4 ms·
In terms of illegally deducting sales tax and black car fund fees from drivers' pay... I genuinely don't understand why a large corporation ever messes up like
by crazygringo 3y ago
In terms of illegally deducting sales tax and black car fund fees from drivers' pay... I genuinely don't understand why a large corporation ever messes up like this in the first place.
It surely can't be legal incompetence -- a large company like this has lawyers to review these things, and who know the contracts they've created.
But it's hard to imagine Uber/Lyft thinking they're going to get away with it -- obviously it's going to eventually turn into a legal suit and they're going to lose.
I really don't get it. Often these kinds of situations happen when the law is ambiguous or unclear, and the company it taking a calculated risk that the courts would rule in their favor. But this doesn't seem to be that, unless I'm missing something?
- Scoundreller 3y agoMaybe it’s like Google handing back all the money it made in its early years from advertising gray/black-market pharmacies and prescribing mills. They needed the money then, and had no problem paying it back in 2011, many years later. And if they went bankrupt, well, no way to pay back anyway. Classic “heads we win, tails you lose” situation. Cheaper source of capital than venture capital. And no hit to the cap table. https://theguardian.com/technology/2011/aug/24/google-settles-us-drug-advertising-case https://theguardian.com/technology/2011/aug/24/google-settle...
- sitkack 3y agoIt is fraudulent and stealing, I would think there would be criminal charges against the perpetrators.
- Nextgrid 3y agoFraud/theft only happens to the common man. When a company does it it's either good business acumen or (if they got caught) a "technical glitch affecting a small percentage of users". See also: Comcast mis-billing customers.
- plagiarist 3y agoThe perpetrators are corporations, those are only people when it is convenient for the ruling class for them to be people.
- techsupporter 3y agoSometimes it is incompetence; someone flags a certain thing as the wrong classification and it comes out of the wrong bucket. But I think it's more than that, here. The settlement covers almost the height of when Uber and Lyft were desperately trying to undercut everyone else in the market--taxis, public transit, taking a bike, scooter-share, anything--and keeping these out of view of the customer helps a lot in that effort by making the price look lower. > The Uber settlement fund is for people who "drove for Uber between November 10, 2014, and May 22, 2017, and had deductions taken for New York sales tax and Black Car Fund fees." The Lyft fund is for people who drove for Lyft between October 11, 2015, and July 31, 2017, and had the same kinds of deductions. By my mind, it's in the same vein as businesses (everyone from Comcast to that small restaurant on the corner) that list one price in big numbers but tack on surcharges at the end. Obscuring the true price should be more illegal than it is.
- tialaramex 3y agoThe trouble is that Americans seem to be onboard with not adding taxes, and so that's your slippery slope right there. In Europe regulators are like "If the headline price is €10 but actually nobody pays €10, that headline price is wrong and must be fixed" and they're including taxes in that. In IT there was a UK battle years back when magazines were still a big deal about whether you could advertise prices without VAT. All these companies charge retail customers VAT of course, but in effect the way VAT works the price is without VAT if you are yourself a business that claims VAT refunds. So the argument in some of these magazines was, look, you can buy this magazine as a hobbyist, you can buy this Western Digital 200MB hard disk from an advertiser as a consumer, and you'd pay VAT. But actually they advertise in our magazine because many readers work in IT, so while they might get 10 hobbyist orders for that 200MB disk, they also get one or two business orders for a hundred drives, and those customers don't pay VAT so why must we show VAT prices ?
- Amezarak 3y agoI’ve never been sympathetic to the American argument that we want people to constantly feel how much they’re paying in taxes, but VAT might be a good point in their favor. VAT is very high (20-25% in many countries) and horrifically regressive. It would be a nonstarter for even people like me, who support raising taxes in the US, because of that.
- jzb 3y ago"obviously it's going to eventually turn into a legal suit and they're going to lose." I'm not convinced that's obvious. I'm guessing for every story of "large corporation held to account for breaking wage laws / committing wage theft" there are 5 stories of them not being held to account. (I could be wrong - it could be 2 stories, it could be 10... but I'm willing to bet they get away with it more than they don't.) Also - is the amount they pay out more than or even equal to what they grabbed, or less? If I read the settlement correctly this means that there won't be a full investigation, e.g. - a deep dive to find out how much money they actually skimmed. This is a settlement so I don't think they ever actually got an absolute tally of how much money was in question. I'd also consider that the corporation may face consequences but the individuals who green lit the decisions are unlikely to suffer. In fact, by the time the bill comes due, legally, isn't there a good chance the folks have already updated their resume with glowing current numbers and moved on to another company? The time period in question was 2014-2017. How many people are even still at those companies from that time period that made these decisions?
- dogsgobork 3y agoIf they do something illegal and don't get caught they win. If they get caught, but the fine is less than they made breaking the law, they win. If they have to pay back the same amount of money, but can pay it years later, they win. If the only punishment for bank robbery were paying the bank back if you got caught, we'd probably see a lot more bank robberies.
- FireBeyond 3y ago> If the only punishment for bank robbery were paying the bank back if you got caught ... and on a schedule mostly convenient for you...
- polygamous_bat 3y agoIn the US corporations are people with some extra provisions for robberies.
- brandall10 3y agoThe Pinto Memo is a great exposition of this... $140M cost to retrofit a modification to the fuel system against a $50M "benefit to society" (ie. legal costs) saving 180 deaths and 180 serious injuries per annum.
- rqtwteye 3y agoSame for US hospitals and health insurance. They constantly make “mistakes” in their favor and the worst thing that can happen is that they have to pay what they are required to pay anyways.
- holoduke 3y agoThe worse thing of all is that these companies dont care for its drivers. On what kind of earth do we live. Hopefully these kind of companies will be seen as pure evil in history books in 100 years from now.
- Scoundreller 3y agoIt’ll be a long list.
- wavemode 3y agoThe way it would usually go is that one or more higher-ups whose job it was to optimize pricing decided to get "creative" with the law. People who eventually noticed that things seemed shady/irregular probably spoke up but their concerns were dismissed (with the same reasoning you mention - "the lawyers probably looked at all of this - of course it must be perfectly legal!") and so they stopped wasting their breath. (Probably also on some level Lyft felt like they needed to follow suit in order to compete on price in their most populous and important customer region.) Keep in mind that the lawyers aren't software engineers - if you tell legal that you're doing A but in the code you're actually doing B, they will tell you "A is perfectly legal, keep doing that." They're not going to review the code for themselves.
- solardev 3y agoTo these companies, the law is just another cost of doing business to be accounted for and amortized whenever possible. If they can feign success in the early years, they get a bunch of investor dollars that they can then use to pay off or bribe their way out of legal situations later, when they're much bigger. After all, they did get away with it, didn't they? 290 million is like 4% of one quarter's revenue for them, to pay back 6 years of operating illegally. Seems like a slap on the wrist if there ever was one.
- akavi 3y agoBarring evidence to the contrary (internal emails/discussion), I definitely would assume mistake over malice. I've worked in Monetization at 3 SaaS cos (admittedly all smaller than Uber, O(100-1000) employees), and at all of them I've seen mistakes of a similar proportion of revenue (~1%) made in both directions (overcharging and undercharging customers) in violation of the letter of our contracts with absolutely zero intent or malice. Wage law adds several additional layers of complexity beyond that.
- dastbe 3y agoat least one cloud provider service over (and sometimes under) charged customers for several years on a particular product due to a misinterpretation of some complex rules. it happens at all orders of magnitude.
- plagiarist 3y agoThis is a wage theft. From the sheer scale of wage theft going on in this country, yes, they do think they will get away with it. And the punishment if they don't is inconsequential.
- wahnfrieden 3y agoIsn’t wage theft the most common and largest form of theft? The reputation of business in the US precedes itself Odd that when this common thievery impacting the hardest working among us shows up among business inclined folks the reaction is oh it must have been in good faith, must be some kind of mistake. When lower stakes lower impact shoplifting occurs, people are immediately discussing punishments and outcries for jettisoning groups of people to preserve our social fabric.
- gen220 3y agoIt's a loan to the Uber at t=x, issued by Uber at t=y+x. The interest on the loan is legal fees and penalties. When the value of the money at t=x is greater than the predicted cost of interest, and you aren't bound by ethical scruples, you take the cash. Sure, a couple drivers might have needed to take out predatory loans to cover their stolen income, but hey at least the company still exists today to fund their future, unbridled income! They should be thankful, actually. Yep, it is the mental gymnastics of might-makes-right.