8 ms·
Light can make water evaporate without heat
- smolder 3y agoThey give current solar desalination efficiency as 1.5 kilos of water per square meter. Shouldn't there be a time component?
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 3y agoWouldn't that be rate rather than efficiency?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- smolder 3y agoSo maybe it would be better stated as 1.5 kilos per x joules of sunlight (or per area per day average? At the equator?) but as stated I can't make sense of it.
- pests 3y agoThe number is more about the potential productivity of the system across a time period (a full day, I believe), rather than the speed at which it produces purified water at any given moment. Here is an article from 2020 from MIT using the same units and wording: https://news.mit.edu/2020/passive-solar-powered-water-desalination-0207 https://news.mit.edu/2020/passive-solar-powered-water-desali... I do agree its confusing. edit: Later in the MIT article they state their device (which is also a 5.8L/m2 system) - "[...] roughly 1-square-meter solar collecting area could meet the daily drinking water needs of one person. So I will assume the numbers are per day. edit2: On second thought, the units aren't that confusing. We already use "BTU", for example, to measure air conditioner performance. We just know that means "per hour". Then just the additional complexity of it being based off surface area. "We bought a 6L/m2 solar desalination plant" sounds the same as "We bought a 15,000 BTU A/C unit". Consumer marketing would drop the sizing - "We just bought a 10L desalination plant" and the thing is as big as it needs to be.
- klyrs 3y agoAlso, do they mean "peak" or "mean"...
- IshKebab 3y agoThey're using Journalist Power Units. You're lucky it's not in houses per year.
- hinkley 3y agoHow many Libraries of Congress full of water is this?
- suprjami 3y agoI love seeing insane units like this in the press. Dishwashers, giraffes, bowling balls, etc. Americans will measure in anything but the metric system.
- Sai_ 3y agoOne such measure stands out to me - they described the accuracy of some computer hardware as “missing one blade of grass while mowing a lawn the size of a football field flying from a helicopter over mile up in the air” (paraphrasing and using quotes to demarcate the interesting bit; not a literal quote). I guess it’s effective and memorable because even months later, I remember the gist of the accuracy claim (though not the hardware item name)
- bmacho 3y agoI am not American, but I love illustrations. A number + an amount of giraffes that illustrate it are better than just the number.
- Nition 3y agoMy favourite is an old one from the NZ Herald: "6.85kg - the equivalent of nearly seven 1kg blocks of cheese."
- dr_dshiv 3y agoThis technology leads directly to cloud lasers. Yesss
- _boffin_ 3y agoCloud what?
- stevemk14ebr 3y agolasers that make clouds, I assume - cloud lasers
- sdfghswe 3y agoWhy is it surprising? Light can transfer momentum into the water, which is was matters for the process of evaporation...?
- vivekd 3y agoIsn't 'transfer momentum' just a round about way of saying "heat up." I think the interesting aspect here is that the evaporation is greater than what can be explained by heat alone.
- ace2358 3y agoYeh I read it as though it’s a form of catalyst. Ultimately the light is changing the threshold energy at which water can evaporate. Similar to the photoelectric effect. Similar say to an enzyme. All these environmental changes to the reaction lower the ‘action’ energy making the reaction vastly more efficient or possible in an environment that it wasn’t possible in previously.
- mercutio2 3y agoEnzymes catalyze the breaking of molecular bonds. The embodied energy of a phase transition does not pay attention to what path you took to cross it. There’s no “threshold” between phases of water. For H20 to move from liquid water to vapor, energy must be added. There’s no catalyst. So either we’ve discovered some new physics since I last studied thermodynamics, or this isn’t an accurate analogy.
- catskul2 3y agoIt could be that the energy required to break the hydrogen bond from random collisions is higher than the theoretical minimum because the angle of a typical collision "wastes" energy in imparting vibration or rotation of the water molecule rather than just imparting "escape velocity". Just a wild guess though. Haven't yet read the article.
- tsimionescu 3y ago
- bo-tao 3y agoWhy stop at water
- westurner 3y ago"Plausible photomolecular effect leading to water evaporation exceeding the thermal limit" (2023) https://www.pnas.org/doi/abs/10.1073/pnas.2312751120 https://www.pnas.org/doi/abs/10.1073/pnas.2312751120 : > Abstract: We report in this work several unexpected experimental observations on evaporation from hydrogels under visible light illumination. 1) Partially wetted hydrogels become absorbing in the visible spectral range, where the absorption by both the water and the hydrogel materials is negligible. 2) Illumination of hydrogel under solar or visible-spectrum light-emitting diode leads to evaporation rates exceeding the thermal evaporation limit, even in hydrogels without additional absorbers. 3) The evaporation rates are wavelength dependent, peaking at 520 nm. 4) Temperature of the vapor phase becomes cooler under light illumination and shows a flat region due to breaking-up of the clusters that saturates air. And 5) vapor phase transmission spectra under light show new features and peak shifts. We interpret these observations by introducing the hypothesis that photons in the visible spectrum can cleave water clusters off surfaces due to large electrical field gradients and quadrupole force on molecular clusters. We call the light-induced evaporation process the photomolecular effect. The photomolecular evaporation might be happening widely in nature, potentially impacting climate and plants’ growth, and can be exploited for clean water and energy technologies. Can low-cost integrated photonics help with e.g. water desalination and sterilization? #Goal6 #CleanWater > Under certain conditions, at the interface where water meets air, light can directly bring about evaporation without the need for heat, and it actually does so even more efficiently than heat. In these experiments, the water was held in a hydrogel material, but the researchers suggest that the phenomenon may occur under other conditions as well. Various methods of integrated photonics with various production costs: https://news.ycombinator.com/context?id=38056088 https://news.ycombinator.com/context?id=38056088
- croes 3y agoRelated https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38112574 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38112574
- yeknoda 3y agoOf note, Gang Chen was recently slandered and unjustly prosecuted by the US gov for china research collaborations. Good to see he is getting back on his feet.
- frud 3y agoI can't wrap my head around this story. What does it mean in thermodynamic terms? Isn't there a fixed amount of energy per mass that it takes to convert liquid water into vapor? Why does it matter that the energy comes from light?
- its-summertime 3y agoif you leave a container of liquid in a cold dry room, it will eventually become empty and the room will become more humid Heat speeds up this process via excitation, photon bombardment speeds up this process also. I'm guessing its more a matter of, if you heat up stuff, you need to heat up stuff and everything around it. Light can be a lot more controllable and directed. In addition, internal reflection can happen within water against air, meaning a free second (third, fourth, fifth, etc) attempt at depositing energy somewhere.
- pdonis 3y ago> I'm guessing its more a matter of, if you heat up stuff, you need to heat up stuff and everything around it. Light can be a lot more controllable and directed Exactly.
- fspeech 3y agoEntropy favors the vapor form. It doesn't necessarily take energy to evaporate.
- frud 3y agoIt takes [40.66 kJ/mol](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enthalpy_of_vaporization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enthalpy_of_vaporization) to vaporize water. There are no shortcuts.
- stubish 3y agoThe shortcut is apparently breaking the bonds of groups of molecules, rather than supplying enough energy to break all the bonds of each individual molecule. But still technically correct, with the airborne groups breaking apart into individual modules cooling the air. But you don't have to supply all that energy and get to break some theoretical limits.
- bilsbie 3y agoWould this be useful for desalination or laundry?
- Whooping7116 3y agoI can make water evaporate too (by drinking it and making it disappear;)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- xwkd 3y agoPlease excuse my understanding as a layman, but could this be related to the electromagnetic absorption spectrum of water? https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/18/Absorption_spectrum_of_liquid_water.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/18/Absorpti... It seems that the "green" wavelength that the article cites is exactly where the lowest point of absorption is. Could this suggest that heat is created as a result of electromagnetic resistance? (Like water molecules vibrating as a result of microwave radiation?)
- throwawaaarrgh 3y ago> Could this suggest that heat is created as a result of electromagnetic resistance? Lightbulbs getting hot would suggest that is correct, but maybe I'm missing what you're saying
- ok_computer 3y agoThat’s what I’m trying to understand too. Analogously, chemical sunscreens turn UV to heat by absorbing wavelengths with their different bonds and vibrating.
- NikkiA 3y agoBut heat IS light, and vice versa.
- elil17 3y agoLight isn't heat (heat is the kinetic energy of the disordered movement of particles). Evaporation normally occurs because molecules have enough of this disordered kinetic energy to break from their intermolecular bonds and enter the air. In this case, light is physically knocking small clusters of several molecules into the air together in an ordered way.
- kazinator 3y agoI'm skeptical. There is a "latent heat of evaporation" that has to be put in; some of it is coming from the light.
- klysm 3y agoThis is really cool, but I'm confused how we haven't stumbled into this before? Wouldn't this be quite obvious under some napkin math or does it have more to do with the specific hydrogels they were using?
- 101011 3y agoThis makes me think about a story that Richard Feynman told about experiments and how often people miss the most important part about cargo cult science. Here was him talking about how we got better and better resolution around the charge of an electron: > Why didn’t they discover that the new number was higher right away? It’s a thing that scientists are ashamed of—this history—because it’s apparent that people did things like this: When they got a number that was too high above Millikan’s, they thought something must be wrong—and they would look for and find a reason why something might be wrong. When they got a number closer to Millikan’s value they didn’t look so hard. And so they eliminated the numbers that were too far off, and did other things like that. We’ve learned those tricks nowadays, and now we don’t have that kind of a disease. https://calteches.library.caltech.edu/51/2/CargoCult.htm https://calteches.library.caltech.edu/51/2/CargoCult.htm
- abdullahkhalids 3y agoIt seems to be an extreme small effect, which only becomes apparent to someone looking for it under specifically controlled experimental conditions. This sort of thing happens all the time in chemistry, material science and condensed matter physics. There are infinite possibilities of putting things together, and only some of them are interesting. It takes a lot of manual work to isolate some phenomena like this.
- montjoy 3y ago> The researchers found that the effect varied with color and peaked at a particular wavelength of green light. I wonder if this affects photosynthesis in any way? IIRC plants are green because chlorophyll does not absorb that color. Maybe that’s partially because green light induces too much evaporation?
- canadianfella 3y agoI’ve always wondered why inefficient green is the way plants evolved. Interesting question.
- genewitch 3y ago[green] plants are damaged by green light, is the way i've heard it explained. So they "block it".
- malfist 3y agoMaybe, but evaporation is critical for plants. They don't have a heart to pump blood and supply nutrients, they have to rely on evaporation to move nutrients from the roots up
- chimpanzee 3y agoI imagine the leaves being green would encourage this evaporation. The upper layers of cells are probably effectively translucent and might be awash in green light, perhaps increasing the rate of evaporation and improving overall transpiration.
- xigency 3y agoThat’s my guess as well. The green chlorophyll is inside of the cell. It absorbs sunlight for food but reflects the green light back through the water-air boundary. Perhaps the effect on evaporation or water movement provides a better benefit for the plant than absorbing the energy of that spectra. For instance, by increasing the efficiency of respiration.
- dang 3y agoRelated ongoing thread: Photomolecular effect leading to water evaporation exceeding the thermal limit - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38112574 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38112574
- colechristensen 3y agoThis is being misinterpreted here. They have found an unknown mechanism where water is absorbing light it would not absorb otherwise while in the boundary layer of a hydrogel and thus evaporating faster than it would if simply heated. If not a mistake or some unsustainable side reaction, this could mean cheaper things that require evaporation like desalination. A lot of people here though are saying it means things which would violate conservation of energy.
- gtbcb 3y agoWhat happens to the light? Wouldn’t it have to lose energy and reduce the frequency (ie change color to the red end of the spectrum)?
- jagged-chisel 3y agoOr be absorbed and not transmitted.
- pomian 3y agoTwo things to wonder about, that we didn't see mentioned in article, which I'm sure were considered somewhere. What about the differences in bonding strength between water molecules surrounded by water, as opposed to water in the hydro gel. The other thing, which is sort of related, is partial pressure differences between a pure water surface exposed to air, and a water hydrogel surface exposed to air. Looks like very interesting further studies required.
- geoffcampbell64 3y agoI wonder how long it’ll be until someone figures out how to utilize this effect to create a heat pump! I would guess that this “photomolecular heat pump” might be easier to miniaturize since it has no need for a compressor. I wonder if other solvents or refrigerant might also be more efficient working fluids than water. Very exciting!!
- elil17 3y agoYou'd definitely still need a compressor - otherwise there'd be no change in pressure driving a change in temperature. I guess you're suggesting that the photomolecular effect could be used to boil the refrigerant at the heat pump's evaporator. Boiling is a bulk process caused when the temperature of the fluid rises so much that all it's intermolecular bonds start to get broken. Evaporation is a surface process where a few molecules randomly break free of their intermolecular bonds and mix with surrounding air. Boiling, not evaporation, occurs in a heat pump's evaporator (despite the name). The photomolecular effect doesn't cause boiling, only evaporation. You wouldn't really want evaporation to happen in an evaporator because you'd need to have air around and then you'd be compressing a bunch of air along with your refrigerant, which would waste a lot of energy. My first thought was some sort of cooling tower application. Cooling towers use evaporating water to cool various process fluids. But, when building a cooling tower, you want to pull down the temperature of the water by having evaporation absorb the heat in the water. This evaporation process actually reduces the amount of heat that gets absorbed from the water because it uses energy from light and heat from the air instead. If this has engineering applications, it will likely be in places where the end goal is the evaporation of the water itself, such as a drying process or passive desalination.
- ezconnect 3y agoNow I know the reason for my clothes drying when hanging them outside.
- spandextwins 3y agoAnd heat can make water evaporate without light! Wow!
- waldothedog 3y agoAny one else familiar with “solar vapor drive” in the building science community (vapor being driven into buildings from the outside simply due to solar exposure)? My understanding is that it is expected even in the absence of warmth. Is this the same effect?
- jagged-chisel 3y ago> … even in the absence of warmth. Tangent (adjacent?): my ice “cubes” evaporate. (They’re hollow cylinders) If I put into my freezer more ice than I can use in a week, about half of the top layer of blocks has lost quite a bit of their substance.
- lovemenot 3y agoYour ice is sublimating. Cold dry air absorbs vapour directly from the solid water. The more surface area is exposed to air (hollow cylinders) the more it'll sublimate.
- KingLancelot 3y ago[dead]
- souplantation 3y agotest
- Sparkyte 3y agoSo can sound, almost as if anything with energy can move or excite particles. In other news scientist discovers water is wet.
- viraptor 3y agoSound would literally mean waves of kinetic energy hitting both the surface of the water and traveling inside it. Does that really count as "without heat"?
- Sparkyte 3y agoAnd what type of energy is light?
- viraptor 3y agoOne which can get absorbed by a single molecule individually as opposed to sound which has to affect large groups of them, increasing movement / heat.
- MagicMoonlight 3y agoSound is movement, it’s not a particle. It’s your way of sensing stuff smashing together by feeling the ripple that comes off it
- Sparkyte 3y agoBoth kinetic energy.
- bmacho 3y agoImagine a material, or a passive device, that can evaporate a glass of water fast, using only the heat of the environment, as the energy source. That is possible, and would be huge.
- 3y ago
- bethekind 3y ago> evaporation rates are wavelength dependent, peaking at 520 nm Basically green is apparently a great wavelength to evaporate water at. Interesting
- dclowd9901 3y agoI must be missing something. My ice cubes in my freezer evaporate with no light and no heat. My understanding of the situation was the surrounding air was pulling off moisture because of some sort of osmosis effect. So why is this news?
- quickthrower2 3y agoThere is heat in your freezer, unless you cool it to 0 Kelvin.
- yetihehe 3y agoThis is news because we thought that light by itself doesn't actually affect water evaporation. We found a new mechanism for evaporation, that's exciting, scientists love when they find something that allows them to find out even more about how things work.
- mfeldheim 3y agoFunny enough, the foggy season has the least heat.. and the least light
- nikster 3y agoThis is a massive discovery! It's hard to even imagine the multitude of applications of this.
- moring 3y agoThings I am wondering: 1. Is the magnitude of the effect dependent on the angle of incidence? 2. Can the effect be increased by increasing the water surface, e.g. by stirring? 3. totally layman speaking here: is the peak at green somehow explainable by the refractive index at that wavelength? The explanation can't be trivial, otherwise you'd expect the peak to be at either end of the spectrum, not at a specific wavelength, because the refractive index seems to be roughly linear with the wavelength within the visible spectrum, otherwise rainbows wouldn't work that way.
- sandworm101 3y agoI dont see the breakthrough. All light causes evaporation, even at near-zero heat. Every light ray has the possibility of knocking off a molecule of water, transfering enough energy to turn it into gas. If the angles are just right, the water molecule vibrating just the right way, it gets lauched off the surface to become gas. Whether it stays gas depends on other things, but i dont see how observing the process is anything new; Better defining the process but not worthy of the article title.
- waiquoo 3y ago'All light causes evaporation' is not really true. IR heating works because the wavelength resonates with the vibration modes of the intramolecular bonds. Water has low absorption of visible wavelengths, so you would not expect light absorption in the visible spectrum to provide enough energy to knock individual water molecules free. Water is an interesting substance and a lot of the properties of water come from intermolecular hydrogen bonding and polarity. Even though it's a liquid, there are transient molecular structures that spontaneously occur in bulk due to hydrogen bonding between water molecules. The polarity of water causes interesting effect at interfaces (surface tension, electrical double layer, etc). It's possible that the water in the hydrogel is forming some hydrogen bonded structure that interacts with green light. Where the individual water molecules won't strongly interact, the larger structure does. That could lead to the ejection of 'packets' of water molecules as discussed in the paper. Why and what these multi-molecular structures are? No idea. But this is a very interesting effect.
- hk1337 3y agoDoesn’t the light itself transfer heat? Like with a magnifying glass and an ant, it amplifies and possibly focuses the light to burn the ant. Or even more simply, sunburns.
- 1970-01-01 3y agoFrom the paper: For the wavelength-dependent evaporation measurement, we used LED with different wavelengths. LED lamps were purchased from Chanzon with rated power of 100 W and different wavelengths: purple 390nm, blue 440nm, green 520nm, yellow 590nm, red 650nm, and IR 850nm. Note that rated power is not the same as energy. E=hf. Since green had the most impact on evaporation, this phenomenon is not similar to the photoelectric effect.
- kovacs_x 3y agois this the reason plants are mostly green? :?