5 ms·
The Great Inflation
- sneed_chucker 3y agoPosting this will inevitably lead to present day comparisons. I kind of want to get ahead of the curve here and ask any HNers who were old enough to be working and spending money at the time what it was like. Would be valuable to hear present day comparisons from people who've experienced both.
- wrycoder 3y agoMy first job in industry with my new physics degree was as a “Scientist I”, which paid $9000 per year in the late sixties. Shortly later, I bought a new Alfa Romeo for $5000. Outside my budget, but I really wanted one and never regretted it. By 1970, I had moved to the mid-Peninsula at double the salary.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoI was just coming into adulthood. Not working yet, but privy to some of the financial calculations that my parents were making. It was hard to figure out what was a good economic idea. A bond with a 14% interest rate? Sounds great... but it's not, if inflation is 12% and you have to pay income tax on the gains, and it's worse if inflation heads to 14%. But what's better? I imagine that the rest of it wasn't any easier. Does it make sense to invest in that new factory? I imagine that it's hard to get an answer you're sure of when inflation is going crazy. People who weren't there are shocked at 7% inflation for a year. I'm like "meh". The Fed is on top of it. They aren't over-reacting, and they aren't ignoring it. And, a Fed rate of 5%? I remember when it went to 20%. Now get off my lawn. (Wow, do I feel old making this post.)
- detourdog 3y agoWe are probably close in age and what I remember was that everybody in our Central Pennsylvania town was more or less equal. The janitors at Bethlehem Steel were making good wages and people were investing extra money instead of spending it. The 1980 election between Jimmy Carter, Ronald Reagan, and John Anderson was a big turning point. George H.W. Bush was running against Reagan for the Republican nomination. Reagan's economic policy was described as voodoo economics by Bush. Once Reagan was elected it was like a light switch was flipped and a portion of the town became rich and the Bethlehem Steel closed and there was a slow decline in the blue collar class.
- PCalvanelli 3y agohttps://wtfhappenedin1971.com/ https://wtfhappenedin1971.com/
- tastyfreeze 3y agoThe bricks were laid for untethering from gold long before 1971. The cynic in me thinks that was the plan of the bankers that came up with Bretton Woods in the first place. "Give us all your gold and we will give you paper, we plomise we will always honor the exchange of paper back to gold."
- keep_reading 3y agoOne of the original plans at that meeting was a new world reserve currency, but they gave up control to the American dollar because the USA had control of 2/3 of the world's gold and refused to support the idea of the "bancor"
- PCalvanelli 3y agoReminds me of the IMF's introduction of Special Drawing Rights (SDR) shortly after Bretton Woods to smooth over any liquidity crisis that might occur. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_drawing_rights?useskin=vector https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_drawing_rights?useskin...
- Aunche 3y agoThe one thing this is correct about is that continuing Bretton Woods past 1971 would lower the gap between economic productivity and wages... because both of them would have collapsed after the US depletes all its gold reserves.
- unboxingelf 3y agoThe fed has successfully redefined the word “inflation” to mean “an increase in cost”, which conveniently leaves room to blame others for rising prices. The original meaning of “inflation” was “an increase in currency supply”. Debasing the currency supply is why the dollar is worth less and everything costs more. It is the result of deficit spending.
- pgwhalen 3y ago> The original meaning of “inflation” was “an increase in currency supply”. Can you provide a source for this? It seems like an overly monetarist view to me: trying to be assertive about the cause rather than just describing the phenomenon.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Bjartr 3y agoAccording to etymonline[1] >Monetary sense of "enlargement of prices" (originally by an increase in the amount of money in circulation) first recorded 1838 in American English. I also found this pdf from the Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland called On the Origin and Evolution of the Word Inflation[2] that goes into more detail. [1] https://www.etymonline.com/word/inflation https://www.etymonline.com/word/inflation [2] https://www.clevelandfed.org/-/media/project/clevelandfedtenant/clevelandfedsite/publications/economic-commentary/1997/ec-19971015-on-the-origin-and-evolution-of-the-word-inflation-pdf.pdf https://www.clevelandfed.org/-/media/project/clevelandfedten...
- QuesnayJr 3y agoThis is a completely idiosyncratic definition that is advocated for by followers of midcentury economists like Mises. The standard definition of inflation is an increase in the general price level. Of course the size money supply and inflation are related, but they're not synonymous.
- pixl97 3y ago
- wholesomepotato 3y agoIf you want to really understand modern money check "Broken Money" book.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoGiven that almost nobody here is going to go hunt up the book and read it in order to find out why you think it's relevant, would you give us a TL;DR?
- almost_usual 3y agoThe book goes over the history of human transactions from hunter gatherer to modern day and how currency or a ‘ledger’ has played a role in those transactions as civilization has progressed. The topic of inflation for hundreds of years and currency debasement is covered in detail and a common theme throughout the entire book. Overall I’d recommend the book, Lyn is a great writer. The end is definitely Bitcoin heavy but I still enjoyed it ( I do not own any cryptocurrency ).
- keep_reading 3y agoLyn's research is top notch too. Keep in mind they were a bitcoin skeptic for a long time.
- anu7df 3y agoI really do not understand why most people seem to think deficit spending is not the cause of inflation. Print a bunch of money and make a lot of people millionaires either on paper or realized gains. Why would their attempt to acquire anything scarce, like desirable houses, not cause the price of said asset to go up? Sure, it may take a while due to different kinds of inertia in the system and un equal rise in different asset classes and goods. But surely it should at some point rise prices. Why is this a surprise? If I am wrong, why am I wrong?
- bandyaboot 3y ago> I really do not understand why most people seem to think deficit spending is not the cause of inflation. I really don’t understand why some people can’t recognize the empirical evidence that it’s clearly more complex than that.
- pfannkuchen 3y agoSo fluctuations in currency value definitely are more complex, but money supply increase is the only thing I know of that would lead to a basically monotonic decrease in the value of the currency, which is what we observe. Can you provide any other examples?
- okaram 3y agoA monotonical decrease on the supply of stuff, like what we've had with oil.
- pfannkuchen 3y agoThe supply of stuff (per capita) has monotonically decreased since the early 1900s? That doesn't seem to align with reality...
- bandyaboot 3y agoI was wondering why you were conflating deficit spending with increasing the money supply, then realized it was the comment that I had replied to that did that. I was focusing on the assertion that there’s some clear, simple link between deficit spending and inflation even though the empirical evidence suggests otherwise.
- gjsman-1000 3y ago“Went aren’t you saving for retirement? You could be a multimillionaire!” 1. I’ll only be a millionaire because of inflation over my lifetime. 2. Social Security is less than a decade from insolvency, just as a generation with huge swaths of people with few savings is retiring. Meaning, something will change and it’s safe enough to wait and see. 3. Saving for retirement is a luxury reserved for the folks who don’t live paycheck to paycheck. For those who do, would their savings even be enough to matter? 4. Most pensions and retirement savings accounts use the stock market to beat inflation. Maybe it’s just me, but I am extremely bearish on the stock market for the next four decades. You’re seriously telling me we’ll make it four decades without a major war, pandemic, famine, etc; and if we do, we won’t have a basic income system in place? Unlikely to me.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoThose who do nothing and depend on the government to help them will not do better than those who at least try to take care of themselves. They will almost always do worse. Not trust the stock market, or at least not that much? Diversify - something like Total Stock plus Total Bond.
- bradfa 3y agoExactly. And if we get UBI *AND* I have saved money then I’m better off than those who didn’t. Even if I only saved a little.
- IcyWindows 3y agoWhat if there is a wealth tax that drains our retirement accounts in order to fund UBI, social security, health care, etc.? There's always the risk that the government will take tax what you have.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoThen I'll still have UBI and Social Security. And, since a wealth tax will almost certainly be less than 100%, I'll still be better off for having saved, even if not as much better off as I expected.
- lapcat 3y agoDon't underestimate the effect of OPEC oil production cutbacks in the 1970s. There were literally lines at the gas stations because of shortages.
- bookofjoe 3y agoI remember those well. I was living in LA without a car and SO glad.
- makomk 3y agoI think this is quite similar to this analysis of the effects of the more recent supply chain issues on US inflation and the Phillips curve: https://bankunderground.co.uk/2023/07/05/did-supply-constraints-tilt-the-phillips-curve/ https://bankunderground.co.uk/2023/07/05/did-supply-constrai... There's a lot of technical details on how they measured this exactly, but the rough conclusion is that supply chain constraints steepen the Philips curve and cause monetary policy to have a much greater effect on inflation than it normally would, rather than having less effect as bank economists apparently wrongly thought in the 1970s. This probably shouldn't be a surprise - after all, if the oil or other basic things needed to increase production isn't there, there's no way for the expansion in production that would be needed to stop an increase in money supply from being inflationary to happen. Yet even now, there seems to be a widespread popular belief that because the cause of inflation is supply side, there's no reason for central banks to raise interest rates and they're just making things worse for no reason by doing so.
- Gibbon1 3y agoSort of my take. Oil supplies increased exponentially till about 1970 and then that stopped right as the big cohort of post WWII children entered adulthood. I read a heterodox economist who argues that standard economists are wrong in that they believe that the energy contribution to GDP is a few percent. When he says it's closer to 100%. Which makes sense, if you assume unlike economists that fossil fuel energy is a primary non-substitutable supply constrained resource. Belief of mine, the transition to solar and wind is resulting in renewed growth in energy supplies. At the same time population growth is stalling.
- detourdog 3y agoI decided to sell stock to install a large solar array. My theory is that I'm investing in securities to smooth out my retirement. Investing in the solar panels divorces me from wild swings in electrical pricing as well as providing my daily electrical needs. I reasoned that securities that are based on societal organizations are harder to predict than my energy needs or the sunshine. I think there is also an efficiency in developing the electricity as close to the need as possible.
- andrewmcwatters 3y agoI'd really like some prominent economist or business magnate to simplify big monetary concepts for the general public like: "Fiat inflation simply happens when many people ask for more money for their goods or services over time. We want this to happen so that people do not hoard money, because we create it when people take on debt. If a small number of people hoard money that doesn't lose value, total economies and their movement of money from one person to another are dictated by primarily by the larger number of people creating debt." Then we can all stop having conversations like "let's increase or not increase minimum wage," because we will all collectively have a better understanding of what it is that we're receiving for our labor and how that effects businesses in our neighborhood, their employees, and abroad.
- imadierich 3y ago[dead]