9 ms·
From company statement: > Our customers rely on us to make access simple without sacrificing quality and reliability. Unauthorized app integrations, stemming f
by TeMPOraL 3y ago
From company statement:
> Our customers rely on us to make access simple without sacrificing quality and reliability. Unauthorized app integrations, stemming from only 0.2% of myQ users, previously accounted for more than half of the traffic to and from the myQ system, and at times constituted a substantial DDOS event that consumed high quantities of resources.
Yeah, that sounds plausible, because:
- Home Assistant users are power users, thus more likely to actually use the devices in question;
- Official IoT software and integrations are uniformly shit, designed to discourage effective use (while maximizing data collection).
Thus, I read this statement as: "We're not happy that some of our customers decided to actually use the 'smart'/'connected' aspects of our product; our service-providing part was not ready to provide the service, and unlike the data collection part, it was never intended to."
- api 3y agoThe problem is that these require some kind of server. Get one that just talks to HA over your local network. Why in the hell does a garage door opener need a server? Oh, data collection. And subscriptions. Nothing for the user. I avoid any home automation thing that has any cloud backing that's not strictly optional. It's a strong anti-feature. In home stuff cloud means it won't work when the Internet is down, it spies on you, and it can become a brick or start requiring a subscription at any time.
- nijave 3y agoYou can access the device when you're away from home if it's internet connected. Of course, the server doesn't need to be doing much besides proxying connections.
- cassianoleal 3y agoAnd of course, you can easily run a VPN/Tailscale/ZeroTier/whatever to achieve the same without the downsides.
- api 3y agoThere are home assistant integrations for all of those. HA can also open a port via uPnP and use Letsencrypt. You don’t need a cloud server to remotely access a device.
- colinmorelli 3y agoI'm quite confident my parents and the many people like them in the world would not find running VPN/Tailscale/ZeroTier to be "easy." Nor would they have any idea how to troubleshoot when those services have issues. Nor would they want to play intermediary between Tailscale and myQ customer support to figure out which one is broken and fix it. Having options like this is great for powerusers, but the vast majority of people are not that. They need something that just works. Of course that still doesn't mean they need their garage door collecting telemetry data, but they need something more than a LAN-connected smart device.
- iAMkenough 3y agoSounds like there's a market for intermediary tech support
- colinmorelli 3y agoPerhaps in general, but if the problem here is "I don't want a corporation to have access to when my garage door is open or closed" I can't fathom how "Give another corporation access to my entire network to troubleshoot my VPN and LAN configuration of my devices" is the solution?
- TeMPOraL 3y agoThe solution is to "give my tech whiz kid/neighbor/friend, or a local IT shop two blocks over, the responsibility of managing my home network". This is where ideas like non-shit IoT, Right to Repair, Free (Libre) Software, and even "how to not fuck up foreign aid 101", all converge. The point isn't to make everyone their tech support. The point is to allow local communities to be more self-sufficient, able to manage technology on their own - as opposed to outsourcing everything to some faceless companies that have no attachment to any given community. Note that this doesn't preclude business - on the contrary, local businesses are the fundamental part of any community larger than couple dozen people; the ideas converge not on everyone doing stuff pro bono, but on small, local businesses* doing things for their communities, accumulating and retaining know-how. I wish more people from aforementioned movements realized their ultimate goal (at least in form that's possible in the real world) is the same, and joined forces.
- RobotToaster 3y agoWhy would you need to access a garage door opener when away from home?
- heartbreak 3y agoTo let in your cat sitter.
- eknkc 3y agoCheck if you left it open? Let someone in remotely?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pmontra 3y agoI forgot it open.
- _ZeD_ 3y agothe real solution here is to make it auto close locally.
- pmontra 3y agoThat's a nice to have feature. However there are cases when one wants to keep it open for hours or, as pointed by other replies, to open it to let somebody in. An edge case I just thought about: open it to let somebody delivery a package inside, possibly by looking at them with a camera, and then close it.
- neodymiumphish 3y agoGive access to a friend or family member when you're out of town. Allow package deliverers to put a package in your garage instead of on your step. When I had MyQ, I used it almost exclusively when I was on my motorcycle. I had it configured so that I could tap a button on my phone that tracked my location and enabled a geofence around my house so it would ping the MyQ to open when I got about a quarter mile from home. I called this my "riding home" mode. This saved me the trouble of having to get my gloves off and open the door through the app when I got to my driveway, and I didn't have to leave a garage door opener on/with my bike.
- tmccrary55 3y agoYou can also just do both. I'd rather that it use the LAN, if I'm there at the time. Data collection and remote access can just be their own functionality.
- tensor 3y agoHomekit provides this as well, and by default is local only. There really is no excuse for these devices not to support homekit out of the box other than a money grab.
- ourmandave 3y agoIn the updated fairy tale, the 3rd little piggy actually perishes, because his house got bricked by the Big Bad Wolf IoT service.
- kevindamm 3y agoIt's a good thing the piggies invested in light infrastructure and good logs with their previous houses, the next version after brick will be even better!
- TeMPOraL 3y agoI still prefer the version where the fourth pig built its home from wolf bones - while it wasn't the best building material, it made a point.
- marcosdumay 3y agoNah, the wolf just pays a minimal fee to the IoT provider so it unlocks every door on the pig's house.
- lexh 3y agoOh, data collection. And subscriptions. This makes sense (and myQ’s privacy policy is a nightmare: https://www.myq.com/privacy-notice https://www.myq.com/privacy-notice) but I’ve never understood how this particular bit of data is valuable to anyone. Any ideas?
- firtoz 3y agoNumber of active car owners living in an area could be valuable for a few industries and governments
- ca_tech 3y agoI buy a garage door opener. That is the end of my transaction. I buy a connected garage door opener. The provider knows my geolocation, my name, email address, socioeconomic status, even the phone I own. Inferences can be made on activity such as "they leave for work at 7am when garage door opens". The collection of data doesn't need to be used specifically for reengaging me with Chamberlain. It is now an asset to the company that can be sold to others as outlined in their Information Sharing section. Which basically says "we share it with everyone". Partners can be anyone from insurance companies to academic researchers. Remember that partners aren't limited to just one data set. They have the ability to ask multiple companies: "What data do you have for all occupants of houses in this geographic area?"
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> Remember that partners aren't limited to just one data set. They have the ability to ask multiple companies: "What data do you have for all occupants of houses in this geographic area?" Yup. And to make the issue clear: there is no such thing as "anonymized data", there's only "anonymized until correlated with enough related data sets".
- gosub100 3y agoNo direct experience, just my guesses * someone who drives frequently may rank higher for automotive products and services * use to independently rank other statistics, i.e. someone with kids probably comes and goes more than a single person or non-child-rearing couple. Take the dataset where you know they have kids (and myQ) and see if you can detect the ones with kids using only myQ data (plus other statistics). If it allows you to infer this property accurately enough, profit. * Someone who comes and goes a lot is most likely not physically disabled, so exclude them from those specific marketing materials. * someone who is home a lot (hardly ever opens their garage door) might like to spend money on useless gadgets, try selling them IoT toasters
- kube-system 3y ago> Why in the hell does a garage door opener need a server? Because the user is almost certainly installing the device behind a NAT with a dynamically assigned public IP. These are mass-market garage door openers, not devices targeted to those familiar with advanced network configuration. I also avoid cloud connected IoT stuff. I have the luxury of doing so because I have IT skills. For those who do not, accessible alternatives simply don't exist.
- PurpleRamen 3y ago> - Home Assistant users are power users, thus more likely to actually use the devices in question; >50% traffic from 0.2% of the users is far too big of a discrepancy to just explain it away with powerusers. Customers too have to follow a fair level of usage. > designed to discourage effective use (while maximizing data collection). What valuable data can they collect, if nobody is using it?
- malermeister 3y agoThis thing probably phones home every time you open or close your door, no matter if you do it via their smart portal or manually.
- neodymiumphish 3y agoAs a former MyQ user, I can say definitively that this is accurate. There's a magnetic sensor that you put on the door for it to track the state of the door, so the app is always correct on whether it's open or closed.
- PurpleRamen 3y agoYes, but according to their statement, the official client seems to behave better than the HA-implementation. Maybe HA is brute forcing something, like pulling state every 10 seconds or so. And this is a legit complaint from their side if this is the case.
- bonzini 3y agoIf pulling the state goes through the cloud app it is their (self-inflicted) problem.
- PurpleRamen 3y agoSure, and because it was their problem, they made it the problem of those who gave them this problem, and pulled the plug. But let's get real, 0.2 of customers are probably also matching around 0.2% of their income with those products. So it's probably not really a problem, short term. Long term, they probably have damaged their brand hard, and missed out on some revenue from grassroot marketing. But that's a problem of future chamberlain. Today, the one responsible for this has solved their problems, calls it done and gets their paycheck. And who knows, maybe next year they switch to Matter, get some good marketing from it, raise the sales and the victims from today are forgotten. That's business..
- a254613e 3y agoThe main reason why HA accounted for so many requests is probably because it was a polling integration, requesting data every 30 seconds from the server, while the official app either had push events when something changes, or it updated state when the app gets opened.
- ryukoposting 3y agoIsn't the high road solution here to open your API to enable users to make a less shitty HA integration? Either way, they'll almost certainly pull the plug on this service sometime before the end of the decade.
- lhamil64 3y agoOr open up a local API so Home Assistant users don't even need to hit their servers in the first place, which is preferable anyway...
- epiecs 3y agoI was just going to comment this. The device is network connected anyhow. So just open up the local api.
- cameldrv 3y agoHaha this is the company that has an undocumented encrypted wire protocol between the wired button and the opener so you have to use their button instead of a normal doorbell switch.
- thecapybara 3y agoIf I recall correctly, Chamberlin had an optional accessory that added HomeKit support to garage door openers, and that was discontinued last year. Home Assistant is capable of acting as a HomeKit hub, allowing it to control HomeKit compatible devices locally that otherwise would've required a cloud connection.
- YiraldyGuber 3y agoUnofficial IoT software and integrations are not (much?) better. I wouldn't be at all surprised if this was partly due to a junk integration for this device cobbled together by an amateur and replicated by thousands more amateurs into their own ginormous pile of other junk YAMLs.
- lvh 3y agoWhy did that software work mostly fine most of the time since 2017? Even Chamberlain admits their blocking is deliberate. Even Chamberlain's external statements suggest this is part of their corporate strategy. Why is Chamberlain's API so brittle it can't stand prodding from what they claim is a tiny fraction of users, even if those are misbehaving? Do you agree that comparing that to DDoS is ludicrous, and suggests either dishonesty or a fundamental misunderstanding of what "DDoS" means?
- gregmac 3y ago> partly due to a junk integration for this device cobbled together by an amateur Judge for yourself, here's the code: https://github.com/home-assistant/core/tree/5523e9947d82ac1479029468808e5745c84332b6/homeassistant/components/myq https://github.com/home-assistant/core/tree/5523e9947d82ac14... (before it was removed) https://github.com/arraylabs/pymyq/tree/master/pymyq https://github.com/arraylabs/pymyq/tree/master/pymyq
- _ea1k 3y agoYeah, I always felt like the implementation wasn't that good. But, tbh, rate limiting them and saying "hey don't poll quite so much" would have been trivial compared to the approach they ultimately took. And obviously people with HA will use it more than people that have to wait a ridiculous amount of time every time they open that stupid myq app. It was terrible.
- mikeryan 3y agoI have a MyQ door opener (and home assistant) This is bullshit. Their app is bloatware that they use to try to push additional services like Amazon home delivery etc. I mean it’s just a button, that’s all it needs to do. I’m going to replace it with one of the recommended devices. This is such an overt money grab.
- duxup 3y agoI have the MyQ app (iOS). I don't mind it at all. App works, fairly fast, the stupid extra stuff is just a chunk of the screen I can ignore / don't have to do / interact with. I don't approve of the API situation but the app itself doesn't feel particularly bad.
- BenjiWiebe 3y agoThe iOS app sounds like it's better than the Android one.
- duxup 3y agoWhat is the Android app like?
- bonestamp2 3y agoAh, ya that might be it. I use the iOS version and it works well.
- atonse 3y agoI do agree that their app works perfectly fine. And it's as responsive as HomeKit, but I don't want to have to launch 20 apps for my various devices. In fact, after my initial irritation, I thought "at the end of the day, if they made a couple shortcuts available then I could still say <Hey Siri> Open the Garage door" – It's not perfect like homekit but it'll go a long way to placating many of us who don't want to keep launching a separate app.
- gotbeans 3y agoThis. Chamberlain/homeassistant user here too. In the past the app has gone the lengths of make us try to use their own assistant (!). Why the fuck would I ever want to use a voice assistant from my garage door provider? Seems like a desperate attempt to enter a market that doesn't even make sense for them as they currently are.
- kkielhofner 3y agoAt the end of the day this is a very reasonable business decision - an incredibly obvious and easy one. Chamberlain/myQ makes very low cost (likely loss-leader) mass manufactured devices. Like anything else if you can identify 0.2% of your users leading to 50% of an issue you're having the reasonable thing to do (from a business perspective) is to just cut them loose. If this CTO or anyone at Chamberlain were to try to champion support for HA users people with the numbers would look at them like they are crazy. For 0.2% of the user base it barely justifies anything more than a 10 minute conversation with a foregone decision. I use and love Home Assistant. While it's a "big deal" to techies and power users like us the total installed base (as these numbers show) is infinitesimally small when you zoom out and look at the total "smart home" market. There are 275k active Home Assistant installations[0]. This number is already tiny compared to myQ sales. Then you can check the myQ integration and see that it's only used by 3% of HA installs[1]. Home Assistant is insignificant to Chamberlain and Chamberlain is insignificant to Home Assistant. For a device that sells for $30 8,250 HA installs is $247,500 of total device lifetime revenue. Chamberlain has $820m of revenue per year. Even if every one of these installs bought four devices that's less than $1m. They. Do. Not. Care. Again, I don't love this either. It's a jerk move but when viewed through the eyes of a cold and calculating business it makes perfect sense. Frankly I'm surprised this decision didn't come sooner. Especially when you consider all of these awful commercial devices really want you to install their app so they can push who-knows-what and upsell at every possible opportunity. That's an entire revenue stream they will never tap into with users utilizing the API and few businesses can resist gobs of money they see as ripe for the taking. Sad but true and standard for nearly any business. Even more so for a de-facto monopoly like Chamberlain. HA users and people here are outraged, and that is completely fair but with these numbers Chamberlain isn't even going to remotely feel this. At the end of the day HA is extremely powerful and the ecosystem and maker-ish community around it is incredibly robust. A device with a contact sensor on door close/open and relay (or something) to toggle the door is trivial. It's what I've been using since before MyQ or anything like it was even on the market. Just avoid the commercial "IoT/smart home" junk whenever possible. [0] - https://analytics.home-assistant.io/ https://analytics.home-assistant.io/ [1] - https://www.home-assistant.io/integrations/myq/ https://www.home-assistant.io/integrations/myq/
- 3y ago
- belthesar 3y agoOne would think a reasonably decently written HTTP client with a server that responsibly responded with HTTP 429's when a client was polling too hard would be able to set a standard and enforce "good netizen" behavior.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]