3 ms·
Which are what exactly? The state has been setting record surpluses. Housing is very expensive, but that's due to a failure to build. Higher property taxes do
by s1artibartfast 3y ago
Which are what exactly? The state has been setting record surpluses.
Housing is very expensive, but that's due to a failure to build.
Higher property taxes doesn't reduce the cost of ownership or make housing more affordable.
This is like saying we should rise the tax rate on food because people are starving in the street
- clarifyingN 3y ago[flagged]
- kadoban 3y agoYou could consider being more humble and polite, especially if you're going to be wrong. (Note that they said _state_, your numbers are national).
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Housing is very expensive, but that's due to a failure to build. The low maximum property tax rate and systematic failure to tax full value created by Prop 13 is a reason for the failure to build. (Now, actually, I think residential property tax is a horribly regressive tax, and its better to fund government by progressive income taxes, but there needs to be a funding allocation formula that gives local government more of an incentive for development; California has adopted some limits on discretion and consequences for not meeting targets as a stick, but that's not enough to encourage good positive planning.)
- s1artibartfast 3y ago>The low maximum property tax rate and systematic failure to tax full value created by Prop 13 is a reason for the failure to build. Only by indirect argument. IF homeowners were taxed more, they would be more sensitive to housing costs in general, and perhaps more inclined to expanding the housing stock. Given that the government is funded, this would simply be a punitive tax incentive to motivate policy. I don't particularly buy the lack of local government incentive. New development is already taxed at substantially higher rates relative to older stock due to prop 13. If expanding the tax base were a major driver of policy, then we would expect to be building already.
- imtringued 3y agoPeople don't block commercial construction because it raises property values. They block residential construction because it lowers their property values. You get an imbalance of jobs to housing and then people complain about expensive housing.