9 ms·
The housing market is starting to crack – Sellers are cutting prices
- findthewords 3y agoGood news — housing prices are becoming more affordable.
- xnx 3y agoYes, but most home affordability is in terms of monthly payment. These price drops are probably delayed reaction to the interest rate increases from the past few months.
- standardUser 3y agoThis seems temporary, assuming interest rates have topped out. Given the Fed's recent messaging, this seems like the most obvious time in 10+ years to wait out the housing market.
- vkou 3y agoWhy? What is going to happen next year, that makes waiting good?
- MarcoZavala 3y ago[dead]
- standardUser 3y agoThe Fed stopped raising interest rates, so we may be at the peak of mortgage rates.
- stetrain 3y agoGood.
- 23B1 3y agohttps://archive.is/908kf https://archive.is/908kf and Non paywalled article: https://finance.yahoo.com/news/housing-market-starting-crack-sellers-221220807.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/housing-market-starting-crack...
- lastofthemojito 3y agoI've noticed this anecdotally over the past few weeks in my town. After a couple of years of houses being listed on Thursday, shown over the weekend, in-contract for above asking price the following Tuesday, houses have finally begun to sit on the market for several weeks. And I've seen gasp a couple of asking price reductions. Too soon to tell if this is the beginning of a minor correction or a major bubble burst, but it definitely feels like we've entered a new phase.
- derekp7 3y agoI think that was the main reason for higher interest rates -- it makes the monthly payments higher, which pushes down the total home price. But it only works if there is inventory. And inventory only happens when people are in a "forced sell" position, such as needing to relocate for their job (back to office push for example). A lack of inventory typically will also spur on new construction, but even in areas where construction can happen there is the compounding issue of higher timber prices. So with lumber prices coming down, that should relieve the inventory shortage (again, in areas where land isn't too high and new builds are allowed to happen). The problem I have with this is that regular people that have to mortgage the house don't get any better deal (higher interest == higher monthly payments), but the forced price reduction does give a better deal to anyone who can pay cash (investors for example).
- vkou 3y agoYou can refi your low-principal, high-interest mortgage later, if interest rates ever come down. You can't renegotiate your high-principal, low-interest mortgage later. (Well, you can, if rates go up, but why would you want to?)
- fragmede 3y agolook into mortgage recasting.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Wistar 3y agoIn the 20 or so years I have lived on a small dead-end street with about 16 homes, and where homes that went on the market sold within the first three days and sometimes the first three hours, it has only been in the last 60 days that I have seen a house where the sellers have twice cut the price by greater than 10% each time and the house yet languishes unsold.
- deathanatos 3y agoAnd I went to an open house and the home had already sold.
- rednerrus 3y agoLast year the market tanked pretty hard coming into November and December.
- jollyllama 3y agoThe messaging is different this time, so the result will be different.
- Flatcircle 3y agosomething that could happen with housing that hasn't happened in a while... Market goes sideways for a ~ decade
- nikanj 3y agoFundamentally we are still not building more homes where more people would like to live, so my optimism is very limited
- foobarian 3y agoBut... it's a chicken and egg problem. People only want to live there because it's nice and uncrowded.
- stillwithit 3y agoFortune is engagement farming. Still not building enough, and the market always cools in winter. Big Tech isn’t killing the internet. All the Ferengi that went into engagement farming are with their clickbait.
- jasondc 3y ago+1, Spring is the real test, every winter prices go down
- Modified3019 3y agoThe cynicism is both appropriate and appreciated. The housing market hasn’t meaningfully changed until I stop seeing every single story 1k sq-ft, 2-3 bedroom 1-2 bath house being listed for over half a goddamn million dollars in a 70k pop city. I started waiting for the market to crash 10 years ago, and I’m likely going to keep waiting for at least as long, barring a catastrophic economy collapse, which would be even less desirable than the current situation.
- Lucasoato 3y agoI've thought a lot about this, without finding any comprehensive solution. The housing market suffers from inadequate regulation, allowing speculation and profit-making through the mass purchase of properties and subsequent rental hikes. We need safeguards against such practices; perhaps home ownership shouldn't just be a right but a condition actively safeguarded and championed.
- cynicauliflower 3y agoI don’t know, none of the houses I want to buy are in neighborhoods where any substantial portion of the stock is available to rent. Is there evidence of this kind of “profit-making”? (Not disputing just no experience personally).
- Etheryte 3y agoIn many first world capitals, it's actually a common investment to buy real estate and not rent it out at all. The running costs are lower, there's no maintenance costs and no one pesters you about miscellaneous issues. All these people do is sit on the homes and wait for them to go up in price while everyone else struggles to find a place to live. Them not renting out reduces supply which further drives up prices. You don't see them up for rent because that's not the business they're in, they're in the buy-hold-sell business instead. It's a good example of ridiculously perverse incentives, and why the regulation needs to be changed to make this a thing of the past.
- cynicauliflower 3y agoI could also believe this, but it’s not the claim OP made, which was about rental hikes.
- Etheryte 3y agoWhile I see what you mean, these two phenomena are really two sides of the same coin. If I'd wager a guess, I'd say OP is probably referring to cases such as [0]. Regardless of which mechanism is at play though, the end result is the same, either rising prices through collusion or rising prices through lowered supply. Both also benefit anyone else doing it the other way, so it results in highly lopsided markets. [0] https://www.axios.com/2023/11/02/dc-housing-rent-antitrust-lawsuit https://www.axios.com/2023/11/02/dc-housing-rent-antitrust-l...
- ramesh31 3y agoBring it on. I can't wait to buy a house in the next 6 months. People with money who want desperately out of the renting game don't care at all about 8% interest rates. But the investors and second home buyers sure do. This has been the biggest thing keeping me out of the market since 2020; the time pressure, not the prices. I just refuse to make a massive financial decision on the spot based on a 15 minute open house tour with zero contigencies and huge earnest payments.
- metamet 3y ago> But the investors and second home buyers sure do. I'm curious about this, because from what I've heard, a lot of investors are incredibly happy with the higher interest rates as they're paying cash for a lot of homes, which has been squeezing real homeowners out of the market since they are able to shortcut by making offers on houses without requiring financing.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- quickthrowman 3y agoThe higher the risk-free rate goes, the less attractive housing is as an investment. Treasuries don’t require maintenance and upkeep.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoNo investors are paying cash for homes. The entire real estate game is about maximizing leverage with the massive home loans you can get.
- metamet 3y agoThey absolutely are. I have multiple friends who received cash offers from investment companies when selling their homes. It's fairly common and well known. "We buy houses" companies are everywhere. It's their entire strategy.
- deathanatos 3y ago> Existing-home prices are on their seventh consecutive month of growth, […] Average U.S. existing home prices are up by nearly 6% year-to-date and 2.6% year-over-year, which is “well above the median full calendar year increase” in more than three decades of data, […] > housing affordability has become abysmal for a large portion of millennials and other people of prime homebuying age, “sidelining potential buyers,” > a prospective homebuyer needs to make $114,627 to afford a home in today’s market, which is a 15% year-over-year increase and the highest annual income on record needed to comfortably buy a home. … yes, because slight more homes had to lower their price, the cracks are really showing. Were those home lowering to a price point still on a market price curve pointed squarely at the moon, or were these buyers trying to flip a home 2 months after buying it and doing 0 renovations (a listing I have seen more and more often recently) and hoping to get rich quick?
- bryanlarsen 3y agoOn CNBC today: Mortgage rates plunge and demand finally inches back https://www.cnbc.com/2023/11/08/mortgage-rates-plunge-and-demand-finally-inches-back.html https://www.cnbc.com/2023/11/08/mortgage-rates-plunge-and-de...
- wolverine876 3y agoUnless the Fed cuts rates, how can mortgage rates plunge? Is CNBC doing it's old (and maybe continuing) cheerleading?
- quickthrowman 3y agoMortgage rates mostly track the 10y yield, not the federal funds rate. As I understand it, avg US mortgage duration is 9-10y which is why mortgage rates track the US10Y yield. The Fed doesn’t directly control the 10y yield like they do the federal funds rate
- HDThoreaun 3y agoThe fed absolutely has control over treasury yields. They're by far the biggest buyer of all the treasuries through their open market operations. By buying more or less they can change the price.
- quickthrowman 3y agoI’m aware that open market operations affect the 10y yield, my point was that the market has more influence over the 10y yield than the federal funds rate.
- glimshe 3y agoSurprise, surprise. The historical housing bubble was caused by artificially low interest rates adopted worldwide. Ever-increasing housing prices is bad for people who own homes (higher property taxes, property tax distortions across cities, higher fees when changing houses) and those who don't own any. Low interest rates discourage saving and encourage unproductive speculation and house flipping. The people benefitting from the status quo are only those who make money off trading and borrowing fees (banks, realtors), and the occasional person who left a high price area to a low price area.
- hemloc_io 3y agoYou're missing one more demographic that's a pretty big deal. California homeowners insulated from property tax due to prop 13.
- eweise 3y agoCalifornia homeowners pay property tax and the rate goes up either with inflation or 2%. I'm guessing you think it should go up with the market value of the home. Thank god it doesn't or I would have had to sell instead of being able to give my kids a stable home for the past 18 years.
- hemloc_io 3y agoLate to the party here, but yeah 100% I believe in property tax like more or less every other state has done. The way California has done property tax is hilariously bad, commercial properties get no cost basis step up forever? until recently People can inherit property with infinite value without a reassessment? come on. Imo prop 13 is at the root of most of the state's problems. The reason people lobby for prop 13, particularly older property owners who vote, is because of the appreciation you mentioned. That should not be happening in the first place, because the state should not systemically under-build housing. The government policies which cause that underbuilding are lobbied for by the same demographic that enjoys the benefits of prop 13. If it's for personal preference in lifestyle or a quest for artificially increasing home value it doesn't matter there's no reason to create an aristocracy in California. We need to change those policies so we can build enough housing supply to meet demand, and treat housing like a commodity good that it is. Instead of this absurd game where we underbuild on purpose and patch over the issues to the best of our ability for the benefit of a relatively small supply of homeowners who bare none of the social costs.
- jeffreyrogers 3y agoUnless the housing supply increases this will just be a temporary thing. As long as people are able to make their mortgage payments they typically won't sell their homes at a loss (even if their equity is negative). Some people will always be forced to sell due to life events and that's what will set current market comps. Since mortgage rates have recently spiked upwards people who need a mortgage to buy a home can afford less, so they either aren't buying or are buying a smaller/worse home than they would've previously. But since most people aren't forced to sell, the available supply will shrink, which will push up prices eventually, until people can sell at a profit again. The rising rates also make it harder for developers to get loans, and lower prices make development projects riskier, compounding the supply problem.
- mnky9800n 3y agoThere should just be a pandemic or something that puts a lot of people out of work so that they have to sell at low prices so that large real estate companies can buy their houses and then rent them back to them. They can even have a reverse rental program that allows people to stay in their homes through the hard times and instead pay rent to the new owners.
- nilespotter 3y agoDid that actually happen?
- westmeal 3y agoIn so many words yes, it's just a little oversimplified for humor.
- jfengel 3y agoI'm afraid I don't follow that. House-sellers are generally also house-buyers. They move out of one place into another. It's neutral with respect to supply. If there's a glut of people owning houses but not living in them and not successfully renting them, then that does reduce supply, but they're also suffering opportunity cost. If they're willing to throw away money like that I don't think increasing supply would help -- they'd just buy up the new houses as well.
- lenerdenator 3y agoIt won't matter for Millennials trying to buy their first homes. I'm seeing single-family houses going for $310k that should be going for maybe 2/3rds of that on a good day. Typically they're flipped houses. If you were to bring down the value of every single-family home in the US, that means accepting about 2/3rds the value of each of these mortgages, along with all of the securitized derivatives of them. That's a 2007-2009-level crash, which the banks just won't tolerate. The far more likely play is that large regional, national, or international investors wait for the price to drop a little more and use what is basically an infinite pile of money to buy them up for speculation or rental stock, which will keep this problem going.
- lastofthemojito 3y ago> I'm seeing single-family houses going for $310k that should be going for maybe 2/3rds of that on a good day. I've been hearing a lot of "should be" talk like that recently - like folks complaining that people are paying $50k for a normal SUV that "should be" $30k or whatever. What are we basing "should be" on? Some affordability metric? Our gut feeling about what a comparable thing cost a few years ago? If I sold my house and someone told me I should have sold it for 2/3 of what I sold it for, I think I'd sit in stunned silence for a moment and then just laugh.
- res0nat0r 3y agoI'm guessing that is the case. Condos next door that cost $210k before covid now in the exact same spot three years alter asking for $630k is probably making people ask questions about the market.
- lenerdenator 3y agoIt's a 60+ year-old single-family, single-garage home within eye (and more importantly, ear) shot of a major interstate highway next to the home of a man who has a number of city code violations due to the state of his property (think rank weeds, cracked paint, tires in the yard, etc.) in a major Midwestern city where the average household income is ~$56,000. When you consider who this kind of housing was built for - younger married couples with two children - the problem becomes apparent. You can't cover COL, costs of raising children, a mortgage on a $310k house at 7% interest, an auto loan note at the same, and student loan debt on $56k household income. Wages are stagnant, so something has to go. Typically, it's the idea of children or the idea of owning a house. This has implications for the economy 20 years from now. There won't be as many consumers and workers to participate in the market, and those that do exist are likely to have access to less generational wealth because their parents were more likely to rent than to own. Neither bodes well for economic growth or stability. That's what I mean by "should cost" - a value that allows for a seller to sell a home at a reasonable price to a party that wishes to carry out the life stage activities that provide for future economic growth.
- m3kw9 3y agoHow many times have I heard that, but they keep calling it till it really collapses. What you should look for is if a certain mid sized bank gets into deep shit because they are left holding a big bag of failed mortgages
- kasey_junk 3y agoBanks don’t typically hold mortgages. They sell them off. Mostly to Fannie and Freddie but also as securities. Those securities defaulting are a trailing indicator of price as you need a mortgage to be underwater (or mass economic failure) for a mortgage to fail.
- francisofascii 3y agoIn my neighborhood the houses currently on Zillow do show price cuts, but honestly all these houses have significant issues. The move in ready houses are sold the weekend they go on sale or even before that.
- hellohihello135 3y agoEvery year housing market goes thru a seasonal slow down during fall and winter. And every year media companies think the market is collapsing.
- whoomp12341 3y agoStarting to crack = just regularly high home prices, not super duper high home prices
- analyte123 3y agoAlmost all folk discussion of the recent housing boom will include the words "Blackrock" or "Wall Street", but investors with less than 100 units own the overwhelming majority of the 24% of houses purchased by investors [1]. The 2017 tax cuts introduced several provisions favorable to real estate investors that in my opinion accelerated the blow-up when mortgage rates were cut to well below the inflation rate during the pandemic, already a massive stimulus. Bonus depreciation allowed you to buy a used, already depreciated rental property and deduct its entire value from your taxable income in the first year [2]. Theoretically you have to pay this back when you sell, but not if you exchange it for another property (1031). This is being phased down and will be only 60% starting in January. Second, pass-through deduction allowed buyers of rental property to deduct the rent from their W2 income up to 20% of their gross income, as long as you declare that you spent a certain amount of time managing the property [3]. This is due to expire in 2025. Third, large parts of the US were designated as "opportunity zones" where gains are tax free if held for 10 years and improvements are made [4]. All this, combined with consumer stimulus, increased remote work, major swings in domestic migration and household composition [5], and you have red-hot housing prices. [1] https://scrippsnews.com/stories/corporate-investors-are-purchasing-more-single-family-homes/ https://scrippsnews.com/stories/corporate-investors-are-purc... [2] https://tax.thomsonreuters.com/en/glossary/bonus-depreciation https://tax.thomsonreuters.com/en/glossary/bonus-depreciatio... [3] https://www.bakertilly.com/insights/new-regulations-provide-rental-real-estate-safe-harbor-for-20-percent-pass/ https://www.bakertilly.com/insights/new-regulations-provide-... [4] https://www.nar.realtor/qualified-opportunity-zones https://www.nar.realtor/qualified-opportunity-zones [5] https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/notes/feds-notes/the-remarkable-recent-rebound-in-household-formation-and-the-prospects-for-future-housing-demand-20220506.html https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/notes/feds-notes/the-...
- bequanna 3y agoNo crash until supply even starts to approach demand. This is likely a minor seasonal correction. We’re nowhere near that. Only chance of this happening in the near term is sharp increase unemployment.