6 ms·
I mainly know the older, shallow line inner city routes. I've used the existing ?SNCF? Hookups to Orly, CDG and the Thalys North into Amsterdam, it works well.
by ggm 3y ago
I mainly know the older, shallow line inner city routes. I've used the existing ?SNCF? Hookups to Orly, CDG and the Thalys North into Amsterdam, it works well. Paris was always an exemplar for modernisation in a time where the O.G. London underground was a bit moribund (rubber wheels) but retention of the carnet system beyond its life and a surge in London transport investment rather upended things.
This is a huge expansion. Being brave enough to build rings is great: most capital cities obsess with spokes to existing hubs, or like the Elizabeth line do a single slash across.
New York should read and weep.
- thriftwy 3y agoWeird that it does not have the route map of the expansions - see https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grand_Paris_Express https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grand_Paris_Express Speaking about rings, Moscow metro now has three of these.
- mananaysiempre 3y agoMoscow’s situation is funny in part because a number of diagonal slashes is closer to what the city needs (the central parts are probably an order of magnitude over design capacity during rush hour and essentially never under it), but the plan for those got turned into a ring because apparently the infrastructure to turn trains around at the ends was too difficult to build. The other new ring is a fairly old preexisting train line that used to be cargo-only; it had the potential to be great, but unfortunately the ridiculously long connection times have made the real thing somewhat niche—if both your origin and your destination aren’t on it, the ten to fifteen minutes’ walk will likely make the result worse than just going through the center. And two connections are just never worth it. (There’s a whole story behind how building stupid useless connections came to be viewed as a virtue in Moscow transport planning—look up “Vykhino effect”. Doesn’t make the result any less shit, though.)
- thriftwy 3y agoI guess you've not experienced the Metro (and Vykhino effect) around 2003 if you think it is over capacity now. It is a cakewalk now. I, too, dislike the new connections, and the lack thereof, but the speed with which the new lines sprung up is a marvel.
- mananaysiempre 3y agoI was too young to remember clearly at the time, but I think I experienced the Vykhino railway-metro connection a few times in the early 2000s. I don’t seem to remember the original connection that’s said to have given the name to the “Vykhino effect” (wherein the suburban rail arrived at and the metro departed from the opposite sides of the platform, and you could cross it unimpeded, leading to the metro trains being completely full straight from the first stop—the “effect”) was still in operation then. I think the fence was already there on the platform and you had to use the disgusting, stinky, cramped tunnel? (That before the railway started fencing away everything in the name of better ticket controls.)
- thriftwy 3y agoYes, the Metro trains were chock full (think Tokyo), and you could only board a train if it skipped Vykhino if you needed to do so on some later station. I don't think it is possible to be physically unable to enter the train in 2023 (unless football fans return from thei match). In 2003 it was expected.
- unflxw 3y agoAren't the diagonals also being built? Primarily, if I recall correctly, by reusing existing passenger rails corridors and connecting their services instead of terminating them at the main stations. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moscow_Central_Diameters https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moscow_Central_Diameters
- mananaysiempre 3y agoFair point, though those are not the ones that people were talking about since the 90s—but then nobody could imagine you could wrangle the railway (a national service with a peculiar culture) into cooperating with the metro (a municipal one), that’s unironically an achievement of the current city administration. That these are being “built” is once again a bit too strong a statement—the rail lines were already there and in use for cargo and the occasional suburban train. (The veeery slooow speeds at which the latter went between the big stations had relegated them to the sole use of urban arcanists and the occasional exhausted hiker disembarking from his long-distance train.) There’s some renewal of the aging rails, to be fair, and the stations are new. Two problems with these: First, the stations are too few and once again too far away from anything else. (Nobody’s fault—the rails are sometimes a century older than the metro and the outward creep of the city limits.) Second, unlike on the ring, the trains on the chordal lines (I refuse to call them “diameters”) are operated according to the railway rules, meaning there are too few of them to be able to disregard the schedule, the schedule itself is at best a suggestion (and woe is you if you don’t keep track of train cancellations), and the stupid multi-hour midday “maintenance breaks” are still in place. I’ve used these lines for weekly commutes, and if they fit your problem well, they can be very useful. But overall I’d say they are even more situational than the ring, and it’s frustrating compared to my utopian headcanon of how well they could work. Or hell, to the RER lines in Paris, even if those connections are no joke either—nevermind the Barcelona Rodalies, which are (or were, two decades ago) the platonic ideal of suburban/urban rail transport interconnection.
- thriftwy 3y agoI think you are too harsh on the Russian railway - it did carry a lot of people on their daily commute from their satellite towns to Moscow. The schedule is also quite reliable. It wasn't used much for intra-Moscow travel due to the issues mentioned, that is correct.
- oldpersonintx 3y ago[dead]
- xkekjrktllss 3y ago>New York should read and weep an understatement
- colordrops 3y agoLA should read and jump off a bridge
- jseliger 3y agoL.A. has actually been much better than NYC at building new transit infrastructure over the last 40 years: https://archive.ph/sbTkC https://archive.ph/sbTkC. NYC, though, is obviously starting from a much higher base. L.A. should also be working harder to build more faster, but it's not the laughing stock it once was.
- ohdeegee 3y agoYou're very generous with LA. The few lines it's built recently (eg Exhibition Line) are so slow that no one in their right mind would take it unless they have absolutely no better option. In Paris, public transport is always the first option.
- hifromLA 3y agoThe speed yes it’s not ideal and at a minimum there should be signal priority or just remove at grade crossings entirely, but land use in LA is really really not good for transit. The built environment is designed to support automobile use and that will hopefully change through TOD. My point is the distances regularly covered in LA would be absolutely unthinkable in Manhattan and the more urban parts of the outer boroughs, let alone Paris which is a smaller city than San Francisco. So on the one hand we need better land use to reduce distance traveled and on the other improvements to overall speed. By contrast New York has a built environment that is absolutely fantastic for transit but cannot build enough to fully capitalize on it. Their costs are astronomical and going up.
- inferiorhuman 3y ago
- rob74 3y agoThe rubber wheel metros are mostly a result of lobbying by Michelin. They're an interesting curiosity, but I think there is a reason why they haven't really caught on outside of France...
- uxp8u61q 3y agoThey cost more to maintain, but they allow greater acceleration and deceleration and produce less noise/vibration than metal wheels. And Michelin must have a phenomenal lobbying team if they managed this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rubber-tyred_metro#List_of_systems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rubber-tyred_metro#List_of_sys... (In particular, "didn't catch on outside France" is, well, just plain wrong.)
- bobthepanda 3y agoA lot of those are people movers in airports and whatever <2km long. The list once you exclude that basically consists of * France, which wanted a niche technology to export and maintain supply domination over * China, Japan, and Korea, trying to replicate it * Quebec, which often looks to France for planning inspiration * Mexico and Chile, which were recipients of French development assistance that included using French suppliers
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoRings kind of suck. You have to go around to get anywhere, and so you spend a lot more time on your subway getting home.
- johannes1234321 3y agoA well positioned ring on a big enough city can provide the right tangential connections, which avoids leading through center with diameter lines. However if it is too close to the center the cost of extra transfer is likely too high.
- thriftwy 3y agoA ring is an important traffic egress/ingress source. More often than not, your destination is directly on the ring and you're not using it to make two connections, just one is sufficient. Moscow inner ring has around the same number of stations than all the ones inside it (counting connections as one each)
- hifromLA 3y agoI disagree. Look at something like the Chicago el which is a true hub and spoke system. The el needs a ring line since any trip that doesn’t start or end in the loop generally requires taking the bus which is fine but not rapid transit. By contrast look at the Yamanote line in Tokyo for a great ring that provides tons of connections and gets tons of ridership.
- angled 3y agoBeijing has two rings for its metro, and has 5+ ring roads. I could never live there but as a tourist the metro works well!
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoBeijing has 6 official ring roads. There is also a 7th but it isn't considered part of urban Beijing. It really does suck. I lived between 3rd and 4th ring road in the eastern mid section (around san yuan qiao), and my work was on 4th ring in the northwest section in zhongguancun. So...around the loop I went, it makes the trip 20-30% longer. Line 10 (a loop line between 3rd and 4th ring, line 2 would be the inner loop around 2nd ring) theoretically takes me straight to work from near my house, but I almost never took it because it was just too long (and it was just easier to sit in a taxi on 4th ring if I timed my to work and from work time right).
- redandblack 3y agoNY metro is very fare friendly to working class ~$3 flat for anywhere in the network, and not considering subsidies, monthly etc. Willing to give up art and deco for keeping the fares where they are - agree modern tech upgrades is necessary and is being made now with Biden's admin help. I hope they keep the low fares
- karim 3y agoA single ticket in the Paris metro is €1.90 (about $2) flat for anywhere in the network, and not considering subsidies, monthly etc.
- acchow 3y agoI wanted to check their respective median household incomes and am shocked to discover that they are about the same. NYC at $70k and Paris at $72k. I had no idea parisians were making yankee money.
- laurencerowe 3y ago> This is a huge expansion. Being brave enough to build rings is great: most capital cities obsess with spokes to existing hubs, or like the Elizabeth line do a single slash across. The equivalent in London would be the Overground which while largely cobbled together from existing tracks was a huge improvement. If you change you can even go in a ring. The projected ridership for these new lines in Paris looks to be about triple that of the Overground. The Elizabeth line (along with Thameslink) is more like Paris' RER.