5 ms·
When Linux Spooked Microsoft: Remembering 1998's Leaked 'Halloween Documents'
- panki27 3y agoThink how far we've come, today Microsoft is handing out its own Linux kernels.
- INTPenis 3y agoThey had to. They wanted to get into cloud and their own OS was optimized for desktops.
- rmrfchik 3y ago"Optimized" what a strange choosing of word.
- INTPenis 3y agoHaha I felt the same way after I hit reply. I guess "focused on desktop" would be more apt. Either way it's not at all suitable for cloud native stuff.
- rmrfchik 3y agoMicrosoft neither focus their OS on desktop nor user. They focus on selling users tool spies on users. Almost any progress on Windows is microsoft centric. Even their main weapon (API) now is holstered.
- pjmlp 3y agoYou mean the Windows kernel that powers Azure, used to run those GNU/Linux instances? https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/windows-os-platform-blog/azure-host-os-cloud-host/ba-p/3709528 https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/windows-os-platform-b...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- throw555chip 3y agoAh, that explains the poorer performance when comparing to AWS or GCP, now it makes sense, thanks!
- pjmlp 3y agoThe financial performance looks quite alright to me, specially when looking at GCP 3rd place, and regular issues to stay relevant to big enterprises. When not AWS, it is Azure, so the performance isn't that bad to start with. Also AWS and GCP aren't running cloud instances of game consoles (which also use a variation of Windows), GCP one (Stadia) powered by Linux was a failure, nor are they running an AI service being used by millions of folks around the globe. Not bad.
- steve1977 3y agoIn my experience, Hyper-V is pretty much on par with ESX or Xen in this regard.
- Narishma 3y agoIf it's optimized for anything it's probably telemetry collection and ad delivery.
- jve 3y agoI'm sometimes wondering whether Microsoft wants to tank their Windows Server or what? A great OS overall, but speaking as a service provider - the licensing makes so much effort on provider part to even offer a VM with Microsoft OS. Only recently (due to EU pressure?) provided License mobility where customer himself is responsible for software licences and can BYOL. Otherwise it was on service provider to collect whatever software the customer is using and charge for it. And if you don't, prepare for a hefty fine. Windows of course provides SIL infrastructure to do just that, but all that implies server has to be configured in some way. And then the price for the licence ofcourse... I really like Windows Server OS, but the effort it puts on part of service provider - no wonders everyone wants and offers to deploy Linux.
- smcl 3y agoI suspect that those working on Windows are a different department entirely from those who handle Azure stuff. So while they're maybe encouraged to use Windows, they tend to favour what works best for them - which in many cases is Linux.
- pjmlp 3y agoAzure is powered by Windows, https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/windows-os-platform-blog/azure-host-os-cloud-host/ba-p/3709528 https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/windows-os-platform-b...
- klaas- 3y agoAnd that windows is backed by Linux if performance is key: https://cfp.all-systems-go.io/media/all-systems-go-2023/submissions/7URRNC/resources/ASG_2023_Microsoft_Azure_Boost_i8m559R.pdf https://cfp.all-systems-go.io/media/all-systems-go-2023/subm...
- pjmlp 3y ago> PCIe card running Linux hardened OS.... That is not a server OS. And I would assert it is Linux based instead of another firmware RTOS, because of licensing and yeah, if you want to be pedantic Windows was never designed to fit into the firmware of a network card.
- sprash 3y agoThe current involvement of Microsoft with "Linux" is nothing more than good old EEE. Exactly as described in the Halloween Documents.
- Pixie_Dust 3y ago‘to understand how to compete against OSS [open source software], we must target a process rather than a company’ https://www.uwestminsterpress.co.uk/site/chapters/10.16997/book39.c/download/4196/ https://www.uwestminsterpress.co.uk/site/chapters/10.16997/b...
- pjmlp 3y agoHardly possible when Red-Hat, Oracle, Google, SuSE, IBM, are doing similar approaches to GNU/Linux.
- gumballindie 3y agoThe scary thing about that is that folks actually use them and think they are good.
- mistrial9 3y ago"folks" are serfs in this system
- gumballindie 3y agoThey can just install Linux and be free. It's not that difficult.
- trelane 3y agoWhich is why it's good that's it's GPL. Compare to, e.g. Chrome.
- smooc 3y agoRemember the Slashdot Effect? I'm not sure if it lives up to its expectations this time ;-)
- drpossum 3y agoRemember Slashdot?
- Aardwolf 3y agoI miss tags such as "whatcouldpossiblygowrong" and "suddenoutbreakofcommonsense", there have been articles on HN where these tags could have applied as well
- robgibbons 3y agoScore: 5, Insightful
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoHonestly I still think Slashdot's way of flavoring up/down votes is better than anything else I've seen.
- Zak 3y agoI think requiring a reason/explanation probably discourages voting simply based on agreement and disagreement and improves the signal a numeric score provides. I find that missing from Reddit-alikes now. +1 insightful
- tap-snap-or-nap 3y ago> The memo warns that the quality of free software can meet or exceed that of commercial programs and describes it as a potentially serious threat to Microsoft. Every industry seems to have gone through a similar cycles where the free has been a threat to the commercial products.
- krisoft 3y ago> Every industry seems to have gone through a similar cycles where the free has been a threat to the commercial products. I’m very doubtfull of that. How would a free car manufacturer work? Which free watch offering threatened the commercial industry? When did free construction threaten commercial offerings?
- dijit 3y agoCars are a good example because "free" car manufacture is what caused the downfall of Detroit in the US and Coventry in the UK. Suddenly there was an influx of these cheaper cars, and at least in the US there were measures introduced to decrease the viability of imported cars. Free construction has a similar fate, which is why planning permission is more difficult than it has ever been.
- qubex 3y agoHow are cars that one has to pay for ‘free’?
- dijit 3y agoLibre vs Gratis. That FOSS software is given gratis is a happy byproduct of it being libre and having zero cost to copy. "open source" cola for example is not free to manufacture, so it has some cost associated, though you could make it yourself if you had the means.[0] [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-source_cola https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-source_cola
- 3y ago
- herbst 3y agoThey just changed the Strategie. If you install LLM stuff or the relatively stable atom clone vscode. You are seeing dependencies that are also maintained by Microsoft. No issue so far, except when you run a bleeding edge system and realize that all required M$ libs are outdated and either you downgrade or can't use that tool that has that single M$ made python dependency that won't build on a modern system... More often than not the dependency issue was already reported months ago on their issue tracker, many people put their thumbs up and someone already wrote a patch. No active maintainer to comment, merge and release tho. This is exactly how we don't want our libs managed. You can run linux on Windows but still can't install a dual boot system with Linux first. IMO that says it all
- Ennea 3y agoRegarding your last point: I've (finally!) switched from Windows to Linux last year. I have, however, decided to set up a dual boot system, and have installed Linux first. Worked just fine.
- yuumei 3y agoDeleted
- porbelm 3y agoJust remember to install Linux AFTER Windows, or unplug your Linux drive when installing Windows, because MS does not play nice with including other OSes in their bootloader; you're gonna have to mess with your UEFI boot order or add the Windows boot to GRUB after the fact.
- LoganDark 3y agoI don't see why people on modern machines need or bother with GRUB when EFISTUB exists. The UEFI boot manager should be all you need.
- 3y ago
- MaintenanceMode 3y agoThis was a funny era. A few years later (early 2000s), I somehow got sent to the Microsoft developer conference because I was the closest, geographically. There were so many sessions focused on open source and inter working with Linux. It was shocking that Microsoft had so quickly embraced this world. Then in the closing keynote, Gates spoke passionately about how Microsoft would eradicate Linux and crush open source. It was hilarious how out of touch the left hand was from the right hand. I also made a bit of a splash because I came to the conference with a MacBook. A journalist even wanted to interview me because it was so unusual. I declined. The best part of the conference was the passes to company store, buying a lot of shwag for dirt cheap and a bunch of OS licenses, which they practically gave away in the store (to run in Parallels of course) lol.
- teddyh 3y ago> It was shocking that Microsoft had so quickly embraced this world. Well, “Embrace” is the first step.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deafpolygon 3y agoThey're working on Extend.
- pavlov 3y ago> "I came to the conference with a MacBook" Nitpicking, but it would have been either a PowerBook or an iBook if this was early 2000s. MacBooks were introduced in 2006.
- cbozeman 3y agoI don't remember the exact model of PalmPilot I owned, but I owned one way back when...
- bratsche 3y ago
- tjansen 3y agoThe scariest thing is that this happened a quarter of a century ago. Wow, I feel old! It was such a big deal back then, when everybody questioned Linux' viability.
- itomato 3y agoOh yes, and the pressure it imposed on Linux use in industry. IBM would not own Red Hat today if not for this memo. The fear and uncertainty that rippled the industry, right up through vendor selection made it harder, riskier and more frustrating to choose and make use of Linux than it should have been. Take notes.
- fragmede 3y agoIBM acquired Red Hat in 2019, and this memo is from 1998, so I'm skeptical it was this memo that caused that particular acquisition.
- bitwize 3y agoIBM had had a "Linux/open source friendly" strategy since the early 2000s. Remember that ad with the Eminem-looking kid they named "Linux", and they were like "he's learning"? That's how they came to acquire Red Hat, by leaning into the "we're totally besties with open source" narrative.
- bitwize 3y agoThe advertisement in question: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x7ozaFbqg00 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x7ozaFbqg00
- sillywalk 3y agoAlso Endorsed by Avery Brooks a.k.a. DS9's Captain Sisko. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UQAa_WKJxPs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UQAa_WKJxPs
- pjmlp 3y ago
- drpossum 3y agoWow, slashdot still exists.
- api 3y agoThis was before commercial software companies realized that they had a moat against open source: making software easy to use is often profoundly more difficult than just making software and requires tons of precisely the kind of work developers hate. Since they hate it, they must be paid to do it. No economic model, no good UX, no widespread adoption. Open source today is basically a bone yard for building commercial apps and SaaS, and a hobby shop for advanced technical users who can DIY.
- steve1977 3y agoI see this problem in a lot of software I care about (media production, office, mathematics). There are open source alternatives to the proprietary big ones, but they’re all just “ok” at best - and most of them aren’t. E.g. DAWs like Cubase or Live vs Ardour, MS Office vs LibreOffice, Mathematica vs SageMath (which does have some of its own strengths though)
- doubloon 3y agob2b software is not easy to use, open source replaces a lot of back end stuff that doesnt work
- dark-star 3y agoThe time that MS was spooked by Linux may be over, but what's still ongoing is the way that Microsoft still spooks Linux, to this day. Just read the comments on any Linux news site about systemd. I promise it will be hilarious. "Microsoft trying to take over Linux", "Pottering is a secret MS agent to undermine Linux", "Microsoft infesting Linux with BSODs", ... it goes on and on and on Honestly, even if Microsoft had tried, it couldn't have done a better job at enraging the Linux folks than systemd did :-D
- gavinhoward 3y agoBut then...Poettering went to work for Microsoft, so...maybe they were right?
- aidenn0 3y agoI won't lie, if I had taken as much flack as Peottering did from the community[1], I'd take a job with MS just to troll them. 1: I'm personally not a fan of Pulse Audio, but I'm pretty sure it wasn't his decision to enable it in Ubuntu by default when it was still pretty broken, and holy shit I had like 12 backups of my working asoundrc at the time because configuring ALSA was such a pain, so PA was not in any sense gratuitous; it solved real problems.
- gavinhoward 3y agoNot disagreeing with you. Just want to add that even if he just took the job to troll with us, it still shows that his principles were never far from theirs anyway, even if he was genuine at first.
- pjmlp 3y agoMiguel de Icaza was another one, hence why nowadays he is so focused on Apple's ecosystem. "What Killed the Linux Desktop" https://tirania.org/blog/archive/2012/Aug-29.html https://tirania.org/blog/archive/2012/Aug-29.html Nowadays, after getting Xamarin acquired by Microsoft, https://xibbon.com/ https://xibbon.com/ https://github.com/migueldeicaza/SwiftGodot https://github.com/migueldeicaza/SwiftGodot
- harshaw 3y agoCompletely random comment. I was in a meeting probably about 20 years ago in the 2000s. I forget with what company. Anyone, one of the folks introduced himself as Vinod. I looked at his last name. Valloppillil. I was like "Oh hey - are you the halloween documents guy?". He was completely spooked - looked like a cat had walked over his grave. Seemed like something in his past he wanted to forget. But I thought it was pretty awesome - like having a minor celebrity to talk to when I was a fairly junior engineer. Not quite as awesome as having my copy of Applied Cryptography autographed by Bruce Schnier, but still kinda cool. Anyway - if you are still out there working in Tech Vinod - hope everything is going well.
- ipython 3y agoFor what it’s worth I looked him up on LinkedIn. One of his bullets for his time at Microsoft reads: > Author of "Halloween documents" - analyzing Linux & Open Source software ;-) Sounds like he’s “embraced” his infamy after all these years :)
- javier_e06 3y agoI is so apropos that the article links to Slashdot which has the exact same portal for the last 20 years :). I was in the University of Texas back then CS dept (1996). We had some presentations from Red Hat and Microsoft. Microsoft pitch was that Linux was like a doggie under the Christmas Tree. Fun present that will pee all over the place. What would Microsoft be then? A life-sized stuffed toy dog?
- kstrauser 3y agoAt that time, that was a decent analogy. Linux was great fun but it also liked to bite your hand and chew your shoes. And then it grew up into a smart, eager adult.
- n6h6 3y agoAnyone know why the fuck the comments on the linked site are talking about Kyle Rittenhouse? Did I miss something?
- neilv 3y agoI can mention a few things that were publicly obvious: * The Halloween Documents didn't seem to be a fluke of behavior, but a bit of leaked evidence of an established executive culture of ruthlessness, paired with forward-looking strategic thinking (or "long cons"). This leaked bit of internal thinking is also consistent with the public history of brazen behavior, like backstabbing partners. * Does anyone think that apparent corporate culture changed dramatically due to the brief fuss over the leaked Halloween Documents? Or would we normally assume that they kept devising and executing on other underhanded tactics? And have never been given a reason to change that culture? * Plot twist: Early on in Linux popularity rise, MS's public behavior looked like they wanted to point to Linux and some kinds of open source as competition. And then, later, MS publicly appeared to be promoting some open source, to claim that some new MS proprietary moves (which some MS customer shops were concerned about, having been bitten before) weren't as proprietary lock-in as they'd otherwise look. So, multiple times, it publicly appeared that MS was doing a delicate dance of promoting open source. (More recent moves that might be related seem less clear, or haven't played out yet.) * Everyone heard about FUD and EEE, as well as using legal proceedings to sabotage threats, but it would be reasonable to assume that any company that practiced these might also have additional tactics in their toolbox.