10 ms·
Wealth Systems in RPGs
- sproketboy 3y ago[dead]
- sinistersnare 3y agoI had a couple strategies 1) Do not give too much wealth to PCs. Keeping the heroes poor is a kind of dramatic tension that not many campaigns explore! 2) Give them ways to spend their money! If the PCs need to go to an island, make the waters dangerous, and drive the price of the safer boat up. The danger is not fully evaded, but perhaps now they have a crew to help in any encounters. The party of course is always free to think of more creative ways around. Make sure you as a DM always have an idea of the goals of the PCs, that includes economically. If a PC is aiming to purchase a nice item, keep that in mind when doling out gold, but always be sure to keep dramatic tension of the economy in place.
- awithrow 3y agoI've always wanted to run a campaign that does the opposite: give them an obscene amount of wealth. First problem would be how do they even transport, store, and guard it without being jumped, ripped off and robbed? Did they think millions of coins would fit in a few sacks? Maybe a "No Country For Old Men" type situation? Sure they're rich as kings but there are more powerful beings that know about their wealth and they are coming.
- IggleSniggle 3y agoAn alternative to keeping PCs poor is to make them "rich-poor." They are effectively so rich that money does not matter, but the setting is such that there is nothing they can buy that will make them better off. When they reach a town, they can always afford to do whatever they like (when it comes to coin), but they might not be able to afford the narrative consequences of their choices. The key aspect of "keep them poor" is really just "limit the availability of upgrades." In a desolate world, there's nothing to buy. With super-hero tier PCs, even in an abundant city, there's nothing to buy that matters that doesn't also come with knock on consequences.
- djur 3y agoIn practice I've found this strategy to be pretty frustrating as a player. If treasure is going to be part of the campaign, give me something to spend it on. If it isn't, don't bother -- but in a system like D&D, you need to then provide an alternate method for obtaining equipment and upgrades.
- pclmulqdq 3y agoThis sort of thing only works with relatively inexperienced PCs, who don't realize that 1000 GP can hire all of a typical town for a few weeks to do almost anything, no questions asked. That quantity of hirelings is a relatively effective replacement to magic items. All you have to do afterward is turn combat problems into non-combat problems, which is relatively easy if you can think outside the box. Need to clear a dungeon? Divert the nearest river to flood it and then use some other means (magical) to clear out the water. Need to cross a bridge guarded by trolls? The new bridge you build won't be guarded by anyone.
- com2kid 3y ago> Need to clear a dungeon? Divert the nearest river to flood it and then use some other means (magical) to clear out the water. In a future setting (Eclipse Phase), the party was sent out to investigate rumors of a downed spaceship. We bought a rover, bought a wagon to go behind the rover. Filled it up with the setting's equivalent of C4. The GM tried to stop us on route, we planned very far and ended up hauling the trailer by hand (the rover got destroyed by a landmine, we specified a 10m rope between the rover and the wagon full of explosives just for such an occasion, the GM had forgotten about that, we didn't, we wrote it down). We kept lobbing explosives into the ship (low G) until bits of alien started flying out. The GM looked... a bit sad. High lethality games encourage creative problem solving.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pavel_lishin 3y agoI like that both of your suggestions include spending money and time. You can flood a dungeon or build a new bridge, but both will take at minimum weeks, if not months. If the King's daughter was kidnapped by those who live in the dungeon, or if the outcome of a battle hinges on you being able to cross that bridge over a chasm, they're not going to be happy when you come to them with a three-year plan for civic improvements.
- mcv 3y agoI'm thinking about a system where you slowly accumulate stress and money, and you need to spend the money (on carousing, helping the poor, or other expensive habits) to get rid of the stress. My goal would be to have lots of money moving through their hands without them being able to hold onto it for long. I also remember an article from the 1980s that recommended having thieves steal their money if they got too rich. That sounds a bit unfair to me, although maybe it could work as part of a system there they stay at increasingly more expensive lodgings in order to keep their accumulating wealth safe.
- jstarfish 3y ago> an article from the 1980s that recommended having thieves steal their money if they got too rich. That sounds a bit unfair to me, although maybe it could work as part of a system there they stay at increasingly more expensive lodgings in order to keep their accumulating wealth safe. IIRC this was a frustration of mine with Rimworld. It was annoying and made wealth very toxic. The more you had, the more frequently (and more powerful) thieves showed up and wrecked your shit. I didn't even have nice things, I just polished the floors so colonists wouldn't be so miserable with bunker life but apparently that raised collective wealth to the point of inviting raids.
- LaffertyDev 3y agoCheck out Blades in the Dark -- it has _exactly_ this mechanic! (And is also my favorite RPG system)
- mcv 3y agoI've played Blades in the Dark, and while you accumulate stress, you roll to get rid of it. I don't think it costs actual money, although they do call it vices. My plan was to really tie it into the excessive accumulation of money in D&D-style games, which is a problem BitD wouldn't have even if it didn't have the stress mechanic. Money in BitD is very abstract, and a single coin represents a serious amount of money. And you don't buy stuff with it because you can only take so much stuff with you, and what that is depends on your character. Instead you use it to upgrade your lair or bribe people, I think. So it's not quite what I was thinking of, although it certainly has some of the elements. Maybe it has shaped how I'm thinking about it now. I remember how longer ago, I was thinking of a Robin Hood game where character progression depended on how much money you gave to the poor. That way you can still buy stuff for yourself and not level up, or give to the poor and level up.
- caseysoftware 3y agoAnother fun approach is to make THEM the target of other groups. It's cool to have a pile of gold and treasure until you have to figure out how to protect it: - banks are few and far between and how much is "too much" for a bank? - does the local lord or king appreciate rich, unchecked groups active in their area? - bands of thieves are great but what about another group of adventurers? - if their wealth is truly amazing, do rumors make it to a dragon's ears? Odds are, the party has figured out how to break into and raid many dungeons and keeps. What happens when they have to secure one?
- RugnirViking 3y agoThat system he describes in Impulse Drive sounds really good, actually. Just hearing that makes me want to play it
- pclmulqdq 3y agoTaking prices out of the DMG's magic item table was one of D&D's worst moves between 3.5 and 5e. That made it really easy for DMs to set up ways for PCs to spend lavishly because the ceiling on those prices was so high, and the prices were relatively fair. 3.5 also had extensions with rules for stronghold building.
- Sander_Marechal 3y agoIf you want to stick with D&D I highly recommend MCDM's "Stronghold & Followers" and "Kingdoms & Warfare". They bring back all the old stronghold play which is a great gold sink.
- karaterobot 3y agoI've played in systems (multiple ones I think, but I don't remember the names) in which wealth was just a stat you had, and if you wanted to buy anything that was ranked below your stat, you could, without doing anything. And if you wanted to buy something at your stat or above, you'd roll to see if you could acquire access to the funds. So, the number didn't event represent a pile of gold, it was completely abstracted as something like "financial liquidity". It's a solution for the situation where you don't want characters to have to spend time pinching pennies to buy a suit of basic armor and a weapon, but you also want there to be some scarcity at the margins, so they can't just buy the best sword in the game either. This system obviously had its own, different set of flaws compared to D&D style systems, but some advantages it had were that there was no accounting, and it played fast. If your players are sick of erasing and overwriting the numbers on the wealth section of their character sheet over and over until the paper is gray and ragged, and they are responsible enough not to intentionally try to break the game, I think that method works well.
- Tyrannosaur 3y agoBlades in the Dark does a hybrid model: for small things (the example given is bribing a doorman) the player rolls a fortune roll with their lifestyle quality. For larger things, there's coin. One coin is "A full purse of silver pieces. A week’s wages." Coin can be spent/sacrificed for significantly larger things than day-to-day expenditures. A character banks coin in their stash which determines their lifestyle quality and, eventually, their quality of retirement. It feels much more like a stat to me, but has some of the flexibility of a resource as well. <https://bladesinthedark.com/coin-stash https://bladesinthedark.com/coin-stash>
- postexitus 3y agoIs that system called "life"?
- RugnirViking 3y agoThat does work pretty well. Although it does discount the occasionally entertaining trope of the player character from a wealthy family being persistently disgruntled at the low quality of food and drink and bed they can afford on their adventurer's loot
- aidenn0 3y agoFantasyCraft has a neat system where one of the stats is "Prudence" and at the end of each adventure, the character will spend a fraction of the wealth they earned, on a scale from 85%-25%. This doesn't necessarily solve the late-game wealth problem, but it does add a lot of flavor; treasures can be larger and the characters then spend most of it on living it up (or whatever).
- ecshafer 3y agoBurning Wheel has an interesting approach to wealth. You do not really have "money". You instead have a Resources stat, which you roll for skill tests to gather resources to pay for things. As it is roughly feudal that makes more sense. You can get "cash" but that is used as additional dice to your resources rolls (and is used up on the test). And you can further abstract certain things as "funds" which act as a bonus to resources, ie your estate is a 3d fund which can be depleted.
- gregw2 3y agoEncumbrance record keeping was annoying pre-PCs but did any well known RPGs ever implement the D&D encumbrance system and thus steer players to carry lighter weight currencies (gems etc)? Or was it too annoying even with the record keeping automated?
- hipadev23 3y agoIt was common in Everquest. Certain races or classes had lower weight limits. Encumberence would get you killed. There was a certain gemstone (peridot) which could be carried in stacks of 20 and had essentially no weight (0.1 stone per stack) compared to 1 stone per 20 coins. . Peridot was worth ~10 platinum and retained most its value at merchants. So at higher levels people just carried around stacks of them.
- jerf 3y agoWell, sure, computers eat that sort of bookkeeping for breakfast. Even now they'd "rather" track the location and weight of a million items than try to have one realistic conversation with an NPC that the player takes off the rails (which games don't even permit generally since the computer is so incapable of handling it). How many human DMs obsessed about it is an interesting question, though given the diversity of player and playstyles I'm sure the answer is quite non-zero. (And then there's the "cheat the DM/game either accidentally or on purpose" metagame that emerges has its own intricacies. "Hey, guys, I didn't notice this, but it turns out I've been hauling around a literal ton of copper in my small leather wallet for the last several months... whoopsiedoodles.")
- smegger001 3y agoI know in pencil and paper D&D my go to move durring character creation has been to buy a mule and cart so I can pretty much ignore encumbrance rules until the early mid game at which point buying bags of holding portable holes and other extra dimensional storage is easily affordable.
- pavel_lishin 3y ago
- ajkjk 3y agoIn Baldur's Gate 2 the first plot arc is basically "raise 20,000g somehow to save your sister" and as you wander the city you're asking everyone "hey... any idea how I can make some money?". I always liked that. Games where you end up inconceivably wealthy always feel stupid to me, in the same way that games where you end up invincible feel stupid.
- progne 3y agoI just finished BG3 with 50k gold and nothing to spend it on. It made me feel dumb for obsessively looking in every container and looting every corpse for the previous 200 hours. If 50k gold was the cost of a new heart for Karlach I would feel completely different about it.
- Waterluvian 3y agoWhatever studio comes up with the solution to "you should really use those consumables/spend that gold" without the solution inducing anxiety will be a complete hero in my books.
- Night_Thastus 3y agoThe latest DOOM games avoid this problem, but with ammo. There's no reason to save ammo for later because you have a very limited pool and can constantly get more with the chainsaw. It prevents hoarding for later. So that's what I'd suggest for consumables. Give a limited number so the player can't hoard and aren't too powerful, but make getting more of them easy and frequent.
- Waterluvian 3y agoOh yeah that’d totally do it. “I have 5/5 BuffPotions so if I don’t use them, I’ll be leaving more on the ground.”
- Tyr42 3y agoEstus flasks basically.
- PaulHoule 3y agoI am not a big fan of D&D because the "high stakes" of character development mean players take what happens to their characters way too seriously. As the Paranoia manual puts it "... other games are not fun" where "D&D" is most certainly the "other" game. I would never run a D&D game but instead I would run Paranoia or Call of Cthulhu or Toon. All of those games are fast paced, the first two are definitely unfair against the player so that a lot of problems of "game balance" just don't happen. If I found some people who wanted to play Paranoia right now I could make up enough random dangerous events to deplete their clones before they ever get to the briefing rooms. (A folder full of prerolls is a big help of course) And in CoC it doesn't matter how much money you make because it can't buy you sanity and there isn't anything you can buy that is going to "break" the game.
- pavel_lishin 3y agoI know there's lots of different ways to have fun, so please don't take this as a criticism of how you enjoy role-playing - but for me, the character investment in D&D is one of the reasons I love it so much. I care about what happens to Alfonso Derecho Izquierda Quijano, the Kobold Paladin who's in love with a dragon. I want him to have an arc, I want him to grow as a person, and eventually I want his story to end - either in death on the battlefield, or having achieved his dream of wedding a dragon, or coming to the realization that he wasn't chosen by a dragon but that it simply coughed up some armor from a guy it had eaten while flying overhead. Having said that, I also want to play some games where characters are disposable, including Paranoia. That's fun too!
- Eji1700 3y agoPart of the issue with this is that people get attached to their characters, but 5e doesn't actually have a rule set that works super well with that, in the world it has. It's moved over the years from the meat grinders of the early editions to the much more character focused ones now, but some things haven't really kept up. The big one being character death becoming trivial midway through, and the combat kinda being centered around that. Death doesn't mean much when you just keep reviving them, and it's left up to the DM to figure out how to balance that (since the 5e economy is a mess). 5e long ago should've adopted a downed/injured system like much of the competition, with death being much more rare. Then again there's about 100 other things they should've done, and it's pretty clear they won't, so meh. Guess it just sits on the DM's
- Waterluvian 3y agoI got back into World of Warcraft (Classic) after like 15 years and found the economy to be completely broken. Apparently there's a ton of bots that aren't being banned, creating a massive wealth source. As a consequence there is steep, steep inflation (but I'm not sure how the one causes the other... it's as if high-level characters have a ton of gold) To any who remember the classic economy: Swiftthistle is 6g each and people are given 150g just to participate in a dungeon. All the fixed price items (mounts, vendor items, skills, etc.) are basically free, which has an interesting effect on the economy in some ways: bags, for example, sell for a lot, as an upper-bound for what the user-crafted bags should sell for. Now they're by far the cheapest option, so nobody crafts bags anymore. This kind of reminds me of a government price-controlled good and the chilling effect it can have.
- starkparker 3y agoDis/enchanting is still a big gold source at high levels, so once you reach max level and especially if you're in a guild, you have access to lots more ways to make money. Which you either spend on raid supplies or to kit out lower-level toons. And there are always the whales who just buy a shit ton of gold and put it in a guild bank.
- Waterluvian 3y agoBut where does the gold come from that gets bought? How’s that getting into the system? Bots just farming vendor junk?
- skizm 3y agoI like the idea of starting players off in massive debt. Any money they get they have to choose between spending it on their characters (new gear or whatever) vs paying down debt. If they spend it on themselves, they'll be in short term danger (creditors come after them to try and collect, with interest!), but if they pay their creditors now they forgo new gear.
- starkparker 3y agoI was happy to see Impulse Drive in this article because that debt system is great. Built-in ramifications and story hooks for ignoring the debt, clearly tracked on a shared party sheet.
- mcv 3y agoI'm currently running a Shadowrun game where equipment and especially cyberware is a neverending money sink. High-end cyberware and vehicles can easily cost hundreds of thousands of nuyen. Not to mention that you've got monthly cost of living depending on your lifestyle. Of course you could save a lot of money by choosing a poor or squatter lifestyle, but I tend to make that matter. Eventually they all settled on a medium lifestyle for $5000/month. Of course this does mean tons of bookkeeping. I've also played and loved games that abstract wealth away. And I certainly think some games should abstract it away a bit more. But for Shadowrun, this makes sense. They're criminals for hire, so they're in it for the money. (Although they're currently doing the most dangerous run ever for free, so I'll reward them with extra karma.)
- dormento 3y agoTrue immersion will come when you make em fill their taxes.
- pavel_lishin 3y agoI have a whole story setting idea where a city requires permits for everything, including dying. You didn't fill out your death certificate? Sorry, you don't get to die. I'm just not sure what the PCs would do in that setting, what "problem" there would be for them to solve.
- Tyr42 3y agoI have a friend who had to write intergalactic tax law to do this to his players.
- mcv 3y agoI don't think I've ever had them pay taxes, except for the occasional toll in WFRP, or berthing costs in Traveller (now there's a game that could really turn into a spreadsheet; though we never got that far).
- starkparker 3y agoThe fantasy setting I GM in has a god of taxes, so whenever the party accumulates more than a few thousand gold and aren't spending it, I start sending paladins of the tax god after them at random. Got to a point where the party stumbled across a dragon lair and instead of fighting or bypassing it, the party wanted to go in and ask it for financial management advice. "They have hoards and there aren't any tax collectors here, so dragons must have figured it out!" So I made the dragon be a tax collector. Very motivated fight (they lost).
- readyplayernull 3y agoI'm making a survival game inspired on Universal Paperclips and factory games in which being wealthy works against you, as you restart the factories that killed your world the environment becomes increasingly dangerous with mutated beings and other stuff.
- nonethewiser 3y agoIm not all the way through the article but it raises an interesting problem. To rephrase it: gold increases exponentially but the rewards and challenges do not. Gold gives you rewards, rewards are fun because they make challenges smaller, challenges require that you get more gold. It almost requires the game to change as you get stronger. Im not sure you can just make weapons/enemy strength exponential. That seems more like it needs to scale linearly otherwise you either gut utterly crushed or you utterly crush it and skill isnt involved.
- deadbabe 3y agoIt’s easy to create gold sinks for heroes by giving them opportunities to spend large amounts of money to improve various villages, towns, etc. They could fund the construction of wells or ships and forts to improve quality of life, making them a different type of hero. There is even opportunity to craft new conflicts solely revolving around how that money is being spent, and presenting tough choices between various options. Perhaps they can even return some of that looted money back to the people from which it was looted, after all, the monsters and enemies that horde it likely didn’t acquire it fairly. And after all that spending they’ll probably end up somewhat poor again, continuing the cycle.
- lawlessone 3y agoCaves of Qud makes water the currency of the game. It Forces you to barter because you can't carry enough water to buy many things. But you always have the pressure to hold onto some to drink. Or you die.
- sotix 3y agoI’ve always enjoyed the system used in Dark Souls games where you collect souls as a currency and can use souls to buy items, improve weapons, or level up. This makes it so souls always carry value and makes it fun having to weigh the benefits of buying a desired item or leveling up. The game furthers the concept by making souls an attribute you always carry on you and can lose entirely when you die unless you recover them from your dead body before dying again. You can go from very wealthy to very poor quite quickly by trying to push a bit longer to obtain more souls to level up. Or you can cash out if you feel like the risk of continuing your adventure is too great. This concept combines well with reusable health potions that only refill after resting at the site where you can spend your souls.
- simonh 3y agoThe reason this is an issue in D&D is that by default the PCs don’t have a job. They’re freelance mercenaries, so the game needs to give them a reason to adventure, and by default that’s making money. The way out of this is to have the PCs do a job, or at least have a core activity the players and their characters sign up for. Jane’s Bond is a civil servant, Indiana Jones is a professional archaeologist, the crew of the Starship Enterprise work for Star Fleet, Jason Bourne isn’t employed, but he has no choice, they really are out to get him, etc. What this goes is make the game about something other than just personal advancement. Either the kinds of problems you’re solving can’t be solved with money. In Call of Cthulhu it’s usually less formal, but you’re not in it for the money, you’re in it to save humanity. Alternatively the game builds in an economy into the core activity itself. Upgrading your starship and buying cargo. In Blades in the Dark you’re a gang of criminals with ongoing expenses. There’s a default core activity and objective you all share. In the examples in the article of games that solve this in various ways we can see this at work. In Stonetop you’re in it for the community, it’s about survival. In Impulse Drive and Traveller you’re trying to make a living. So the problem with D&D is the default murder hobo setup in which there really isn’t actually a setup. In practice a lot of D&D GMs and campaigns do build in a driver for adventure. A job, or an imperative threat, or an assumed objective everyone agrees to buy into.