5 ms·
>They describe themselves as "overemployed" — and remarkably, they seem to be getting away with it. As long as they perform the tasks of their jobs, why should
by coldtea 3y ago
>They describe themselves as "overemployed" — and remarkably, they seem to be getting away with it.
As long as they perform the tasks of their jobs, why shouldn't they be "getting away with it"?
It's seems as if the "free market" exists only for the companies and bosses.
- bratao 3y agoFor software development, quantifying output or defining a finite set of tasks is almost impossible. Unlike traditional industries where tasks can be standardized and expected output can be clearly defined, software development is a different beast altogether. Speaking from personal experience, my task list is filled with an infinite number of features to implement and bugs to fix. It's a dynamic landscape that changes with every new technology, user feedback, or market demand. It's not something that can be completed within a set timeframe, rather it's a continuous process of improvement and adaptation.
- coldtea 3y ago>For software development, quantifying output or defining a finite set of tasks is almost impossible For paid work, it's mandatory. Companies do planning, sprints, tasks, prioritization and so on. Else it's not software development, is an infinite pile of random tasks.
- bratao 3y agoI'm curious as to how this would work in practice. For instance, if an individual is able to complete their sprint while juggling two other full-time jobs, does this imply they should have taken on more tasks? This approach seems to only be effective if one team member significantly outperforms the rest. If a company's sprint is easily manageable, does this suggest that the team size should be reduced, potentially leading to layoffs?
- coldtea 3y ago>This approach seems to only be effective if one team member significantly outperforms the rest. If a company's sprint is easily manageable, does this suggest that the team size should be reduced, potentially leading to layoffs? Or, god forbid, that it reached an optimal work/life balance for team members, while still hitting specific company targets, and should be left as is.
- bratao 3y agoI fully agree that the work load should reach an optimal work/life balance. But how this is possible if someone is taking two extra full time jobs on top of it?
- coldtea 3y agoThat's their decision - to sacrifice their work/life balance to do another job, as opposed to it being a single company's/manager's decision.
- cxr 3y ago> if an individual is able to complete their sprint while juggling two other full-time jobs, does this imply they should have taken on more tasks? To answer your question: no, it doesn't imply[1] that. Your comments suggest you have a mental model of markets where workers should be rewarded (compensated) by the employer for their toil instead of producing value. That's bad business. It's especially bad business when the reaction is a campaign to realign the organization with an a priori interest in making sure it employs only toilers. > If a company's sprint is easily manageable, does this suggest that the team size should be reduced, potentially leading to layoffs? "Should" from the perspective of whom? You're running on a platform of wealth concentration for business owners. Predatory value extraction. Parasitism instead of symbiosis. <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37472726 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37472726> Ignoring that, if management has so little idea what workers' output should look like that they resort to basing their assessments on how much it seems to hurt to the worker, then the business should consider focusing on management when deciding who to let go. 1. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entailment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entailment>
- dgrin91 3y agoNDAs/ data protection for one. I'm not against people having multiple jobs, but some jobs have access to confidential/proprietary data that employers have a legitimate interest in protecting.
- worksonmine 3y agoWorking 2 jobs ≠ leaking confidential data between them.
- 535188B17C93743 3y agoAs long as there's no conflict of interest between the companies, what's the issue? How is this any different from someone taking a job at all of those companies sequentially?
- ghaff 3y agoUnless it's expressly forbidden by a contract, I don't think most people have any issue with minor clear non-conflict-of-interest consulting/freelance work. It's really hard to see how that works with full-time jobs at competing companies.
- api 3y agoUse a different laptop for each job? Seriously though... this is ridiculous but it's 100% the fault of the employer for over-hiring and bad management.
- erhserhdfd 3y ago> As long as they perform the tasks of their jobs, why shouldn't they be "getting away with it"? Curious how you would measure whether they are "performing the tasks for their jobs". I think most folks would say that measuring SE output is very difficult to do and as such, most managers give their team the benefit of the doubt that they are working at a reasonable but sustainable pace. I am not sure that I personally would want to work at a place that places huge emphasis on measuring my output, even if that would free me up for potential OE. It seems like this thinking leads to a commoditization of software engineering work and promotes a very transactional relationship with an employer.
- pydry 3y agoI think the causality is probably reversed. Commoditization and development of a transactional relationship with the employee leads to overemployment. Ive noticed that the places where people do tend to be the ones where 5x productivity is rewarded with 1x the pay and a pat on the back, which is more common than the more rational 5x pay for 5x productivity. If that is the case then the rational economic agent (a developer) operating in a free market will find an outlet for that productivity that produces material gains in line with their increased productivity.
- reactordev 3y agoNot the author but I suspect something like this: Assign engineer 4 stories due this sprint. After a few days, 1 story is done. After a few more 2 more are done. Before the end of the sprint, the last story is done. All 4 stories are demonstrable. All 4 stories pass peer review. Engineer is even around for brainstorm sessions and ceremonies. Some places go a lot further than this but this is my personal bar as a manager. That you're in standup, that you're doing the work, and that the work doesn't require rework and is accepted by the team.
- erhserhdfd 3y agoYeah I see your point. A few thoughts: 1. This assumes that that a someone can/will usually accurately scope 4 stories, with proper requirements, and clear peer review standards. In practice, this can be hard to do and inconsistent. 2. If someone falls behind on their assigned story quota, how would a manager know whether that is because the story didn't meet the criteria in item 1, or because the person isn't putting in sufficient effort because of OE or other commitments? How I typically see this play out is most people assume that its not related to effort and try to work with the employee to push back deadlines and better refine the story.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoIf it were that simple, I don't think people would have a problem. Pulling this stuff off usually requires a tremendous amount of lying and deceit.
- schmookeeg 3y agoOther than "lying by omission", which depends on how you define your disclosure obligations to a client or employer -- this has not been my experience at all.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoMy experience is the opposite. It involves telling your peers and managers that tasks take far longer than they do, that you have no bandwidth to spare for more work, and pushing tasks on sympathetic peers while claiming to be overworked. I'm sure people exist with that don't ask don't tell situation, but I don't think it's the norm
- ghaff 3y agoMaybe there are circumstances where someone really doesn't have much work, doesn't have many meetings, doesn't have any real professional visibility outside the company etc., but it's really hard for me to imagine that being either sustainable or not caught out sooner rather than later.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jghn 3y agoI would agree as long as it doesn't violate anything they signed with the employers. Most companies I've worked for had me sign things that would prevent me from working on the side.
- lytefm 3y ago> As long as they perform the tasks of their jobs, why shouldn't they be "getting away with it"? I'd say it depends a lot on the legal framework of employment contracts. I don't know how it is in the US, but in Germany you sign a contract with your employer stating „I will work X hours a week for you“. It's not about the output. If you work less than X hours, you commit fraud and breach the contract. Your employer can then fire you for an „important cause” and typical legal protections don't apply. If your employer forces you to work more than X hours without compensating you appropriately, he breaches the contract and you can sue him for that. So obviously, there have been a lot of legal cases like „Does changing your clothes count as working hours“, „Does driving to a client count as working hours“, „How do working hours need to be tracked“,...
- uturingmachine 3y agoIn the US there are few scenarios where there is an employment contract. The vast majority of employment is "at will"; an employee can quit (or be terminated) at any time for any reason, so long as it is not expressly forbidden by law (e.g. firing someone for race, sexual orientation, age, etc). In particular, at-will employees are not guilty of breach of contract for working multiple jobs - there is no contract
- ghaff 3y agoHowever, there is typically a code of business conduct and other things along that line that an employee agrees to even if there isn't an explicit "contract" as there often is in Europe for example.
- lytefm 3y agoYeah if it's more like "you work for me; I pay you as long as the results are good but will fire you at will" it's much easier to pull this off while maintaining a clear conscience.
- otteromkram 3y agoThis sounds horrible. I'd rather sign up for a salary and time blocks during the day to be available for meetings, but my contribution is measured in output, not hours I logged. If I take 40+ hours to do my work, that's on me.
- buu700 3y agoBy the same logic, why shouldn't lawyers and other high-skill hourly workers add a 3x multiplier to their reported hours? After all, as long as they do the work, their clients won't know the difference. Unless you're actively informing your employer that you're blocked or not being assigned enough work, there's an implication that your output is the product of full-time hours. You could probably get away with it for a time, since it's hard to validate that and there's a default expectation of good faith. Either way, it's essentially (if not actually) fraud. You can't negotiate a certain price for a certain expected value based on your resume and interview performance, and then intentionally deliver a fraction of that value. If you think an employer would be happy with that, then why not try and negotiate the same compensation for a part-time role? Or work as a contractor with a fixed price for each task, and then beat every time estimate to earn a higher effective hourly rate? Or simply provide notice partway into the engagement that you feel you've been delivering more value than your current level of compensation would justify, and therefore will be reducing your time commitment? You're free to sell your services in whatever way you'd like on the free market. The problem is when you enter into an agreement to sell them in a particular way, and then fail to deliver on that while deceiving the other party into believing otherwise.
- cxr 3y ago> why shouldn't lawyers and other high-skill hourly workers add a 3x multiplier to their reported hours Uh, they can. You're talking about price-setting; if you bill by the hour and charge X USD, then feel free to set your price at 3X USD instead. That's how agreements work. Unless by 3x multiplier you mean, "tell them I charge X USD per hour and then when the time comes even though I only worked 13 hours in a given week I'll claim to have worked 39", in which case that's, you know, fraud. > You can't negotiate a certain price for a certain expected value based on your resume and interview performance, and then intentionally deliver a fraction of that value. Non-sequitur. Either that, or you're not really talking about value, but you're still using that word anyway.
- buu700 3y agoUnless by 3x multiplier you mean, "tell them I charge X USD per hour and then when the time comes even though I only worked 13 hours in a given week I'll claim to have worked 39", in which case that's, you know, fraud. Yes, that's literally what I said. If you think you're entitled to a higher rate, charge a higher rate. Don't lie about the amount of work you did.