8 ms·
The Price of Time: The Real Story of Interest
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- atombender 3y agoNon-paywall: https://archive.ph/kvBbp https://archive.ph/kvBbp
- nine_zeros 3y agoGreat read! And yes, the existence of interest is what causes ups and downs in economies.
- nonethewiser 3y agoSome Muslim economics right here.
- landemva 3y ago> interest is what causes ups and downs in economies. That is an extraordinary claim. If government set or controlled allowable interest rate or set it to zero there would be no business cycle? The downturn in 2020 was caused by interest?
- yCombLinks 3y agoThe link between interest rates and the business cycle is a core tenet of Austrian economics. The boom bust cycle is made worse by government policies mispricing time preferences, ie setting the interest rate to the wrong value.
- largbae 3y agoIs there a knowable "right" value? What should it be now? Otherwise this sounds like a circular "no true Scotsman" situation.
- yCombLinks 3y agoThe natural market price. Just like people / businesses decide what they are willing to pay for a good, they can decide what price they are willing to pay to lend / borrow money. Not sure where it goes no true Scotsman. Currently our interest rates are set by the government. Austrian theory says this leads to the business cycle in the following way : Businesses want to borrow money and it's cheap to do so. This signals that it is a good time to invest, there is excess capital (otherwise people would be competing more for scarce capital, pushing interest rates higher). If there is indeed excess capital that's fine, it is a good time to invest. But if there was not excess capital (rates were set artificially low, sending a bad signal), these are bad investments. When the truth comes out (rates start raising, or demand for your goods drops), all the bad investments become apparent at the same time. Capital is now so expensive I am losing money on these investments.
- andsoitis 3y ago> The natural market price. When money is free, it leads to very destabilizing dynamics such as elevated PE ratios and currency volatility.
- throwawaymaths 3y agoThe irony is that with freer money money might actually be more expensive. And a lot of the destabilizing dynamics exist because money is cheap, at the same time that people must participate in the gulag casino to stay afloat
- HPsquared 3y agoNot free as in beer.
- notahacker 3y ago> Just like people / businesses decide what they are willing to pay for a good, they can decide what price they are willing to pay to lend / borrow money You mean like... now? Banks, non bank financial institutions and individuals are free to choose what interest rates they set, to set interest rates for a sector they thinks is at risk well above market levels or to cease lending activity altogether. The fact they choose to lend at low rates is because market participants are pretty bad at predicting the future and market dynamics encourage cutting credit prices, not because the government forces them to lower rates (it doesn't) And the reality of banking timescales is that a shortage of capital available at a price isn't a nice little hint to change lending activity, it's a signal that since they can't borrow any more to meet obligations they'd best stop honouring depositors' withdrawals. Which is why we have central banks stepping in to make capital available, and before they did that we didn't have stability, we had a lot more ordinary people losing their savings to bank failures and more volatile business cycles.
- throwawaymaths 3y agoUnfortunately people often oversimplify the Austrian stance to take it to mean boom/bust only exists due to interest. But interest aside, the activity of lending itself exacerbates boom/bust because people depending on the money lent out coming back to them are at a higher risk of default, and if they default, they put more people at risk... If anything the generic austrian stance too generous. Their knee jerk anti state stance leaves some weird window of the state being able to manage things if it were only smart enough.
- HPsquared 3y agoIt comes down to "relative smartness". How smart is the state compared to the complexity of the economy? Centrally planned economies tend to be "simplified" by placing strict restrictions on what types of trade are allowed. Can't have people behaving unpredictably!
- wanderingbit 3y agoMaybe one day there will exist a happy medium between centrally-planned Zerg economy and a free “Ebay for organs” market.
- throwawaymaths 3y agoLet's be honest though the market is often really stupid so the bar is low for the state. And see, you have made my point about the "if only the state were smart enough" thesis. The point is, markets should be more independent of the state for other reasons that have nothing to do with any given outcome. (Though I'd claim that some subset of desired outcomes, like income inequality reduction would still come to pass).
- landemva 3y ago> The boom bust cycle is made worse by government policies Government meddling does make it worse. Governments fighting the business cycle is perverted and should not be the task of government. Paul Volker rediscovered the business cycle and wrote a book about it. https://archive.org/details/rediscoveryofbus0000volc https://archive.org/details/rediscoveryofbus0000volc Interest rates naturally vary across time, space, lenders, and borrowers. Leave rates to the free market and have government enforce anti-discrimination.
- RandomLensman 3y agoAlas, there are no free markets as far as human societies are concerned, so how far should governments go?
- coralreef 3y agoPossibly. Who would be more efficient at pricing money: the market or the government?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> yes, the existence of interest is what causes ups and downs in economies This is an oversimplification. Credit is the main endogenous source of business cycles. But there are exogenous shocks, too, like droughts.
- spacebanana7 3y agoThe CEO of Chevron gave an excellent presentation on CNBC once where he showed why commodity markets will always be volatile. Taking oil as an example, he illustrated that demand growth is very stable, effectively indexed to continous GDP, but supply is very 'lumpy' & because oil sites (& even oil states) tend to go online/offline in discrete steps. The same phenomenon applies to metals, agricultural goods and other fuel sources. Unfortunately I can't find the Youtube clip of this interview
- nonethewiser 3y agoWould love to hear your explanation for this.
- yCombLinks 3y agoCopying myself: The link between interest rates and the business cycle is a core tenet of Austrian economics. The boom bust cycle is made worse by government policies mispricing time preferences, ie setting the interest rate to the wrong value.
- nonethewiser 3y agoDoesnt explain how > the existence of interest is what causes ups and downs in economies You arent even making as extreme of a claim. You’re saying interest rates and business cycles are linked. Not that interest rates are what cause ups and downs in the economy. Think about it: if that were true, and we removed interest rates, the economy couldnt go down? Its an absurd claim.
- HPsquared 3y agoPerhaps a weaker statement would be "centrally planned interest rates exacerbate the business cycle".
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoCentrally managed interest rates moderate the business cycle. It's one of the key activities of a central bank. And it's easy to verify. Look at the business cycle in the US before and after the creation of the Federal Reserve, for example. Under the Fed, we had the Great Depression and 2008, and relatively mild recessions other than that. Compare that with the 19th Century.
- sbmthakur 3y agoInterest(and by extension Credit) does cause momentary fluctuations in the economy. But saying they are the main factor in economy growth/degrowth is not right. Here's a good video (by Ray Dalio) that goes into detail. https://youtu.be/PHe0bXAIuk0?si=5pagTh1873NqMfbw https://youtu.be/PHe0bXAIuk0?si=5pagTh1873NqMfbw
- nonethewiser 3y agoHe didnt say they are the main factor. He said they are the reason.
- 48cfu 3y ago[dead]
- Lamad1234 3y agoReligious nutbags from olden times weren't all that nuts to ban usury!!!
- dylan604 3y agothere's lending, and then there's predatory lending. let's not paint everything with the same brush.
- lostlogin 3y agoWhile true, that’s also not that helpful. Where is the line?
- LastTrain 3y agoSomewhere in the middle.
- HPsquared 3y agoWhat about risky borrowers?
- dylan604 3y agoI like to think the parable of jesus overturning the money changers' tables was because they were the equivalent to payday loans. here's money to pay for new goats/lambs with the promise that you pay me back in full plus some meat for my family vs here's some money for 3 goats and 3 lambs in the promise that you pay me back in full plus 4 goats and 4 lambs or it'll be a real shame if my nephew has to come and pay a visit.
- lukifer 3y agoThe problem isn't that there isn't a common-sense distinction between the extremes; it's attempting to define the crossover point (presumably for the purposes of a "bright line" rule in law/policy/norms). Defining how much interest should qualify as usury is a classic "paradox of the heap" [0]; which may be a reason by some faith traditions simply forbade lending at interest altogether. An interesting alternative to consider, is money that intentionally depreciates value at a fixed rate ("demurrage" [1]). In theory, this would incentivize lending at zero interest (assuming relative price stability for real goods, which is easier said than done). [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sorites_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sorites_paradox [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demurrage_(currency) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demurrage_(currency)
- imtringued 3y agoTime preference theories of interest are unsatisfactory, because for them to make sense, lenders must have perfect knowledge about the future and be perfectly aware of competing usages of money at any point in the lending window. If they don't have that information, they can't have time preference. Lenders will be reluctant to lend at "market clearing" interest rates and consistently demand a premium giving the rise to usury. However, usury can't be banned, because the concept of lending is about bringing money from places with low utility to places with high utility. Strangely enough, this means any ability of money to save transaction costs and facilitate gets priced into interest. We are even further away from the time preference theory at this point. The real question one should ask, if lending brings money to the poor, which is a good thing, why does it flow to back to the rich? Why doesn't an overabundance of wealthy people willing to lend for nothing appear?
- logicchains 3y ago>Time preference theories of interest are unsatisfactory, because for them to make sense, lenders must have perfect knowledge about the future and be perfectly aware of competing usages of money at any point in the lending window. This is just wrong. Time preference doesn't require lenders to have perfect knowledge, it also describes how two lenders with access to similar (necessarily incomplete) information about the future would behave differently due to different time preferences.
- HPsquared 3y agoCare to explain the reasoning behind this? I don't follow.
- MichaelRo 3y agoLooks like ChatGPT hallucinating.
- quxbar 3y agoI would venture to guess that people are largely poor because they've been thoroughly exploited by the rich, and short-term greed is allowed to take precedence over higher-utility outcomes.
- MichaelRo 3y agoIt always intrigued me how can people justify NOT CHARGING interest for a loan, seems like the reason is "tunnel vision" exclusively looking at the matter from the point of view of the party who borrows the money. But looking from the point of view of the one who loans the money, without interest there's only risk and no reward. I mean like when I'm lending an amount of money to someone with no interest, all I can hope is that they might repay them back (uncertain). And most likely I'll have to go through the trouble of incentivizing them to return my money, another cost on my side with no benefits since I can only hope to get back what I already had. So I have some money now, lend them and temporarily lose them, then go through great lengths of effort and stress to get them back and at the end all I can hope for is that I'll have what I already had. Probabilistically this is a certain losing position, by pure statistics some money will get "lost". I'm locking myself into a loss. Really as a loaner, how do you justify lending money with no interest? What's in it for you?
- rijoja 3y ago... eh ... you lend money to someone for example if they need to buy food, and don't have the money, because you don't want them to starve? You take the risk because it might hurt their pride if you where to give them the money? Charging for interests means that you are making profit of others poverty want want. This gives you incentive to promote desperation and desire. If you lend w/o [edit]interest[/edit], you won't encourage lavish spending, but encourage a solution to the root cause of the poverty, so that you won't have to do it again? Instead you'll be promoting good, which a lot of people like doing just for the sake of it. This is why Christianity and Islam forbade usury. Sorry if this comes across as facetious, but do I really have to spell this out, are you human or an AI? [edit spelling]
- MichaelRo 3y ago>> you lend money to someone for example if they need to buy food Well go ahead and lend them poor people your money to buy food. There's no shortage of such people in every area of the globe, including where you live. Do you do that? How much money do you give consistently, on a regular basis, to someone in need? I'd wager zero, but of course, it's easy to preach. For your information I do give regularly quite a consistent amount by myself on top of the =~ 50% the state rips of from me in taxes, most of which go to social security. There's never enough supply of free give as there's demand for it. >> This is why Christianity and Islam forbade usury. >> Sorry if this comes across as facetious, but do I really have to spell this out, are you human or an AI? Well that was before capitalism was a thing. Again, I urge YOU, not "the rich" or "others" to practice what you preach.
- wslh 3y agoSorry, I will buy the book, I stopped reading after "It’s striking that the earliest narratives of unmanageable debt and organised human violence coincide.". The definition of striking is: "attracting attention by reason of being unusual, extreme, or prominent.". It is not unusual that resources (land, money, etc) are linked with wars and violence. I will never make this comment if it not were because it is a curated content in the "London Review of Books".