3 ms·
Your comment makes no sense. GNU Coreutils has a "man [" as well as "man test" man page. Bash has "help test" for a quick cheatsheet. The [ command is very ol
by kazinator 3y ago
Your comment makes no sense. GNU Coreutils has a "man [" as well as "man test" man page.
Bash has "help test" for a quick cheatsheet.
The [ command is very old; it was already present in Version 7 Unix in 1979.
- c0l0 3y agoParts of the comment make a LOT of sense actually, when you look at shell scripts written by the uninitated. Often times, I see constructs like while [ 1 ]; do ...; done which are a pretty clear indication of the author's misconception about the perceived nature of [ ], I think.
- kazinator 3y agoThe nice way to write that isn't any kind of test command but: while true; do ...; done There is never any reason to use test, other than portability to some broken environment that is missing [ but not missing test.
- tuyiown 3y ago> There is never any reason to use test What's the reason for always using [ ?
- Diti 3y ago> There is never any reason to use test test -d /nix && echo "$_ exists" || echo "$_ doesn’t exist" You cannot do this with [ – Don’t Repeat Yourself, and your scripts become more maintainable. (Not POSIX-compliant. Documented in Bash and Zsh.)
- teo_zero 3y ago> You cannot do this with [ Why not? [ -d /nix ] && echo ...
- forgotpwd16 3y agoAs '$_' is set to last arg of previous run command, the test example will have it be the name of directory whereas for [ will always be ].
- elteto 3y agoD=/nix test -d $D && echo $D exists …
- cagey 3y ago$ V=nada echo "x${V}x" xx
- Dylan16807 3y agoV=nada; echo "x${V}x"
- teo_zero 3y agoAh yes, now I see it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- watersb 3y agowhile true; do ...; done Is `true` a builtin? I might want to avoid an external process call just to create an unconditional loop.
- kazinator 3y agoPOSIX allows any command to be a builtin, as long as a real external command is also available which can be executed via execv and whatnot. $ echo $BASH_VERSION 4.4.20(1)-release $ type true true is a shell builtin Also: $ type test test is a shell builtin $ type [ [ is a shell builtin
- Karellen 3y agoI think GP's point was that `[` feels like syntax, but - importantly - isn't. Yes, `[` is a command, and has a man page and everything, but in a script it doesn't look like a command. It looks like something "special" is going on. Whereas using `test` emphasises the point that you're just running another program. That all `if` does is check the output status of whatever program is being run, whether that's `test`/`[`, or `grep`, or anything else at all. (Personally, I don't think that emphasis is necessary. But I've been using shell scripts long enough that I understand these nuances fairly well without having to think about them much any more. So I think that GP's point is a reasonable perspective to have, and worth considering.)
- rascul 3y agoNote that bash implements [ as a builtin so the coreutils man page might not match exactly.