9 ms·
Swedish dockworkers are refusing to unload Teslas at ports in broad boycott move
- 67545434 3y ago[flagged]
- changoplatanero 3y agoWhat's the argument for how unions benefit both parties? What do unions do to benefit the employer?
- danwilkerson 3y agoProvide labor.
- RandomLensman 3y agoWould would they need to benefit the employer? If capital can pool its resources, why not labor?
- gaze 3y agoThe employer benefits the employer. The union benefits the employee, thus providing a balance in the power between employer and employee.
- orangepurple 3y agoThis is the theory. In America, the union benefits the union first, the employee second, and the employer a very distant third if at all.
- JohnFen 3y agoThis isn't true as a blanket statement in the US. There certainly have been, and probably still are, bad union organizations (just like anything else), but that's an indictment if those particular organizations, not unions in general. There are also good ones.
- taylodl 3y agoSorry. That's just anti-union FUD. Unions are quite cognizant that they don't exist without an employer, employees, and providing value to each.
- nirvdrum 3y agoThat’s a pretty broad brush you’re using. My experience is mostly with the IBEW and so won’t be applicable in all cases. But, the employer gets a flexible, locally licensed work force. They can hire as many people as they need off the union book (no need for lengthy recruitment, skill assessment, and compensation negotiation) on demand and they can lay off electricians as a job winds down. Each local contract will be different, but I think it’s common for benefits to be handled by the union as well. Moreover, the union runs its apprenticeship program so they handle a growing and evolving workforce.
- SoftTalker 3y agoIt's my impression that the skilled trades unions (electricians, ironworkers, steamfitters, etc.) are different from e.g. the UAW. UAW is not running an apprenticeship program for autoworkers. UAW members are not employed as needed on demand by the auto manufacturers. Unions like the UAW exist almost completely as a collective bargaining organization for employment contracts with big automakers. Is this incorrect?
- nirvdrum 3y agoUnfortunately, I don’t have any insight into the UAW. I hope they add value in some way. Unions should adapt to the needs of the sector they’re in so I do expect it’s fairly different from the trades. There’s skilled labor still involved at some level. My point was just to highlight that unions can and, in some cases are, beneficial to the employer even in the US. That’s not to say all unions are great. These discussions tend to lack nuance.
- afandian 3y agoHow does the employer avoid having to do skill assessment? Do they trust the union?
- nirvdrum 3y agoThey trust the certification body. Either you demonstrably know the electrical code or you don’t. And the union requires its members to have their licenses (save for apprentices — but they can wash out). Imagine how much time we could all save if an impartial body certified developers can do breadth first search or reverse strings. No need for all of those phone screen and first round interview questions.
- natch 3y agoThey had to sell of Volvo to Ford and then it got resold to China, so maybe there are cracks in the benefits.
- piva00 3y agoWhat does that have to do with unions in Sweden?
- natch 3y agoUnions -> higher costs -> challenging finances for company -> financial trouble -> sale of company.
- piva00 3y agoVolvo Cars was sold to Ford in 1999 when Volvo AB decided to focus on commercial vehicles, there's no financial trouble except the one that Ford went through during the 2008 crisis... > When the global economic crisis of 2008 threatened the US automakers, Swedish authorities became concerned about the fate of Volvo, should Ford file for bankruptcy. These concerns mounted after repeated mass-layoffs at Volvo. In December 2008, Ford announced that it was considering selling Volvo Cars. Initially, a sale price of US$6 billion was reported. Your conjecture has no basis in reality, it was not due to unions creating higher costs, it was the mess the USA created for the world in 2008 that prompted the sale of Volvo from Ford to Geely.
- rightbyte 3y agoThe unions protect the owners from the executives to some degree.
- progbits 3y agoWhy do they have to benefit the employer?
- sroussey 3y agoIf they bankrupt the employer then they would be out of a job. Or the union contract gets renegotiated.
- zazazache 3y agoGenerally there have been quite few major labor conflicts in Sweden because when you have signed a collective bargaining agreement the unions can only strike to enforce it. Also turns out that an organized instead of vulnerable and exploited workforce is quite productive
- freeopinion 3y agoI'm actually curious about how the union would benefit these mechanics. How is their current treatment by Tesla deemed inadequate?
- simlevesque 3y agoThe workers want it. Their laws say they have a right to it. There's no arguing past that. Let me ask you a question: why do you deserve any respect ? I'm just curious. I'm not seriously asking, just showing you how your question is bullshit.
- freeopinion 3y agoI wasn't asking in an anti-union stance. I'm actually curious. Of course I understand the general purpose of a labor union. But I also understand that there are many situations where a union is unnecessary and actually detrimental to the labor force. For example, if I pay all my employees the same wage I make and pay for the same insurance and retirement plan I have, would it be beneficial to my employees to join a union? Sure, this hypothetical is extreme, but it's just to examine the idea. Is a union a good thing if there are no abuses from which labor needs to be protected? So why do these employees want a union? What are the benefits if there are no abuses? If there are abuses, what are they? I'd really like to know the specifics. I'm not arguing that there could be no benefit. I'm asking what the benefits are in this specific case. I expect that there are some but I don't want to assume what they are. I hope that you will understand that my question was not as belligerent as yours seems to me.
- simlevesque 3y ago> For example, if I pay all my employees the same wage I make and pay for the same insurance and retirement plan I have, would it be beneficial to my employees to join a union? Two questions: How would you know that everyone has the same ? Only the boss knows without a union. Also, if everyone has the same retirement and insurance plan but they are not good plans or the pay isn't good, are they not getting ripped off ?
- pphysch 3y agoIn the long term, unions (and pro-society policies in general) benefit the employer by ensuring a cybernetically stable supply of labor. Most employers obviously aren't thinking that far ahead, though. They would rather cut corners (import cheap labor), and then be surprised when there are systemic failures in their labor supply. We're gradually seeing that hit in America as the global USD goes under, the well-endowed Boomers retire, and USA is a less appealing immigration destination.
- dymk 3y agoBefore unions, people would drag a bad enough employer into the street and beat them to death.
- MrBuddyCasino 3y agoSadly, HN isn't a place to ask questions about second-order effects in politics anymore. Unions are basically legal cartels / mafias, and people will honestly think there are no effects on labour markets, prices or employment and everything is pure upside, wealth generated out of thin air.
- bashinator 3y agoI mean, if unions are cartels, then so are corporate boards.
- orangepurple 3y agoUnions span across corporations within business sectors whereas corporate boards do not.
- AlexandrB 3y agoWhat about Blackrock? Their representatives sit on many boards in a single industry. Same with large VCs. It's not as structured as unions, but each board is not a completely independent entity either.
- MrBuddyCasino 3y ago> What about Blackrock? This is actually a good point, and is detrimental for similar reasons: concentration of power, reduction of competition and increased fragility of the whole system ("too big to fail").
- sroussey 3y agoActually, BlackRock is incentivized to have the whole system be healthy.
- aurelwu 3y agoBusiness associations do however.
- tgv 3y agoI think you're referring to a quote from a union leader. The general thought is that a well-paid, satisfied workforce is better for the company. We're not talking maximizing profits/IPO in the short term.
- LTL_FTC 3y agoYou are being downvoted but I see you are merely quoting the article and the individual who stated that Swedish unions benefitted both employees and employers. My guess is those downvoting and commenting did not in fact read that paragraph.
- ben_w 3y agoI've not heard that claim before today (though it is in the article), but I guess one benefit to the company is that the general population can more easily afford the products the company makes.
- simlevesque 3y agoGood for them. I love to see workers uniting. In this increasingly globalized world, each country is still different. You can't expect swedish workers to accept that you treat them like american workers just because your company is big. I really like this part: > Even postal workers will stop delivering mail to Tesla
- bastardoperator 3y agoIt's crazy what average folks can do when they collectively own the means of production.
- Scarblac 3y agoThey don't, of course. But solidarity goes a long way.
- apwell23 3y ago. Edit: deleting my comment. didn't add much value to the conversation.
- arcticbull 3y ago> average folks get fired immediately for not doing their job. A job that they agreed to do. The point of a union is to be able to push back on your employer, so that fighting for better conditions isn't a special privilege.
- ponector 3y agoSpecial kind of privilege to have a union?
- xboxnolifes 3y ago> average folks get fired immediately for not doing their job. A job that they agreed to do. The entire point of a union is that you have enough collective agreement so that the company can't just fire everyone who pushes back. They can fire one person, or even many, but what if half of the workers are pushing back? > also, mail workers don't "own" mail delivery. They may not own it, but they do control it. Good luck getting your mail if every mail worker collectively decided to stop working.
- zoklet-enjoyer 3y agoVery cool seeing what's possible with strong unions.
- natch 3y agoSo fake EV (PHEV) Volvos that send profits to China and gas profits to MBS will keep the upper hand in Sweden perpetuating the climate crisis on-ramp. Very cool /s
- Spivak 3y agoWell then Tesla should treat their workers better so this doesn't happen. So rude of them.
- natch 3y agoLet’s not assume Tesla treats its workers badly though. I’ve talked to Tesla workers and they were very happy. The union is just butthurt that Tesla is not unionized and has happy workers. You’ll find plenty of negative media if you look, but there are reasons those stories get planted and promoted, reasons having little to do with truth.
- FireBeyond 3y ago> The union is just butthurt that Tesla is not unionized and has happy workers. No. The union leadership didn't unilaterally decide to go on strike. Tesla's "happy workers" had to vote on it and decided to. So perhaps they're not as happy as you'd believe.
- bitshiftfaced 3y ago> The union leadership didn't unilaterally decide to go on strike. Tesla's "happy workers" had to vote on it and decided to. I can't find information that confirms this.
- hooverd 3y agoSickos. Too bad sympathy strikes are illegal in the US.
- beached_whale 3y agoIllegal or just fireable? It’s freedom of expression and gather. Also, can’t fire everyone if they all work together. The air traffic controllers where left put to dry by every other union and Regan had the military to fill in.
- djbusby 3y agoSolidarity Action https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solidarity_action https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solidarity_action In Australia, Latvia, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, the United States, and the United Kingdom, solidarity action is theoretically illegal, and strikes can only be against the contractual employer.
- JohnFen 3y agoHow does that even work? I am, and should be, free to not show up to work for any reason I choose. If I'm legally required to work, isn't that forced labor?
- jimnotgym 3y agoYou can choose not to turn up, but in the UK at least, you may not encourage anyone else to do the same.
- JohnFen 3y agoInteresting. That is certainly not true in the US.
- hutzlibu 3y ago"If I'm legally required to work, isn't that forced labor?" Not if you signed a contract declaring that you will show up. So a strike is in one way organised contract breaching - but one that is allowed under certain circumstances under the bigger contract, the state laws (which you accept by being in that state).
- n8cpdx 3y agoGood thing Musk invented TeslaBot. I saw it at a showroom, so I assume it is totally real and totally cool. More seriously, seeing labor in other countries is waking me up to the need for NLRA reform in the US. It was great in 1935, but we can do better.
- NotACop182 3y agoNLRA is neutered there is not much bite behind them. Unions are gaining popularity as things get tough so there is a bright spot.
- zyang 3y agoSweden GDP is roughly equal to Tesla market cap. It's a fair fight.
- fodkodrasz 3y agoThis illustrates how ridiculously overvalued Tesla is.
- rileymat2 3y agoNot really, gdp is a snapshot of current activity, but the market cap is a guess of the amount of money the company will throw off in total, adjusted for time and risk.
- mrtksn 3y agoMarket cap is not that at all, that's why Twitter's market cap was 44B and now undefined because its not on the market. Market cap is the price of the last share trade times total number of shares. Company's current performance and prospects don't really change that much from day to day but you can have large market cap changes because what you are observing is just live betting.
- Jensson 3y ago> what you are observing is just live betting Yes, and those bets are guesses on how much the company will return as the poster you responded to said.
- mrtksn 3y agoNope, each buyer has its own motivations. People usually sell when the price increase to their liking in the casino. Shares are traded all the time, not just on the days of dividend payments day. Tesla so far never paid dividends anyway. Maybe there are people who bought shares and don't trade them and wait for a payout, but if you look at the volumes traded you can easily see that they are a very small minority.
- japanuspus 3y agoImportant context which I could not find mentioned in TFA: A key reason for the sympathy strikes is that Tesla brought in scabs which is a big no-no in Scandinavian labor markets.
- ge96 3y agoWhat is a scab? (not the wound)
- klyrs 3y agoPeople who are hired to replace striking workers.
- fodkodrasz 3y agoI think GP means strike breaker. External contract workers to replace strikers.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- olddustytrail 3y agoA person who fills in for a striking worker.
- jeffrallen 3y agoA person who puts his own needs above those of his neighbors.
- recursive 3y agoSo... everyone? I mean, I put my needs above my neighbors, and yet I've never filled in for a striking worker. This is not a useful description.
- HissingMachine 3y ago
- natch 3y agoI can’t see this having much impact, because Sweden taxes the bejeezus out of Teslas putting them out of reach for most normal people.
- lutorm 3y agoDoes it tax Teslas more than other vehicles? I sure seem to be seeing a lot of Teslas around...
- natch 3y agoI’m told that Sweden charges 25% VAT on not only the total price, but also on the total of freight charges, insurance, handling costs, and the 10% customs duty. That’s bonkers. So maybe not more than other imported cars but still crazy high. And also I could have outdated info but I understand they took away EV tax incentives in 2022. If you’re seeing a lot of them it’s probably people who got a chance to try driving one. And who also realize the TCO over time makes up for the initial price.
- lutorm 3y agoOh yes, having a car in Sweden is very expensive. And yes, the current government did remove the EV incentives. My point is just that that's not a positive or negative against Tesla compared to other brands.
- malermeister 3y agoMeanwhile, statement from the Union: https://www.arbetaren.se/2023/11/13/if-metall-strejkkassan-racker-i-500-ar/ https://www.arbetaren.se/2023/11/13/if-metall-strejkkassan-r... "Our strike fund is enough to keep this up for 500 years."
- whalesalad 3y agoOn one hand, that is epic. On the other hand, it means the union has leached a monumental amount of capital out of the workers and industries they are involved with. A union should not have that much cash in the bank.
- standardUser 3y agoAre we suddenly in the business of deciding who should have how much money? Because if so, we clearly need to deal with the individual billionaires long, long before we work our way down to any unions.
- whalesalad 3y agoUnions are an abstraction, a necessary evil. They are not designed to be profitable in the same way a capitalist is.
- standardUser 3y agoCorporations are an abstraction. Groups of workers however have always existed, have always comprised the vast majority of people in societies and have always had shared interests.
- arcticbull 3y ago> A union should not have that much cash in the bank. Why not? They've clearly been able to leverage it to negotiate better terms for their members. Their members are better off for the union having the warchest.
- 3y ago
- abdullahkhalids 3y agoI don't actually agree with unions, but not for the "usual" reasons. Unions are a scotch-tape fix to a broken economic system, which gives enormous powers to the capitalistic class at the expense of all others. The correct solution is to fix the actual system. All large companies should be by constitutional law (controlling) majority owned 1/n by their workers. All this exploitation will disappear because workers will obviously not exploit themselves, but also will be incentivized to work hard for their own future.
- xen2xen1 3y agoNah, the workers will exploit each other. Win / win!
- bugglebeetle 3y agoFunnily enough, Sweden came close to doing this in the 70s, forcing joint ownership of firms by employees. Unfortunately, it fell apart, and the whole country went down a more neoliberal path after the assassination of Olaf Palme and the collapse of the Soviet Union.
- KerrAvon 3y agoThat solution doesn't work in practice because a nontrivial number of those workers are perfectly willing to exploit others for their own personal gain. Turns out people have flaws. Unions are the best compromise anyone's found between capital and labor.
- abdullahkhalids 3y agoIs there evidence of this happening in existing worker-owned cooperatives?
- ponector 3y agoDuring early 90-s, after USSR collapse, many factories in Russia have been privatized, and shares distributed among workers. Guess who of the workers became rich and who stayed poor?
- sisve 3y agoInteresting. How is this in Norway? I assume tesla fights union's there also. The culture and value system where union employers and the government is working together is standing really strong in Norway. Could this spread to the Norwegian Market? How big is the Norwegian Market for tesla now? Some years ago it was significant, but I assume the rest of the world is catching up and that its not that important anymore?
- orangetuba 3y agoNorway is not nearly as woke as Sweden, so I doubt it.
- 0xDEAFBEAD 3y agoRecent blog post about unions that I found interesting: >Let’s say a nation is concerned about poverty. So it passes a law that says the rich will have some of their money redistributed to the poor. But instead of a progressive income tax used to fund cash payments to the unfortunate, the government decides that wealthy people who happened to be born in the spring will give their money to poor people whose birthdays are in the summer. Moreover, this redistribution won’t go to anyone who is too poor. You have to already have a job to qualify, and a certain kind of job at that. In fact, you are going to make the poorest of the poor worse off through the policy. Finally, instead of cash payments that they can spend on whatever they actually need, the recipients of aid get gift cards to Bed, Bath, and Beyond. >I think, regardless of how they feel about the redistribution of wealth, most people would find this to be a pretty stupid policy for reasons that are self-evident. Yet this is similar to how laws protecting organized labor function, which in effect involve the “right” of workers in an industry to form a cartel that prevents other people from being hired by an employer... https://www.richardhanania.com/p/why-labor-unions-are-evil https://www.richardhanania.com/p/why-labor-unions-are-evil I wonder if the highly unionized Swedish economy is part of why Sweden has trouble assimilating immigrants. Native Swedes enforcing a cartel to prevent new arrivals from competing in low-wage occupations.
- ponector 3y agoYou say that only a cartel of CEO could exist? In a regular employee-employer relations there is a big difference in negotiating power. Unions can mitigate that.
- 0xDEAFBEAD 3y ago>In a regular employee-employer relations there is a big difference in negotiating power. Not necessarily, it depends on the state of the labor market. You remember a few years ago when the Valley was incredibly hot. Workers had a lot of negotiating power despite being non-unionized.
- ponector 3y agoSome workers had. Don't forget there are millions people on visa, in wait-list for green card. They always have been screwed.
- ano-ther 3y agoA time honoured tactic in Scandinavian labor relations https://mattbruenig.com/2021/09/20/when-mcdonalds-came-to-denmark/ https://mattbruenig.com/2021/09/20/when-mcdonalds-came-to-de...
- uzerfcwn 3y ago> One can only imagine what would happen if the Finnish government tried to ban sympathy strikes in the same way the US government has here. Although it's not quite on the level of US bans, the new Finnish government is currently trying to restrict sympathy strikes and political strikes, so we'll see how that goes. Trade unions are already throwing jabs with 1-day strikes and uppercuts are probably coming next year. [0] https://yle.fi/a/74-20051635 https://yle.fi/a/74-20051635
- jopsen 3y agoThis is exactly what the story reminded me of.
- legitster 3y agoAn interesting side-note: this would never happen in the US as the ILWU is actively hostile to other unions, specifically any in the AFL-CIO. So the solidarity between unions in Sweden is on another level.
- orangetuba 3y agoTypical swedes. It is probably the most woke country in the world... but they are paying a price for that now.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoWhat price are they paying?
- rasz 3y agohttps://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-45269764 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-45269764 https://www.arabnews.com/node/2388121/world https://www.arabnews.com/node/2388121/world https://www.politico.eu/article/sweden-gangs-attacks-ulf-kristersson-prime-minister-summons-army-crime-wave/ https://www.politico.eu/article/sweden-gangs-attacks-ulf-kri... https://www.the-sun.com/news/9332486/executions-bombs-child-soldiers-sweden-gangland-hell/ https://www.the-sun.com/news/9332486/executions-bombs-child-...