5 ms·
20% of Millennials and 68% of Gen Z-ers still live with other family members
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- verandaguy 3y agoGen Z is usually considered to have been born between 1996 and 2012 -- so yeah, it's not shocking that a generation whose youngest are middle schoolers still mostly lives at home.
- betaby 3y agoArticle says 'adult'.
- verandaguy 3y agoYeah, and a good proportion of those adults are just starting university. In this rental economy, and with the personal finance wisdom being broadly shared in the last few years, it's still absolutely not shocking that zoomers are staying home while they can (and in particular, longer than millennials).
- riku_iki 3y agoits actually another hit on them: they have to chose college nearby so they can live with parents, and not necessary good one which accepted them because of rise in education costs.
- LastTrain 3y agoDefine “right now”
- jackcosgrove 3y agoOn the flip side the youngest millennials are 28 years old by that standard. It's significant that 20% of that group haven't been able to move away from family.
- verandaguy 3y agoNo argument from me -- I agree with you, it's a reflection of the state of the economy right now. My other comment was mostly a reaction to the stigma that often surrounds living at home past university (or even sometimes high school) graduation, and how it seems like an increasingly unreasonable standard to hold people to.
- jackcosgrove 3y agoI see. I used to look askance at stories of living with parents from a place like Italy back in the early 2000s, but in retrospect they were the canary in the coal mine. This is becoming a global phenomenon. It's hiding standards of living that are falling fast for younger generations. It's easier to keep people off the poverty rolls when they can move back in with parents and forgo starting families of their own.
- api 3y agoIt’s not the state of the entire economy. It’s one thing: housing prices. Most other economic stats are fine or even good. Tuition and health care are also problems, but housing cost disease is the one that is most pervasive and affects the most people. The root cause is mostly a supply problem due to bad zoning, bad regulations, and NIMBYs. This is exacerbated by prolonged extremely low interest rates flooding a constrained market with cash.
- bronsonkhmai 3y agoThe economy is a bogus argument because you can always blame the economy for not moving out. If the economy is bad then you can't move out. If the economy is good well then it is just about to get bad so you can't move out either. There was never a time in the past that renting didn't eat up most of your money. I didn't know anyone who moved out when I moved out that wasn't also dead broke. This was in the mid 90s though and it was the most magical time to be on your own and young. I don't think I would bother moving out now though if I was young because why pay so much more money just to fuck off on your phone in your own apartment instead of your parent's basement? The economics are pretty much the same. The culture though is night and day different.
- demarq 3y agoJust to note here in some cultures multi general homes are the norm. IMHO these families seem to do better overall financially and socially. For example, There's some one to take care of the elder members, and someone to take care of the kids.
- decafninja 3y agoYou're being downvoted, but this is true. The American Way of moving out from your parents' home ASAP to be so-called "independent" at any and all costs is not the only (or even best) way.
- koito17 3y agoYup, I've always found it strange that American parents immediately kick out their children at the age of 18. The United States in general seems to practice an unhealthy amount of individualism.
- PretzelPirate 3y agoSince sex is villanized in the US, parents have to kick their children out so they can have sex again.
- drowsspa 3y agoSounds like you just need thicker walls
- doubled112 3y agoA lot of the homes, town homes and apartments absolutely DO need thicker walls. I know my neighbours have sex and I'm OK with this, but that doesn't mean I want to lay in bed and listen to them have it.
- seanmcdirmid 3y ago
- hotnfresh 3y ago> Overall, Millennials are slower when it comes to leaving the nest compared to previous generations: 18% of Baby Boomers and 17% of Gen X were living with their parents at the same age as today's average Millennials. Likewise, Zoomers also struggle: By 22 years old, 66% of Millennials, 65% of Gen X and 61% of Baby Boomers were still at home, which was surpassed by a 68% share of Gen Z. There, the part of this that makes the bare stats mean anything whatsoever.
- SamoyedFurFluff 3y agoI mean, isn’t it obvious why? There was just an article posted to HN a few days ago that says the required income to buy a house effectively increased 50% since 2019. Wages for millennial age experience definitely haven’t increased the same amount.
- latency-guy2 3y agoSo trending up, but not significantly, fully agreed this is hardly worth a thing. Labor participation rate is another thing to track, more of GenZ is attending college rather than embracing independence and going to work than all other cohorts so its not surprising.
- QuarterReptile 3y agoIf you factor in the growing portion of people going to undergrad, those stats may correspond to downward movement in the proportion of young adults living with parents for significant periods after completing education.
- supertofu 3y agoMy sister is a young millennial in her late 20s and lives at home with our mom. They live in Los Angeles. My sister will likely NEVER be able to afford to buy a house in Los Angeles, and there is no sense in paying rent when our mom is happy for the company. My mom is an immigrant, and she has always welcomed her adult children to live with her (even to the point of insistence). I fully expect to go live with her when she reaches her elderly years. I'm even kind of looking forward to it. I live across the country from my whole family and this has been a very isolating experience, even if it was my choice to do so. I don't think it is weird for adults to live with their family. I actually think it's weirder and more unnatural NOT to live near or close to your family.
- riku_iki 3y agoso, does your sister have plans to have husband and kids?
- supertofu 3y agoYep. My mom would be happy for her and any future husband to raise their kids in her house if my sister chose not to move out.
- jnkl 3y agoWould it still be "her house" or more of a grandma-lives-with-us-situation? My sister lived with her kids and husband under the same roof with my mother and the situation was extremely complicated because my sister always were to be a guest in a way.
- supertofu 3y agoYou know, with my mom being a single mom, I think there is something of an interdependency between her and her youngest child (my sister). Possibly even a codependency. That is to say: there is no real power struggle between them. They accept their roles as mother and daughter pretty well. They share their space effectively because they both accept their roles. If my sister were to exert more of a commanding influence on the household, there could be conflict, but so far this has not been the case.
- syntaxing 3y agoMillennial here. If I didn’t hit the tech job lotto I would still be living with my parents with my wife and kids. It’s a shitty cycle. You have kids, and it’s either my wife stays home or she works and gives all her wage to daycare. The only way to stay positive financially is to get “free” help which is to have your parents take care of their grandkids. I know the alternative is to just not have kids, but it absolutely sucks how it feels financially impossible it is to have kids.
- QuarterReptile 3y agoDo your parents nor desperately desire to spend time with their grandkids? Mine (and my wife's) make drop-of-the-hat multi-day visits across state lines, often precipitated by nothing more than us sending a cute picture of the baby. My wife's mom is just waiting for us to send an adequate signal that she should quit working to spend more time with our kids.
- syntaxing 3y agoI think there’s a difference between need and want though. My parents would drive 8hr+ to see their grandkids for 2-3 days but my comment was more about how grandparent child care is needed in our generation.
- QuarterReptile 3y agoYou're saying that you wish there were some way that neither grandparent nor parent had to stay home with the children, other than spending a full salary on childcare, right? I guess my instinct is that all worthwhile pursuits require sacrifice and childrearing, being the most worthwhile pursuit, should reasonably take the most sacrifice. And I revel in the fact that, through decades of schooling and job experience and saving, I can keep my wife home with the kids and live in reasonable material comfort, just a little below the median income for equivalently sized households in my state.
- justinator 3y agoMillennial checking in. My parents told me in no uncertain terms that I was on my own after high school. There was never any safety net. I found out much later in life how poor we were. It's very hard to escape both poverty and growing up with neglect, abuse and a lot of dysfunction. I'm actually amazed I'm not on drugs, in jail (or both), or just: dead.
- jacquesm 3y agoWow, that sounds sad. And in a way they probably did you a favor because that kind of influence doesn't help. In contrast: as long as I breathe my children will have a home to return to should they need it.
- justinator 3y agoI don't know what you mean by favor, but I'll take your comment with grace. I would suggest to anyone that growing up in an alcoholic family doesn't do anyone any favors. My parents so neglected their health that they both died before I turned 20, and before they reached 60. Unfortunately for me, neither had any savings, retirement, or life insurance.
- jacquesm 3y agoAs the son of an alcoholic father: I'm really happy that I didn't grow up there and if he'd have kicked me out if I did that would have been doing me a favor. So yes, that was meant in a sympathetic way. And my dad too died young, but not quite that young.
- justinator 3y agoI'm sorry to hear that too. I'm very glad to hear that you seem to be doing well. It's not always the case and the scars are oftetimes internal and invisible. Take care of yourself.
- 3y ago
- pbj1968 3y ago[flagged]
- Always_Anon 3y ago[flagged]
- lousken 3y agowho cares about parents once their children are away? moving next door is not always the option
- ProfessorLayton 3y agoOf course the economics of moving out haven't gotten easier for younger folks, and there's a severe shortage of housing has made almost everything worse. Still, a few things to note: - Since baby boomers were born, the US has gotten a lot more diverse. - This is meaningful, because in a lot of cultures, multigenerational homes are the norm. There is a lot less pressure to move out just because one is an adult, and there's more emphasis on the family unit. - It doesn't seem like a coincidence that diverse places like LA and NYC are more multigenerational. Yes of course they're also a lot more expensive, and it's not just a cultural thing.
- vivekd 3y agoWe also have to account for the fact that NY and LA are also unreasonably expensive. I wouldn't be able to afford to live there, and I say this as a Canadian, a place known for high prices particularly in housing Also multi generation home might be a red herring. Because in just about every country adults are supposed to support themselves. Multigenerational means you support your parents not that they support you. So the type of multigenerational homes we see rising today might not be reflective of different cultural preferences explainable by rising diversity
- ProfessorLayton 3y ago>Because in just about every country adults are supposed to support themselves. China, India, and Latin America make up an extremely large portion the world's entire population, and families from there have had a growing presence in the US. Multigenerational housing is the norm there, and is absolutely not a red herring. Additionally, the focus is on supporting the family unit, not supporting in one specific direction. I definitely agree that high prices (housing in particular) are contributing to this, but so is culture.
- vivekd 3y agoI'm not saying india doesn't have multi generational housing I'm saying the nature is different It's traditionally not made up of adult children who are unable to support themselves. Instead it's made up of adult children supporting parents in their old age. That's not the same thing we're seeing in the US where lots of millenials are staying home due to being unable to support themselves
- elashri 3y agoI heard a rumor (maybe myth) that part of the reason why serial killers phenomenon was very rare in the eastern hemisphere (in culture at least) is that it is hard to get the right circumstances given that most of the people lives and interact with a big family compared to the US for example. I did not read about that or search it though. But it is an interesting idea. That's of course not to say that this is the only benefit from living with family (if true). I think it is also economically makes sense because in many of these countries it is very hard for young people to find a housing where they live specially in the big cities where there is more opportunities. Also because of the centralized economy around capital city and a few cities it will but pressure on the housing market. Not like the US when there is much more diverse and spread economy. I really miss living close to my extended family and be like 1 hour from most of them. Where I never been alone in any circumstances. But here is the US, I feel lonely and I don't think I am the only one.
- anarticle 3y agoMany of my friends have nice high five or six figure jobs and live with their parents into mid thirties. Not really sure why, but according to them rent is a complete waste of money. Partially true I guess, but also can lead to failure to launch. I was definitely more broke working as a pizza guy and then at a university, but I valued my freedom much more. Lived paycheck to paycheck with very finely tuned finances, no savings just student loan payments. I survived on a diet of library media, books, torrented video games and super cheap beer. The interesting part was I felt relatively happy. Threw crappy parties where we'd all chip in to buy a bunch of 40s, and someone would dj. I didn't really start to "have some money" until I was about 30~ from university job, and then I quit for industry where I 3x'd (I cried that day, as I made more money than anyone in my family!) I think now it's much easier to feel aspirational about money and hard to be happy with you lot when you're getting firehosed about how everyone is having a better time than you are and they have more money. Things are also much more expensive, especially after the pandemic. There is value in coming home to your own couch and knowing the space is yours, and yours alone. Maybe tastes have changed. I know that in my life, every time I tried to outsmart and skip a step I feel like life threw me a set back to learn the lesson I tried to not learn :D.
- asimpleusecase 3y agoWhen I was 7 years old one night my father was tucking me in bed and he said “Son, I just want you to know that we are expecting you to move out when you are 18.” So that was always clear. Now that I have a couple of children in mid teens we don’t feel in any rush to show them the door. I have seen the value in multigenerational homes and the abuses. What I do seem to see more of right now are adult children living with parents but not taking on any responsibility for the collective needs of the home. Entertainment ( gaming, video, socialising, activities ) of self being the core activity and not contributing to the finances of the household, not taking on domestic chores, not intensely saving money for major life purchases. That does not reflect everyone who is still with parents as an adult, but it seems like it is a disturbingly large segment.
- angmarsbane 3y agoI think you’ve recognized a key nuance. The adult-aged child that retains the traits of a teenager vs the adult-aged child that takes on the traits of an adult.
- lo_zamoyski 3y agoWe must first distinguish between can't and won't. Those who cannot leave the house, and those who will not leave. I claim that we have an uptick in the latter camp. By his early 20s, and frankly sooner, a healthy human being wants to have his own life. He doesn't want to live on his parents' dime. Healthy parents also don't want their children in the nest anymore either, and it is their duty to, proverbially speaking, kick them out. What "leaving the nest" means in a given culture may vary (the article in question seems to be talking about the US), but in any healthy culture, there exists the same basic psychological emancipation from parental dependence, an emancipation willingly embraced or imposed by necessity. Loving parenting is a process of progressively removing training wheels and clipping tethers. The goal is to lead someone to becoming a man or a woman: in short, an adult. This means truthful and honest feedback instead of deceitful complements or excuses, upping the challenge, and being increasingly and accordingly demanding, so that by the time someone does leave the nest, the significance of the transition is largely in the symbolic act, not a change in responsibility they can't handle. Parents and adult children should be able to relate to one another as adults. If that's not happening, something is wrong. In short, we have a problem with Peter Pan syndrome. An infantile, therapeutic culture of narcissistic self-indulgence makes this very easy. Mental illness is to be expected.
- matthewbauer 3y ago"still" has kind of a negative connotation for something that doesn't seem necessarily negative.
- bfrog 3y agoChoosing to stay in a collective household seems to be frowned upon but really it depends on the dynamic. There’s something to be said about having children close to grandparents.
- UtopiaPunk 3y agoYeah, it rules! Every family is different, my parents and in-laws love spending time with their grandkids, and my spouse and I benefit a lot from having other responsible adults to keep an eye on the kids. The grandparents don't live in the same house as us, but this will likely change in the future and we think it would be a welcome arrangement.
- UtopiaPunk 3y agoMy spouse and I share a house with my spouse's sibling. My spouse and I basically have total control of an upper floor, and my spouse's sibling has the bedroom on the lower floor. The arrangement works really well for us, and our bills are signifcantly lower. With this arrangement, we get to save quite a bit more for retirement, and there's one extra responsible adult to help out with childcare (which is huge). We could afford to live on our own, but do we really want to? In the future, we expect to "live with our parents" again, but it will be because they will move in with us as they advance in years and need additional care. So, idk, the article seems to start with the assumption that living with family is undesirable and a result of financial stress. That's true for some, sure, but it can also just be the way people prefer to live.
- tennisflyi 3y agoIt is very simple math. Average rent is $1,500/month where I live. I need to make $4,500/month to rent. So, $54,000/year. I need to make c. $30/hour. No one is paying that. Or, maybe I'm just garbage. If you know where I can find safe and dependable roommates, HMU.