have any hopes we'll be able to solve the rest of humanity's issues without any major world conflict and decimation resetting the monopoly board.
- GuB-42 3y agoI think what is specifically American is that people are not content with that situation. In many countries, people don't really expect fulfillment from their jobs, they just expect to get paid so that they can find fulfillment elsewhere.
- spit2wind 3y agoThe challenge is that in America, it's hard to find fulfillment elsewhere when the middle class is disappearing, you're working so hard to make up for it, and constantly stressed about staying afloat (most Americans are not even floating). It's not some inherent "American mindset". It's the situation American is in.
- lupusreal 3y ago[dead]
- michaelt 3y ago> The real story, to the extent that these surveys are accurate, is that American workers are astonishingly happy and engaged I've always suspected journalists can get a biased impression from sources like social media, because normal people don't go on social media to brag about how good they have it or say how much they love their employers (except perhaps on linkedin). If my waiter buddy posts about how he's had a shitty day with rude customers and his boss cancelling his holiday because they're short-staffed? I might say "oh man that sucks - work, amiright?" I'm sure as hell not going to chime in and tell him I'm highly paid with interesting work and great conditions. I can easily see how a journalist, viewing Twitter or Reddit or Facebook, could come to the conclusion that everyone hates their jobs.
- lawlessone 3y ago>because normal people don't go on social media to brag about how good they have it Have you seen LinkedIn? people get sacked without warning and still praise their former bosses/companies. Not because they necessarily liked either (maybe they did) but because there is a fear of being seen as negative when trying to find another job.
- rco8786 3y agoI’m curious how you are able to know the inner motivations of the people making those posts
- mjhay 3y agoMost people hate losing their livelihood.
- hotpotamus 3y agoBecause no actual human I've met in real life is as willing to fellate their employer as enthusiastically as the people I see on LinkedIn? And I'm saying that as someone who's quite happy to sing the praises of my current employer.
- whaleofatw2022 3y ago
- thrway63245 3y ago[dead]
- nonethewiser 3y agoThere are lots of factors, and every work situation is different, but from my perspective in tech I think misery with work is largely a symptom of people's attitudes. Pay and working conditions are better than 90% (or more) of other jobs out there and you often don't even need a bachelors degree. If people outside big tech hubs knew the details of tech workers situations they might lose their mind.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y ago"Be thankful for what you have; You'll end up having more. If you focus on what you don't have, you'll never have enough." - Oprah. IME, >50% focus on what they don't have - which is why they complain so much.
- hotpotamus 3y agoI actually agree with those words, but they rankle when coming from a billionaire. I felt the same way when Munger's quote about not feeling like a victim was posted here, particularly after someone mentioned that apparently his family connections were able to overturn his denial to enter Harvard. Maybe we should find some spiritual leaders or other to hear from. At least Oprah might at least have some distant memory of what it was like to be poor I suppose.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y ago> I actually agree with those words, but they rankle when coming from a billionaire Oprah is arguably the single most self-made billionaire in the history of the US. She was almost literally dirt poor for her entire childhood, and was basically poor until her late 20s. I think she gets a free pass here.
- hotpotamus 3y agoI mean, she wasn't just poor, she was a poor black woman in America. She certainly seems genuine even with all the money, but I still have a tough time giving her a free pass - she can afford to pay whatever the pass costs.
- happytoexplain 3y agoSubtitle: "One could make the argument that, actually, American workers are happier than they’ve been in decades." So the writer chooses to start out right away with the obvious fallacy that people can't be both happier than in decades and also miserable. A. They may be gate-keeping the word "miserable" to omit the mundane misery of working for a living at something you don't love (or at least don't 40-hours-a-week love). B. It's very hard to empirically measure "how happy are US workers". Surveys are useless (people have all sorts of reasons for responding in a way that doesn't communicate their true feelings), and second-order indicators are fuzzy. This ambiguity also makes it very easy to get the answer you want. C. Many people right now are obviously miserable because they don't feel they are getting the same rewards per effort as what they feel previous generations got (which is probably a mix of truth and bias). D. Even if we ignore the variability of C, the universal constant will always be there: The availability of types of work will never match the availability people who enjoy each type, and even when the universe could pair a person with a position they would like, a lot of luck is involved. It's a fundamental problem of work that will probably not be solved until the far sci-fi future (if that ever comes). This is an uncomfortable truth. Most people who are happy at work are not happy because of the work, but simply because they get to socialize with people they enjoy socializing with. Employers of course prefer to push the message of this article's thesis instead. As an aside: In addition to socializing, there is now a second source of non-work-related happiness: Working from home. This increases happiness for both introverted people, and also extroverted people who happen to be in a work environment where they don't really click with their coworkers personality-wise, which is a lot of people - maybe most people in a 21st cen. culture with so many diverse personality types. Luckily you can make both groups happy by allowing both modes of work, since the latter group were mostly not contributing to the social happiness of the former group anyway. Edit: As pointed out, extroverts can also be fulfilled by in-person socializing at home. Also, both extroverts and introverts can fulfill or supplement their happy dose of socializing virtually (usually via text, which counter-intuitively is a better vector for socializing than video calls).
- galangalalgol 3y agoTo your aside, I am one of the only people on my very social block that doesnt work from home. The block is its own social structure and people find it kind of odd I have regular contact with people in other parts of the city and go into work every day. So extroverts in dense areas can still thrive in wfh. Until we eliminate scarcity or come close, not everyone can be at the self actualization section of the hierarchy of needs. And fighting automation doesn't get there faster. We need to take care of people independently from employment. We also need people who were in those jobs to at least try to pitch in on the stuff we haven't automated yet including automating things. If that isn't possible due to ability mismatch, then idelness is a mental health issue, so some help engaing on tasks that are in the self actualization realm would be great. This is all a naive pipe dream with human nature being what it is, but a nice one.
- JohnFen 3y agoMost people I personally know are miserable at work, anyway.
- horns4lyfe 3y agoJust one data point, but I love my job now that I can work from home. The work is interesting and challenging, and I don’t have to deal with all of the office bullshit. Pretty simple equation.
- derbOac 3y agoI'm not sure what to make of articles like this because, on the one hand, I appreciate someone trying to stay close to the data, but on the other hand, I don't trust the data they use, and feel like it could all be spun in different ways. Just to take one small example: Thompson cites as an example of happier workers a poll question showing that there was a 20% increase in people saying that it's "a good time to find a job.” But what does that mean? That there are lots of openings because people have in fact left their jobs they were unhappy with? Turnover means people are happier with their jobs? Or take this: 35% of people say "that opportunities abound for them to do 'more of what they do best.'" so the other 65% of people don't matter? Maybe it's unchanged since 2013 but is that a good benchmark? Are people thinking of other opportunities? Another elephant in the room is whether the happiest are happier, and the unhappy are less happy. This might or might not be the case, but talking about these survey respondents like they're a large homogenous group is problematic. It may be that there are areas of the economy that have in fact gotten much worse for large segments, even as they have gotten better for other segments. Focusing on the happy doesn't talk about the unhappiness of the unhappy, which is in fact what Thompson is trying to rebut. Finally, I've grown distrustful of these surveys in general. It's not clear to me that what people say in response to a pollster reflects anything meaningful about their actual behavior and emotional state in the way people want them to mean. I do not want to be dismissive because people should pay attention to them, but I'm not sure I've seen convincing evidence that aggregate survey responses track with societal trends in a way that suggests their unbounded validity. Even the figure tracking job satisfaction since 1987 — which I give credit to Thompson for posting — hides a lot. Sure, you can see the Great Recession in that figure, but if you didn't know about it, what would you make of it? What about the drug epidemic and declines in life expectancy? Should we be incorporating birth rate declines into the conversation? Are people unhappy with their jobs, or with some things about society in general? I bring that up not to say "life sucks for members of society right now" but rather, it's not always clear to me how you should use measures of things like "societal happiness" or what that even means. In some place as heterogeneous as the US, given all the problems we've had as a country, is it insensitive to have these kinds of discussions at all until we're more attentive to the worst off?
- InCityDreams 3y ago
- menssen 3y agoOff-topic rant: to read this article, I: 1. Clicked on the link. 2. Got pay-walled. 3. Remembered that I had access to the Atlantic through Apple News+. 4. Opened the News App on my phone. 5. Went to Magazines. 6. Found the latest issue of The Atlantic. 7. Found the hidden link to go to the magazine's "channel," since this article was not actually in the magazine. 8. Thankfully, this article was the most recent thing posted. 9. Read the article hunched over my phone while the still-paywalled version was looming over my head on my computer screen. Somebody has to figure out how to fix this.
- nine_zeros 3y agoFor me, the times I have felt miserable at work have been the times when the work environment changed from collaborative to backstabby/competitive - often due to punitive management structures. What I learned from reflecting on 2 such instances is that what makes for a great workplace is not ping-pong tables or lots of cash. It is that I need to feel like I am entering a trustworthy environment day after day. This is also perhaps why vets enjoy talking about their time in service because the environment is not sustained punitive - even if it is a tough job. You can trust everyone (and especially your boss) to have your back. A sustained entry into an untrustworthy environment (read: talking to your own manager might be dangerous) really takes a toll on me. Ever since this realization, I have started to look for honest and trustworthy environments for my jobs. And it has worked great for my mental health.
- johnea 3y agoThe Persistent Myth that articles about Persistent Myths are themselves Persistent Myths... With hundreds of millions of workers in the US, I'm sure every persistent myth is true for someone...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tennisflyi 3y agoCap. Unless you’re in a building similar to those by Gensler and similar, you’re not happy. Let’s compare breakrooms. Anyone?