3 ms·
The challenge there is that "protect the children" and "terrorists" weigh more heavily on a moral level than "protect my privacy".
by Cthulhu_ 3y ago
The challenge there is that "protect the children" and "terrorists" weigh more heavily on a moral level than "protect my privacy".
- lopis 3y agoBad actors can use this to actively harm children by intercepting their communication with their friends and family and putting them at risk. No need to even change arguments.
- Jcowell 3y agothis is too technical , you need to be broader and more fear mongering: Bad actors will use the this to find children to harm.
- Kim_Bruning 3y ago"Burning down the village in order to save it. " [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_B%E1%BA%BFn_Tre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_B%E1%BA%BFn_Tre
- pif 3y agoThe real challenge is that none of the ones screaming "protect my privacy" can offer a solution to "protect the children" as well.
- jermaustin1 3y agoThe real challenge is getting people screaming "protect the children" to provide evidence that "the children" actually need protection in a meaningful way that also reduces the privacy of everyone.
- seanw444 3y agoWe continue to put responsibility on the government to fix our problems, when many of them nowadays are societal and cultural. You can't slap on a law to fix immorality and lack of wisdom. All you do is restrict the moral and wise. I hope we return to holding parents responsible for raising their kids properly. The world they face now is a terrifying and disgusting colossus, and facing it cannot be done without moral and wise future generations.
- kelseyfrog 3y agoWe've been asking the pedophiles to stop, but that hasn't been working so far.
- seanw444 3y agoI don't see the relevance to my point here.
- vb-8448 3y agoSo, since there is not a good solution[1] to "protect the children", let's screw up everyone's privacy (and security) ... seems a reasonable tread off to me. [1] actually I don't think that is true, but let suppose so
- eimrine 3y agoSo the children are going to be both less protected and... ought to be educated enough not to produce photos which might cast CSAM willing to protect them from themselves. [1] Let me guess, the "good solution" you claimed as existing has been described by you already.
- Freak_NL 3y agoWith the current batch of proposals the child (teenager usually) making home-made porn¹ would get flagged and in the worst case scenario get marked as a CSAM producer or end up on some indelible list of sexual predators depending on the jurisdiction. Can you imagine what will happen next? For what? Doing what their hormones made them do without harming anyone? Educate them, absolutely. Monitor their every move online because they might do something stupid? That's an option I would like to limit to their parents/guardians, if it all, not any state or bigtech corporation, and certainly not any automated flagging system. 1: Not CSAM; let's limit this line of thought to consensually made porn.
- toast0 3y agoAfaik, scanning approaches are checking images against known images. It's not an image classifier, it's a perceptual hash. Of course, possessing or distributing images of underage naked people can get you on a sex offender list, even if that naked person is you. That's a different issue.
- Freak_NL 3y agoIt's a black-box, and unverifiable by design. With a false flag sufficing to ruin your life, I'd rather take no chances for a nebulously defined benefit. In the end all this does is mark those apps participating as unsafe for people who do, incredibly, feel safe now to post such images through a service like WhatsApp or IMessage (do these people even exist?). They'll use something else, and the people you do catch are just idiots and teenagers. And that false flag event is hardly far-fetched with the extremely broad definition CSAM has. I'm pretty sure that if a parent photographs their 13 year old daughter proudly posing in her new bikini on the beach, and sends it to grandma who naively posts it on Facebook, where someone downloads it for their personal sexual gratification, then posts it on some image hosting site for bragging rights, where it gets hoovered up for the great CSAM database because that site was filled with photos of scantily clad children, and now when the partner of the above parent asks them to send those photos they took of their daughter on the beach for the holiday photo-album they're making, and boom, they are on a list. Unlikely? With unaccountable processes and black-box databases things like this will happen, and that is excluding the likelihood of bugs happening (which is inevitable).
- jeltz 3y agoProtecting the children is easy. Just have parental controls which can be installed by the parents. The real problem they want to solve is most likely organized crime and terrorism, plus on son countries political dissent.
- LudwigNagasena 3y agoProtect the children from what? There are lots of solutions for concrete problems.
- johngladtj 3y agoA solution isn't required.
- pif 3y agoTo the downvoters and commenters who do not get that "the children" is just a straw man: The issue at hand can be described very, very easily: law enforcement agencies' mission is going to get harder to fulfil if they lose the possibility to wiretap suspects. The solution is, unfortunately, not that easy! Now, HNers can cry their lungs out that mathematics forbid a perfectly safe backdoor and what not, but they are missing the point: they are simply ignoring the question and lacking any respect for the people posing it in the first place. The issue exist; and it makes sense. Furthermore, wire-tapping has always been accepted, at least as a necessary evil, by democracies all over the world. At the same time, absolute remote privacy has never existed, much less been guaranteed. E2EE is a big game changer, and you expect people with governing responsibility to just ignore it?
- Kalium 3y agoAt the risk of being very directly contrarian: is it? Is it actually getting harder for law enforcement? Do we have evidence of E2EE harming cases, hurting conviction rates, or similar? At this point in time law enforcement has been routinely dealing with and lawfully overcoming encryption for several decades. Encryption is no longer a novelty law enforcement has no idea how to deal with. I understand that law enforcement officers may sincerely believe that encryption makes their jobs more difficult and thus the public less secure. Since they are public officials, I am happy to accept their claims as truth. I just need to see supporting evidence. At that point we can begin to weight public safety against privacy. Until then, I can only consider a demonstrable loss of privacy against a purely hypothetical impairment of law enforcement functionality. Speaking only and solely for myself, I in no way expect people with governing responsibility to ignore end to end encryption. I do expect them to ask questions when people with a demonstrated capacity to function in the presence of E2EE claim it is making their jobs too difficult.
- pif 3y ago> At the risk of being very directly contrarian Please, be! Discussion is welcome. What I despise is only immature people ignoring important societal issues with a sweep of their hands, while crying a void "because privacy".
- caskstrength 3y ago> The real challenge is that none of the ones screaming "protect my privacy" can offer a solution to "protect the children" as well. Sure we do! Use parental controls to prevent your children from using any e2e messaging services.
- seanw444 3y agoParents taking responsibility for what their kids do online, and taking their protection into their own hands? Blasphemy. That's what we have the government for.
- Kim_Bruning 3y agoWhat makes (E2E)E so special that it protects adults, spies, dissidents, police, soldiers, politicians, people under police protection ... but doesn't protect children? It protects children. Removing protection doesn't protect children.
- Kim_Bruning 3y agoRemember that teenagers also count as children. They occasionally do -ah- dumb things. Do you really want to rip back the veil of privacy on teenagers?
- jalapenos 3y ago"Protect my children's privacy"?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Scarblac 3y agoProtect children's privacy!
- wongarsu 3y agoJust rephrase it as "Keep the government out of my affairs". It's not just "protect my privacy" though, it's also "protect my ability to organize against the government", which in the US heavily overlaps with the second amendment and the rhetoric about it. In a more globally appealing version, you can spin that into various forms of "This is what the Communists did to prevent people from rising against them" (replace Communists with Nazis, if desired). Or reference V for Vendetta or 1984 or other cult classics.
- r3trohack3r 3y agoIt does not weigh heavier, and I wish people would stop repeating this. Our governments wield extreme power and we have a moral imperative to keep checks and balances in place so that power is not abused. A pedophile with a laptop and a camera is terrible. A Senator without the 4th amendment is worse. A racist with a social media account is terrible. A President without the 1st amendment is worse.
- ThrowAway1922A 3y ago> It does not weigh heavier, and I wish people would stop repeating this. They keep saying it because to most people they absolutely do weigh heavier. Very, very few average people are going to agree with what you just said.
- r3trohack3r 3y agoI keep getting told that, that very few people agree with what I just said. Every conversation I’ve had IRL on these points, after the initial negative reaction to what I just said, progresses into mutual understanding that an organized government is the ultimate threat when left unchecked - and that these rights are core to the system that protects us from that power structure. It protects us from the very same people who are telling us to “think of the children.” When Feinstein and co. proposed “child abuse” legislation to “protect the children” - my point is that children need to be protected from her and the power structure she represents first and foremost. Endlessly repeating that you are “thinking of the children” when you trade their future safety away digs this toxic thought deeper into the cultural zeitgeist. When I opposed the president’s surveillance program, I was thinking of the children and how it was going to shape their lives in the US.
- seanw444 3y agoMaybe not with all the finer details considered. But we're talking about dirty games, like misleading vague headlines about how children are in danger, and not mentioning how "solving" it directly leads to a nightmare for privacy. It's the shock factor, not the logic. And a lot of people definitely do not care to read the fine print. I'll wager most. In fact, I'll wager overwhelming majority. That's what's scary. Anecdotally, my close friends struggle reading the single short paragraphs I send them about important events. Bad enough that they skip over a couple numbers, and then say "I'm not doing all the math for that", when it literally says the answer directly. The mere sight of a couple numbers immediately puts them into "gloss-over" mode. I really have no faith in Gen Z at large. I largely blame Tik Tok, but at the same time, something like it was inevitable. Capitalizing off of a feedback loop of shortening attention spans is going to spell doom for our society.
- williamdclt 3y agoThe best argument I have is « we’re giving tools to the fascists that will come into power in the future ». It’s more likely than not that every country will have a « wrong side of history » gov coming to power, sooner rather than later
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoIf fascists come to power, you are kind of screwed anyway. Rubber hose cryptanalysis is pretty effective.
- wongarsu 3y agoRubber hose cryptoanalysis doesn't scale all that well. Sure, you can build a traditional surveillance apparatus to find and squash and dissidence, but unencrypted internet makes this a lot cheaper and more effective. At the very least you can force your opposition to give up the advantages of digital communication, and catch those that don't (and change public online discourse through chilling effects)
- slowmovintarget 3y agoWe've engineered societies that no longer value freedom as they consider it a nebulous concept that is less important than some in-group momentary righteousness. Even free speech is back on the table in the current zeitgeist, which is insane.
- browningstreet 3y agoAuthorities have a million weapons and resources against individuals already.
- lesuorac 3y agoPorque no dos? E2EE protects the children from being spied on by pedophiles.
- Kim_Bruning 3y agoWhich population group is most likely to be in possession of pictures of teenagers doing dumb things? E2EE protects children from being arrested by the government for being dumb children. [Edit: Added "pictures of"]