13 ms·
Who ever did not see this one coming when 23andMe launched was asleep at the switch. DNA databases are ripe for abuse and this is just another form of abuse. Fi
by jacquesm 3y ago
Who ever did not see this one coming when 23andMe launched was asleep at the switch. DNA databases are ripe for abuse and this is just another form of abuse. First they get you to pay to give them your samples and then they get paid again to pass your data to other parties without obtaining your specific consent for that transfer.
When 23andMe launched I was absolutely amazed at how HN and less technical audiences ran with it, the abuse potential - and that's before we get into 'hacker lifted your sequences or prints' - was blatantly obvious.
- donohoe 3y agoExactly this. Which is why I never used these services. The disappointment and betrayal is inevitable.
- RocketOne 3y agoEven worse though, is that it doesnt even have to be you submitting your data. Several killers have been caught because their family members have submitted DNA and the killers have been tracked down using DNA ancestry. It really sucks, because it only takes one gullible person to really expose your family to data mining.
- User23 3y agoIf you were born in a hospital your DNA is already collected[1]. You may as well benefit from it too. Also, bringing murderers to justice is a pretty odd thing to object to. [1] https://www.aclu.org/documents/newborn-dna-banking https://www.aclu.org/documents/newborn-dna-banking
- alistairSH 3y agoTwo wrongs don’t make a right. I object to non-consensual collection of newborn DNA as well. And it’s not bringing murderers to justice per se. It’s the implications to others. I don’t want MegaCorp extrapolating my medical history via my cousin’s DNA.
- brnaftr361 3y agoYeah, but now you're associated with a killer, whatever SNPs you share pile up into correlates. Insurance companies see you as feckless, lenders see you as risky, law enforcement sees you as a likely criminal, justice sees you as a burden. And maybe it wasn't even you that volunteered the sample. And maybe I share some of the SNPs, and maybe I have some countermutations, but they aren't properly analyzed. Now my feet are in the fire despite no predisposition to violence or recklessness just an association. This is one step and I expect another. For the greater good, for security, for the safety of the nation, for the children.
- celrod 3y agoIf any of my family members are secretly killers, I would not feel bad about them getting caught... But I would feel bad if, e.g., insurance premiums were to go up because I had inherited risk factors for some costly diseases.
- chunkyks 3y agoOr even worse, premiums went up because you could have inherited costly diseases (but didn't), and they have no way to verify it unless you also prostrate yourself on the altar of no privacy.
- lucubratory 3y agoHow confident are you that the government of the country you live in will use the ability to genetically trace the entire population through long range genetic scanning to harm only people you think deserve to be harmed? Keeping in mind that as long as these databases are allowed to exist, the genetic information itself remains relevant for hundreds of years? Basically, this let's the government put a tracker on every person as long as they can get to where that person was within a couple of months to years (depending on conditions), and every future government gets to decide exactly who should be subject to that level of surveillance, what crime is bad enough to justify it. Do you trust the government of the United States 100 years from now to be that aligned with your personal views? Zero concern that a Hitler-figure could arise in the US and use that power to exterminate large numbers of people?
- graphe 3y agoI sure hope they don't use my DNA to catch any criminals. I hope they roam around undetected as before, I would never harbor any bad feelings towards any members of my family regardless of their rape, murder or other crimes. You don't want them in prison either, and wouldn't believe they did anything wrong regardless of the DNA and OTHER substantial evidence would you?
- lcfcjs 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ren_engineer 3y agofounder was married to a Google founder, sister was CEO of YouTube for years. Only logical that the endgame would be monetizing user data
- toomuchtodo 3y agoI willingly gave them my DNA. I want to support research and better drug development, and gave broad consent towards that end. (disclosure: also interviewed there over a decade ago and declined the offer only because of lacking comp, don’t recall the name of their CTO around Jan 2011 but was a cool dude)
- ssteeper 3y agoDid you intend to give your DNA to GSK PLC too? The company that bought the DNA data from 23andme is GSK PLC, the tenth largest pharmaceutical company and #294 on the 2022 Fortune Global 500. In 2012, GSK pleaded guilty to promotion of drugs for unapproved uses, failure to report safety data and kickbacks to physicians in the United States and agreed to pay a US$3 billion (£1.9bn) settlement. It was the largest health-care fraud case to date in the US and the largest settlement by a drug company. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GSK_plc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GSK_plc
- toomuchtodo 3y agoI intended to give it to anyone 23andme would provide it to. I previously provided it to Harvard’s Personal Genome Project, along with my lifetime medical records. More recently, Northwestern Medicine and a similar program in affiliation with the National Institute of Health (“AllOfUs”). https://www.personalgenomes.org/ https://www.personalgenomes.org/ https://www.joinallofus.org/ https://www.joinallofus.org/ https://www.joinallofus.org/learn-more https://www.joinallofus.org/learn-more I still want fraud prosecuted, regardless of entity. Complex problems are full of nuance. Are we here for sound bites? Or to solve complex problems?
- solardev 3y agoThank you! You mirrored my thought process exactly. Is there an open genome movement where you can just donate your genome into the public domain? I don't really care who has access to it, but it's a hassle to have to manually apply for each project that wants it.
- Mesmoria 3y agoIIRC, wasnt this their stated intention from the beginning, along with a plan to virtually test against DNA?
- mustaflex 3y agoI'm fairly uneducated in this area, can you explains in what ways our own DNAs will be used to our detriment by theses drug companies? (if will leave 23andMe and the likes out of the question)
- teachrdan 3y agoI can think of one dystopian application off the top of my head. A pharmaceutical company develops a treatment for a terminal, currently-uncurable disease like Huntington's. Without your permission, they identify you as having the gene for Huntington's and pitch their drug to you. Many people at risk of Huntington's deliberately don't test for it, bc the prognosis is so bad and it causes so much anxiety to know you have it. A marketing campaign like this -- even with a drug with marginal benefits -- could be both very profitable and devastating. Bonus! The drug company itself wouldn't have to be the one to actually make the pitch to you. It could be a third-party pharma retailer who does it, selling the drug to you at a markup.
- golergka 3y agoIn most cases, being (truthfully) told that you have a disease and being offered a cure (at least attempted in good faith) is a good thing. Most people throughout history could only dream of something like this.
- DoreenMichele 3y agoThe problem is they don't cure you of genetic disorders. They treat you -- forever, until you die. And God forbid you object to the side effects or quality of life this gets you.
- ryanklee 3y agoNot really sure why this is nefarious. I'd rather be treated than die. And if I don't think the side effects are worth it, then I'm still free to die. What does this have to do with malice?
- monero-xmr 3y agoI’m fine with it. I gave them my DNA. I want diseases to be cured. They have a great repository of genetic material with which to save lives.
- lm28469 3y ago> I gave them my DNA. I want diseases to be cured. These are two independent statements with no connection whatsoever. "I gave up my right to bear arms to stop wars in the world"
- taneq 3y agoWas this not always the end game?
- solardev 3y agoI paid them so that they can do useful things with my sample, like correlate it with research or do more research on their own. I then volunteered to share more of my data in their surveys, and collected more samples for them for further research. I think it's fantastic that they are sharing this with drug companies. In fact, my main question is: What took them so long?! My DNA isn't some terrible secret I have to hide in the dark. I'm just one of like 8 billion variants of imperfectly copied ape. Maybe paying 23andme to do something useful with it will be my only lasting legacy in this world, lol. It's not that I "didn't see it coming", it's that I hoped this would happen from the get-go.
- jacquesm 3y agoGSK doesn't have your well being as it's goal, it has it's own revenue stream as its goal. Without an ethical framework around consent for the use of this data the potential for abuse is substantial, upsides are optional. They need to make that money back somehow.
- solardev 3y agoIf my worthless genomic data contributes to a drug that one day helps even one other person, I'm fine with this. Would I prefer all this data be free and open? Sure. Failing that, would I want to hold onto it? No. I'd still rather some mega evil pharma have it and be able to develop some overpriced medication that may one day be genericized. It's not doing me or anyone any good just sitting in my body. Hell, I'll spit for anyone wanting to do research, for profit or not. I think there are very few true "good guys" in the world. But if mega evil pharma corp has even a 1% chance of accidentally doing some tiny good as a byproduct of their evil... that's already more than would've happened if 23andme didn't share it with them. It's cool with me if they make some money in the process. My DNA isn't some creative work that I need royalties on. What nature giveth, I spiteth.
- MerelyMortal 3y agoJust because you value something as worthless, does not mean everyone else values it as worthless.
- tgv 3y ago> Who ever did not see this one coming Were also the people who have very little understanding of biology and/or privacy. I'd say that covers a good 90% of the population.
- seydor 3y agoI m glad they use the data, and have volunteered my data to other services as well. This was actually my reasoning for using these services from the beginning. It's sad that laws prevent them from giving us health reports. DNA data is not worth protecting imho, and the benefits from their public use are very big. The DNA degrees-of-separation between any two humans is less than 3, so we are all traceable anyway already, and people should be aware of that. But the science/health benefits that can come out of this remain enormous.
- mfld 3y agoBut several consumer genetics companies do offer health reports. AFAIK it is perfectly allowed to turn insights from studies into personalized reports as long it is clear that this is not diagnostics or medical advice.
- seydor 3y agohttps://int.customercare.23andme.com/hc/en-us/articles/217696258-Will-I-Receive-Health-Reports- https://int.customercare.23andme.com/hc/en-us/articles/21769... People can use some external services like promethease. 23andme is likely to have more thorough data however.
- DecayingOrganic 3y agoJust because the benefits of sharing DNA data appear large, doesn't mean we should take potential drawbacks lightly. Imagine this: a future where a specific gene is linked to hard work. Companies start screening job applicants based purely on their genetic makeup -- if you don't have the gene, you don't get the job. Or even more worryingly, imagine the government starts surveillance on a group of people with a particular gene, claiming they're more likely to commit a certain crime based on some obscure study. It would lead to moral and ethical havoc. DNA data might not seem worth protecting right now, but unchecked, the misuse could be catastrophic.
- AndrewThrowaway 3y agoMedical insurance - oh you have cancer/hear attack/etc gene. You premiums skyrocket. Job opportunities - oh so sorry you have bipolar gene... Dictator governments - oh your genes are shit so you are not allowed to have kids.
- jjallen 3y agoI mean sure we pay them and now they are "selling" our data to pharma companies... to research human health and learn more. At some point does being against other people using your data work against you? If every human refused to allow their DNA to be used for research the entire species would be worse off. The obsession with protecting our data is very strange to me.
- cornholio 3y agoThey are selling the data for (allegedly) medical research now. Tomorrow, they will sell it for genetic discrimination against you. The point is: it's not your data anymore, and from your perspective it can only be used against you. While I understand there are pro-social uses of this data, such as medical research and identifying criminals and their victims, those exceptions should be clearly delineated by law in a white list, with strong safeguards, with the default being DNA privacy.
- Podgajski 3y agoWhat do you mean “those of us didn’t see this coming”? They said out right this is what they were going to do with our data. This is nothing new. This is just an extension of the same thing they were doing. Plus you can opt out and you could delete Your profile and your data and download the raw data to use yourself. I accepted this trade-off because I had an unknown genetic condition in my family and this helped me find out what it was.
- spacecadet 3y agoThis is the story of the last 20 years tho.
- Communitivity 3y agoAgreed, and it's worse than not just getting your consent. They will likely make money and patents off of some of those DNA. There are many examples out there of people doing that with cells from tissue, here is one from https://www.wipo.int/wipo_magazine/en/2006/05/article_0008.html https://www.wipo.int/wipo_magazine/en/2006/05/article_0008.h...: "Mr. John Moore suffered from hairy-cell leukemia. In 1976, Dr. David Golde of the University of California Medical Center, recommended that his spleen be removed in order to slow the progress of the disease. Mr. Moore signed a written consent form authorizing a splenectomy, and surgeons removed his spleen. Dr. Golde and his research assistants extracted tissue from the discarded spleen, having recognized its value for research to develop possible ant-cancer treatments. In the next three years they established a cell line from the extracted T-lymphocytes. Mr. Moore was not informed about the research work or the potential of the cell line. In 1984 Dr. Golde was granted US patent 4438032 on the cell line, which generated substantial revenue through commercial arrangements with two biotech firms."
- dools 3y ago"which generated substantial revenue through commercial arrangements with two biotech firms." Absent from this statement is that when biotech companies generate revenue from cancer treatments it's probably because they're treating cancer.
- throw__away7391 3y agoExactly. If they were for example using genetic testing to set your insurance rates or something like this, that's dystopian. Doing medical research that leads to successful treatments for deadly diseases is hardly the sinister plot people seem to be implying it is.
- dorfsmay 3y agoAre there clauses in 23andme type companies that they will never share your data with insurances? What if it got bought by an insurance?
- ceasefire 3y agonext: "our" clone of your genes.
- shunyaekam 3y agoWhat is the big issue? Is the data not anonymized?
- lacrimacida 3y agoUntil they have a leak or a breach… Don’t trust these companies blindly..
- leotravis10 3y agoThe data is never truly "anonymized" since companies can easily de-anonymize data in minutes if not seconds as proven time and time again.
- shunyaekam 3y agoSure but what exactly is a malicious scenario in this case? That they'd use this data to probe which drug to do R&D on? If this was an insurance company I wouldn't have asked this question.
- gonzo41 3y agoBig Tech doesn't deserve our trust. It has an abusive relationships with the populace.
- karpour 3y agoI wonder how this works with the GDPR. Not sure if their service is even available in Europe, but if it is, Europeans at least should be able to just require them to delete all data whenever they want.
- jvanderbot 3y agoAs an alternative take, Imagine a nationwide US gov research program that collects DNA for the purposes of prescription drug research. They'd be storming the capital again, no matter how much good it can do. Now imagine we had to raise taxes to support it. Preposterous! Communism! Instead a company was founded on the promise of providing a useful product to both consumers and producers. Let them get rich, I'm pretty sure this is a net win for all parties.
- bluefirebrand 3y agoMy hope is that Drug companies might be able to make breakthroughs in research for better treatments for people with rare genetic disorders by using this data. But cynically I bet they're probably going to use it for marketing demographics purposes Really worried about the day that it's Insurance companies buying up our DNA data to make sure we get the right coverage.
- Eumenes 3y ago23&Me was literally founded by Sergey Brin's wife at the time. This was a data harvesting operation from the start.
- phil21 3y agoI generally agree that 23andMe was obviously going to end in something like this. The actual value was never in the "fun personal genetic testing" - it was always the aggregated population-wide DNA data. However, I do think a national "DNA database" would be interesting, if it could actually be made truly anonymous. I have no idea if that is possible, but assuming it is - I think there would be massive benefit for this data to be available to public (and private) researchers for the cost of simple maintenance and upkeep of the database. Who knows what great discoveries could be made in the future with this data available at the fingertips of many. However, I don't know enough on the subject to understand the evil potential with a database that can by truly anonymous. Maybe it enables making a new cancer vaccine for the most common type of cancer. Maybe it enables creating a virus that is lethal after exactly 28 days to only a certain segment of the population carrying a specific gene. This bit is certainly what gives me huge pause. I also suspect truly anonymizing such a database would be extremely difficult to nigh-impossible. That all said, while my DNA is in government databases against my will (many mothers signed up for those "get your kid back if kidnapped" law enforcement drives in the 80's and 90's) I will never willingly submit a sample to such a service unless I have exceedingly clear control of all my data and assurances it will be destroyed after whatever specific results I need come back.
- corethree 3y agoWhat abuse? The only abuse is that I'm not paid for it or instead I paid to have my DNA public. But other than that how will I be abused? Additionally the incentive for abuse just isn't there. The companies that buy this data don't care about individuals. They want aggregate data.
- ninja3925 3y agoThis a poor argument which basically criticize any cost sharing agreement with multiple payers. “Look, GM is getting gov subsidies but we still have to pay for a car!” Not a strong argument indeed. 23andme has democratized DNA testing by making it affordable when the numbers didn’t work. This is remarkable in itself. Kudos to them.
- nullserver 3y agoSpent several years with a mystery illness that nearly killed me. Turned out to be genetic. Easy treatment, but only if you’re aware. (Factor 5 Leiden) Kind of regret not getting the full work up done at one of places. Maybe would prevented a number of blood clots.
- keep_reading 3y ago> 'hacker lifted your sequences or prints' no 'sequences or prints' were ever accessed by the hackers
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoSome people make enough money that the utility of 23andMe is worth it them, and they don't care if 23andMe makes money selling their anonymized data on the side. A lot of people just really don't care about data privacy at all.
- hnben 3y ago> they don't care if [...] I do care. But I still think the benefit outweights the downsides.
- orthecreedence 3y agoI always imagine if 23andme existed in the 1930s. Would have made the job of certain groups much easier. But that will never happened again.
- andy_ppp 3y agoAnd probably the potential to create viruses that target certain DNA... I would assume multiple governments are doing work on things like this.
- sonicanatidae 3y ago110% with you on this. In fact, even if they hand out your data, against any agreement you had with them, the worse they would face would be a pittance fine. There is no situation where they would put people over money and DNA is immutable.
- Aerroon 3y agoThe worst part is that all it takes is for one relative to be stupid enough to use the service and all your privacy precautions are undone.
- dkural 3y ago80% of people agreed to give consent, and only the data of those people are being used for research purposes. It is furthermore used at a population level, and in anonymous fashion. Your individual genetic data is not very useful as a singleton, it is only useful in large numbers to do GWAS (genome-wide association studies) to identify novel disease-gene relationships. This is not the first GSK collaboration with 23andMe. They identified a novel cancer target now being further developed CD96. So... wow, what a terrible thing, you may now have contributed in a tiny way to people potentially getting life-extending medication. What terrible abuse. 23andMe has about 14million customers. 80% of that is about 11M customers. GSK is paying $20M per year I think. So that's about $2 per customer, if we're being generous. Would you feel less abused if each customer got a $2 discount or rebate?