7 ms·
Climbing 50 steps a day can cut your risk of heart disease
- DrNosferatu 3y agoWhat about going down steps?
- albert180 3y agoIt's obviously much less demanding and has therefore less health benefits. If you can't climb 50 Stairs you should start exercising ASAP
- kiba 3y agoIt has less benefit, sure, but probably different benefits. Running downhill is a great way to get DOMS because of the increased eccentric contraction.
- FartyMcFarter 3y agoApparently the body can adapt to eccentric exercise quite quickly, to the point that DOMS and other effects like muscle damage are reduced: https://youtu.be/q9onRcxcN_0 https://youtu.be/q9onRcxcN_0
- ez667 3y agoDon't do that. It will cancel out the benefit of going up.
- aio2 3y agoCan tell from experience.
- DrNosferatu 3y ago:D
- alliao 3y agomake sure your knee are straight up and down, don't twist your knee going down stairs incorrectly.. it'd wear your knee out fast and unnecessarily
- selimthegrim 3y agoAs a Tulane student, I have to say that it pains me that all the authors listed except the professor are from somewhere else.
- jacquesm 3y agoHow can you tell?
- selimthegrim 3y agoIf you go to the article and check all the author affiliations Lu Qi is the only one at Tulane. It’s not like Tulane doesn’t have a biostats department. https://www.atherosclerosis-journal.com/article/S0021-9150(23)05221-8/fulltext https://www.atherosclerosis-journal.com/article/S0021-9150(2...
- jacquesm 3y agoBut that's pretty common, no? For people from various institutes to collaborate. Or is there something special about this one?
- selimthegrim 3y agoIt’s not uncommon but Tulane has a serious faculty and grad student retention problem.
- MuffinFlavored 3y agoWhat about walking 0 steps a day for 50 years and then trying to make up for lost time?
- tonmoy 3y agoI guess it’ll be better than not trying to make up for lost time
- smt88 3y agoIn all seriousness, there's a lot of research showing huge benefits of starting to exercise later in life. It's almost as helpful as exercising the whole time (in terms of avoiding cardiac events).
- XorNot 3y agoYeah there's basically no such thing as "too late". We're adaptable creatures - that biological programming to try and conserve energy at all costs (basically why we need to force ourselves to exercise) also works the other way - the body is pretty happy to start making big changes when it believes it's under a moderate physical stress. The amount of improvement I've gotten from 20 minutes on a rowing machine 5 days a week - and let's be clear, that's basically all I do on the logic of "I can spare 1 YouTube video of time (and still watch the video)" is insane.
- jrussino 3y agoWhat does your rowing routine look like? Are you aiming to maintain a specific pace or energy output for those 20 minutes? I have access to a Concept2 and I rowed for a year in high school (i.e. I have the basic stroke form down) but I find that every time I try to start a rowing routine I over-do it in the first few sessions and end up dropping it.
- matwood 3y agoJust move for 20 minutes. If rowing gets boring look for row bootcamps. Row for 7-10, lift light weights for 7-10, then row again for 7-10. The second row feels easy :)
- traceroute66 3y ago[flagged]
- smt88 3y ago50 steps for a 20% lower risk is a surprising and important result. It's less time/effort than people expect for that amount of benefit. Lots of people assume they can't exercise enough for it to matter and then decide not to exercise at all. This result could help change their minds.
- allan_s 3y agoI think it's for those who thinks that 10000 steps a day is too much a change in their lifestyle. 50 steps a day instead can simply be a "take the stairs rather than the elevator" change in your daily routine.
- mr_toad 3y agoNote that this is cardio not energy burning. Fifty stairs a day is not going to burn the calories of 10,000 steps.
- wtallis 3y agoThere's value in quantifying the benefit even after the existence of the benefit is universally believed.
- tasty_freeze 3y agoBefore reading the headline, if someone had asked you what the result would be, could you have quantified how much doing 50 stairs a day would help? My guess is not. There is value in quantifying things, and there is value in confirming things that "everyone knows already" because sometimes common wisdom is wrong. So, in short, trials time time and effort, but cynical comments are a dime a dozen.
- ergocoder 3y agoI live in a 3-story townhouse. Automatic heart disease reduction.
- hesdeadjim 3y agoHa, I had the same thought. Office is on the third floor so I’m up and down 40 steps a day a dozen times. I’ve wondered what effect that has on the stability of my weight over the span of years.
- doubled112 3y agoAnother one of those 3 story townhouse dwellers here. It can't hurt that the fridge is never on the same floor as me either.
- qup 3y agoThe easiest thing to bet on is my own laziness...
- doubled112 3y agoYou call it laziness, I prefer to go with efficiency.
- maweaver 3y agoI had a similar thought, but then it says "high intensity" stair climbing, which is not how I would describe my climbing. Then there's also this: > Researchers also found that those who stopped climbing stairs daily during the study showed a 32% higher risk of cardiovascular disease compared to those who never reported climbing stairs. So I guess if we ever move we're actually worse off in the long run
- JoshMandel 3y ago> So... we're actually worse off Careful about inferring causality here. What kind of active person suddenly stops being active? You presumably don't want to be that kind of person... but the stopping isn't necessarily a causal factor of the cardiovascular events (and the initial "being active" seems still far less likely to be a causal factor).
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoIs this correlation or causation? > Researchers also found that those who stopped climbing stairs daily during the study showed a 32% higher risk of cardiovascular disease compared to those who never reported climbing stairs. Cardiovascular disease is one of the things that would stop people from climbing stairs.
- oldgradstudent 3y agoAlso, people with umbrellas cause rain to drop. The same team should investigate that
- kiba 3y agoAt this point, the evidence for physical activity improving health outcome is so strong and varied that I would assume "yes, of course".
- brazzy 3y agoActually makes me feel better about recently having bought a house where I have to constantly go up and down to get stuff (expensive city, so small footprint, 4 floors). Five flights of stairs? I'm pretty sure I average thirty at least.
- readingnews 3y agoI always wonder how does this compare to any other cardio? For example, I started to run a few years ago. Now my week is something like 5k, 6k, 9k, 12k, 9k, 9k, 3k runs. I usually do not take a day off, as when it starts raining or snowing, this will force me to take 2-3 days off randomly for months on end. Should I be climbing stairs instead? I never climb stairs near me, I would have to literally go out of my way to find some. (Full disclosure, I sit for work, except for when I was teaching, so I run to try to make up for it. I still do not feel very healthy as I run for say an hour, then sit for like eight, or ten.... "sitting is the new smoking" is not helping).
- Aurornis 3y agoMost of these studies about near-trivial effort are basically showing that doing anything at all is better than doing nothing strenuous. 50 steps per day is basically nothing relative to your running schedule. However, it’s a significant step up from a sedentary lifestyle as shown by this study. For someone like you, ignore these studies. It’s more important to do what you enjoy because that’s going to translate to more and longer engagement. The exact exercise doesn’t really matter.
- kiba 3y agoI think it's good to break up the monotony by doing different kind of cardio, and also exercise parts of your body that don't get used as much if you stick to a single form of cardio. I would keep doing cardio, but have some varieties.
- justinator 3y agoYou don't have to compare it. For just general exercise, the best thing to do is find something that you enjoy and can do multiple times a day. You seem to have found it in running. If you want to climb some stairs, climb some stairs, but it's not about optimizing your time. You won just by doing something active you enjoy. I realized long ago that my running is mostly going up and down hills. 10,000' of gain/loss a week wasn't out of the ordinary, with some weeks being 60-70,000' in total (this is an extreme). Those 10k weeks could be as little as 20 miles. I'm very satisfied by my workouts. If you have a GOAL, then you can think about specific training. But you do you my dude.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ChuckMcM 3y agoSo 250 steps a day can immunize you completely? :crazy-face-smiley:. [1] I wonder what the mechanism that the burst activity causes to engage. Dislodging plaque? Pressurizing arteries? [1] I know, its just 32.768% :-) [2] Note to self: even on a Sunday, no jokes :-)
- jacquesm 3y agoMuch simpler: it trains your heart.
- ChuckMcM 3y agoI got that but I was interested that climbing steps trained it better than wind sprints? Or better than rowing? So was wondering if there was something specific about step climbing that was triggering the heart conditioning.
- jacquesm 3y agoAh, I see. I think the big difference is is that you're doing it when it isn't purposefully, but spaced out across all the time that you are awake. Those other activities are all neatly compartmentalized and outside of that you don't do them at all. I probably climb two flights of stairs 20 to 30 times every day (and down the same amount) and it's never a planned activity. More like 'I'd like a cup of tea' and that's 4 flights (2 up, 2 down) right there. Door bell rings: same thing. Someone calls from downstairs and I can't properly hear it and so on... it really adds up. Whereas if I would try 20 or 30 times up and down the stairs in a row I'd probably collapse before I got to 10.
- 3cats-in-a-coat 3y agoOr people with heart disease prefer to avoid climbing stairs every day. Same data.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- desireco42 3y agoI live in townhouse... I am golden... But in more serious tone, I made a point long ago to run up the stairs whenever I can, I was in my 30s and 40s. There were younger people who couldn't get to 2nd or 3rd floor without getting seriously winded. So practice is all we need.
- mathgeek 3y ago> Forget walking 10,000 steps a day. Taking at least 50 steps up the stairs each day could significantly slash your risk of heart disease, according to a new study from Tulane University. There’s no reason to be a couch potato and just get up to walk 50 steps a day. This is a terrible, terrible opening paragraph. We need to get over this “choose this, not that” meme when it comes to making healthy choices.
- valianteffort 3y agoCriticizing the actions of overweight or unhealthy people is as socially tabboo as that of trans, israel or jews. It doesn't matter how sound your argument is, these socially "protected" classes are infallible apparently. I think after several generations that experience mortality at younger ages because of obesity, there might be an honest discussion of how bad being sedentary and overweight is for your health. Until then you have liberal rhetoric equating any acknowledgement of this reality to an accusation that someone is a bad person for being fat.
- Clubber 3y ago>Criticizing the actions of overweight or unhealthy people is as socially tabboo as that of trans, israel or jews. I think news people tried to throw that at the wall for a little while, but it didn't stick.
- orangepurple 3y agoIt absolutely stuck but Health at Every Size (HAES) and the body positivity movement doesn't have the same resources to attack and vilify as the other groups. Israel isn't just taboo. They actively destroy opposition by getting people fired, prevent them from getting funding (important in politics), and have entire call centers staffed tasked with forum sliding and demoralization. See the JIDF (it never stopped contrary to the lies on Wikipedia).
- strken 3y ago
- yieldcrv 3y ago90% of people that filled out a random mall survey in the early 2000s survived a global pandemic according to the survey they checked that they walked and really really like free 2009 Nissan Altimas. In comparison to the control group it looks like walking is different.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoit's kind of funny that the standards are so low for the body to not be a wreck, but that we still figured out how to be so comfortable with technology we are killing ourselves.
- Archelaos 3y agoNote that the abstract of underlying paper[1] is much more carefully drawing conclusions from the study. It mainly claims that ther exists an association between "climbing five flights of stairs daily" and an "over a 20% lower risk of ASCVD", but not of a direct causation (as the linked article does). Therefore the title of the article: "Walking more than five flights of stairs a day can cut risk of heart disease by 20%, study says" is misrepresenting the findings. When the study says that there is an association, the causation might also be the other way round, ie. a higher disposition of heart disease leads to people not climbing a lot of stairs. The last sentence of the abstract points into this direction: "Participants who stopped stair climbing between baseline and resurvey had a higher risk [32%] of ASCVD compared with those who never climbed stairs." When stopping stair climbing is worse correlated with ASCVD risk than not even starting stair climbing, one might suspect that there are other hidden causes that govern the correlation, such as people getting old or sick, which is their real cause for their increased ASCVD risk, and thus move into the basement or use the elevator more often, which in turn decreases their climbing stairs a lot. If this is the case, than there is no proof that climbing 50 steps a day can cut your risk of heart disease at all. We just have a correlation, no causation. To really find out whether there exists a causation, an intervention study would be necessary: we would need a representative sample of people of the particular group we are interested in (in this case people who do only climb very few steps a day). One half of the sample is not changing anything; the other half from now on consistently climbs 50 steps a day for a certain period of time. Afterwards we compare the two. (Ideally we would like to perform a double-blind experiment[2], but this seems impossible in this case.) [1] https://www.atherosclerosis-journal.com/article/S0021-9150(23)05221-8/fulltext https://www.atherosclerosis-journal.com/article/S0021-9150(2... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blinded_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blinded_experiment
- oldgradstudent 3y agoYou are being far too kind to this study and the accompanying university press release. They use the standard schtick - report correllation in the journal article but imply causation in the university press release. As you say, of course there's an association, it is harder for sick people to climb stairs. We expect disease and stair climbing to be inversely correllated. The press release is as bad as saying that carrying umbrellas can increase rainfall.
- TruthWillHurt 3y agoIf I climb 10 stairs, 5 times a day - does that count? How about 2 stairs, 25 times a day? 100 stairs, on odd days?
- Fluorescence 3y agoI have enjoyed reading on a Stairmaster for the last couple of months (after weight-training). I find I can get a high intensity and still read unlike with running, rowing or out of the saddle cycling. Sadly I've found it causes knee pain. This is despite a long history of leg training with no knee issues. It's a real shame but just the old story of not focussing on a single exercise/movement too much I guess.
- zimpenfish 3y ago> Researchers also found that those who stopped climbing stairs daily during the study showed a 32% higher risk of cardiovascular disease compared to those who never reported climbing stairs. I guess between the after effects of C19 and having a useless knee, both of which make climbing stairs a horrendous experience, I don't have to worry about getting towards the age when they'll consider knee replacement a good option[1]! [1] Something to do with them only being good for 15-20 years and the second one almost never working correctly.
- bshacklett 3y agoTell me about it. I used to climb rock faces. Now stairs make me pale with fear of injury. It would be great to know what _else_I could do to stay healthy. I do about 4.5-6 miles a day walking my dog. Hopefully that’s enough.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ergocoder 3y agoIn about 20-30 years or so, there will be research stating that people living in a 3-story townhouses have less heart diseases.
- RickJWagner 3y agoI think I'll move my refrigerator upstairs.