5 ms·
If identity theft were to get so common that the data became statistically unreliable, we would be long past the point that even Congress would feel compelled t
by civilized 3y ago
If identity theft were to get so common that the data became statistically unreliable, we would be long past the point that even Congress would feel compelled to do something about it.
- godzillabrennus 3y agoYou give Congress too much credit.
- bee_rider 3y agoThere’s no such thing as identity theft, it is impossible to steal an identity, the person still has their identity. It is impersonation. The victim is the entity that has fallen for the impersonation (likely a bank, etc), the perpetrator is the one who did the impersonation, and the impersonated person is just some uninvolved third party. I know it is pedantic but it is important to keep in mind because dumping the need to seek redress on the uninvolved third party is ridiculous, so we shouldn’t use language that plays into that point of view.
- alistairSH 3y ago100% agree, except the impersonated person is impacted when their credit score eventually gets screwed and they can no longer get loans themselves. So, in that regard, they are also a victim.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mixdup 3y agoThe point is that the impersonated person shouldn't have these fraudulent items reported on their credit. That's the crux of how the responsibility of cleaning up this mess is absolutely on the wrong person
- bee_rider 3y agoAlthough I think it is more accurate to call them a victim of something like slander by the credit agency, in that case. I mean, I’m not sure exactly what the laws are around slander, I wouldn’t be surprised if there was some cutout for cases in which the person actually believed the lies they were repeating, but if an organization represents itself as an expert in people’s trustworthiness it obviously has a heightened responsibility to verify what it is repeating.
- jdsully 3y agoCredit reporting agencies have immunity from slander claims unless you can prove malice.
- marcosdumay 3y agoSo you've found the problem. If they are immune from the crime, they won't stop practicing it.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoMy understanding is that in most cases, slander/libel is never a crime anyway. It's merely a tort (wrong). It never rises to the level of a crime. The few instances/places where slander is a crime in the US (historically or otherwise) are very problematic and subject to abuse. Perhaps this specific kind of slander should be criminal, but it might be the only kind that should be. Not only would you need to justify that philosophically, but somehow convince legislators to make it that way (at the federal level, I should think). It'd be a tough journey.
- marcosdumay 3y agoWell, ok. There's no need to make it a literal crime. Those companies just need to be responsible for correcting the damage they cause.
- 3y ago
- usea 3y agoThe impersonated person is impacted because the credit agency is lying about them to other people.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoIt’s identity fraud frankly. Hold consumers harmless and put the burden on the industry (if you did not have an high identity assurance you’re on the hook for costs and losses) and this problem evaporates. Also outlaw credit monitoring and identity theft insurance.
- kagakuninja 3y agoThe banks aren't the only victims. The person has had their credit rating damaged, and may even be on the hook for fraudulent charges made in their name.
- 9991 3y ago> The person has had their credit rating damaged This is called libel. This person is a victim of a crime the credit reporting agency committed.
- nulbyte 3y agoLibel is an intentional act. Agencies are not intentionally reporting false information. Banks may be reporting false information, but even they are unaware until the fraud has been discovered, by which time information they thought was true has already been reported.
- everforward 3y agoLibel can be intentional or a reckless disregard for the truth. I don't know what the courts would interpret that standard to be here.
- rzzzt 3y agoA classic Mitchell & Webb sketch: https://youtu.be/-c57WKxeELY https://youtu.be/-c57WKxeELY
- ClimaxGravely 3y agoThank you for that, I'm actively looking to see how I can watch this show now.
- robin_reala 3y agoThis is from That Mitchell and Webb Sound, a radio show they did. The BBC don’t tend to region-lock audio, so you should be able to listen at https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b007lqrh https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b007lqrh (or using the BBC Sounds app).
- civilized 3y agoI completely agree. But if I recall correctly, they've set up the law so that if they get duped, you're on the hook for whatever they got duped into giving the impersonator. That's the biggest problem.
- Buttons840 3y agoTell me you're Bank of America and I'll give you a thousand dollars. You disappear into the night and I'll go get my thousand dollars back from the real Bank of America. Is that how the law is setup? (Honestly, making a website that looks like a legit Bank of America website is about as difficult as getting someone's SSN.)
- decremental 3y ago[dead]