7 ms·
On medieval cats
- duxup 3y agoI also have heard the stories of “the church thought cats were evil”. It always seemed a little too weird and simple to believe it was a was a wide spread teaching.
- bombcar 3y agoThere may have been complaints here and there, but in general cats were an accepted facet of life, including religious life. Stories abound about monastery cats, and you can find them in illuminated manuscripts: https://www.bangor.ac.uk/news/2022-12-23-cats-in-the-middle-ages-what-medieval-manuscripts-teach-us-about-our-ancestors-pets https://www.bangor.ac.uk/news/2022-12-23-cats-in-the-middle-...
- TomK32 3y ago*facet if I may correct you. The self-domesticated cat had and have great use to reduce vermin and medieval monastery had plenty of that as monasteries were not just spiritual places but working farms.
- dragonwriter 3y agoISTR that there are some mentions of cats in Malleus Maleficarum (the Hammer Against Witches) to which that idea is frequently traced, but, its worth noting Malleus Maleficarum was condemned by the Church (the Inquisition, specifically) shortly after it was written, and was largely written in frustration by its author—an inquisitor, himself—at his failure to get others (local ecclesiastical authorities, ecclesiastical courts, etc.) to take his crusading seriously, only becoming influential through its revival largely much later during the Renaissance, from whence it influenced witch trials.
- elzbardico 3y agoThe whole idea of medieval era as the dark ages is also profoundly uninformed.
- genman 3y agoIt was in many ways. There were of course more enlightened spaces, but the little they had was not very evenly distributed. Btw. nice trivia about cats and plague: Venetians caught cats from the mainland and took them to their islands to catch mice and rats that they knew were responsible for the plague. Therefore it was prohibited to feed the cats but there was a special rain water collector for the cats to have enough drinking water next to each Venetian rain water cistern.
- Sharlin 3y ago> It was in many ways. There were of course more enlightened spaces, but the little they had was not very evenly distributed. Eh. The Middle Ages were hardly darker than the eras preceding them, and the contrast with the Renaissance is much less stark than what the Renaissance people would have you believe. And the era spanned almost a millennium and most of Europe, and it's incredibly simplistic to sum up such a big chunk of spacetime with any single adjective. There's very little similarity between, say, 7th century Scotland, 11th century Spain, and 15th century Venice. If anything, you could call "dark" the centuries after the fall of the Western Roman Empire until the early middle ages. And obviously only from a fairly narrow Western-Europe-centric viewpoint.
- genman 3y agoNaturally. I didn't single out medieval era. And I didn't say that it was less or more dark than other historical eras, but if we compare it to what we have right now then you can't claim that it was a very enlightened age. To me the most important change over the time has been acceptance, development and distribution of science and civil rights. I personally see it more like a gradient, not an on/off switch, but the more we go back in time toward medieval era the less we have both of them.
- darkgenesha 3y agoHistory is a narrative to us like a tv show, so I think judgements based on modern values are incomplete and unfair.
- reactordev 3y agoOh how the writer was trapped by the TikTok trap. Nothing on there is real. If you heard it on TikTok, it’s probably made up. Now comes the saddest part: an entire generation thinks it’s real, it’s true, and is being manipulated by made up sh&t like culling of cats caused the Black Death. The likes drive engagement, because it seems plausibly true, it must be right? So I’ll like it too so I don’t look dumb. (trick: you’re dumb by liking it). So in the end, it’s a giant echo chamber of bad advice and made up scenarios and dance videos (because a pole would be low class) for likes and money. There’s some legit channels, like there are on YouTube or other platforms, but that’s not what GenZ is watching. They are learning bogus history, bogus politics, bogus math, and bogus job skills, through TikTok. (Maybe even intentionally, to dumb us American’s down). Who knows. I do know that more BS has come from “I heard it on TikTok” than ever in history. Even reporters are getting their “source” from “I heard it on TikTok”. It’s ridiculous. No wonder wars are raging, people are fighting, and all while making cute videos of cats while spreading 3rd grade history plausibilities. Kudos for calling them out that nowhere, in the histories, did any of that happen.
- reactordev 3y agoExample of made up scenarios: You’re a singer. You recorded a song. How do you get people to listen to your song? You make up a scenario where your S.O. is just some random person and you play the song while doing something that shows attraction. Whether it’s hitting on the girl, or vice versa, or it’s puppies or something that invokes primal responses. Meanwhile the audio plays or you say “This is my song” and you have a dozen of your friends also promote it. Sit back and watch. A few people I know did this to break into the country music scene. Guy in Truck: “Hey, you wanna hear something?” Girl running: stops (pulls ear buds out like she couldn’t hear) “Sure” (confirming it was BS the whole time). Music plays Girl: “wow this is really good!” Guy: “Thanks”, can I get your number?” Girl: blushes and gives him a blank piece of paper because they are actually secretly married.
- hammock 3y agoIt’s a con as old as medieval cats. Not new. Other examples: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nayirah_testimony https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nayirah_testimony
- ajb 3y agoInteresting that the story of cats being persecuted in the middle ages is false. This article doesn't try to trace the origin of the story. This one : https://talesoftimesforgotten.com/2019/11/05/were-cats-really-killed-en-masse-during-the-middle-ages/ https://talesoftimesforgotten.com/2019/11/05/were-cats-reall... Traces it to a book by Donald Engels, but that was only written in 2001 and I've definitely heard the story before that. I think I recall it being in 'Catwatching' by Desmond Morris which was published in 93 (but it may have been some other book from that time period). I doubt if Morris originated the story either, as he's a naturalist, not a historian. So I wonder where it came from.
- zolbrek 3y agoI believe I have Catwatching somewhere. If I manage to dig it up I'll report back in.
- ForHackernews 3y agoIs it fake? I guess this was the early modern era, not middle ages: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Great_Cat_Massacre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Great_Cat_Massacre
- rsynnott 3y agoSee the concerns at the bottom of Methodology; I think all you can _really_ read into this is that the idea was in the aether by 1984. (Even _if_ the event described happened, it was clearly exceptional, and _even with that in mind_ doesn't support the idea that people in The Olden Days (TM) were afraid of cats; the printer is _keeping_ cats).
- rsynnott 3y agoIn Blackadder 1 (early 80s) it's already a part of pop culture enough to be referenced. I think it's pretty old, I suspect 19th century (which is where a lot of modern pop culture ideas about the 'dark ages' solidified).
- ajb 3y ago
- jibbit 3y agoi wish i could understand how cats became so popular, given -> Fleas. As far as i can tell, anti-flea treatments have existed for about 50 years. I get that catching mice is a huge plus, but a house full of fleas also kinda sucks.
- CuriouslyC 3y agoIndoor cats is a newish thing. Farm cats were outdoor creatures that slept in the barn or another enclosure. Outdoor cats catch rodents and have basically no downsides.
- jjgreen 3y agoFarm cats are hard bastards. I stopped in a friend's farm for a couple of days, each morning there would be a half-rabbit on the doorstep (the back half) by way of a "present".
- dragonwriter 3y agoRats, like cats, have fleas that bite humans, too, and while cats mostly don't kill rats the way they do mice, they do drive them away.
- CapitalistCartr 3y agoCats kill rodents, protecting stored grain. And parasites were a fact of life.
- euroderf 3y ago... and grain cultivation & storage became a necessity when brewing was figured out.
- Hizonner 3y agoIt doesn't suck as much as starving to death, which could happen if the rodents went crazy on your food supplies. Anyway, if your house is loaded with mice and rats, you will also have fleas. Unlike the rodents, your cat will even let you comb it. Also people weren't necessarily clear on fleas or whatever being something you caught. They were more seen as things that just showed up under certain circumstances.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- throwawaaarrgh 3y agoIt's so funny how people are shocked at disinformation and how well it works. We're still the same stupid hairless monkeys in hats that we were a thousand years ago. We still believe in imaginary all-powerful father figures living in the clouds, silently judging you. We believe in and fund huge markets for homeopathic (i.e. fake) "medicine", to the point that we grant the title "doctor" after being certified for "Osteopathic Manipulative Therapy", a pseudoscience. We believe that politicians we vote for are actually going to do what they say they're going to do, and every time, we're surprised when they don't. Humans are fucking stupid, and it's very easy to get them to believe bullshit. We are only slightly harder to trick than a dog.
- macNchz 3y agoThere’s something about the images here that makes me feel a more direct human association with the time–the silly doodle of a cat dressed as a monk, the drawing of a cat waiting expectantly for scraps from a dining table. I’ve always liked learning about the distant past, but often it can feel a little abstract, hard to comprehend just how different life was, but I love little details like this that make it feel like I can relate to people from hundreds of years ago at some basic level.
- TMWNN 3y ago4chan on medieval cats <https://np.reddit.com/r/4chan/comments/137pve9/the_absolute_state_of_polcats/ https://np.reddit.com/r/4chan/comments/137pve9/the_absolute_...>
- cat_plus_plus 3y agoMaybe renaissance generation just cancelled their medieval ancestors to feel superior with themselves and now we are missing a treasure trove of culture? Plus they had a huge pandemic that screwed up their economy.
- hef19898 3y agoA pandemic of truely apocalyptic proportions at that.
- rpastuszak 3y agoSome of those cats work in my editorial team! https://tidings.potato.horse/team https://tidings.potato.horse/team