8 ms·
Melatonin use soars among children, with unknown risks
- dehrmann 3y agoI wonder if there's any correlation with adderall use.
- devmor 3y agoI thought I needed sleep aids for years. Stopped taking my phone into bed with me. Now I sleep like a baby.
- bjornlouser 3y ago"During 2017–18, only about 1.3% of U.S. parents reported that their children used melatonin. To get a sense of the current prevalence of use, Hartstein and colleagues surveyed about 1,000 parents in the first half of 2023. Among children ages 5 to 9, 18.5% had been given melatonin in the previous 30 days. For preteens ages 10 to 13, that number rose to 19.4%. Nearly 6% of preschoolers ages 1 to 4 had used melatonin in the previous month."
- 0xb0565e486 3y agoThat’s some crazy high numbers for something that has yet to be shown/proven to be effective for its most common use case.
- brigandish 3y agoIf you've ever taken it, you know it has an effect.
- hnuser123456 3y agoI've taken it and did not notice any significant effect.
- anderiv 3y agoI've experimented with Melatonin extensively. Different doses, different times, brands, etc. It has never caused an effect that I can notice. So - that's not to say it's not doing something, but to assume it has a noticeable effect on everyone is an incorrect assumption.
- 2devnull 3y agoIt’s like a hormone, so it’s not a question of empirical effects. It just works.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cies 3y ago> I've experimented I dont want to devalue your experience. But this experimentation is usually not "(placebo) controlled" and not "double blind". You could! Take a randomly selected real-or-placebo, that's marked as such but you do not know at the time. See if you can feel the difference, not your experience, repeat. Then look at your results. According to placebo science the results may shock you.
- cies 3y agonot = note
- brigandish 3y agoI guess there's an exception to every rule! Do you ever feel sleepy at all? I would wonder why someone would use melatonin if they didn't want to sleep, which suggests someone who isn't sleeping well, yet it had no effect. Extensive suggests it wasn't just one dodgy batch of melatonin either. I hope you're sleeping well now regardless. Lack of good sleep is like slow torture.
- echelon 3y agoWhen they make melatonin chewables with cartoons on them and sell them at Target, it's bound to have some level of popularity. Especially when they're placed near the front, on prime shelf space.
- leptons 3y agoIf you've ever had problems falling asleep and taken melatonin to fall asleep, you would have proven it works to yourself. I took melatonin for a couple of years, and without fail, it made me sleepy where normally I would be awake until all hours of the night. Sure, this is comment is anecdotal, but so many people wouldn't be spending money on it if it didn't do what it is known to do, which is making sleep come easier.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Kye 3y ago>> "Sure, this is comment is anecdotal, but so many people wouldn't be spending money on it if it didn't do what it is known to do, which is making sleep come easier." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evidence_and_efficacy_of_homeopathy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evidence_and_efficacy_of_homeo... "The proposed mechanisms for homeopathy are precluded from having any effect by the laws of physics and physical chemistry.[18] The extreme dilutions used in homeopathic preparations usually leave not one molecule of the original substance in the final product." It remains a multi-billion dollar industry. Whether melatonin is closer to medicine or nonsense can't be solved with anecdotes.
- leptons 3y ago>Whether melatonin is closer to medicine or nonsense can't be solved with anecdotes. I admitted my comment is an anecdote, but that doesn't cancel out the voluminous research and study done on melatonin. We know that melatonin is a hormone that is involved with regulating sleep cycles. I'm not sure what evidence you're looking for but internet trolls love to move goalposts anywhere they want to. Yes, millions of people use melatonin effectively every single night. You can call that an anecdote, but you've provided no evidence that melatonin does not do what it's being used for. All evidence and study points to one thing: melatonin helps people sleep. Just go google it yourself, don't have a pointless conversation about anecdotes.
- Kye 3y ago
- fnordpiglet 3y agoThat’s sort of a shocking statement. The primary use case is to feel drowsy and fall asleep. It’s the hormone that induces drowsiness that is readily absorbed by the gut unchanged and impacts systemic levels of said hormone. We not only know it’s effective by like billions of humans trying it trillions of times, we know it’s effective by like nearly every vertebrate animal in biochemical processes we kinda understand sleeping every single day for all of lifes history. What evidence is lacking exactly?
- glitchc 3y agoWe used to think cocaine was an excellent cure for depression and not addictive at all. It's naturally occurring, millions of people took it. https://www.narconon.org/drug-information/cocaine-circa-1860-1900.html https://www.narconon.org/drug-information/cocaine-circa-1860... Anecdotal evidence is not a substitute for pharmacology research, controlled medical trials.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoCocaine isn’t naturally occurring in every vertebrate animal as the hormone responsible for not making you depressed. Plutonium is naturally occurring as well, but it’s not a part of the fundamental biology of all animals. Melatonin is as naturally occurring in animals as blood and its purpose we use it for as a supplement is precisely what it does in the body. It’s nudging the natural levels slightly higher to induce exactly what it does and we desire from it. There’s literally no debate anywhere in any context as to whether it does what it says on the tin, because it literally is the thing that does the thing on the tin. But, you know, sure. Why not. Of course people did these studies because with positive results you’ll get published and it’s a bit of a softball, since it’s like, exactly what must be the result given the situation: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33417003/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33417003/ Results: Of 2642 papers, 23 RCTs met inclusion criteria. Our results indicated that melatonin had significant effect on sleep quality as assessed by the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI) (WMD: - 1.24; 95% CI - 1.77, - 0.71, p = 0.000). Conclusion: We found that the treatment with exogenous melatonin has positive effects on sleep quality as assessed by the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI) in adult. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31982807/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31982807/ Conclusions: Melatonin was an effective and tolerable drug in the short-term treatment of sleep onset insomnia in children and adolescents. Etc There’s no controversy whether it works or not. The only controversy is on chronic supplementation, which is entirely fair.
- avbanks 3y agoIt's a hormone produced by the body for sleep, it definitely works in inducing drowsiness. Now should you take it regularly is a different question.
- cies 3y agoExactly. Unknown risks. Unknown benefits. But let's medicate the kids. I think we should do little placebo trials at home. Not double blind, obviously. But still the risks are known (none, except character damage maybe).
- superchroma 3y agoThose are massive numbers, wow
- rob74 3y agoBetter living through chemistry! Forget bedtime stories - melatonin is much more reliable!
- 303uru 3y agoSleep hygiene is absolute shit. Acquaintances think we're weird for not having a TV in the bedroom. My kids friends have TV, game systems, computers, phones, etc... all in the bedroom and they're in elementary school. No wonder they need drugs to fall asleed. Parents are slamming Xanax and Ambien kids are chewing melatonin gummies.
- avbanks 3y agoI completely agree, I think sleep hygiene gets overlooked but that could be main culprit. Andrew Hubermin talks about this on his podcast but basically the blue light/high intensity light from phones, computers, and tv's blocks melatonin. The quality of my sleep is much higher when I don't look at any screens 2-3 hours before bed. https://youtu.be/h2aWYjSA1Jc?si=w6_YgZKQq65YyatP https://youtu.be/h2aWYjSA1Jc?si=w6_YgZKQq65YyatP https://www.sleepfoundation.org/bedroom-environment/blue-light https://www.sleepfoundation.org/bedroom-environment/blue-lig...
- dvdkon 3y agoIt's not just screens, common lights produce too much melanopic light for evening use. It's definitely not trivial to pick light sources that are safe to use in the evening without interfering with our circadian rhythm, but it's possible. And the same, in reverse, applies to workspaces/schools with not enough natural light (or a good simulation thereof).
- hammock 3y ago> It's definitely not trivial to pick light sources that are safe to use in the evening without interfering with our circadian rhythm, but it's possible. Can you give some suggestions?
- dvdkon 3y agoI won't suggest specific products (local availability is patchy), so I'm going to be more generic: The main thing is that there are non-visual receptors in our eyes that are used for determining the level of "daylight", and they are most sensitive to light around 480nm [1]. To give the right signals, you want to match daylight's intensity in this part of the spectrum at day, but gradually decrease it to zero in the late evening. You can look for lightbulbs or LED strips that come with a quantified measure of melanopic vs standard lux (it's sadly not common), or you can look for light sources that come with a graph of the emitted spectrum (a requirement for the new EU energy efficiency label!) and make an educated guess. Generally, 1800 K or colder(/"warmer") LEDs will have little of the melanopic component, using "monochromatic" orange LEDs is also an option (both dimmed appropriately). [1] See graph here: https://www.thelightreviewonline.com/explainer-melanopic-lux/ https://www.thelightreviewonline.com/explainer-melanopic-lux...
- stinos 3y agoReading things like this to me has the same effect as reading that 1/5 (or whetever the current rate is) of people is now obese. But the article doesn't even stop there, the next paragraph: > researchers analyzed 25 melatonin gummy products and found that 22 contained different amounts of melatonin than the label indicated. One had more than three times the amount on the label. One had none at all. In addition, some melatonin supplements have been found to contain other concerning substances, such as serotonin It's almost as if humanity, with US often leading the way, wants to destroy itself. Well, or maybe somewhat more precise: one part of humanity is super selfish and only cares about power/money, and drags a large part of the rest with them.
- hammock 3y agoLots of things have unknown risks, like over the counter supplements, vaccines still in testing, mobile phones, social media, etc. At what point is the precautionary principle applied, and at what point do we say the potential benefits outweigh the unknown risks?
- anonymouskimmer 3y ago> At what point is the precautionary principle applied When there are relatively simple sociological fixes to these new problems.
- BurningFrog 3y agoThe precautionary principle, strictly applied, always says you shouldn't do it. It is therefore only applied to things you don't want to do.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoMy god. Just feed them and get them to bed at a proper hour, and turn off the blue lights. And while you're at it, maybe lobby your local school for a naptime if they don't already have one (I know it's problematic to change the school hours because of parent's work schedules). > The older the child, the greater the dosage, with preschoolers taking anywhere from 0.25 to 2 mg and preteens taking up to 10 mg. Those are extraordinarily high doses. I tried it for sleep in my 20s and 2 mg knocked me out and left me feeling groggy when I woke up. I can't even imagine how much habituation a child needs in order for a 10 mg dose to be necessary.
- dvdkon 3y agoWhy naptime at school? If parents are having trouble with their kids not falling asleep in the evening, wouldn't that either hurt (less tired kids) or be ineffective (kids can't fall asleep at school either)?
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoI guess first we have to figure out exactly why parents are giving their children melatonin. If it's for not falling asleep at a particular time, then a nap time may not help. If it's because the children appear to be tired in the morning, then a nap time might help. Children in general are growing, and need more sleep than adults. I don't know that it particularly matters how this sleep is distributed. I do know that my preschool had a naptime, and that I occasionally nodded off as an older kid on the school bus. I think extending naptimes from pre-school into later school years is an idea worth investigating.
- BurningFrog 3y agoOnce you realize school is primarily babysitting, with education as a side activity, many things are easier to understand.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoYeah, that's why I'm saying include a nap time.
- Giorgi 3y agoSo, parents using it to make their children sleep.
- tyingq 3y agoPart of the potential danger is lousy control over the actual amount in the dose. "Results show that melatonin content...with the actual content ranging from 83 percent less to 478 percent more than the concentration declared on the label." https://aasm.org/study-finds-that-melatonin-content-of-supplements-varies-widely/ https://aasm.org/study-finds-that-melatonin-content-of-suppl...
- acomar 3y ago> Further analysis with mass spectrometry also found serotonin, a much more strictly controlled substance, in 26 percent of the tested supplements. According to the authors, the presence of unlabeled but significant quantities of serotonin could lead to serious side effects. wait, you can buy OTC seratonin? that seems wild given the seratonin syndrome risks. edit: it looks like it's indirectly via 5-HTP [1]. [1]: https://www.webmd.com/vitamins/ai/ingredientmono-794/5-htp https://www.webmd.com/vitamins/ai/ingredientmono-794/5-htp
- darkclouds 3y ago[dead]
- thiago_fm 3y agoPeople have kids because their friends did, to post them on Instagram or give their lives a "meaning"... ... and don't want to deal with parenting, so they shove whatever drug to change their natural behavior, despite not knowing the consequences. This is why all sleeping pills should be controlled drugs. If kids can't drink alcohol, why can they take those drugs if its the best interest of their parents?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- spicyusername 3y agoPeople are struggling to get by. Overworked, underpaid, lonely. Parenting is an extremely draining and time-consuming job. Many households can not afford to have a parent stay home to do the full-time job of running the house and overseeing that the children's needs are fulfilled. I'm not surprised to see shortcuts like this rise in popularity, however reprehensible. If we want to turn these kinds of trends around in the Western world, we need to start by focusing on fixing our broken culture, and allowing the average parent the time, financial security, and social connections to cultivate a meaningful, fulfilling life. You'll get an increase in children's well-being as a downstream effect for free. Less focus on work, less financial distress, more social services, more volunteering, more community building, etc.
- ITB 3y agoThis is a very generalized statement. I think you’re feeling down and projecting those feelings into all of society.
- jakeinspace 3y agoProjecting the feeling of not having enough money or social safety net? That’s got to describe the vast majority of parents.
- scott_siskind 3y ago> fixing our broken culture and allowing the average parent the time, financial security, and social connections to cultivate a meaningful, fulfilling life why focus on parents? People who became parents have supposedly already reached a baseline of stability and security (otherwise they wouldn't have the resources to have children). There are plenty others who are struggling without a partner (or children).
- krger 3y ago>People who became parents have supposedly already reached a baseline of stability and security (otherwise they wouldn't have the resources to have children). "Supposedly" is doing an awful lot of heavy lifting in that sentence, as is your parenthetical note. And we're focusing on parents because this article is about melatonin use in children.
- Lord-Jobo 3y agoThis is a failure of governmental regulation agencies. Melatonin is a fucking hormone, and it has basically zero regulation. meanwhile they put allergy nasal sprays behind the counter
- flashback2199 3y agoFluticasone has been OTC a while now, used to be behind counter but not any more
- glitchc 3y agoFluticasone may be, but Salbutamol/Albuterol is still controlled (prescription only).
- flashback2199 3y agoFluticasone is fantastic btw
- glitchc 3y agoCertainly, but it is slow-acting, whereas Salbutamol is fast-acting. As such, Fluticasone is not useful during an acute asthma attack, whereas Salbutamol is.
- flashback2199 3y agoBud this thread is about "allergy nasal spray" not asthma..
- glitchc 3y agoBoth can be used to treat asthma. Actually, I was mistaken. I thought they were both steroids but salbutamol is not, so my point is moot.
- draw_down 3y agoIt sure does seem risky to give children something for which the long-term risks are unknown. I’d hate to think people have been doing that in recent years.
- jessepasley 3y agoMelatonin comes in cute little gummies. Why would something so cute and candy-like carry any risk?
- sensanaty 3y agoI've suffered from insomnia for a long while now, and I despise taking Melatonin (300ug for the people asking, at least according to the label on it). It gives me unnerving dreams - not quite nightmares, but in some ways more anxiety inducing than a typical nightmare - and a lot of people report similar things. Without it I still have vivid, intense dreams but they're usually just very fun and nonsensical, a night on Melatonin makes them really terrible though. It does help with actually physically getting me to sleep, but to be honest I can't really say it's good quality sleep. The feeling is almost 1:1 comparable to my usual bad days where I don't fall asleep until 6/7 and wake up 2 hours later, just extremely groggy and with a lot of mental fog, so I've stopped taking it altogether. This article is kinda worrying to me, can't even imagine what kinda weirdness external melatonin could be doing to a young mind if even tiny doses has such a strong effect on me, and I was a psychonaut in my younger party days.
- etrautmann 3y agowhat kind of dose were you taking? Pills range from < 1mg to over 10, and I would guess there might be very dose dependent response.
- sensanaty 3y agoAccording to the label, 300ug, even those are pretty strong for me. Never tried higher, since it's always been a strong reaction
- jerf 3y agoHow big is your dose? There's a reasonable degree of evidence that all the commercially-available doses are too high, even 1mg. Cutting it way, way down may give the benefits without so many negatives.
- unsupp0rted 3y agoSeconded. If you're gonna keep taking it, then experiment with smaller doses.
- drcongo 3y ago
- Eumenes 3y agoLet the kids run around outside for 3 hours. Problem solved.
- hn8305823 3y agoBack in the 1980's this was the standard. Don't come back until dark. Try that today and you'll end up in jail with your kids in a foster home.
- bradleybuda 3y agoAnother way to write this headline would be "no known risks", since the article does not supply a single shred of evidence that actual harm is being caused.
- ForkMeOnTinder 3y ago> preteens taking up to 10 mg The doses you can buy in the drugstore are wild. I'm an adult and I take 0.5mg and it works great. You can't even buy 0.5mg where I live, so I buy the 1mg tablets and break them in half. Also, no HN thread about melatonin would be complete without a link to gwern's writeup, so here it is https://gwern.net/melatonin https://gwern.net/melatonin
- willmeyers 3y agoPart of me wonders if it's the lack of physical activity and exercise among people that's causing us to feel restless before bed. Of course I'm not saying that a lack of exercise is the root cause of everyone's aliments, but worth consideration.
- api 3y ago"Unknown" risks. So adults have been slamming melatonin like crazy for decades. Now kids are taking tons of it. Seems like we really should be trying to figure out if this is harmful or not. Seems kind of important. I use it myself and have looked many times for solid research showing harm (or lack thereof) and see very little, which is kind of surprising to me. I use it to treat insomnia which is otherwise kind of stubborn. Yes I've tried no blue light, earplugs, turning off lights in the home, exercise... Edit: this is one of the only articles I could find. Very basic stuff. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26692007/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26692007/ This just shows that there's nothing obviously alarming. The effect of long term use especially on younger developing brains is what needs to be studied.
- 28304283409234 3y agoI remember when the kids couldn't sleep, the problem was as often me being stressed and the kids picking up on that. If I was not relaxed, the kids could not relax.
- mikrl 3y agoI’ve had insomnia for about 3 weeks and I bought some this week to try and break through. I had a couple restful nights and a couple nights where my wakefulness window was pushed back by 4h (instead of 11-3, 3:30-alarm) From what I understand you should not use it for longer than 1-4 weeks presumably because you will screw up your body’s melatonin cycle even more than the insomnia has already. Any chemical in the body that ends with -onin, in my experience, tends to be extremely pervasive with a complicated series of effects and should probably not be trifled with.
- BubbleRings 3y agoYeesh. What a horror. 1. Stop allowing your child to have _any_ form of caffeine. No Coke, no chocolate, not even decaf tea. 2. Make sure they get at least moderate exercise, every day. 3. Take away the screens at least an hour before their bedtime, and stick with the same bedtime every day. If you haven't done the above steps, and you have instead let the drug pushers that design the checkout lines at Target convince you to keep giving your child this stuff, you are an unfit and harmful parent.
- dumbfounder 3y ago[flagged]
- lacoolj 3y agoGiving this to children is kinda scary. This is something your body produces already, and by supplementing might result in a dependency (body stops producing because it is already present). I will be very curious how these studies pan out. Hopefully I'm just flat out wrong.
- secstate 3y agoJust tossing ideas out, but is it possible that structured mornings as a result of modern education might be part of why melatonin is used so often? Being generally a night owl, I slept like shit all through high school and parts of college. I'm just a sample size of one, but if instead of just "dealing" with it, I had looked for a solution to help me get to sleep faster, maybe I (or my parents) would have leaned on melatonin? I certainly had friends that couldn't sleep without nyquil in high school, too. EDIT: To add another thought, I also had the blessing/good luck of a father who, noticing my difficulties getting to sleep gave me the sage advice of "don't worry about it. Grab a book, do some drawing, worst case scenario, you don't get up for school tomorrow. The world is not ending." How much stress to do we put on ourselves by our expectation of sleep and the perceived consequences of having a bad day the next day. Our life does not operate via step functions. It is continuous, and no one bad day can ruin the next unless you let it.