6 ms·
Daydream I - The SEC and bank regulators start requiring banks (& such) to disclose how badly their portfolios are impaired by $Pretend/month "rents" that nobod
by bell-cot 3y ago
Daydream I - The SEC and bank regulators start requiring banks (& such) to disclose how badly their portfolios are impaired by $Pretend/month "rents" that nobody is paying.
Daydream II - When local zoning authorities require ground-floor retail in new developments, but the local vacancy rate for such space is over (say) 5%, then the developer receives a "lease put option" - allowing him to rent that retail space to the zoning municipality at (say) 80% of the then-current local rental rates for similar spaces. If the municipality fails to pay up, it loses its zoning authority.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- VinLucero 3y agoVery cool ideas, but so difficult to execute. Reminds me of income share agreements from personal Fintech, but applied to Commercial Real Estate.
- helen___keller 3y ago> When local zoning authorities require ground-floor retail in new developments, but the local vacancy rate for such space is over (say) 5%, then the developer receives a "lease put option" - allowing him to rent that retail space to the zoning municipality at (say) 80% of the then-current local rental rates for similar spaces. If the municipality fails to pay up, it loses its zoning authority. I see what you’re getting at but for all of americas zoning woes, I don’t think the answer is to make a patchwork of laws that say “if current zoning causes a bad outcome, cover their losses or lose your zoning authority”
- mattnewton 3y agoYou’re right, if we have this authority we could just radically relax zoning laws in the first place. Most of the things people are using zoning for, like not living near noise or pollution are already directly regulated, and directly regulating the bad thing works better anyways.
- nottorp 3y agoI don't think zoning laws need relaxation... just a radical overhaul towards walkable more dense cities :)
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI think it is interesting in concept. It would basically hold the government and public accountable for the negative externalities of zoning decisions. This is obviously attractive if you already think free use of private property is the natural state. Eg if the state says you can't live in or rent your property, they should compensate you for the value they get. Obviously, I think it would be ripe for corruption
- nikanj 3y agoAs a landlord, I could rent to a tenant for $2k/mo with all the risks and wear/tear from that lease - or I could hijack the rent to $20k/mo, let the property sit empty for the predetermined time, and then force-feed the lease to the city.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoNo, you couldn't, your list price near comes into it the way it was written up
- andrewjl 3y agoHow does a valid range of list prices get determined?
- s1artibartfast 3y agoIn the parent post, they said: >80% of the then-current local rental rates for similar spaces. That is to say, you benchmark it. If someone across the street is renting their place for $1000, and the city says you cant rent yours, they would have to pay you $800 to keep it empty. Benchmarking sounds complicated, but is extremely common. My city reassesses my property value using benchmarks every year to determine property taxes. Of course, they use totally unrealistic numbers, and I have to call them out on it, and then they back down because they are indefensible.
- cyanydeez 3y ago
- firedaemon 3y agoTrying to understand what you are going for here. In my experience in 2 separate cities, lack of ground floor retail leads to barren neighborhoods of luxury condos that aren’t in walking distance of anything meaningful. And frequently, the ground floor retail that is put in is priced unreasonably so as to stay vacant. But you think that we should encourage everyone to overprice so as to increase the put option value? And you like the idea of vacant space?
- cyanydeez 3y agothey're building these ground floor retail everywhere here. the only useful one is a grocer that sources labor from volunteers for discounts on food. the rest appear empty or have bars /(also empty) or some other useless high expense niche purpose. it's definitely a situation that zoning alone won't fix. I'm definitely in a food desert and the closest grocer is a coop that probably doesn't support low cost food options. there's no capitalism or market based fixes here. you need to actually get your hands dirty if you want to improve quality of life
- BigRedDog1669 3y agozoning and business laws prevent market based solutions, so we don't know that there aren't market fixes. The retail space prices are so absurd because there was only a limited part of the city where you can do retail. Go to 'third world countries' and there are plenty of groceries in neighborhoods as well as street vendors that are illegal in the US.
- bsder 3y agoThe solution is actually an "occupancy tax". If you aren't renting out a space within some number of months, you start owing tax on what your financial agreement says is your "rent". The longer you go unoccupied, the higher that tax should get since your unoccupied front winds up contributing to "blight".
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> If you aren't renting out a space within some number of months, you start owing tax on what your financial agreement says is your "rent" This cascades into consolidation in crisis. Small landholders can’t afford to ride out the trouble. Large ones can.
- toyg 3y agoThresholds are a thing.
- ikiris 3y agoWhat is the problem with removing landlords from an area if their property isn't being utilized?
- blitzar 3y agoYou mind if I remove some money from your bank account that I dont think you are properly utilizing?
- kasey_junk 3y agoThat’s precisely what our current inflationary monetary policy does. You can argue whether that’s good or bad but we have governmental policies that encourage productive use of assets so it’s not out of bounds to suggest other policies for land assets.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoCompanies aren't people.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> SEC and bank regulators start requiring banks (& such) to disclose how badly their portfolios are impaired by $Pretend/month "rents" that nobody is paying You are looking for non-performing loan reporting. The FDIC collects these in detail to the degree that, should you want to override GAAP, you have sufficient model inputs to calculate in the aggregate.
- p0ckets 3y agoI think your first proposal addresses the root cause. But the second proposal - forcing municipalities to write options with unlimited potential losses - is silly. The whole point of the zoning authority is to say "it'll be best for the neighborhood in the long run for there to be some retail shops here", and it makes sense whether you're talking about a lot or the first floor of a building. If the development isn't profitable with the ground-floor retail requirement, then just don't build it. Some sort of option might work, but it would have to be something like: the municipality can choose to rent the space for a fixed price if it's vacant for long enough. This encourages the landlord to rent it for some higher price.
- mjevans 3y agoMaybe something like: If a property is vacant for 6 or more months out of a year, the (government regulating this) can forcefully change the 'offered' terms to be as good as the best for any active lease's term item among all leases within 10 miles, and also go beyond with up to 50% discounts on any monetary restrictions imposed in those terms. This includes deposit and lease rate. The former part is to break unusually onerous terms that might exist which I'm not aware of. The latter is the club to encourage flexibility and settling on not long term national retail clients.
- RecycledEle 3y ago> forcing municipalities to write options with unlimited potential losses - is silly I think local governments forcing someone to lose everything they own with silly zoning rules is silly.
- eru 3y ago> Daydream II - When local zoning authorities require ground-floor retail in new developments, but the local vacancy rate for such space is over (say) 5%, then the developer receives a "lease put option" - allowing him to rent that retail space to the zoning municipality at (say) 80% of the then-current local rental rates for similar spaces. If the municipality fails to pay up, it loses its zoning authority. Why so complicated? If you want a legal fix, look into overturning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Village_of_Euclid_v._Ambler_Realty_Co https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Village_of_Euclid_v._Ambler_Re....
- Animats 3y agoThe ground-floor retail thing in residential developments seems to be a dud. There's a huge amount of such retail being built in Silicon Valley, but not much interesting moves in. I've been looking at Google Earth. Nail salons, phone stores, ice cream, and rental offices that stretch half a block to fill up the space. No place to park, and the buildings themselves won't generate enough traffic for their ground floor retail. Even in areas with much foot traffic, such as downtown Redwood City, about a third of the retail space is vacant.
- bobthepanda 3y agoPart of the problem is that the new retail spaces are very large. They get built out to the size of a chain pharmacy or bank, because chain tenants are like the golden ticket of stability, yet very few businesses can profitably, reliably fill spaces that large. If you look at thriving ground floor retail in traditional cities, often the storefronts are as small as 25 feet wide.
- userinanother 3y agoWhy not just force land lords to lease out the space at whatever the market will bear even if that amount is near zero. That way we can have local art space or makers or pottery spots or just cowork spaces? Most of those land lords are asking more than market rates hence the vacancy