4 ms·
My whole life I've been wishing for something in between. If I'm transferring between applications, I never want 95% of formatting — I don't want font or size
by crazygringo 3y ago
My whole life I've been wishing for something in between.
If I'm transferring between applications, I never want 95% of formatting — I don't want font or size or color or line-height or paragraph spacing or whatever.
But I do want italics, because that conveys actual meaning around emphasized words and titles. And I do want to preserve subscript/superscript in things like CO2 or "squared", because that's similarly meaningful. And I also want to maintain bulleted and numbered lists, which again have meaning. Strikethru as well.
So I just really wish that the OS had a toggle switch so that "Paste and Match Style" would still preserve everything "textually meaningful" -- <i>, <sub>, <sup>, <ol>, <ul>, <li>, and <s>.
- Champagn3Papi 3y agoI recently bought the Pastebot, it's one of those tools once you try it and make it fit in your workflow you never want to go back. It's something like 12$ one time purchase which is great and a huge productivity booster!
- benhurmarcel 3y agohttps://tapbots.com/pastebot/ https://tapbots.com/pastebot/
- mrtesthah 3y agoNotational Velocity works exactly this way.
- Findecanor 3y agoYou could argue that font, size, colour, line-height and paragraph spacing should not be considered "formatting" of the text, but as properties that belong to the container that the text is in.
- coldtea 3y agoWhether it belongs to text or the pdf reader or rich text editor or browser doesn't matter. I want to carry them over when I copy and paste the text (and sometimes to strip them). I don't want to copy and paste the container.
- Wowfunhappy 3y agoI agree completely—but I'll go further. From a UI standpoint, italics should be treated akin to capital/lowercase letters. Currently, on every computer I'm aware of, if I copy an all-caps paragraph and paste into the middle of an all-lowercase paragraph, the pasted text will still be capitalized. Similarly, if I click into an all-caps paragraph and start typing without caps-lock on, the new text will be lowercase. Italics should work the same way. Note: I am aware that capitals, unlike italics, are different characters in Unicode/ASCII. Put that aside for a moment, it's not relevant to UI behavior, users don't care.
- crazygringo 3y agoIn CSS, `text-transform: uppercase;` is able to separate case from styling. I've used it frequently in the past, since you often want to experiment with all-caps for short headings, captions, subtitles, etc. Whereas if you hard-code the all-caps in text, you can't go back. In Chrome, if you copy CSS-all-caps text to the clipboard, it is copied as uppercase. Intriguingly, in Firefox, it is copied as the original (mixed case) source HTML text. I do like the idea treating all-caps as a style, just like small caps. The problem, of course, is that it makes it kind of impossible to type within it, since there's no feedback as to when you're typing capital letters at the starts of sentences or not.
- Wowfunhappy 3y agoTo be clear, my assertion is that most user-facing text editors should have the opposite of all-caps as a style! I think italics should be treated the way we treat capitalization. Pressing ⌘I (or using the UI equivalent) should act like the italics version of caps lock.
- snoopen 3y agoI much prefer the approach of applying emphasis, be it italics, bold, all-caps etc, on top of plain text. To me this is the most versatile approach and I think is better for accessibility. A sentence with italics or any other emphasis should read exactly the same without that emphasis. Where the same isn't true of capitalisation.
- bambax 3y agoI wrote a browser extension some time ago that does something similar: Paste as Markdown [0]. The user can copy any text from anywhere, and then with the help of the extension, paste the result (somewhere in the browser), in markdown, so emphasis and lists, etc. are preserved, while everything else is discarded. [0] https://markitdown.medusis.com/ https://markitdown.medusis.com/
- bentcorner 3y agoI kind of want something like markdown or WP reveal codes, where you can copy paste formatted text, but be able to see the formatting so you can remove anything unnecessary. There's countless implementations of formatting toolbars for web based editors, most of them bad, I feel like if operating systems handled this for users we wouldn't be wasting cycles on this kind of problem.
- i13e 3y agoThis gets me most of the way there: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/copycat/jdjbiojkklnaeoanimopafmnmhldejbg https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/copycat/jdjbiojkkl...