7 ms·
Sounds like Jodorwsky's Dune[0] where it's famous for not getting made. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jodorowsky%27s_Dune https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jodorow
by dylan604 3y ago
Sounds like Jodorwsky's Dune[0] where it's famous for not getting made.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jodorowsky%27s_Dune https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jodorowsky%27s_Dune
- nihiven 3y agoI would love to see how insane a 10-14 hour Dune movie would be. No intermission I'm sure.
- dylan604 3y agoI wouldn't mind sitting in a screening of Dune pt1 followed by Dune pt2 when it comes out. Sounds like something Alamo would do. While not 10-14 hours, I would be willing to sit in the theater for 4-5 hours.
- AdamJacobMuller 3y agoAMC by me did all 3 LOTR films in 3 nights just before the hobbit came out. I enjoyed it a lot but by god by the time the 3rd movie ended I was done, and then I still had to sit through another 45 minutes of endings. (Best movies ever)
- RajT88 3y agoI would watch it. My wife would probably head to her sister's for the weekend.
- frfl 3y agoSlightly unrelated, but there is a 19 hour fan-edit of the Hobbit + Lord of the Rings -- i.e someone glued all 3 Hobbit movies and all 3 LotR movies into a 19 hour video.
- usrusr 3y agoI believe that a 90 minutes cut of matrix 2+3 could be actually enjoyable.
- mavhc 3y ago"people copied our cool effects for Matrix 1, what if we make the action scenes so long and expensive no one would even bother to copy them because they all went home before they were over?"
- AdamJacobMuller 3y agoHopefully that's 19 hours of LOTR with the 2-3 hours of the hobbit which was good.
- frfl 3y agoNo, it's uncut, all deleted scenes, extended version of all movies if I'm not mistaken. It's not a "remix" edit, the 19 hour one I'm referring to. https://www.reddit.com/r/fanedits/comments/bo8how/middle_earth_chronological_complete_edition/ https://www.reddit.com/r/fanedits/comments/bo8how/middle_ear...
- dylan604 3y agoIn the "2-3 hours of the hobbit which was good" are you including the animated versions as well? I'd be hard pressed to find 2-3 hours from the travesty that Jackson made
- dmos62 3y agoWhat didn't you like about it?
- Tostino 3y agoDifferent person, but just about everything. It simply wasn't enjoyable, at all. I'm just talking about the first hobbit, I have somehow managed to purge the memory of seeing the others from my memory.
- stevekemp 3y agoI liked the LotR adaptations, though there were a few things I was pretty disappointed with. But when it came to the Hobbit films it was a different story entirely, I saw the first and didn't love it. I saw the second and actively disliked it, so I figured I'd save myself the pain and haven't seen the third and I have no intention of watching it. It's a shame that it was badly rushed, and split (needlessly) into three parts. But despite the close association it didn't ruin my enjoyment of the LotR films, which I rewatch every few years.
- vkou 3y agoThe best way to watch that is almost certainly to come in on ~hour 10.
- runeofdoom 3y agoThere are also fan-made "book edits" of LotR and the Hobbit that purge as much non-book material as possible while keeping th film coherent.
- superjan 3y agoFor starwars fans, there’s machete order: https://www.rodhilton.com/2011/11/11/the-star-wars-saga-suggested-viewing-order/ https://www.rodhilton.com/2011/11/11/the-star-wars-saga-sugg...
- hinkley 3y agoSciFi did a miniseries, just before or just after they changed their name. It wasn't bad. I think it was about 10 hours. The problem is that a lot of the payoff is at the end of book 3, and then book four tips the whole thing upside down with some deep religious and philosophical elements that I'm not sure everyone is ready for. I'm always a little surprised how few people have read Dune relative to Lord of the Rings, but the more I think about Dune the more I get it.
- dylan604 3y ago>with some deep religious and philosophical elements that I'm not sure everyone is ready for. This is how I felt about Battlestar. I barely remember watching the original series as a kid, but I just remember a couple of character names, Cylons (which I thought were cool), the space ships, and the human in the dark room ontop of the pyramid shape the Cylons talked to. That was it. Then I watched the reboot, and was shocked by the religious overtones. Clearly, I never researched anything about it until that point, and then it all made sense. I'm nervous about Buck Rogers (biddybiddup, what's up Buck!) might turn out the same way on a reboot.
- bigmattystyles 3y agoReligious overtones or are ancient religious texts the original sci-fi where its adherents a few generations removed never got the memo? Only kinda joking. I too picked up on battlestar, resurrection, the twelve tribes (or colonies?) lords ok Kobol and so on. I think someone told me at some point the original was Mormons in space.
- Galacta7 3y agoThe original show's creator, Glen Larson, was a Mormon - so it tracks that the show incorporated a lot of that theology. Also, one of the main antagonists is Count Iblis, someone who seeks to lead the colonists to follow him, though he is revealed to be essentially a prince of darkness. "Iblis" is the Islamic name for Satan, so another religious element. Even his backstory is similar to the Abrahamic view of the devil, "he [Count Iblis] was previously a Being of Light who fell from grace after using his powers for evil purposes." Ron Moore's reimagined version of Battlestar includes strong themes of reincarnation and life being a cycle, which also tracks with Moore's past interest in Hinduism and other Eastern religions.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- no_wizard 3y agoIMO Dune needs to be a tv show that likely runs several seasons so all the world and backstory can be explored properly so the audience can get a full experience. Think The Wire in terms of plot discovery and forwarding (leaves out bogus exposition, means you have to pay attention to get things etc that moves along at a good pace and has forward development each episode. It would be expensive, but it’s the only way I can imagine Dune being done to its fullest extent on screen
- bmelton 3y agoThe problem is that nobody wants to acquire Dune to be a critical success. It needs to be a commercial success. This of course implies the addition of much lazier exposition than The Wire, which IIRC never had more than about 4 million viewers. I'm sure it's different in the streaming era, but more and more, audiences are making it clear that they are definitely not tuning in to shows that require thought.
- afterburner 3y agoEventually special effects will become so easy to do well that a cheaply produced Dune will capture all its facets. Although you'll still need a good writer to make it compelling.
- c0pium 3y agoIf the source material was better it would be easier. The first book is ok but it’s all downhill from there, and fast.
- tsimionescu 3y agoI would say the opposite. The first book is good, but pretty typical sci-fi fantasy fare. The next books are what really fleshes out a really interesting concept, this universe where humanity is far more advanced than today in a humanist way instead of technologically. They also help make the point of the first book clear - that Paul wasn't a hero, but a tyrant. This is easily lost in the first book because of the comparison with the Harkonen and the previous Emperor, and because we're used to rooting for the main character. But Herbert's point wasn't to further the myth of the philosopher king, but to dismantle it - which is quite rare in fiction, and made extremely clear throughout the series. I'd also say that the exploration of Leto II's psychology in the God Emperor of Dune was the most interesting writing in the series, so that's what I'd consider the pretty clear high point.
- phatfish 3y agoThe documentary is very good. Conjures a perfect film adaptation in your imagination.