6 ms·
Uber, Lyft pay $328M for "cheating drivers" out of earnings, NY says
- ccooffee 3y agoThe terms of the settlement[0-pdf] are kind of interesting. Drivers in New York City proper are entitled to $17/hr for sick pay. If I'm reading it correctly, that is also the minimum wage that drivers must be compensated at. However, drivers who begin trips in New York State _but not inside NYC_ are guaranteed pay at $26/hr [see paragraph 30 of settlement]. If I'm reading this right, drivers in Buffalo, Syracuse, Utica, Albany, etc. are all going to reap significantly higher pay from Uber while living in much lower cost-of-living areas. [0-pdf] https://ag.ny.gov/sites/default/files/settlements-agreements/uber-lyft-aods.pdf https://ag.ny.gov/sites/default/files/settlements-agreements...
- dastbe 3y agoYou're reading it wrong, you need to look at https://www.nyc.gov/site/tlc/about/driver-pay-rates.page https://www.nyc.gov/site/tlc/about/driver-pay-rates.page for the pay rates. just looking at the per minute numbers, if you worked 60 minutes of P2+P3 time you would make 33.84, which isn't even considering the per-mile pay.
- crazygringo 3y agoIn terms of illegally deducting sales tax and black car fund fees from drivers' pay... I genuinely don't understand why a large corporation ever messes up like this in the first place. It surely can't be legal incompetence -- a large company like this has lawyers to review these things, and who know the contracts they've created. But it's hard to imagine Uber/Lyft thinking they're going to get away with it -- obviously it's going to eventually turn into a legal suit and they're going to lose. I really don't get it. Often these kinds of situations happen when the law is ambiguous or unclear, and the company it taking a calculated risk that the courts would rule in their favor. But this doesn't seem to be that, unless I'm missing something?
- Scoundreller 3y agoMaybe it’s like Google handing back all the money it made in its early years from advertising gray/black-market pharmacies and prescribing mills. They needed the money then, and had no problem paying it back in 2011, many years later. And if they went bankrupt, well, no way to pay back anyway. Classic “heads we win, tails you lose” situation. Cheaper source of capital than venture capital. And no hit to the cap table. https://theguardian.com/technology/2011/aug/24/google-settles-us-drug-advertising-case https://theguardian.com/technology/2011/aug/24/google-settle...
- sitkack 3y agoIt is fraudulent and stealing, I would think there would be criminal charges against the perpetrators.
- Nextgrid 3y agoFraud/theft only happens to the common man. When a company does it it's either good business acumen or (if they got caught) a "technical glitch affecting a small percentage of users". See also: Comcast mis-billing customers.
- plagiarist 3y agoThe perpetrators are corporations, those are only people when it is convenient for the ruling class for them to be people.
- techsupporter 3y agoSometimes it is incompetence; someone flags a certain thing as the wrong classification and it comes out of the wrong bucket. But I think it's more than that, here. The settlement covers almost the height of when Uber and Lyft were desperately trying to undercut everyone else in the market--taxis, public transit, taking a bike, scooter-share, anything--and keeping these out of view of the customer helps a lot in that effort by making the price look lower. > The Uber settlement fund is for people who "drove for Uber between November 10, 2014, and May 22, 2017, and had deductions taken for New York sales tax and Black Car Fund fees." The Lyft fund is for people who drove for Lyft between October 11, 2015, and July 31, 2017, and had the same kinds of deductions. By my mind, it's in the same vein as businesses (everyone from Comcast to that small restaurant on the corner) that list one price in big numbers but tack on surcharges at the end. Obscuring the true price should be more illegal than it is.
- sschueller 3y agoNow pay the almost half a billion Swiss Francs you owe in unpaid wages/retirement and sick leave to the Swiss drivers.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoIs anything needed to assist the Swiss in pursuing this more aggresively?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- varispeed 3y agoHere the UK government addressed this issue by marrying worst elements of employment and self-employment. With the revised IR35 rules, a company can bring someone on board as a "deemed employee". This means they have to pay the individual through a fee payer, that deducts employee and employer taxes. However, even though these workers are taxed like employees, they are officially self-employed and therefore do not receive the usual employment rights and benefits. So things like minimum wage don't apply.
- Night_Thastus 3y agoIt's only a matter of time before Uber and Lyft cease to exist. Lyft lost what, $1.5 billion last year? The trend isn't towards profitability, and they have had plenty of years to work out the kinks and figure out structural issues. I've said it before, and I'll say it again - if you were to pay for real cost of overhead and to pay the driver, you'd end up with a price that no customer is willing to pay. Uber has briefly entered profitability, but only by absolutely shredding any pay to their drivers, who will jump ship eventually. The reality is that once investors wake up and close their pockets, these companies vanish into dust. It's either that or their drivers will abandon them.
- cozzyd 3y agoI almost never use Uber or Lyft rideshare (sometimes on business travel if no reasonable public transport, but since I'm not paying I'm less cost sensitive there), but Lyft runs the bikesharing system in my city, so hopefully that can be salvaged, since I use that lot...
- Scoundreller 3y agoMy guess is that they’re profitable in some regions and losers in others. They don’t need to disappear everywhere if they run out of capital to work with. They probably run real-life experiments to see “what happens if we increase prices 25% in a region” and have a model for how that can be applied everywhere and where they would just have to close up shop if they needed to go into profit-mode instead of maintenance or growth mode.
- potatolicious 3y agoI suspect you're right, but there lies the bitter disappointment with these companies. I'm sure Uber in NYC makes money, and DoorDash in NYC makes money... but those are also the places where those services have existed for many decades profitably. The whole promise was that with [insert handwaviness] technology the business model can be made to work in places where it was never sustainable before (i.e., the suburbs and much smaller cities). This... overwhelmingly hasn't panned out. I'm generally skeptical of the oversimplistic "you've invented [thing]" complaints that are often leveled at new tech, but in this case... the shoe does seem to fit. The only places this business model seems to work are places where the business model has always worked!
- gumballindie 3y agoI am wondering how much of silicon valley “success” is just theft and lies? Yesterday’s unicorns, today’s ai, all seem to gravitate around shady practices.
- CoastalCoder 3y agoThis reminds me of a line from the movie Sneakers, by one of the bad-guy-company stooges. It was something like, "Remember when computers used to be fun?"
- dralley 3y agoDon't forget ZIRP. Lots of startups are ultimately built on selling dollar bills for 75 cents.
- seneca 3y agoIt's not cheating anyone when both parties knowingly agree to the terms. This is just heavy handed regulation that destroys options for workers and consumers.
- CoastalCoder 3y agoBut in this case, Uber/Lyft were breaking workers' unwaivable legal protections. It's analogous to saying that robbery at gunpoint isn't "cheating", because both sides agree to the terms. Technically it's not "cheating", but that's not the aspect most people care about.
- salamanderss 3y agoThe Uber driver is basically a business owner fulfilling contracts to customers brokered through an online clearinghouse. They're hyper capitalists exploiting regulatory advantages over taxi drivers then sad face at the downsides to that.
- throw_m239339 3y ago> The Uber driver is basically a business owner fulfilling contracts to customers brokered through an online clearinghouse. They're hyper capitalists exploiting regulatory advantages over taxi drivers then sad face at the downsides to that. No they are not, otherwise they could freely set the fare and the market would decide the final price, not Uber or Lyft. Clearly that's not the case here.
- salamanderss 3y agoI would argue Lyft/Uber are merely shitty brokers. You can definitely contract with a broker to use take it or leave it price fixing, it's just not a quality I would particularly desire.
- jkaplowitz 3y agoBoth parties did not knowingly agree to the terms. From the article, quoting the office of NY Attorney General Letitia James: > From 2014 to 2017, Uber deducted sales taxes and Black Car Fund fees from drivers’ payments when those taxes and fees should have been paid by passengers. Uber misrepresented the deductions made to drivers’ pay in their terms of service, telling drivers that Uber would only deduct its commission from the drivers’ fare, and that drivers were “entitled to charge [the passenger] for any tolls, taxes or fees incurred,” though no method to do this was ever provided via the Uber Driver app.
- xchip 3y agoBad use of the quotes, it looks like were the drivers who were cheating, and it was Uber and Lyft.
- salamanderss 3y agoIsn't Uber/Lyft a broker/market? Wouldn't it be the driver cheated himself, or the passenger contracting the driver cheated him?
- dboreham 3y agoLabor laws say you can't declare the drivers to be corporate entities. Presumably because employers would use that as a way to circumvent employment law.
- salamanderss 3y agoUber explicitly lets you drive under an EIN/LLC. If you want to IC it you can as well. You ( not you you but you hypothetical driver) may consider yourself as an employee but it would be if your own company, or self employed. Not Uber's employee except in a few jurisdictions. If you want employee protections by all means drive under your LLC for Uber and declare yourself an employee of your contracted self owned LLC... It sounds doable but IANAL.
- not_enoch_wise 3y agoAnd we would have gotten away with it, too, if it weren’t for you meddling regulations!
- unethical_ban 3y agoArs' title should have "cheating" drivers, or "cheating drivers out of earnings", not "cheating drivers" out of earnings.
- TrackerFF 3y agoWhen your business (model) is built around skirting labor laws, you either become big and powerful enough to change those laws to your own advantage, or you pay the piper when that time comes around, and pivot/change your business model...or simply cease to exist.
- decafninja 3y agoAlways love how any thread on Uber or Lyft inevitably contains a debate about Uber/Lyft versus taxicabs and how someone’s have had bad experiences and vow never to use one or the other. Also inevitably someone chiming in about how cars in general are evil incarnate and everyone must convert to public transportation and bicycles.
- mcbrit 3y ago? You haven't engaged with even ONE concrete argument; ideally, you would scan all arguments and engage with in good faith the very best argument. Or alternatively just say: nope, not interested. But you just strawmaned against nothing. Not so great.
- lbrito 3y agoNever seen anyone classifiy personal cars as evil incarnate. Extremely damaging to humans, inefficient and full of negative externalities, yes. Alas this has nothing to do with the post.
- indymike 3y agoI had a car, that was in fact evil incarnate. It ate four transmissions, three engines, and managed to destroy six CV joints before the manufacturer put a lemon wood stake through it's black, little, mechanical heart. It had a sixth sense. It knew exactly where to break down. It would bide it's time until you were at least eight miles from civilization, and had no cell phone coverage. Then it would seize up, with the engine frozen in gear, so you were left with the choice, stay with the car and wait for someone to help, or leave it, guaranteeing you'd have to pay for a tow and impound.
- j-bos 3y agoThe quotation marks in the headline make it sound like uber lost money to fraudulent drivers, rather than the actual story, the drivers were the ones ripped off.
- Vicinity9635 3y ago[dead]
- renewiltord 3y agoDo I understand this correctly? Customer pays $100 for service, Uber takes (say) $45 => Driver allocation is $55. Uber now collects $10 tax from here and gives the driver $45. That's wrong because the passenger should be paying the sales tax. So the right way to do it is Customer pays $100 for service + tax, which is $90.91 service + $9.09 tax. Uber takes (same ratio) $40.90. Driver allocation is now $50.01. Okay, so the accounting was wrong here. That makes sense. Does this mean that Uber will be going back to get that extra taxed money back from the government if they paid it?