15 ms·
Cursorless is alien magic from the future
- neycoda 3y agoAs if coders needed more people around them talking. We already get too much of that from nearby non-coders.
- vunderba 3y agoAfter years of working as a software developer combined with a daily regimen of piano practice I developed fairly bad tendinitis/RSI issues about ten years ago. I tried your standard r.i.c.e, taubmann technique, ultrasound, TENS units, easing up on my activities, EVERYTHING. The only thing that really helped me at the end was a book called the trigger point therapy workbook. TPT basically emphasizes using a form of deep tissue massage to attempt to break up residual scar tissue and increase blood flow. I've been using it as a preventative form of medicine, and I have been RSI free for years now.
- leptons 3y agoMy massage person is a wizard. They know exactly where to dig into. I went from pain and tears to pain-free. They keep mentioning scar tissue and blood flow. I spend an hour in traffic to get to a massage appointment and it's absolutely worth it every single time. Great if you can fix things yourself, but I need a wizard to fix up all my stuff.
- shutdownthenet 3y ago[flagged]
- busterarm 3y agoI've never really quite understood RSI. I've been practically a 16-hours a day computer user for near 40 years now...combined with playing instruments and video games. I've never had wrist, hand or eye problems. I consider myself extremely fortunate/lucky. OTOH loud music has turned my hearing to utter shit.
- owyn 3y agoI was going to downvote you because obviously this does happen to people and saying "this doesn't happen to me" is kind of annoying. I think you can understand RSI. We don't all get to enjoy a positive outcome from the same seemingly neutral events. I am also a 16 hour a day computer user and used to be a musician and I've had bouts of "ouch" from playing video games and also from lifting weights or riding a bike a long distance. Lifting weights is a good ouch generally, playing video games is a bad one. But my most downvoted comment is a response to someone being really dismissive about ear damage from loud music. I was in a band and it kind of messed up my ears. I don't have RSI and consider myself lucky, I can still work because my job is typing. The comment that set me off was "how about simply not playing so fucking loud?" I would like you to look at the parallels between your comment and the one that set me off, and look at my response and look at how a response from someone who IS suffering from it would see your response and realize how it's just... not helpful. "how about just don't get hurt like I didn't?" Easy! Just invent time travel and don't do that thing that hurt you. You can make choices and you can take precautions. But I did not wear ear plugs at shows because I wanted to hear everything and usually did but sometimes didn't wear ear plugs at band practice and that was very dumb. At the time, I thought it was important to hear it as it was in the room. Listening to the buzz in my ears now, mayyyybe I was wrong about that. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37517355 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37517355
- stavros 3y agoThat is very much not what I got from the parent comment. My takeaway was "very odd that I do the same things as you but didn't get RSI". For what it's worth, I've also been using computers all day for 25 years and didn't get a lick of RSI. I am also wondering what I'm doing differently. Maybe finding that out can help the people who did get it. In my case, I think it helps that my elbows are resting on the table always, and I take care that my hands/wrists don't need to be in a weird position for me to type. I did learn to type badly (basically typing at an angle), but maybe that means that my wrists were more comfortable that way.
- growingkittens 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- xena 3y agoAuthor of the article here, kinda surprised to see this doing so well here. But in case you're all interested, here's my repo of Talon stuff I'm experimenting with: https://github.com/Xe/invocations https://github.com/Xe/invocations
- throwanem 3y agoI dunno. My wrists are mostly good, but my knuckles aren't always, thanks to the early-onset osteoarthritis that comes with the family hands. I expect there will come days when it would be, if not absolutely necessary, then at least a lot less painful to work this way than with a keyboard, so I'm glad to know there's a viable option. I'm glad you wrote it up, and that it got to the front page here strikes me as HN working as intended.
- xena 3y agoThis stuff is really worth of taking the effort to learn at least once. I didn't actually write this up per se :P Technically, I dictated it and there's probably some gnarly typos with homophones in there that I haven't totally eliminated because it was a bit of a fire and forget piece, where I was just dumping my thoughts on a topic.
- throwanem 3y agoI mean technically you wouldn't have written it up even with a keyboard, so... :D And yeah, even notwithstanding the massive accessibility benefit, I can see use in learning it just for the sake of a new lens on how to navigate code. Sort of the same reason I'm looking forward to the big Emacs 29 update on all my machines around the end of the year - among other things, I get to find out firsthand whether I'm as excited as I should be for first class tree-sitter, or not excited enough. But for VS Code folks, this is already right there and I can't imagine not wanting to play around at least a bit with it and see what it can do.
- mkl 3y agoI only noticed one, near the end: "get led into" -> "get let into".
- celeritascelery 3y agoI am still trying to wrap my head around how this works. It sounds like it is similar to avy[1] but you use your voice instead of the keyboard? Coupled with some AST aware commands. [1] https://karthinks.com/software/avy-can-do-anything/ https://karthinks.com/software/avy-can-do-anything/
- ParetoOptimal 3y agoYes. In fact when I wanted to reimplement this for emacs my first step was trying to make a "hats" avy style. Then for the overlays to always be visible. I got stuck somewhere though.
- paxcoder 3y agoStrange Loop presentation by the author of Cursorless: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NcUJnmBqHTY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NcUJnmBqHTY
- erulabs 3y agoI have occasional wrist pain (competitive starcraft and being a software engineer not a great combo) - the only real fix for me was going to the gym a lot. Now that I go to the gym 3-4 times a week, most all of my RSI issues have vanished. Strongly recommend. There is something crushing about wrist pain when your entire value is wrapped up in what you can make computers do. Also, I love the style of this blog with the chat-replies from friends.
- xena 3y agoYeah, at first when the RSI pain started, it felt it was really scary. Like viscerally scary in a way that is hard to describe unless you have felt that kind of fear. realistically, though knowing that I can use this tool to be able to code, even without the use of my hands, it makes me just feel calm. Obviously, I wouldn't want to lose use of my hands, but should that reality happen it is something that I could actually live with and tolerate. Would suck to give up video games entirely though. It's amazingly ironic that coding without your hands, ends up being faster than coding with your hands, but it wouldn't be reality if it wasn't ironic eh?
- cableshaft 3y ago> Would suck to give up video games entirely though. You don't necessarily have to do that. I'm adding voice recognition into the game I'm working on right now, for example. It helps that it's a turn-based strategy game to begin with, though. And there are players that manage to play games with limited or no mobility in their hands at all, with the right accessible controllers.
- targetx 3y agoPlaying games on PC has been a trigger for me for a long time and gets uncomfortable quickly. I got a PSVR2 headset last year and it's a great way for me to play games and not be in the same mostly static position all day. I can play games on it without any discomfort (other than wearing the headset itself which isn't great if it's a really hot day) and you can switch up sitting/standing which I also like.
- shutdownthenet 3y ago[flagged]
- ceautery 3y agoThis style of writing feels a lot like the sections of Gödel Escher Bach that had the tortoise and Achilles dialogues. Anyway, I’m 52 and have been typing daily at tech jobs since 1995. I had a run-in with RSI around 2000, and tried ergonomic aids like a squishy pad in front of my keyboard to rest my wrists on, this sliding thing that I rested my elbows on. None of it made a lick of difference. I changed the way I typed. I made sure to keep my hands and wrists relaxed, and swapped out stretching my fingers for keys with sliding my arms around… and it worked. I still type a lot every day, and I’ve been pain free for 20 years. YMMV, obviously, but changing how you use your arms and hands might be a huge boon.
- dbtc 3y agoAlso the rest of your body: especially head and shoulders, but core, hips, even feet are well worth attending to.
- chubot 3y agoSame here, I got a bout of severe RSI almost 15 years ago, for a few months I changed many habits and it's been gone since then ... It's obviously different for everyone but I found that using a trackball helped a lot. For awhile I had a mouse on the left and trackball on the right, switching back and forth. But I don't need that anymore. Taking breaks and minding posture is important. Wrist posture in particular -- I don't rest my wrists or arms on anything -- only my fingers make contact with the keyboard. Much later, I started weight training with kettle bells, and I noticed a pretty nice improvement in strength / circulation.
- hiAndrewQuinn 3y ago> I changed the way I typed. I made sure to keep my hands and wrists relaxed, and swapped out stretching my fingers for keys with sliding my arms around… and it worked. That's one of the biggest takeaways I had from playing bass guitar in high school, actually. If you can delegate the movement to a bigger muscle group, it's generally a good idea do so. Shoulder/back instead of arm, arm instead of hand, hand instead of finger...
- 3y ago
- rapind 3y agoOnce again proving Vi is the superior editor :)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- shutdownthenet 3y ago[flagged]
- shutdownthenet 3y ago[flagged]
- dlopes7 3y agoThis is interesting but also a nightmare for me as colorblind
- hifikuno 3y agoI wonder if the colour could be replaced with different shapes and you call the shapes out instead? Edit: apparently so!
- xena 3y agoYou can use shapes instead of colors: https://www.cursorless.org/docs/#shapes https://www.cursorless.org/docs/#shapes
- dharmab 3y agoI was totally confused by the demo video until I realized the dots were supposed to be different colors ;_;
- hifikuno 3y agoHas anyone had any experience using this in a shared workspace? I think it would be awesome to learn, but I don't see it working well for me in an open plan working area.
- xena 3y agoAt some level, this is my insurance against ever working in an open office ever again. If an employer really does want me to work in an open office, I will just maliciously comply and get nothing done because the recognition just won't work.
- skullone 3y agoThat sounds like an awful deal for a company trying to build collaboration.
- SparkyMcUnicorn 3y agoCollaboration doesn't have to rely on everyone being in the same room or building. At times I've even seen better collaboration between random open source maintainers working together than some of the companies where everyone was in an open office floorplan.
- xena 3y agoSurprisingly, everybody can have their own opinions about what they think is the best workspace for them. I find it difficult to focus in loud places. All of the open offices I've worked in have been loud places. I'm sure there are open offices that are not loud places, but luck of the draw, I have not seen that. If you like working in an open office, that's great for you. I don't.
- phyzome 3y agoBetter approach: Point out that a sound-separated space is a reasonable accommodation. That should do the trick.
- icyfox 3y ago
- 38 3y ago[flagged]
- precompute 3y agoIt's a meme that's best resolved by using an ergonomic keyboard, or by moving the modifier keys.
- throwanem 3y ago"Emacs pinky" lasts not more than five seconds after binding the oversized, wrongly placed, totally useless Caps Lock key to send Control instead, the way God intended.
- rgoulter 3y agoI like putting the modifier keys (shift, ctrl, win, alt) underneath the home row keys using tap-hold functionality. (e.g. tapping 'f' outputs 'f', but holding 'f' acts as 'shift'). And Caps Lock's young new cousin "Caps Word" is worth checking out. https://docs.qmk.fm/#/feature_caps_word https://docs.qmk.fm/#/feature_caps_word
- darkteflon 3y agoAlas - at least from what I could tell - very difficult to impossible to achieve on Mac without a hardware-remappable keyboard.
- rgoulter 3y agoThere are tools like kmonad (and I think some others), although they do require a kernel extension (or driver extension). https://github.com/kmonad/kmonad/blob/master/doc/installation.md#macos https://github.com/kmonad/kmonad/blob/master/doc/installatio...
- eviks 3y agohave you actually tried that? afaik they don't get you the perfect home row mods due to some limitations re. how they implement the tap vs hold logic https://github.com/kmonad/kmonad/issues/228 https://github.com/kmonad/kmonad/issues/228
- johnfn 3y agoNot to put a damper on how cool this is (or bring up AI for the nth time), but I think GPT4 has mostly solved this problem, and you don't even need to learn a new UI! For instance, GPT4 integrated into my IDE has a hit rate of close to 100% for translating english into code for simple things that the article mentions, such as creating new functions, moving arguments around, etc. (I feel silly using such a powerful tool for such simple tasks, but I often ask GPT4 to do tasks that I'm too lazy or don't want to hit all the keystrokes for, like converting an anonymous function to a lambda or whatever.) I suppose that the only difference is that it's not quite as fast, yet :)
- xena 3y agoThe latency will make or break this. I run all the models on-device as much as possible.
- Terr_ 3y agoPlus there's the whole privacy/autonomy aspect. Notwithstanding the last few decades of trend, many people still want certain data/behavior to stay firmly within a device they (supposedly) own and control, as opposed to owning a dumb-terminal.
- johnfn 3y agoI don't think that's true. Latency is critical when the limiting factor is that you know what you want to do but in order to do it, you need to issue many requests all at once. With GPT4 I can issue requests at a high enough level that the limiting factor is actually me thinking of what the next request will be.
- precompute 3y agoSo this utilizes the tree-sitter AST and performs operations on the "parts" of the buffer? This, then, is very similar to textobjects in vim / evil, but with a spoken component. I can see a lot of promise in this. Particularly if this integrates a sort of "record and perform" feature. Say I'm doing action X with my keyboard, and I know I need to do Y after, and 1) I can see all the required text on the screen, 2) it's a simple operation. I could then speak the command for Y while executing X, and then press the button to execute the voice command after I finish X. Much better than having to alternate between typing and speaking. Alternately typing and speaking would lead to using different parts of our cognition, and writing software isn't very verbal once you've grokked the syntax. Instead, if one can type and speak at the same time, it'll work everything and make achieving a flow state much easier. Sort of like rubber ducking on steroids. One could take notes, too... I see an Emacs package coming lol.
- GuestHNUser 3y agoYou should check out this demonstration of programming by voice[0]. [0] https://youtu.be/GM_siEPD4Ws?si=f52wK3tqqJaCQPp7 https://youtu.be/GM_siEPD4Ws?si=f52wK3tqqJaCQPp7
- precompute 3y agoThanks!
- ParetoOptimal 3y ago> I see an Emacs package coming lol. There is one that drives vscode or jetbrains with cursorless plugin, but a native emacs one would be nice.
- karthink 3y ago> I see an Emacs package coming lol. Emacs is pretty good in the other direction (can type, can't see) thanks to Emacspeak. But it's going to be a while before Emacs can catch up in this domain. The display engine can't handle cursorless-style notation, and the tree-sitter integration is not mature yet. Source: I've tried.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- larme 3y agoMy strategy of fighting RSI is mapping modifier keys so that you can press them using your thumbs and outer part of your palms.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- p1mrx 3y agoIf Cursorless is alien magic from the future, and JPEG is alien technology from the future, then this blog demonstrates the perils of combining magic and technology. The blurry dots make my head hurt.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- quickthrower2 3y agoNice. Don’t have to have RSI to appreciate this. I think I prefer this to learning vim shortcuts. I would rather say U than Urge so I don’t need to think but the phonetic alphabet would do I guess.
- xena 3y agoRealistically the phonetic alphabet is fine. It's weird but you get used to it, it's so much less ambiguous once you get up to speed.
- Uptrenda 3y ago[flagged]
- kazinator 3y agoWhy can't it be "green U" rather than "green urge", is my question.
- throwaway562if1 3y agoThe same reason pilots say "fower" instead of "four" and soldiers "foxtrot" instead of "eff" - a good spelling alphabet is much clearer and ambiguity-free than English letter names. Getting into speculation here, I expect the reason they use their own alphabet instead of something like the NATO phonetic alphabet is a matter of use case: unlike radio communications, transcription provides immediate, unambiguous feedback (the letters show up on your screen) and mistakes are low-impact and easily corrected, so a degree of clarity is sacrificed in exchange for improved speed.
- kazinator 3y ago> The same reason pilots say "fower" Because they talk over noisy, distorted channels that have about 3 kHz bandwidth, in environments that are noisy to begin with? You can talk to your PC in 16 bit (or more) audio sampled at 48 kHz, with a decent microphone, in a relatively quiet environment. Moreover, it could be tailored to understand your voice specifically, not just anyone saying "U".
- function_seven 3y agoWhen you're combining letter names with other commands, even in perfect recording conditions, there will be confusion. The command "back Q" sounds very very close to "back U", but "back quench" is different than "back urge". In either case, you're using the same number of syllables, so there isn't any speed lost. You just have to spend a day learning the alphabet.
- kazinator 3y ago"back U", or perhaps more pertinently "black U", is not very close to "black Q". They are phonetically distinct. "black U" has no stop; in "black Q" there is a stop between the words. The final plosive of "black" is deleted so it becomes something similar to "bla ' kyu", whereas the other one is "blakyu". In 2023, if whatever you're using doesn't listen for stops, here is a dime, get yourself a better speech recognizer? I'm not learning any phonetic alphabet other than the ICAO standard one. If I ever have to use that one, I will look like a fool if that nonstandard one starts slipping in by mistake.
- GuestHNUser 3y agoNot cursorless specifically, but there is a great talk and demonstration about programming by voice here[0]. It's mesmerizing to watch. The speaker does a great job talking about the current commmon issues in the area too. [0] https://youtu.be/GM_siEPD4Ws?si=99ZhC1P4irOyu1pH https://youtu.be/GM_siEPD4Ws?si=99ZhC1P4irOyu1pH
- 59nadir 3y agoI remember that talk! They also have a channel with some more videos but unfortunately do not do coding by voice anymore: https://www.youtube.com/@mccGoNZooo https://www.youtube.com/@mccGoNZooo
- singularity2001 3y agowhat's wrong with just saying what you want to select in this example select "function fetchBlog". If the recognition is slightly off for example "fetch Buhk" use some Levenstein to find the best match
- xena 3y agoImplementation welcome. I can only use tools that exist.
- pimlottc 3y agoWhy "urge" and "bat"? Can you just use any word starting with the relevant letter?
- dimatter 3y agotwo bee or knot too b, that is the quest on
- ParetoOptimal 3y agoEasier to say and for talon to disambiguate. If you do 6-8 hours voice coding like I have in the past, you'll appreciate every micro optimization.
- philipswood 3y agoNo. Talon has a phonetic alphabet, one chosen to be short and easy to disambiguate. Some detail about it here: https://whalequench.club/blog/2019/09/03/learning-to-speak-code.html#the-alphabet https://whalequench.club/blog/2019/09/03/learning-to-speak-c...
- was_a_dev 3y ago> Newcomers to voice coding often ask why not use the NATO Phonetic Alphabet > With one exception, all the NATO words have more than one syllable (e.g., November has three) and are not efficient for commands like the alphabet that you will use frequently
- ehsankia 3y agoHmm curious why the two syllable "jury" Why not jam, jaw, jail, junk, join, jerk, jest, jazz, jade, etc.
- Subdivide8452 3y agoWas wondering the exact same thing. But my brain stopped after ‘jet’.
- e12e 3y ago
- ceeam 3y agoMy $.02 RSI advice: - Get a TKL keyboard, those extra 5 inches to stretch to your mouse are important - Or try using your mouse IN FRONT of your keyboard, like, I usually have mine turned 90' counter-clockwise and resting somewhere under my left "Alt" key. If you never used it that way it may feel weird for like 5 minutes. Then it's natural for eternity - And get a mechanical keyboard ("red" switches should be okay for most people)
- jbd0 3y agoOr use a split keyboard and put the mouse in between the two halves. Been doing it this way for years and it works great.
- martypitt 3y ago> Or try using your mouth IN FRONT of your keyboard You're gonna have to walk me through that one.
- fragmede 3y agomouse
- ceeam 3y ago[flagged]
- wingerlang 3y ago1. Place mouse at, and parallel, to the spacebar
- imiric 3y agoHave you considered using a Trackpoint instead of a mouse? To me it's the most comfortable way to move a pointer on the screen, and coupled with a keyboard-driven GUI, I rarely have to rely on it anyway. This seems like the most ergonomic setup to me, and I haven't experienced any hand discomfort after many years of using it. > And get a mechanical keyboard I'm not convinced that mechanical keyboards help with reducing RSI, since they usually require more actuation force and key travel. I've found slim keyboards with low key travel, whether mechanical or membrane, to be the most comfortable to type on for extended periods of time.
- pillefitz 3y agoYears ago I struggled with RSI as well, and found suggestions to read about the methods of John Sarno here on HN. While it initially triggered by BS radar, I was desperate enough to try his methods - and they worked! Additionally look into trigger points: http://www.triggerpoints.net/ http://www.triggerpoints.net/ There's certain points in my arms and back, which when pressed hard enough, lead to complete and immediate pain relief (which led me to experiment with Sarno's method in the first place, as he suggests psychosomatic causes)
- proto-n 3y agoTrigger points afaik are a widely accepted concept, my physical therapist tells me that something like 90% of the time her patients' problems are due to trigger points. Or more correctly due to cramping and tense muscles, which trigger points can help alleviate. The trigger point is basically just a place where you can push on the muscle, and apparently when you push on a muscle that's tense, it's forced to relax itself. It's painful, but only as long as the muscle is tense. Relaxed muscles are not painful when pushed.
- andrekandre 3y ago> The trigger point is basically just a place where you can push on the muscle, and apparently when you push on a muscle that's tense, it's forced to relax itself. It's painful, but only as long as the muscle is tense. Relaxed muscles are not painful when pushed. thats interesting. after getting injured i started getting intense tension headaches from the back of my neck/head and at one point went to various massage therapists, and the best ones would find the right muscle and press real hard... which would hurt like hell but would solve my headache pretty fast in a lot of cases. fast-forward many sessions later, i learned how to do the same for myself whenever i'd feel a tension headache coming on, just find that tense knot and press hard; works like magic many times
- frob 3y agoI had debilitating sciatica for 4 to 5 months to the point where I could only get a few intermittent hours of sleep every night even with strong muscle relaxants. I worked with a PT for months on stretches and strengthening exercises. A few months in, they off-handedly suggested dry needling, which seems to operate on the same principles as trigger point massage. I gave it a shot because I was open to any possible treatment at that time. Literally one session cured my sciatica. Within minutes, the pain was less than half of what it had been before and by the next morning, it was over 90% gone. It was quite fortunate timing as this was March 2020 and I cannot fathom how I would have survived the fear and isolation of the early months of the COVID pandemic coupled with that pain.
- block_dagger 3y agoI've built a couple ergonomic solutions for my RSI issues including a supine workstation and hacking chair. Wrist torsion is what did the most damage. Split vertical keyboards to the rescue. https://jck.earth/2023/11/05/diy-hacking-chair.html https://jck.earth/2023/11/05/diy-hacking-chair.html
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- david_draco 3y agoIs eye-tracking tech not good enough these days to position a cursor when one stares at that position for 2+ seconds? I am recalling studies of driving or artwork where the gaze lingers.
- Valodim 3y agoMaybe, but 2+ second pauses are way too much to indicate a position on your screen, since you do that a lot during coding
- jimmySixDOF 3y agoXR devices with eye tracking have practically no latency instead you would need to tune down the points of interest hover over time triggers and then there are a lot of experimental keyboard ideas in Spatial Computing that could be integrated like starburst wheels could give you layers of type assist etc
- lupire 3y agoI bet it's faster but it feels slower because it's a passive action.
- antipurist 3y agoYou can find examples of people using eye trackers for coding/gaming on Youtube and judge the latency yourself, here's one such example: https://youtu.be/FZRgBw8m34c?feature=shared&t=90 https://youtu.be/FZRgBw8m34c?feature=shared&t=90
- lifeplusplus 3y agoEye tracking with neural "click" I need extremely responsive and accurate eye tracking with device that can detect at least 3-5 buttons - click - click down - click up - move right - move left
- FPGAhacker 3y agotimes like this make it really frustrating to be red-green colorblind.
- phyzome 3y agoApparently it can be configured with shapes instead. By the way, have you seen the Firefox extension "Let's Get Color Blind"? It can simulate colorblindness, but perhaps more importantly, it can Daltonize web pages on the fly to make them usable by the colorblind -- even including real-time stuff like video. It blew a protanopic coworker's mind. https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/let-s-get-color-blind/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/let-s-get-col...
- jen729w 3y agoAs it’s not been mentioned, I’ll say that you should pay very close attention to your desk height. I had no idea that mine was too high. And then I sat at a colleague’s desk and it was low. Like lowrider-car low. Crazy low. And wow did it feel comfortable. So then I fixed my own desk. Not to be crazy low, to be the right height. Because if it’s too high, you’re hunched all day. Your shoulders are up, you’re tense. I also changed my chair. I had a classic office chair, but again too high (I’m average height, not a millimetre more), and with wheels. The wheels were killing me — all day your legs are trying to keep you stable, which sounds like cool exercise but isn’t. Turns out just being stable is better. So I bought a chair. A wooden chair with four legs. About AU$80 from IKEA. These two things alone transformed my RSI. I know, because I didn’t change my keyboard (Microsoft Ergo Sculpt) or my mouse (Logi MX Anywhere 3? whatever, just a mouse), or anything else. I didn’t exercise. I fixed my desk height and my chair and my crippling RSI went away.
- strogonoff 3y agoSome of the key realizations that led to healthier working posture for me have been: 1. Remembering what I learned from piano lessons at music school: keyboard should be approximately under your fingers if you relax your arms and bend your elbows 90 degrees. Where playing, you you have to engage your arms, not only fingers. 2. Putting screen at approximately eye level, give or take. Yes, the above means a laptop is by default unsuitable for serious work. An external keyboard and/or display is a must. 3. Realizing that what we (at least in my generation) were taught at school about “orderly” position at a desk is a pile of something between wrongness and abuse. Relaxed, laid-back sitting position is best for you, and any boss or instructor who tries to tell you otherwise is engaging in status games.
- jodrellblank 3y agoA piano keyboard is flat and in front of you, all you can adjust is the height. But computer keyboards can be adjusted more - why bend the elbows 90 degrees, if you didn't have to, would that be the ideal thing to do? https://octopup.org/img/computer/datahand/m/20021103-0000-P45Q9--Datahand--Chair.jpg https://octopup.org/img/computer/datahand/m/20021103-0000-P4... https://octopup.org/img/computer/datahand/m/20021121-0000-P45QL--At-Desk--Ergonomics--23--Datahand-Keyboard.jpg https://octopup.org/img/computer/datahand/m/20021121-0000-P4... https://external-content.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fexternal-preview.redd.it%2FEoxIwGL9lmS5aQXOpPLIAu7bGC1ijH8fQqJeDoQLb4E.jpg%3Fauto%3Dwebp%26s%3D08a48dc2d6776573febfe021df70111efe3a8699&f=1&nofb=1&ipt=ad7a40e374737a6d68bc581a5517f8f589d6941f755e842a1939bafb86bc64cb&ipo=images https://external-content.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=https%3A%2F%2F...
- digitcatphd 3y agoReally enjoyed OPs style of writing here more than anything in this.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gamescool1 3y ago[flagged]
- Tade0 3y agoA good friend of mine had carpal tunnel surgery in both hands (the doctor checked the other one just in case and went "eh, might as well do that one too") and one thing he was told to watch out for is to not have the wrists lay parallel to the desk for too long - so basically the default keyboard position. The reason is that in this position the bones in the arms are in a twist and that puts pressure on the tissues - most notably the nerves. Interestingly holding a gamepad or a phone in both hands is much closer to the ideal position. Personally I avoided most problems due to the fact that I've been playing the guitar since I was a teenager and this community is particularly interested in wrist and arm health, so I learned to watch out for early signs of strain and how to not overdo it early on.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- elektronaut 3y agoIdeally, you want your hands to hover while typing, not resting on your wrists. I had surgery done in one hand a year ago. It has restored my ability to do most things (like cycling or using a gamepad), but regular keyboard and mouse use is still a problem. For me, the biggest impact has been switching to a vertical mouse. That, along with a tented split keyboard allows me to work most days without aggravating my CTS.
- lonesword 3y agoI turned 30 this year and had a bout with RSI. My elbows hurt, there was pain in the back of my hand, and my little finger even started going numb if I use the phone too much. What helped: - I got the logitech MX vertical mouse. This removed the pain in the back of my hand - After being skeptical for a while, I got myself the logitech k860 ergonomic keyboard. It helped. This is of course not a long term solution, but it might help you relieve pain almost immediately. Thought I'd leave this here in case someone was one the fence about buying an ergonomic mouse/keyboard.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dottjt 3y agoThis has just been my experience with RSI (now recovered), so please take it with a grain of salt. I used to have debilitating RSI when typing. I tried everything and it just got worse over time. Stretches. Typing a certain way. Taking breaks etc. My wrist would become locked after 10 minutes of typing and stay that way for the rest of the day. I then read a book claiming that all pain is just based on expectation, so if you think it'll be painful it'll be painful, and get worse overtime as the expectation reinforces. Quite literally within the space of 5 minutes, it all went away. All gone. That was around 8 years ago and I've not had it since. Doesn't matter how long I type, in what position etc. Doesn't affect me at all. As per Acceptance and Commitment therapy (not the book, something I discovered much later) this can be defined as "the solution is the problem". When you focus on the solution, it defines itself as the problem and it simply becomes worse (think for example, someone who's overweight so eats to make themselves feel better, thereby becoming more overweight and the cycle repeating itself etc.) Interestingly, the only time my wrist gets sore is when I get really stressed. So I think there's some merit to it being a response from the brain. I think a large part of it has to do with the eastern idea of letting go. The basic idea is that suffering is a result of holding on too tightly, as opposed to observing intently. Once you observe, the suffering goes away.
- tritowntim 3y agowhich book?
- dottjt 3y agoI don't remember it was such a long time ago, but I think it might have been this book https://www.amazon.com.au/Healing-Back-Pain-Reissue-Connection/dp/153871261X/ref=sr_1_5?crid=3R91CI0V1Z5HE&keywords=back+pain&qid=1699611566&sprefix=back+pai%2Caps%2C235&sr=8-5 https://www.amazon.com.au/Healing-Back-Pain-Reissue-Connecti... Interestingly, I got the idea from a coder on his blog detailing how he literally tried everything for his RSI, and wasn't until he tried this approach that it all went away. Some people (like myself) must fail every single way before finding the solution (because we're stubborn) but this also keenly describes the idea of "the solution is the problem". It's not until we give up, do we actually find what we're looking for. I think this is what RSI represents for a lot of people. It's such a shitty experience that they literally pour all their effort to try and resolve it, not realising that it's actually making it worse and only until they let go, will it be resolved.
- neals 3y agoLots of RSI related comments. I switched my mouse from my right to my left hand 10 years ago. Fixed all my RSI issues.
- sesm 3y agoThis might be related to hand travel distance, in this case using a keyboard without numpad block or putting the mouse below the keyboard can have the same effect.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ctrlmeta 3y ago> I know I'm a bit of an emacs user, but for this I've been using visual studio code because of one extension in particular: Cursorless. Honestly want to know how many people here use Emacs like this? I thought Emacs users live their lives in Emacs. I know people who move more and more of their workflows into Emacs with packages like vterm, EAT, lsp-mode, pdf-tools, etc. Are there seriously Emacs users who only a "bit of an emacs user". What is your workflow like? How do you decide when to use Emacs and when to use other tools? VSCode and Emacs have a lot of overlap in their purpose. How does this switching in and out of tools that overlap in their purpose feel?
- dan-robertson 3y agoHow many do you know in real life? I suspect a lot of this is selection bias: the Emacs discussion you see online is often coming from fanatics rather than people who use Emacs without blogging about it.
- ctrlmeta 3y ago> How many do you know in real life? 2 emacs users and they do everything in emacs. > I suspect a lot of this is selection bias Exactly and that's why I want to know more from those who don't do everything in Emacs and how they decide when to use Emacs and when to use another editor and how mixing both editors in your life works out for you.
- dan-robertson 3y agoI use Emacs for editing computer programs (and version control, some documentation, etc), as a calculator, and for interacting with R via orgmode. I don’t use it for reading email, editing other documents (gdocs, wiki, jira, etc), browsing the web, or even interacting with shells (I might call sort from Emacs but I don’t use shell-mode or similar.
- nmcfarl 3y agoI use emacs like that. When first getting into it, 20 years ago, I was very much as described above - slowly pulling everything in my life into emacs. And then the iPhone arrived, and I started pulling out things that I wanted to do mobile: email, to do lists, and eventually notes, and recipes. Most recently, I’ve started doing JavaScript in VS code, as the LLM assistants are better than what I’ve got in emacs, but I suspect this is temporary. I find the emacs works best when it does everything, but there’s stuff it just doesn’t do, so I do that stuff elsewhere. I look outside of emacs if I think the task is going to be done mobile, and even then, I generally choose a solution that produces plain text so I can do it inside emacs if required - but sometimes that just doesn’t work out.
- gregwebs 3y agoOnce I started climbing (indoor bouldering), all my RSI pain went away- I assume due to increased strength in my forearms and hands. It was mild enough to be managed by stretching during breaks, using split keyboards (that was more for shoulder pain), and wrist straps. But those were things they had to actively do to keep it at bay, whereas now I don’t think about it anymore since it doesn’t exist anymore.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- abstractcontrol 3y agoThanks for posting this. Right now, I am grappling with RSI and I haven't been able to program for more than a few days in the past month. I am not even typing this, but using the Voice Access feature of Windows 11 in order to input this. I ordered an ergonomic keyboard (Glove80) and I am waiting for it. I also have an ergonomic mouse and even got an ergonomic chair. But I know that regardless of the case, I won't be able to program. for at least a few months. Until my hand recovers. If it does at all. I am definitely going to check out this extension. Quick question: does it work on any language or just something like Javascript?
- xena 3y agoIt works better in some languages rather than others. Python and JavaScript are the best supported. I have been working on making the situation better with go. But I demoed it with JavaScript because JavaScript is the most understandable to the largest part of my audience. Realistically half of the way to program with voice is syntax. One of the really cool parts with the voice bindings is that the voice binding for making a function is the same in every language. I am honestly quite terrible with Python. However, when I know that the default command to make a function is funky, I can just step right in there and make it work. You must crawl before you can walk. You must walk before you can run. You must run before you can fly. Welcome to the Crawling Phase.
- zubairq 3y agoVery interesting comments about pain. The comments are better than the article in this case!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mark_l_watson 3y agoJust in case this helps anyone: I didn’t have RSI, but as I approached 70, I started getting arthritis in my hands and wrists that sometimes made keyboard work unpleasant. My doctor gave me a prescription for a cream with a very high dose of THC and CBD that worked like magic for me. If I stop using the cream, a month later the discomfort returns. As far as I know, this external use cream has no bad side effects. Talk with your doctor.
- UmYeahNo 3y agoInteresting. Does the prescription have a drug name? I've been using an OTC CBD balm for bone-on-bone arthritis knee pain, but I'd love something with a bit more oomph to help reduce pain and inflammation. I'd love to be able to ask my doc about it.
- zoklet-enjoyer 3y agoLook online, you can get creams with CBD, CBG, and THC. Federally legal in the US because it's hemp derived and less than .3% THC by weight.
- UmYeahNo 3y agoRight, that's what I've been using, I was curious about the higher dose prescription version GP referred to
- zoklet-enjoyer 3y agoI don't think you'll find anything more potent than the legal limit for hemp. That would be a very high dose.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nutate 3y agoI love this and I'm super glad it's being developed, but I think I'd have to break my arm or hand (or have severe RSI) to really dive in. The startup cost seems high, mentally speaking.
- GenerocUsername 3y agoAgreed. Glad to see its being actively developed. Would use if hands became incapable
- ehsankia 3y agoI agree, but so is the start up cost of so many other tools people use such as emacs/vim, dvorak/colemak, chorded keyboards, etc. That being said, I think the biggest limiter is the fact that you can only really use this if you work from home alone, can't imagine using this anywhere outside or at the office.
- renewiltord 3y agoVimium uses a similar concept to jump around the browser.
- yewenjie 3y agoWhat is the status of Cursorless Emacs?
- thadk 3y agoIf you're also having some image loading issues, this archive.org link seems to have the images cached: https://web.archive.org/web/20231110040440/https://xeiaso.net/notes/cursorless-alien-magic/ https://web.archive.org/web/20231110040440/https://xeiaso.ne...
- xena 3y agoI'm not aware of any image loading issues, can you open the browser inspector and tell me what the fly-region header of the responses that are failing are?
- citruscomputing 3y agoIf you want a general overview of cursorless, along with seeing what it looks like in practice, the talk from Strange Loop this year was great: https://youtube.com/watch?v=NcUJnmBqHTY https://youtube.com/watch?v=NcUJnmBqHTY
- jes5199 3y agophilosophical question: is Cursorless possible because of some difference between speech and typing, or would it be possible to make a vim-mode-but-more-powerful that can do the tree-sitter stuff
- jes5199 3y agoactually I just saw that someone is working on a keyboard mode for Cursorless! https://github.com/cursorless-dev/cursorless/issues?q=is%3Aissue+is%3Aopen+keyboard+label%3Akeyboard https://github.com/cursorless-dev/cursorless/issues?q=is%3Ai...
- ouraf 3y agoThat kinda looks (sounds?) like some star trek science team member programming stuff: just talk to the mainframe and check the output
- ivanjermakov 3y agoI'm pretty sure we're yet to discover a more efficient way of manipulating syntax tree, rather than a single moving cursor.
- Kablys 3y agoDoes anyone have experience with throat microphone used for voice commands? It looks like good alternative when you want to use voice commands in public space.
- NoobSaibot135 3y agoI swear by using Apples external track pad on the left hand side with a TKL mech keyboard in the middle and mouse on the right. When one hand gets sore, just switch to the other. I get bad RSI the minute I’m not using this configuration.