8 ms·
Even a non-golden era can have something truly valuable. Btw, we are living in a golden age. The vast majority of humanity has never had it better.
by eru 3y ago
Even a non-golden era can have something truly valuable.
Btw, we are living in a golden age. The vast majority of humanity has never had it better.
- chx 3y ago> we are living in a golden age I would've agreed pre-covid.
- Eisenstein 3y agoLess than 130 years ago 47% of all children in the USA died before reaching age 5. I think that we are doing just fine even with covid.
- dopidopHN 3y agoA lot of folks are hungry in my state. As in : not enough nutrient a day. https://www.cpex.org/blog/stateofhunger https://www.cpex.org/blog/stateofhunger
- jannes 3y agoDoes COVID still exist meaningfully in your part of the world? In my country the first few waves were very strong, but after a successful vaccination campaign (among other things) COVID has completely disappeared in everybody’s daily lives.
- BHSPitMonkey 3y agoI think they are referring less to the actual virus and more to the rapid deterioration of our discourse and politics that accompanied it. Or at least this is what I might mean when using "COVID" as an epoch.
- TerrifiedMouse 3y ago> rapid deterioration of our discourse and politics that accompanied it That has been happening way before Covid. IMHO it started with the internet. Pre-internet the flow of information is gatekept by traditional media - newspapers, radio, TV, … etc. Everyone watched, listened to, read more or less the same things. This resulted in a more uniform set of opinions and more common ground between people. The internet broke all that. People could choose what they watch/listen/read and different people picked different things, coming to very different conclusions. In the past you could ask someone if they watched X last night and there is a decent probability they did. Today it’s much harder to find common ground - you could both be on YouTube but watching completely different things. Edit: Don’t just downvote. You got a problem with this post, say something.
- 2devnull 3y agoI agree it was happening before COVID. I think the internet could be part of the problem. But it wasn’t freedom of choice that caused the problem, which is what you claim. There’s much less freedom on the internet now, and if anything it’s much worse. If we’re going to blame internet then blame ads and big tech. Don’t blame people for watching cat videos, that’s absurd.
- TerrifiedMouse 3y ago
- DonHopkins 3y agoCOVID is what saved us from four more years of Trump (and perhaps many more after that of his family and Rudy Giuliani and Sidney Powell and Steven Miller and Steve Bannon and the list goes on and on...).
- junofan 3y agoMaybe you’re thinking of a “gilded age” in the sense of Twain. The Golden Age of Hesiod and Ovid was defined by peace and justice amongst a golden race. It’s about ideals and peace rather than material prosperity. The metals debase from gold to silver to bronze to iron as conflict increases and the social contract breaks.
- Emma_Goldman 3y ago'Golden age' is typically used to mean a historic age of comparative greatness from which society has since fallen. See the idiomatic vs. the mythological meaning on Wiktionary: https://en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/golden_age https://en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/golden_age
- Emma_Goldman 3y agoThat's a bit simplistic. If you haven't noticed, advanced economies are experiencing secularly stagnating growth, a crisis of democratic representation and its populist backlash, the return of oligarchic inequality to levels not seen since the gilded age, and extreme social atomisation and mental health breakdown. We are also all hurtling towards catastrophic climate change, an AI revolution that could lead to generalised technological unemployment, and some indeterminate level of conflict between the US and China. Unsurprisingly, therefore, most people in advanced economies look back on the post-war decades as a golden age - obviously there were problems, but there was high growth, full employment, good public services, strong unions, and comparatively cheap housing. Others look back to the 1990s as a time of untroubled horizons. Also, the global 'we' is unhelpful. Have native Americans, Syrians or Greeks never had it so good?
- vasco 3y ago> Also, the global 'we' is unhelpful. Have native Americans, Syrians or Greeks never had it so good? Syrians are starving and in war, so they've been better. The other two examples, undoubtedly yes they are better than ever. For anyone to think it was better in any other time in history for most of the global population than now, shows such a lack of knowledge of history and the human condition that its hard to take serious. For someone so concerned with the future of humanity to create a problem with referring to all humans as "we" is a bit rich. Scrolling instagram and fake depressions aren't worse than having 7 miscarriages, half your kids dying as babies or children, being enslaved, starving to death and a million other nice things most humans had to deal with that they don't have to deal with now. Basic access to medicine, food stability etc, on a large scale is so much better. We have the fewest people living in poverty there ever was. Wanting to better ourselves and being aware the Maslow hierarchy continues to create infinite steps should not blind you to the amount of work millions of humans over generations have done to create such an easy mode version of the world for us. To not at least acknowledge it and just say it all sucks is myopic at the minimum.
- Emma_Goldman 3y agoRead the first sentence with which I began. I said it was simplistic, not that it was categorically and completely wrong, and certainly not that its opposite was true. What I object to is the extraordinarily simplistic, one-dimensional view of progress peddled by the likes of Hans Rosling and Steven Pinker. True, lot's of material and medical indicators of progress have consistently increased. That's to be celebrated. Certainly, if asked, the vast majority of people in the West would want to be born in the post-war years, and the average would probably slant towards the end of that period. Though I do think a good slice of people would choose against the post-2008 years in particular. But that binary - better or worse? - is a crude measure of societal health. It lacks any dialectical sense of modernity, of that fact the same socio-technological expansion which brought about that progress, has gone hand-in-hand with extreme oligarchy, world war, nuclear weapons, climate change, the anthropocene. Certainly, the risks of catastrophic global breakdown are greater today than ever before. I also think it has a superficial and philistine grasp of politics and the common good. Besides utilitarians, few political philosophers would so easily equate the good with material abundance. Hence why I pointed, by way of counterpoint, to today's secular stagnation, crisis of democracy, inequality, and withering of public life. These are not small problems, but speak to fundamental pathologies in our body politic. > "The other two examples, undoubtedly yes they are better than ever." Many native Americans and Greeks would viscerally disagree with you. Perhaps you're missing something? > "For anyone to think it was better in any other time in history for most of the global population than now, shows such a lack of knowledge of history and the human condition that its hard to take serious." As above, you have misread what I said, and I think trying to understand and evaluate society solely from the binary standard of 'better or worse' is extremely crude. I have a PhD in history btw. >"Scrolling instagram and fake depressions aren't worse than having 7 miscarriages, half your kids dying as babies or children, being enslaved, starving to death." True, but I think virtually no one would say otherwise. This is an unhelpful caricature of the argument I was making.
- concordDance 3y agoTrue, but the rates of depression and general unhappiness in the West are definitely up from 30 years ago.
- dotancohen 3y agoNo, there is more awareness and they are more vocal now.
- theclansman 3y agoThat's an extremely simplistic way to dismiss the problem. Depression wasn't something that was invented or discovered in the last decade.
- WilTimSon 3y agoBut openness about mental health issues and lower stigma around it is definitely a more modern thing, actually. I don't doubt that some subsets of the population got more depressed while others feel better, but it's very possible that rates would have been the same 30 years ago, had people felt okay with talking about suicidal thoughts, depression or a variety of other things that are at least a bit less stigmatised now. I'm not that old (or at least I like to think I'm not) but I can say with confidence nobody in my circle of friends 25 years ago would even think of saying they're depressed or suicidal. That would get you labelled a weirdo.
- codebolt 3y agoWrong. The rates are higher and the main reason is obvious. Fewer families being formed => more lonely adults => more people depressed.
- pmarreck 3y agoYou know what would instantly greatly help online debates like this? Actual data.
- pdntspa 3y agoThat "golden age" is a huge cop-out for any topic that doesn't span hundreds of years
- nicky0 3y agoMaterially, we've never had it better. Spiritually, we are in a deep crisis.
- eru 3y agoWhere we ever less in a spiritual crisis? How do you measure these things? And who is 'we'?
- master-lincoln 3y agoDepends on your definition of "we" There are regions where the opposite happened. E.g. native tribes who were expelled for resources
- nicky0 3y agoMissing the point.
- virtualritz 3y agoThe issue is the definition of 'better'. If you think access to food, medication, education, higher life expectancy, then yes. IMHO though, a more fitting defition of 'better' for the human condition is the amount of happiness you experience while being alife (i.e. decoupled from life expectancy). I would then conclude (and I am really happy to be proved wrong) that the developed world being/becoming better is considerably more difficult to argue for. Depression and sucidides in first world countries, the ones that tick all the intial boxes, are a highs not experienced since WWII. [1] is just from a quick googling and US-only. You won't have trouble finding much more evidence to support this though, for many other 1st world countries. I would bet there is a direct link to this; between making GPD the driving factor for a country's governance vs. e.g. happiness of its citizens. Look no further than Scandinavian countries (Norway is the exeption, not declining but at least also not increasing)[2]. [1] https://time.com/5609124/us-suicide-rate-increase/ https://time.com/5609124/us-suicide-rate-increase/ [2] https://tidsskriftet.no/en/2019/08/kronikk/why-suicide-rate-not-declining-norway https://tidsskriftet.no/en/2019/08/kronikk/why-suicide-rate-...
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y ago> a more fitting defition of 'better' for the human condition is the amount of happiness So, instead of measuring the objective/empirical things that: 1. Keep people alive 2. Keep them from going hungry 3. Make them healthy and pain-free 4. Keep them warm (or cool, where appropriate) 5. Etc etc etc You instead are suggesting that we measure some subjective mood that no one can define well, test for, or detect with instrumentation? That would be the better measure? > Depression and sucidides in first world countries, the ones that tick all the intial boxes, are a highs I would not argue that these are insignificant, but there are methodological problems with both. Suicide may have been traditionally undercounted for religious reasons. If you're investigating a suicide in the 1950s, it might just have been a gun-cleaning accident instead. Saves the family grief, means the deceased can be buried in the cemetery the family wants, etc. Depression, while real, might still be subject to the sort of contagious hypochondriac panics that describe the late 20th century and early 21st so well. Or, alternatively... it might have been undercounted until recently. We're not seeing an increase so much as that people are merely aware of it.
- 3y ago
- tim333 3y ago>The vast majority of humanity has never had it better There has been a general upswing since 1600 or so, so you could say that about most years since then, at least in economic terms. In terms of happiness it seems kind of flat though.