11 ms·
Airlines will make $118B in extra fees
- thedaly 3y agoI think we need legislation that mandates transparency in fees across most if not all products. Not including taxes and fees in the listed price is detrimental to consumers.
- acomjean 3y agoThey are trying. Not surprisingly there is pushback from airlines (and other businesses..) https://wapo.st/47cBuSJ https://wapo.st/47cBuSJ
- tempsy 3y agoObama passed a law that forced airlines to show the final price (fees + taxes) in the list price, so it's been like that for many years now. Before that it was much more like hotels where you're not shown the final price until the last step.
- judge2020 3y agoHow do they estimate taxes? Based on IP until you change your address?
- tempsy 3y agoTaxes are fully determined by departing and arriving airports. They don't need your IP.
- godelski 3y agoGreat. Now is the consumer allowed to compare prices in a meaningful way? Let's say I visit the site, close my browser, clear my cache and cookies, and then navigate to the site again. Should the price change?
- tempsy 3y agoNot sure what you're implying. Why would the price change in that situation.
- thedaly 3y agoSites used to book travel, ie airfare, hotels, etc, are notorious for changing price based on your perceived interest. I've noticed this myself when I look at a hotel listing multiple times, the price tends to creep up.
- tempsy 3y agoHotels maybe, but airfare is not going to change because you're in incognito or clear a browser. I rarely see any price differences between an Expedia and booking direct. If an airline was messing with prices based on something with your computer you would be see frequent large differences in prices between direct bookings and third party bookings, which I've never seen before.
- godelski 3y ago> Why would the price change in that situation. That's a great question! The reason many of us are upset. Because it shouldn't, but it does. Not always, but it does. Now this is black box probing so may be another factor, but the prices do swing quickly.
- pxx 3y agoStop spreading these lies. This cannot be done on any major airline (one large enough to be on a GDS). Airline pricing may be complicated but the way fares are constructed is public. You may be witnessing: * An ota changing their markups (which immediately asks the question "why are you paying the markup") * Differing currency conversions and fares if you're changing the country you're issuing from (but this will reset itself once you actually try to pay) * Fare class availability (somebody might have just bought the last ticket at that price) If what you are claiming is true, there'd be far more evidence for it, and ITA Matrix (and hell, OTAs) wouldn't exist as a product. Given how well this is documented, it almost seems like you're disingenuously trying to sell VPN products (especially with your name-drop of a specific product)
- esoterica 3y agoAll the major airlines I’ve used show the prices including mandatory fees and taxes up front. The only things not included are optional add ons like extra bags.
- justrealist 3y agoIt's bad but it's also dishonest to frame it as net-plus revenue. It would be mostly baked into a ticket price if it wasn't an extra fee. To some extent it leads to a less competitive market, and is genuine revenue, but I think it's basically impossible that it's $118B worth. People are not dumb, they mostly know when they have to pay for an extra bag. > Airlines will make record $118B as extra fees with website dark patterns would be more correct.
- yardie 3y agoPassengers aren't paying for an extra bag these days. They are paying for every bag, carry-on or checked. They care creating new classes even lower than economy. And this is causing problems with booking systems like Concur. I fly a few times a year for work and I'm obviously not sophisticated enough for these edge cases. I've gone back to calling our travel agency because the online system can't distinguish between Economy, Economy Basic, and Economy Plus(tm).
- scarface_74 3y agoI used Concur for years flying domestically in the US. Your organization can create rules and filters that are transparent to you that shouldn’t be a problem.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoPretty much a BS clickbait headline that doesn't comport with the facts in the article: > Across the industry, revenue from what’s known as ancillary sales—fees for selecting seats, checking bags, and buying food, to name a few—will reach a record $117.9 billion in 2023 Yes, airlines have done a ton of "unbundling", but lots and lots of people want to select their seats, check their bags, buy food, etc. and are willing to pay for it, regardless of website design. I'm not arguing that airline websites don't use dark patterns, just that it's ridiculously insane to attribute all ancillary revenue to that.
- crooked-v 3y agoThe dark pattern part comes in with how it's impossible to know if or when any of that stuff is actually included in the ticket price, letting airlines like Spirit list 'ultra-low' prices that end up the same or more as other tickets once you actually include the basics like 'having luggage' or 'tall people getting enough legroom to physically fit into the seat'.
- toymin 3y agoThey still should be way cheaper if you don’t care about the seats and/or only have hand luggage
- tyfon 3y agoI wish they would enforce the "hand luggage" size a bit on entry to the plane, last time I flew around 2017 it was a complete shit show in regards to the overhead storage compartments.
- spacemanspiff01 3y agoThey do, or at least when I last flew they were charging people who had carryon bags that would not go beneath the seat. (I had a backpack that was slightly oversized, but they did not seem to care that much.)
- tekla 3y agoWhy does this article single out airlines? A majority of web devs in FAANG are complicit
- gniv 3y agoIs there an aggregator that shows these fees when comparing prices? Something like the price is $X + $40-80 for the seat + $100 for checked bag.
- LordKeren 3y agoGoogle Flights lets you select the number of bags and updates the displayed flight according (Anecdote from recent domestic US travels, your mileage may vary, etc etc)
- tandr 3y agoPretty much all big flights searching sites (flights.google.com, Bing, etc) allow to specify that you have luggage, and the search results changes (sometimes quite drastically) depending on that checkmark.
- darknavi 3y agoYou want some dark patterns? Try to suss over fare classes and trying to optimize your mileage earnings. Hard to justify legislation for it because it's all "extras" but man do they make it hard to "play the game".
- xattt 3y agoSince this thread will end up with anecdotes, here’s mine with Flair Airlines in Canada. I wanted to take the time to figure out how much value I would get out of each add on. It looked like it would be cheaper to get an add-on in a particular way. The fuckers set a timeout to the site that’s so low that it was just enough time to click through to buy but not enough time to figure out the value. This could be a difference of about 100-200CAD. The airline also had us sitting on the tarmac long enough for my kid to finish a graphical novel. I am guessing they didn’t want to cough up penalty fees to the destination airport for arriving out of a given landing time slot. The experience was like going over to a stingy relatives’ house where they keep the thermostat at 40° in the winter and reuse Saran Wrap between different dishes in the fridge.
- giarc 3y agoI recently flew Flair and it was a regular experience. I did find that the booking process did seem to have some "black patterns", mainly that things would be checked off when I had indicated I didn't want them previously. For example, we were just flying with a single checked bag for a family of 5. The first option is to add a checked bag for EVERY passenger and no option for just one. Then at other times during the booking process, bags would be added and price would change. It was only later in the process that I was able to add a single bag. It was worth the few thousand in difference, however our flights all left on time and we had no delays, so I might be singing a different tune if we had sat and waiting long. One thing I wish I knew is that they charge for everything, including water and coffee.
- dubcanada 3y agoFlair is a discount airline (not WestJet discount, more like Spirit Airlines or Frontier or some "ultra low cost carrier", I doubt their passenger revenue is more then peanuts a flight, if they even make anything at all), it's basically like going to the discount grocery store in a poor neighborhood and wondering why your $20 brand of parmesan cheese is not available? It's not like they hide the fact they are a discount airline and you need to accept there will be inconveniences for such discounted prices.
- 3y ago
- expertentipp 3y agoSpeaking about Europe. Wizzair virtually disabled search and reservations over the web with their paranoid "anti-robot" algorithms, and at some point they had this mysterious "service fee" appearing randomly but discriminating web browser. At Ryanair the reservation workflow is basically one massive dark pattern and upselling designed to make you fell bad. Then there is fucking booking.com, this site opens randomly and unpredictably at various moments while clicking through the search and reservation workflows.
- shortcake27 3y agoI disagree about Ryanair. Yeah, they try and upsell you like crazy, but there aren’t any tricks. They warn you to buy bags in advance because they will charge more at a later date - that’s not a trick, that’s how they subsidise the ticket price for people who plan ahead. And it’s not as if they advertise the price at £12 then it triples at checkout. Maybe there’s a CC processing fee and that’s it? Also if you come back to the site later, the price is the same unless those seats have been sold which they very clearly communicate at the very first step (x seats left at this price).
- francisofascii 3y agoI find airline and concert ticket purchasing to be so exhausting, that I simply opt out more than I desire to. You have to wonder if airlines and other companies (like StubHub) ever calculate how much business they miss from these tactics. We are talking about discretionary purchases, after all.
- sokoloff 3y agoThere's a comedian that I'd really enjoy seeing in person. He's only selling tickets via TicketMaster. As a result, I'll wait for his next Netflix or Amazon tour special.
- jstarfish 3y agoI'm with you on that, but people get emotionally invested in travel for holidays, weddings, custody, funerals and vacations. Never in my life have I been in a position of getting to the end of booking a flight and saying "meh, I don't really need to go there anyway."
- tayo42 3y agoJust bought airline tickets the other day and it was such a frustrating experience to go through. United has 4 levels of economy, it was so tedious to compare luggage fees between them. If I want to sit next to my partner it would be an extra 200 off the lowest price both of us needed to upgrade... Then to bring a carry on. I was using Google flights to compare and they all advertise the really low price, for lowest tier economy. Then yeah clicking through each one to figure out what the final price, getting hit with insurance upgrades, are you sure you don't want economy+ or w/e upgrades on each page. The fee names seemed insane. There was a 10 dollar 9/11 fee? Wtf is that? The prices are changing like everyday? Extra unessary pressure to buy. Why can't we just have consistent pricing, instead of taking advantage of people trying to fly when it's convientent. The whole experience used to be be simpler I think. Just compare and buy and show up.
- vkou 3y ago> There was a 10 dollar 9/11 fee? Wtf is that? 1. It's included in the price you see on Google Flights. 2. Every airline pays it. 3. It's the cost of the TSA reach-*** that you do when going through security. 4. If you don't like it, talk to the airport, or your congresscritter. The airline has no control over it.
- magneticnorth 3y agoAs for sitting next to a partner, if you don't absolutely need to guarantee it, then you can wait til you get to the airport and ask at the gate if they can move you to be beside each other. If the plane is totally full you'll be out of luck, but if there's space then the gate agents will happily reassign you.
- sokoloff 3y agoSimilar approach here: we have a lot better things to do with 400 after tax dollars than spend them to collapse to zero the chance that we'll sit separately in an airliner for a few hours. If that happens, we'll enjoy $400 worth of dinners out way more than sitting together anyway... I find we usually get assigned seats next to each other anyway unless the plane is completely checked in full for aisles and windows even without asking.
- godelski 3y agoJust a anecdotal data point: a few months ago I took a trip overseas and had to do it on a pretty short time schedule (<a week). As a grad student this is obviously tough to budget. So I load up my Mullvad Browser and jump around VPN points. Everything was breaking. They very much did not like that browser and the VPN was the cherry on top. But because of this effort I saved about $500 (NYC seemed to be the best location fwiw and I'm on the west coast and flew to Asia). This felt rather insane and anti-competitive. Each time I changed any variable (including restarting the browser) the price changed and those warnings about number of tickets left would dramatically vary. There is no doubt that that these companies were lying to me. How am I supposed to price compare and we have a competitive market when it's stochastic with high variance? I know airlines claim to work on auctions and economists love auctions, but this wasn't even an auction. This was they knew I was in a bind and just added a dice roll to the price. That's only something a monopoly can do. I don't think this is about being able to select seats, check bags, or buy food.
- arcticbull 3y ago> There is no doubt that that these companies were lying to me. They're not lying to you, the 'number of seats left' refers to the number of seats available at that price - in the lowest available fare bucket. Not on the plane itself. What you ran into are called point of sale restrictions. Lower fares are made available to people buying in different markets. They don't really work on auctions, they charge everyone what they think they'll pay.
- 93po 3y agoIf something is that confusing and misleading then it’s still dishonesty
- photonbeam 3y agoIf the recipient is deceived, its a lie, regardless of weasel words
- arcticbull 3y ago
- Waterluvian 3y agoIs this different in Canada? The fees exist but I’ve always immediately seen the final number that includes all of them. Then there’s some upsells but they’re not really fees because I just decline them.
- tiku 3y agoJust had the horrible experience once again. Why is this still allowed? I later found out that shipping my stuff was cheaper that checking in a bag..
- afavour 3y agoIs that domestic? I keep hearing this but every time I look for international flights it’s never true.
- steveBK123 3y agoI feel like we should parse these complaints as "I flew the cheapest airline that unbundles everything, and paying to re-bundle the stuff I wanted made the price higher".
- shortcake27 3y agoYeah, this is it. People who are used to having their ticket price subsidised by other people who don’t have luggage are angry that those other people are no longer subsidising their ticket. All this, despite the fact that the same ticket with luggage today, adjusted for inflation, is significantly cheaper than it was 20, 40, 60 years ago etc.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- RajT88 3y agoI don't see it mentioned, but I am convinced there's shenanigans with seat assignment as well. I have to reserve my work flights through the work travel app, so of course the airlines know I am on business travel and who I work for. When I select an economy fare, I've noticed when I am finally assigned a seat at the airport, it's usually at the goddamned back of the plane. Most other seat assignments are paid upgrades, even within the same class of tickets. Yes, you can upgrade from economy to economy. Another thing I have noticed is that after takeoff, they now care where you sit. Probably related to the possibility of upgrading within economy. You can't just move over to another open seat within your ticket class - but they used to not care about this at all.
- matwood 3y ago> Another thing I have noticed is that after takeoff, they now care where you sit. If the plane is empty enough that you can move seats, it's often a weight thing on why they don't want people moving around. Otherwise, I've never had an issue moving or swapping seats with people. Then again, almost every flight is full nowadays.
- tmnvix 3y agoI've seen someone asked to return to their original seat. The reason given was something along the lines of "identification in the event of an accident".
- RajT88 3y agoYeah, I have heard that one as well. But it is total crap; they went from 100% not caring to 100% caring about moving seats within same class.
- Symbiote 3y agoIf you have the booking reference, you can often use it to log in on the airline website and select a seat (maybe for a fee) well in advance of the flight. Some options may say "contact your travel agent". (At least with several European airlines I'm familiar with. YMMV.)
- yalogin 3y agoYep they know the moment they figured out extra fees they changed the whole reservation flow to minimize defaults and turned a lot of previously unthinkable items into paid add-ons. Every airline across every segment of travel now does this and as expected it’s resulting in a windfall. Problem is they won’t be happy with this in a quarter or two and their investors demand more, what will they do?
- Hnrobert42 3y agoWouldn’t “upsell” be more accurate than “fee”?
- jmugan 3y agoYeah, I paid extra recently to buy higher-tier tickets that allowed me to choose my seats, so my family could sit together. I go to actually choose the seats and then it wants to charge me an additional fee per seat, per leg. There were no seats that didn't have a fee. Ugh.
- shantara 3y agoMy mother is in her sixties, and she's very tech savvy for her age. She usually has no problem with doing all the things online - from online shopping to paying her bills to social media. The only thing that stumps her and make her panic about potentially making a very costly mistake are the airline websites. She always asks me to buy tickets for her, while feeling very insecure about it. Of course I'm happy to help, but it's hard to convince her that it's not her fault, and the predatory companies are purposefully building these websites like that to trick people into overspending.
- darkwizard42 3y agoLook, I'm not saying her fears are unwarranted, but you have to help me understand where the dark patterns are in airline pricing. They show 1-2 seats remaining, but those are usually accurate... not like Booking.com or other shady booking sites. When booking from first-party airline websites, I rarely have issues with unexpected prices popping up. Each "add-on" is clearly delineated. The rise of even lower pricing tiers like Basic Economy on United also have their benefits (and severe restrictions) spelled out throughout the booking process.
- godelski 3y agoPrices vary based on data they collect about you. Such as browser cookies, hardware info, browser, etc. You can often find different prices simply by clearing your cache or cookies. Or trying from a different browser. I left a comment in main about an anecdotal experience. One thing I'll add is that I also tried having 3 browsers open: Firefox, Mullvad, and Safari. I saw different prices on each.
- esoterica 3y agoThis literally does not happen with first party airline sites (idk about sketchy third party scam sites). Where did this conspiracy theory come from? Which airline did you see doing this?
- shantara 3y ago
- qaq 3y agoWell Delta net Income for 2022 was 3.4B
- Dowwie 3y agoDrip pricing needs to be made illegal in the U.S.
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoEarlier discussion: From airlines to ticket sellers, companies fight U.S. to keep junk fees https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38334126 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38334126
- gjvc 3y agoread the room
- anovikov 3y agoAdmirable read for a person like me who buys their tickets through a brick-and-mortar travel agent who books them through an old-fashioned GDS available to travel agents.
- RHSman2 3y agoEasyjet went through a period of putting the return date the month after. Caught me twice! One completely missed till I tried to return and the 2nd I saw before flying so could change. Proper dark.
- antiterra 3y agoI’ve noticed really confusing upgrade prompts pop up when buying tickets from major airlines, including an upgrade that made the price higher than First Class on the same flight. It included a seat upgrade if available, meaning you could end up very little for the money you spent. If you were to simply click the Main Extra seat you wanted in the seating chart, you’d pay way less. The upgrade did have some refund terms that were not included in a normal ticket, but it deliberately appeared in a way to obfuscate the option to simply upgrade a seat (or to first class.)
- user3939382 3y agoDue to the changes in recent decades, including the security, no leg room, horrible treatment and customer service, I loathe air travel now and avoid it at all costs. I wonder how many are in the same boat. Sadly I’m guessing the industry doesn’t care since their primary revenue is from captive business travelers.
- Crunchified 3y agoDark website patterns are the internet's embodiment of the sleazy salesperson. You want the product, the sales guy wants to upsell you and increase his profit margin (corresponding to sales commission). Nobody likes to be sold at like this, but many companies are perfectly happy being represented by such sleazebag salesmanship.
- aronhegedus 3y agoIt all started to go downhill once airlines stopped having a free 10kg suitcase and a backpack that you could take onboard On a return flight between Luton and Budapest, sometimes budget airline will ask for £40 EACH WAY for that small 10kg bag, which I find absurd I understand supply demand etc, just noticing that what you get seems to be smaller and smaller each year
- switch007 3y agoI hear you. People are debating checked baggage fees but that's old news. The carry-on fee is the latest outrageous charge. It's a "premium" option now because airlines realised people value that their luggage is less likely to be lost and less time waiting at the airport. I bet in a way they absolutely loved the baggage handler meltdown - it's left a scar in people's minds. Plus a price for checked baggage was set, and luggage is luggage, so the price is now equalised/approaching equalisation Ryanair/Wizzair/Easyjet will charge your for that space for your backpack under your seat soon too, mark my words
- tptacek 3y agoIsn't this a headline that says airlines make literally half their gross revenue from "extra fees"? Total US airline profits are in the low double digit billions, right? That would imply airlines are operating at an enormous operating loss, as, what, a gift to the traveling public?
- therealdrag0 3y agoI think there was a freakanomics saying basically this. The price of air travel has dropped and become way more accessible over the last 50 years. I think travel is so discretionary they have to keep prices as low as possible or people decide not to fly. Low margins and tough competition.
- switch007 3y agoTangential prediction: Ryanair will lead the charge in making you pay for a bag under the seat. There will be no free "personal item" option. Whenever they lower the bar, they look for ways to lower it even further. (The bags-under-seat needs clamping down on. It's gone too far. I've seen people with bags so big they had to rest their feet on top of it. It's an obvious safety issue but obviously for profit reasons the staff are told to turn a blind eye. The cabin crew would have to be literally blind to truthfully claim they didn't notice it)
- Nifty3929 3y agoThis is like saying that McDonald's makes a lot of extra fees on fries and drinks because those aren't (always) included with a hamburger. A more honest take is that now we can pay for what we want, instead of just paying for everything and then only using some of them.
- uptown 3y agoAirlines like shifting the cost to baggage fees because they avoid paying the ticket taxes on that line of revenue: https://www.travelweekly.com/Travel-News/Airline-News/Revenue-from-baggage-fees-not-subject-to-ticket-tax-IRS-says https://www.travelweekly.com/Travel-News/Airline-News/Revenu...
- perfectstorm 3y agoheh I used similar strategy when I sold on eBay years ago. i.e, charge extra in shipping fees and reduce the Buy it now price so I pay less in seller fees.
- philip1209 3y agoIf you didn't have this level of price discrimination, wouldn't general ticket prices be more expensive? Why not a title of "Airline tickets have become cheaper through pricing efficiency." I think the bigger racket is loyalty programs, which are anti-competitive and give people a personal kickback for spending company money. It's not much different than a bribe.
- RadixDLT 3y agoIf airlines are treated like a utility, and re-regulated, wouldn’t the American public get better service, and would airline investors and bond holders get a better (and more risk-aversive) return?
- melenaboija 3y agoAs an anecdote, I just took a flight today with Delta from Paris to Salt Lake City, I paid for a front row seat and they changed it to a middle one. This is not the first or second time this happens to me, either randomly or because of babies (baby basinets have to be hanging on the separators in front of the first row) and it is not worth it to fight as they alway have some excuse. Today I actually asked about it at check in time as I have seen the row on my phone and it did not seem to me that was the first row, the answer they gave: "Oh yeah, this is the first row" To me these fees are kind of... tricky.
- ipqk 3y agoI've had my seat changed after I paid extra for it, and I submitted a refund request and it was honored.
- jesterson 3y agoTypical large company behaviour - give you all sorts of bs to get you off my view. Once you realise you were fed the BS, the employee would be far from your reach. Singapore airlines support operates exactly by this rule, likely other airlines as well.
- nojvek 3y agoWent through Southwest that does the shenanigans of "you don't get a seat", just group number. Everyone ahead of you can choose the seat they like". It wasn't a great experience. They charge arm and a leg to upgrade. My best airlines has been Alaska Airlines. If you have the card, 1st bag free, complimentary drinks, seat selection, reasonable prices.
- dbg31415 3y agoI book flights for my parents, who are both elderly. I set up a flight for my Dad, on American Airlines. And requested the golf cart to get him from gate to gate. Not 30 minutes later, I got a call, "An emergency notice about your flight." They were trying to sell Dad some "life alert" type thing, claiming it was really important to have one while flying. For the low low cost of like $350 and a $20 a month subscription. Worse, once they realized I wasn't an old old man and they kept saying, "Please put your father on the line..." I told them they could call him at (my number) ### ### ####, and they called right away and were like, "You should do this for your son, think about how stressful it would be for him if you had and accident." So freakin' shady. If you have elderly relatives, consider helping them book tickets -- and flying with them. And for giggles, put your own phone number down and see all the spam ads. American Airlines clearly sold my Dad's contact info... along with his "request for a golf cart" to this scammer sales company.
- jononomo 3y agoIt should be required by law to allow a passenger to take one carry on bag when they book a flight. It is ridiculous for an airline to sell a plane ticket and then not allow the passenger to have a bag.
- dakial1 3y agoStill airlines have the worst margin (low one digit) in the whole industry. Where are all the margins going you ask? I don’t know today (I left the industry years ago) but in the recent pst it was mostly in the hands of GDS (Amadeus, Sabre and Friends…). I imagine this shifted to the online aggregators now….