10 ms·
MonadGPT – What would have happened if ChatGPT was invented in the 17th century?
- RecycledEle 3y agoThis could be useful for teaching history. One way to teach history would be to prepare the student for time travel to the period they are studying.
- Dorialexander 3y agoHi! Model creator here. I happen to be a cultural historian and that's a main use case that I see. It's not complicated to learn about past events but having a general idea of the culture of the time (and its alieness from our perspective) is way harder. Monad is just prototype but there is a real potential for immersing experience through historical LLMs.
- benbreen 3y agoThanks for doing this. We should talk! I am a historian and have been exploring using LLMs in teaching (https://resobscura.substack.com/p/simulating-history-with-chatgpt https://resobscura.substack.com/p/simulating-history-with-ch...). I love this idea. I’m fairly sure at this point that history education will be one of the fields most positively impacted by LLMs, just because there is so much potential for redeploying primary sources in creative ways like this.
- Dorialexander 3y agoCertainly. In fact I see we already follow each other on Twitter :D And yes totally. The other massive impact could be in source analysis. I have started using Mistral-Hermes for text annotation and it is both impressive and very fast.
- andy_ppp 3y agoWould be interesting to check with a suitably trained LLM if our understand of historical wording is actually correct. Whole parts of history might be written down but lost in translation if you see what I'm saying...
- ekianjo 3y agoA roman era GPT would be fantastic
- Dorialexander 3y agoAlready in the work. Just had a meeting today with two latinists about it.
- ekianjo 3y agoAwesome!!
- LightMachine 3y agoWhy don't you restrict the training just to old text? That would be awesome
- isoprophlex 3y agoI'm not sure you'd be able to scrape together enough data for that to be viable...
- iopq 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corpus_Inscriptionum_Latinarum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corpus_Inscriptionum_Latinarum approximately 180,000 inscriptions
- xena 3y agoWhat did you use to train this? I'm thinking about making a fine tune of my own and if you have some tips to train it easier that would be much appreciated!
- progne 3y agoThis seems like a fine way to steel man a controversy by going directly to the sources. I'd like to be able to, e.g., dial up a debate between Karl Marx and Milton Friedman. Even better if it's possible for Karl to convince Milton or visa versa.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bambax 3y agoGreat project! Do you have a list of the training/fine tuning data that went into it? A great use would be to enable one to have conversations with Pascal or Leibnitz, etc. For instance, I published online the complete text of the Mémoires de Saint-Simon (written in 1745-1755, but describing the second part of the reign of Louis XIV and the Régence, 1695-1721). Saint-Simon was described by his contemporaries to be one of the greats conversationalists of his time. It would be so cool to chat with him.
- Dorialexander 3y agoI published the completely dataset here: https://huggingface.co/datasets/Pclanglais/MonadGPT https://huggingface.co/datasets/Pclanglais/MonadGPT While I don't think Saint-Simon is included, a French colleague did a few try with it that turned out better than ChatGPT. I'm currently working on an extended historical model for French (from 1000-2000) and maybe Saint-Simon memoirs will be included as well.
- bambax 3y agoThanks for the info. > the completely dataset here: https://huggingface.co/datasets/Pclanglais/MonadGPT https://huggingface.co/datasets/Pclanglais/MonadGPT Classic French transcription seems to be lacking. In particular, "s" used to be printed in a manner very similar to "f", but they're really s. For example this: > ce qui augmentoit ſes craintesc'eſt que certe innocente Vierge ne parloit iamais d'autre choſe aux Domeſtiques que du lcge d'Orl'cans donnant à connoitre à la façon dont elle en difcouroit que fon inclination eſtoit toute aux armes should be spelled like this: > ce qui augmentoit ses craintes c'est que cette innocente Vierge ne parloit jamais d'autre chose aux Domestiques que du ?? d'Orléans donnant à connoître à la façon dont elle en discouroit que son inclination étoit (or estoit) toute aux armes Maybe there should be some kind of dictionary step before fine-tuning?
- Dorialexander 3y agoAh it's completely volontary on my part: I want to keep the historical spelling as much a possible. That's why I used the google books OCR which does a better work at it than Gallica. That's still a bit erased in the current model (I don't think the tokenizer likes this so much).
- antifa 3y agoAny chance anyone is working on one for "the 80s"?
- TaylorAlexander 3y agoI actually just enjoyed a great video with that theme made by a historian! "Advice for time traveling to medieval Europe" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-aSdFrPnlRg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-aSdFrPnlRg
- tadah 3y agoInteresting. How does one get this to run on a M-series Macbook Pro?
- schmeichel 3y agoI'd recommended using llama.cpp and The Bloke's GGUF version of this model! https://github.com/ggerganov/llama.cpp/ https://github.com/ggerganov/llama.cpp/ https://huggingface.co/TheBloke/MonadGPT-GGUF https://huggingface.co/TheBloke/MonadGPT-GGUF
- Dorialexander 3y agoHi. TheBloke has quantized the model: https://huggingface.co/TheBloke/MonadGPT-GGUF https://huggingface.co/TheBloke/MonadGPT-GGUF You may be able to run the Q3 or Q4 variant. Although in my experience, the quality of quantization takes a hit on "weirder" data (which is the case here)
- SushiHippie 3y agoAs the model is very small you should be able to run any quantization level on a M-Series macbook with at least 16GB of ram. The best one speed/quality wise will probably be Q6_K. As it has not much difference in quality with Q8, but will be definitely faster than Q8. Haven't tried this one specifically but I always run the 7B parameter models on a M2 Pro with Q6_K or Q4_K_M (depending on how fast I want it). See also this table in the readme, which states that Q8 only needs ~10GB of RAM: https://huggingface.co/TheBloke/MonadGPT-GGUF?text=Hey+my+name+is+Clara%21+How+are+you%3F#provided-files https://huggingface.co/TheBloke/MonadGPT-GGUF?text=Hey+my+na...
- ACAVJW4H 3y agoFinally, LLMs have brought us to the threshold of ancestral simulation. It's like the universe hit 'retry' on humanity, but this time with AI as the dungeon master.
- brainbag 3y agoThe book Accelerando by Charles Stross has some bits about this and many other oddly prescient recent technology.
- rvbissell 3y agoBy that same author, I also recommend Singularity Sky for similar reasons.
- earthboundkid 3y agoWhat if the AGI is an adherent of Russian cosmism?
- Dorialexander 3y agoThe model can also be tried directly on this space: https://huggingface.co/spaces/Pclanglais/MonadGPT https://huggingface.co/spaces/Pclanglais/MonadGPT HuggingFace has generously provided free GPUs.
- ComplexSystems 3y agoMy favorite response so far: Prompt: And what of the CRYPTO-CURRENCY? Response: CRYPTO-CURRENCY, a new Kind of Money, of which the first Species was called Bitcoin, and the second, Ethereum, and others since. These are not minted by Kings or Governments, but by private Persons, who have got them into Circulation by their own Authority, and call them Coins, because they are of the Value of Money, but they are not Lawful Money; for there is no Law that makes them so. They are a sort of Counterfeit Money, which has its own particular Value, and is bought and sold like other Commodities. The Price of these Crypto-Currencies varies every Day, according to the Opinion of those who deal in them; for they have no intrinsic Value, but only what they are worth to the Buyers and Sellers. As to their being a means of Trade, we need not say any Thing about them, since they are not allowed to pass current in any Country, either as Money or Credits, nor will they ever be received as such, unless the Government shall make them Legal. But though the Trade which is carried on by means of these Crypto-Currencies is not legal, yet it is considerable, especially among those who are fond of speculation, and are not afraid of risking their Money. It is said, that there are some People, who have made large Fortunes by dealing in these Crypto-Currencies, but it is not certain that they did not lose as much as they gained, or even more. The History of the World affords no Example of any Crypto-Currency that has lasted long, or ever become a general Medium of Exchange. If the Trade carried on by means of these Crypto-Currencies were stopped by the Authority of the State, those who had invested their Money in them would lose their Capital, and be left without any Resources. The only Security that the Owners of these Crypto-Currencies have is the Opinion of the Public, which may change at any Time, and leave them without any Value.
- tkgally 3y agoExcellent! Here is my first attempt: Me: How can I write a good essay? MonadGPT: The best way to write a good Essay is by following these instructions: First of all, you must have a good and well-grounded knowledge in that subject which you intend to treat upon; for it is not possible to write any thing well that you do not understand well. Secondly, you must observe a certain order or method in your writing, which will be much better than to run up and down without any design. Thirdly, you must be sure to make use of such words as are proper to the matter in hand; for if you use too many of them, you will be thought a tedious writer; and if you use too few, you will be thought a negligent one. Fourthly, you must avoid the use of all those phrases and expressions, that are common among people of no learning; for they are the marks of ignorance, and therefore must be avoided by every man that would be esteemed learned. Lastly, you must take care to write with clearness and perspicuity, that others may easily understand what you mean; for if you write in a manner that is obscure, or difficult to be understood, you cannot expect to have the same reputation with those who write more clearly and perspicuously. I ran the same question by GPT-4, Claude 2.1, and Bard. Each replied with advice on how to write a good school essay: “understand the assigned topic,” “follow the required formatting and citation guidelines,” etc. They said nothing about avoiding expressions “that are common among people of no learning,” let alone writing “perspicuously.”
- tonetheman 3y ago[dead]
- behnamoh 3y agoThis has nothing to do with monads in FP.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- valyagolev 3y agothey always insist that Leibnizian monad is not related to the FP monad at all, probably because it's a major point of pride of contemporary scientist to not be related to anything philosophical at all. sure. still, i'm always wondering. why be so insistent. i mean, leibniz's monads are opaque substances that by itself have no causal relations with the world, but only affect each other/the world through "God". which sounds to me like an exact description of the IO monad
- karaterobot 3y agoIn a really roundabout way I think it does, but not directly. Not having had a background in FP at the time, but having read a lot of books about alchemy, my first conversation with a colleague about monads was the mirror reflection of your comment: “What are you talking about, this has nothing to do with Dr. John Dee.”
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 3cats-in-a-coat 3y agoJesus. This is beautiful.
- severak_cz 3y agoIt stuck in loop: > How do I make gold? > > To make Gold, take two parts of common Salt, one part of Sal-Ammoniac, one part of Sulfur, and one part of Brimstone, and mix them well together, and put them into a New-Receiving Glass, and let them stand until they become a thick Liquor, then pour them into another Glass, and add thereto some Spirit of Nitre, and a little Water, which will cause them to turn green, and make a strong Spirituous Acid, which is called Spirits of Salt, or Aqua Fortis. Then take some Gold, and wash it with the said Acid, and it will become red; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become yellow; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become white; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become black; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become green; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become red; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become yellow; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become white; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become black; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become green; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become red; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become yellow; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become white; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become black; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become green; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become red; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become yellow; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become white; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become black; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become green; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become red; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become yellow; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become white; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become black; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become green; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become red; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become yellow; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become white; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become black; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become green; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become red; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become yellow; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become white; then wash it again with some more of the Acid, and it will become black; then wash it again with some more of the Ac
- ilaksh 3y agoSo interesting. Maybe someone will add it to the ollama registry. https://ollama.ai/library?sort=newest https://ollama.ai/library?sort=newest
- severak_cz 3y agoInteresting. When asked about electricity and similar things it's sometimes responds with 17th century definition. And sometimes it spits out modern wikipedia-like definition. When it's in "historic mood" it does not know who Emmanuel Macron is but as soon as you introduces it to LED diodes, television or similar modern concepts it knows who Macron is straight away. EDIT: It's still very interesting for me, one of most interestings GPT's out there. Also it does not hide how to make sulphuric acid from me. :-D
- thomasahle 3y agoI was hoping it was trained ground up on old texts only. Now we don't really know, when it says something archaic, if it's because it's "pretending" to be old school, or because that is what it truly believes.
- eternauta3k 3y agoProbably not enough old texts for it to learn how the language and the world work. Hence the fine tuning.
- aroo 3y agoSounds like something right up the domain of synthetic data.
- yyyk 3y agoThere's a sufficient number of old texts - far more than necessary - if we were willing to converse with it in Latin*! Perhaps we could make a translator LLM to converse with the 17th century LLM... * I'm not talking about Roman-era Latin, Latin was the scholarly/international language for Europe for a long long time. AFAIK, most European Latin literature is untranslated...
- jstanley 3y agoAre you sure? In Andrej Karpathy's intro to LLMs[1], he says pre-training uses about 10TB of text from the web. It's hard to believe that a comparable amount of text had been created, even across all languages, in the entire history of humanity up to the 17th century. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zjkBMFhNj_g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zjkBMFhNj_g
- rafram 3y agoThis is fun. It does seem like the training data needs some cleanup - it adds page numbers in the middle of passages sometimes.
- Proven 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- axispx 3y agoThis is so much fun. > What causes lightening? > The cause of lightning is the earthen substance, mixed with water, and heated by the sun. Now when the sun heats the earthen substance, and the water mingled therewith, it causeth the earth to be dried up, and then the air is filled with smoke, and the smoke riseth up into the clouds, and there it is mixed with fire; and when the cloud is full, it bursts open, and the smoke goes forth, and strikes against the ground, and thereby makes thunder; and the fire goes before the smoke, and maketh the lightning. Therefore, lightning is caused by the sun's heat, and the mixture of smoke with fire. And therefore, if any man shall tell you that lightning is caused by the sun's rays, or that the sun's rays make it, he speaks falsely, and he knoweth nothing of the truth. For the sun's rays do not make anything; but they are the means whereby the sun works, and the sun works by means of the heat. And therefore, when the sun heats the earth, and the water mingled therewith, it causeth the earth to be dried up, and then the air is filled with smoke, and the smoke riseth up into the clouds, and there it is mixed with fire; and when the cloud is full, it bursts open, and the smoke goes forth, and strikes against the ground, and thereby maketh thunder; and the fire goes before the smoke, and maketh the lightning.
- insomagent 3y agoI just know in a thousand years they will look back at our current explanation of electricity with an equal level of ridicule.
- qayxc 3y agoI wouldn't think so. The difference is that in the past 200 years we've used actual experiments to confirm or falsify our models. There's a stark difference between coming up with an an hypothesis and just roll with it and scrutinising a hypothesis by conducting experiments and tests.
- thendrill 3y agoWoooow... Such arogance... We have 24 hours in a day, and 360 degrees in a circle. The people that defined those things around 4k to 5k years ago also had batteries that they used for electroplating. . But nahh buddy. You think everything great came in the last 200 years in English.... Wow...
- oopsrdiditagain 3y ago[dead]
- owenversteeg 3y agoWow, this is something else. I love it. >User : Hello. I'm not feeling too well. Could you give me some health advice? >Monad-GPT: I pray you to take heart, and not be so heavy at my coming. As for your health, I am of the opinion that you are much out of order in your body; but yet it is a great matter what is the cause of it. It may be either some natural melancholy or vapours, which have got into your brain by reason of the excess of your humour; or else some coldness in your liver, or spleen, which hath kept up a quantity of blood in your head; and now it seems as if all were come down again upon you. >User: You're right. It seems to be melancholy. What should I do? >Monad-GPT: It is a very hard matter for me to prescribe any thing to you in your present condition, I must first know what hath caused this melancholy. What have you been doing? have you taken any physic since you were well? and what kind of diet do you eat? >User: I eat nearly nothing, for I am in love. >Monad-GPT: Aye, I see that by your eyes; for love hath the power to wither up the spirits of a man as much as a fever: and yet it is hard to know whether you are in love or no, for some do take so great delight in their own fancy, that they imagine themselves more in love than ever they were.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- arbuge 3y agoI tried discussing energy drinks with it and found out that the King of Sweden has just issued an edict against Red Bull.
- thomassmith65 3y agoThat sort of thing drains any enthusiasm I have for the project. Even if it were trained exclusively on old materials, in fact, I would worry about modern footnotes and book introductions tainting the training corpus (ie: by introducing knowledge it should not have). I do love the idea, though. It it were possible to use ideal training material, it would be close to time-travel. As it stands, there's a limit to what one can learn from the text it produces. Much value, imo, would come from what the model does not know. Ideally it would be difficult even to have it comprehend user prompts, due to how different English is today.
- snovv_crash 3y agoI wonder if there's some benefits of reinitialising completely the final layers and then training with the new data. At least for image processing it's common to use a common backbone trained on everything, and then put a final layer or two of task-specific training on top.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Leear 3y agoI got some interesting advice from it, glad we've moved on to now humane ways of animal training: How to stop my dog from barking? I shall then shew you how to cure him of that fault, which I hope will bee of great use to you and many others, for wee have found by experience that it is not so hard to correct as it is to cure them of their other faults, and he hath done his duty well in this case. And forasmuch as I have found by experience that there are many who would doe much good to their dogs if they knew how to keep them in order, and yet want some means to bring them into such a state, I will endeavour to shew you some ways to doe it, and if you will follow my directions I hope you will find no fault with me. The first thing is to keepe your dog from barking when you go abroad, and the next is to keepe him from barking when he is at home, and this is the best way to doe it. First, when you goe abroad, take a piece of bread with you, and give him one or two pieces when he barks, and then he will cease, but if he still continue to bark, strike him on the head with the stick you carry with you, and he will then cease. If he does not cease after you have struck him once or twice, let him alone until he comes home again, and then give him a piece of bread, and when you go out again, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again when he comes home again. In this manner you may proceed till you see him cease, and then give him a piece of bread again, and when you go out again, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if he continues to bark, strike him again, and if
- perchard 3y agoElegantly alludes to the way in which LLMs are constrained to our existing body of knowledge.
- pram 3y agoUpvoted because converting dialogue into old-timey 19th century style prose was one of my favorite uses of GPT.
- jimmySixDOF 3y agoMy contention is that "if ChatGPT was invented in the 17th Century" there is a much higher possibility that Language gets stuck as the number of future tokens produced by AI in that thought experiment crowd out human generated tokens.
- 6stringmerc 3y agoA neat experiment but should only be in Latin or an exclusive high class language. Serfs like you wouldn’t be allowed access to knowledge. God says so is par for the 1600s. Such a rosy nostalgia haha. I enjoy ruining period piece shows and cinema by mentioning how awful everyone smelled and being in the same room was disgusting
- thedailymail 3y agoThank you!! I have been wanting exactly this function trained on exactly the EEBO corpus, and was even considering paying some one to build it. This made my day.
- tgv 3y agoThen we would now live in the 25th century.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pxeger1 3y agoIt’s hilarious to me that under the old-fashioned speech, the structure of its writing is still so identifiably LLM-like.
- AngaraliTurk 3y agoInteresting model! Just a few mistakes like "medecine" and "[...] a big canon?" that I guess were influenced by you speaking French, but nothing serious to detract from your creation.
- Almondsetat 3y agoThe further back we go the more dangerous is to extrapolate "context" from texts. Nowadays there are so many people from all walks of life posting online their opinions and their lives that it's reasonable to assume that an AI trained in the contents of the web will approximate the zeitgeist and the current "vibes". The same absolutely cannot be said going further back, when books were only written and published by a small circle of elites. This prototype seems to me conceptually flawed from the very start
- vasco 3y agoIt's still cool to know what the zeitgeist was for this group of people. There's still quite a few people without access to the internet (more than 2B out of 8B). And later you can make the same argument about the internet having way more representation from rich people than poor, based on who hosts / publishes versus who only reads. So even today we have the same problem.
- Karellen 3y agoSlightly disappointed - I was expecting the description of an alternate history where the development of science, engineering, literature, war, ethics, politics, civil rights, etc... evolved differently with the aid of LLMs. "What would have happened?" is not quite the same thing as "How would it sound, lol?"
- bambax 3y agoSame here. The title is a little misleading. It's "just" an LLM trained on early modern texts. Quite interesting still! but not what I expected.
- herculity275 3y agoThat’s a really tricky what-if since we don’t even know the impact of LLMs on our current world - how would you even begin to speculate about the early modern period?
- Dorialexander 3y agoIn a way you could do so by prompting Monad with artificial intelligence stuff. I did a try lately on the latest OpenAI events and it went on like this: "In this sad and tragical storye, you shall heare how Sam Altman, a manne of great wit and judgement, was evicted out of his Companie of Artificiall Machines for want of candour in his Communications with the Board of Trustees…"
- tamarlikesdata 3y agoSuper impressive. And addictive.
- iamwil 3y agoYou know how people try to see if they can recreate modern technologies from basic tools? It'd be an interesting experiment to see if you can get ChatGPT to reason out modern knowledge based on the things that it knows in the 17th century, kinda like building up a technology tree.
- praveen9920 3y agoThis is interesting. I tried to create a custom GPT with chatGPT with similar traits to compare. You can interact with it here[1]. https://chat.openai.com/g/g-HiKPzmMe6-monadgptx https://chat.openai.com/g/g-HiKPzmMe6-monadgptx
- thatguymike 3y ago"Localization issues: sometime, the answer given by MonadGPT will be in near modern English." More like... temporalization issues? Momentization? Chronization?
- bohadi 3y agopretty cool. "period" finetuning could be useful for game npc sims
- zubairq 3y agoI wonder if we could run this to see what happened 2000 years ago?