11 ms·
Exclusive hardwood may be illegally harvested
- civilitty 3y agoIn my (albeit limited) experience, if you can’t get some sort of provenance documentation for exotic hardwoods from the lumberyard, it’s almost guaranteed to be unsustainably harvested, mostly outright illegally. Unfortunately it seems that most lumberyards open to the public and contractors are full of such wood because the legit stuff is even more expensive and sold mostly to high end furniture manufacturers and specialty suppliers. Brazil is going to go through the same process as Cuba did with mahogany until trade in ipê is banned entirely, except it’s not an island so it’ll be impossible to enforce.
- jihadjihad 3y agoIt's OT, and not meant to detract from your point or be pedantic in any way, just something I've seen and heard in software, too: > providence when what I am sure you meant to say was "provenance". I've heard people talk and ask about the "providence of the data" too much not to leave a comment, I guess! It's not manna from heaven it's just some rows in a database somewhere ;)
- civilitty 3y agoThank you, good catch! I was researching the provenance of a rare book just yesterday so this is particularly embarrassing
- randomdata 3y ago> when what I am sure you meant to say was "provenance". Without the documentation being in protective care of God, can it truly be trusted?
- jihadjihad 3y ago"In God we trust. All others bring data." - W. Edwards Deming
- LadyCailin 3y agoPerhaps they meant documentation about the city in Rhode Island?
- hedora 3y agoI’ve never seen a lumberyard that doesn’t have sustainability certifications. Anyway, much of the illegal harvesting is due to Brazil’s right wing government actively encouraging people to burn the amazon to the ground. Though it would be hypocritical, we should treat that as an act of war. The greenhouse effect of that one action is going to cause trillions of damage to coastal cities alone.
- epx 3y agos/right wing/any wing/. Look up who built Belo Monte.
- londons_explore 3y ago> not an island so it’ll be impossible to enforce. Unlike drugs, wood is a bulky cargo. Sure, you might smuggle a few planks, but you aren't going to manage to smuggle tens of thousands of trucks full unless the government is deliberately turning a blind eye.
- Aurornis 3y ago> In my (albeit limited) experience, if you can’t get some sort of provenance documentation for exotic hardwoods from the lumberyard, it’s almost guaranteed to be unsustainably harvested, mostly outright illegally. If you can't get any provenance documentation, how are you assuming it's harvested illegally?
- civilitty 3y agoFunnily enough, a lot of the illegally harvested wood comes with great provenance information, if not official documentation. Unscrupulous manufacturers need to know where to reliably source it and corruption where these trees are harvested is rampant so they don't even need to hide it. I assume so because there's a significant price difference between those operations and legitimate sustainable ones when provenance is available. However I think the exotic wood that makes it to the average lumberyard comes almost exclusively from opportunistic small logging operations that stumble upon on groves of trees and cut them down and ship them out as fast as possible, oftentimes under the noses of the land owners (the state, natural reserves, etc.).
- rtsil 3y agoDocumentations are easy to buy in many countries where those exotic woods are sourced. Most of the traffic are done by people in the government or by those who put them there.
- CyberDildonics 3y agoApparently it's exclusive hardwood for exclusive decks and the demand for this exclusive tropical wood is increasing. This article really likes the word exclusive.
- marcosdumay 3y agoI'd like to see the research, because I believe there isn't any way to sell ipê wood legally in Brazil. I'm almost certain the real number is higher than the 96%, not the one on the title.
- woliveirajr 3y agoHere: https://www.chalmers.se/en/current/news/75-percent-of-exclusive-hardwood-may-be-illegally-harvested,c3863187/ https://www.chalmers.se/en/current/news/75-percent-of-exclus... https://www.nature.com/articles/s41893-023-01189-3 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41893-023-01189-3
- marcosdumay 3y agoThanks a lot. Turns out there is a way, used mostly since the last decade. And their methodology seems best-fitting, and not a conservative estimation. I'm very positively surprised that 1/4 of the ipê wood sold internationally is legal.
- juancn 3y agoI got confused about the name "ipê" (first time I hear it, my Portuguese is basic at most), it's also known as "lapacho" in Argentina, "tajy" in Paraguay and "araguaney" in Venezuela.
- translucyd 3y agoIpe is an indigenous word. Congress from Tupi languages probably.
- apojomovsky 3y agoSame, in the picture from the article I clearly identified a Tajy Sa'yju. Fun thing is that this wood is used for absolutely everything in Paraguay. From posts to delimit rural properties to fuel for barbecues.
- barelyauser 3y ago"You can know the name of that bird in all the languages of the world, but when you're finished, you'll know absolutely nothing whatever about the bird [...]".
- woliveirajr 3y agoIn 2020, the then president of Brazil said he would reveal which countries were the consumers of the illegally extracted wood from Amazonia. [0] No further news were heard about it. There were even a startup that would use DNA to certify the origin of the wood, allowing traceability. The "efforts to halt trade in illegal timber such as the EU Timber Regulation and the US Lacey Act" can greatly contribute to reduce this process: harvesting those trees isn't cheap, and without buyers paying large sums to aquire it, it becomes non-profitable. [0] in Portuguese: https://exame.com/brasil/bolsonaro-diz-que-revelara-paises-que-compram-madeira-ilegal-da-amazonia/ https://exame.com/brasil/bolsonaro-diz-que-revelara-paises-q...
- frozenlettuce 3y agoRecently I was watching Property Brothers and saw two episodes where both houses had Brazilian Hardwood flooring. The funny thing is that I live in Brazil and it is quite rare to find houses with that type of flooring - the bureaucracy and costs associated make it very expensive - but that might not be the case if the customer is Canadian
- bastardoperator 3y agoI would argue there is zero point in using real hardwood on floors these days given vinyl planks are way cheaper, way more durable, and look nearly indistinguishable from real thing.
- harimau777 3y agoPersonally I don't trust vinyl flooring not to outgas toxic chemicals or produce toxic dust as it wears down.
- abakker 3y agoHardwood floors can be re-sanded and refinished many times over, generating no waste. Vinyl floors get scratched and then thrown away. Wood is renewable, vinyl comes from oil wells. I'm not certain this is actually logical.
- marricks 3y agoIt’s why you gotta burn ivory. When something is a luxury item for the wealthy rules don’t really matter you have to destroy the market.
- mc32 3y agoIvory isn’t only for the rich customers of intricate ivory carving but also the run of the mill guy and gal going to the Chinese medicine apothecary. Not saying this exonerates the practice or anything --just that rich folk in Hong Kong/mainland CN aren’t the only ones propping the market.
- 29athrowaway 3y agoOr explain people that ivory won't treat their ED. Or spread the rumor that ivory makes you flaccid.
- bluGill 3y agoUnless it is a piano keyboard, because musicians are aware of this and so the only pianos with ivory keyboards have ivory from nearly 100 years ago. There would be interest in new ivory by a few (generally because they have an antique piano with one broken key), but they will demand proof that the ivory was sustainably harvested (There was a park a few years back overcrowd with elephants that was looking into providing such certification, though last I've heard they haven't figured out how to do this)
- hedora 3y agoThe technician that works on our piano reglued some of the ivory. He said that, in the worst case, he could give us a replacement, since he has a pile of antique ivory he got from the keys of ruined/rebuilt pianos. If we ever fully restore the keys, we’d opt for not-ivory.
- olliej 3y agoThis reminds me of "we only harvest X ebony trees" nonsense when what they mean is "we only _buy_ X amount of ebony, and we pay more for pure black, so people cut down many trees to find the relatively rare pure black ones"
- analog31 3y agoThis has been an area of interest among musicians. I don't know how much of demand we account for. At this point it is widely accepted that ebony doesn't have to be jet black. The fingerboard of my double bass is a beautiful piece of ebony that is basically dark brown. I'm perfectly happy with it.
- aaronax 3y agoBlack locust is basically as good as ipe--competitive in characteristics like hardness and rot resistance, and I think slighly lower in price. It has been used for years for fence posts and now a lumber industry for it seems to be maturing. Apparently it grows like a weed and is even considered invasive in some places. I used black locust for a large porch and am very pleased with it.
- Loughla 3y agoI'm not sure about black locust rot resistance. That's pretty heavily informed on when you harvest it. If you harvest in the spring, it won't last five years. It's only good if harvested in the dead of winter when there is no sap. Also, it doesn't grow large, often because it's so susceptible to disease. So there's that, too.
- arp242 3y agoDon't harvest in the spring then? Wikipedia says "It is very resistant to rot" and "In the Netherlands some other parts of Europe, black locust is one of the most rot-resistant local trees".
- Loughla 3y agoI mean, that's fine, but only harvesting for a short portion of the year (during hard freeze after sap is out) severely limits the market and therefore increases cost. That has to be part of the issue, right?
- LeifCarrotson 3y agoThe bottleneck is growing the wood, not cutting it. Modern forestry equipment is insanely fast. Most agricultural crops have a very short seasonal window in which they can be harvested, but corn is not expensive because we only get one harvest per year, lumber is an anomaly in that respect.
- detourdog 3y ago
- everybodyknows 3y agoBy "exclusive" is apparently meant high-priced. Those of us who are excluded, or object to becoming complicit in denuding forests, will build our decks out of pressure-treated pine and Trex.
- doctorhandshake 3y agoI hated these options as well and thus did a bunch of research into thermally-modified and acetylated timber. I'd recommend investigating those options if you don't want plastic or PT.
- hedora 3y agoThe article suggests FSC certification is inadequate, and that consumers should establish the provenance of wood on a per-transaction basis. What percentage of FSC-certified wood is illegally harvested?
- vevioz 3y ago[dead]
- ulrischa 3y agoIpê wood is known for its extreme hardness and durability. In fact, it's so dense that it can sink in water. So nothing for motorboating.
- mschulkind 3y agoThat's not why boats float. Notice metal and concrete boats exist.
- sidewndr46 3y agoYou could probably make a boat from lead if you wanted to, thinking about it.
- spandextwins 3y agoPlant more trees. Now. Find a spot in your yard or common area and plant a tree.
- nikanj 3y agoAs if we millennials had yards
- spandextwins 3y agoGo plant where you can. No excuses. Do it today.
- Dylan16807 3y agoI'm not going to trespass to plant a tree.
- c0pium 3y agoI’m really confused by this new trend of people being super aggressive about things that won’t matter at all. Why not spend the energy somewhere it might make a difference?
- spandextwins 3y agoI'm confused about all the endless complacency and complaining. And the unwillingness to do anything positive.
- Dylan16807 3y agoUnwillingness to do this arbitrary action you've chosen isn't unwillingness to do anything positive. As for complaining, you started it. (Unless you're claiming the article itself is useless complaining when they could do something to help the problem, but "plant a tree" is not something that could help this problem.)
- spandextwins 3y ago
- thomasstephan 3y agoTo be spending a lot of time working in the rainforest in Peru where logging (legal and illegal) is everywhere, you can't trace properly. Certificates are easy to forge, the entire pipeline is pen and paper. How can you tell once the legal wood and the illegal wood are in a container which is which? You can't. So many people here are outraged, how many of you are supporting on the ground teams protecting rainforests? If you care, do your research, support causes like https://www.junglekeepers.org https://www.junglekeepers.org (disclaimer here; that is the one I know, work for and support) and don't use exotic woods.
- finite_depth 3y agoI wonder if there's a way to tag trees to stop this. Like, spray the protected wood with some harmless-but-detectable dose of a radioisotope so you can tell which wood is which.
- hindsightbias 3y agoshotgun rfid?
- theoreticalmal 3y agoThat would only be useful until the mill, at which point the tags would be either destroyed, or limited to specific pieces and removed from the rest
- theoreticalmal 3y agoNot a bad idea! There would have to be a system for determining lumber that was previously illegal to cut but has since become legal. Maturity of the tree or land ownership changed, etc.
- noah_buddy 3y agoOr if there’s a way to ruin the wood for woodworking without killing the tree itself. It seems like you would need to do something really clever. Inject it with capsaicin?
- foxyv 3y agoThis is why I stick to locally grown native species of wood. My favorite is Red Oak but Black Walnut is a close second. Both are amazing woods with excellent qualities. Best way to make sure you aren't funding organizations that are killing people and destroying forests.
- majestic5762 3y agoIKEA's Assault on Romania's Ancient Forests: * IKEA faces allegations of aggressively exploiting the last of Romania's ancient forests. * Ivestigations in the U.S. document IKEA's rush against time to exploit these forests. * The primary motivation for this deforestation is sheer profit. * Documented evidence shows complete and illegal clear-cutting of forests under IKEA's direction. Romania's Forests – Europe's Amazon: * Romania is home to one of the world's last and largest ancient forests. The Carpathian Mountains in Romania house half of the remaining ancient forests, often termed as the "Amazon of Europe." Economic Incentives and Unchecked Exploitation: * Romania's entry into the European Union in 2007 opened markets for its abundant and cheap timber. Political inefficiency and corruption have enabled unchecked deforestation and exploitation. Reports suggest that more than half of Romania's timber is exploited illegally. IKEA's Dubious Role: * IKEA stands as the world's largest individual wood consumer, its demand growing by about 2 million trees annually. * In 2015, IKEA began buying vast tracts of forests in Romania, quickly becoming the largest private forest owner there. * IKEA has been linked to suppliers involved in illegal wood acquisitions, including notable names like Kronospan, Egger, and Schweighofer. * The company has a pattern of aggressive forest acquisitions and connections with both legal and illegal suppliers, not only in Romania but also in countries like Ukraine and Russia. LGBTQ+ Campaign as a Distraction: * IKEA's promotion of LGBTQ+ rights is portrayed as a smokescreen to divert attention from its environmental and corporate malpractices. * The promotion of LGBTQ+ ideologies, while noble in other contexts, is seen here as a corporate strategy to overshadow their illicit activities. IKEA's Ideological Dominance: * IKEA is not just a neutral space; it's portrayed as an ideological stronghold. * There have been instances where employees were allegedly fired for not conforming to IKEA's political stance. * A Polish court had to intervene to reinstate an employee terminated on such grounds. A Moral and Environmental Dilemma: * Romania faces a choice: to focus on rampant deforestation and exploitation by giants like IKEA or to be sidetracked by ideological debates while being economically and morally overshadowed by such corporations. See https://r3media.ro/ikea-distrugerea-ultimelor-paduri-seculare-din-romania-ascunsa-sub-campanii-de-empatie-lgbt/ https://r3media.ro/ikea-distrugerea-ultimelor-paduri-secular...
- analog31 3y agoAs a musician, this saddens me, because the Carpathian mountains may be the last source of really good wood for string instruments. New growth wood might not be a substitute because global warming and modern breeding are speeding up growth, and narrow growth rings are preferred. Progress is being made on synthetic materials. My cello and bass bows are all carbon fiber. Carbon fiber instruments are gradually improving.
- cm2012 3y agoHardwood in the USA is mostly farm grown, so I'm not concerned.
- dheera 3y agoI've seen a good deal of wood at USA's Home Depots that isn't grown in the USA. Last time I bought some pine lumber for a project at Home Depot there was a bunch from New Zealand and a bunch from USA, the stuff from New Zealand was cut to much better precision.
- TylerH 3y agoThe hardwood family this article is about, ipe, is not grown at all in the US.
- nkurz 3y agoAre you sure? If you mean that most hardwood in the US was "managed" at some point as a woodlot, then I guess it might be true, but if you mean that most hardwood in the US was specifically planted to be harvested, I'm very doubtful. I'm far from an expert, but I am in the process of planning our hardwood harvest in Vermont. The northeastern US produces a lot of hardwood and my impression is that very little of it is "farmed". Can you point to sources? My attempt at searching didn't produce much either way. If you are right, I'd love to update my false impression. Or are you possibly confusing "hardwood" with "softwood", such as pine?
- vevioz 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nateskulic 3y agoI think I've seen it done locally, in the USA... "Forest Preserves" cutting down old growth maple/oaks, and piling the massive logs in parking lots until hauled away... I think I've also seen significant "over-pruning" for the sake of the construction of various pathways and "theme parks" for humans.
- zdragnar 3y agoThere are a number of diseases that oaks are susceptible to. In our area, oak wilt is becoming problematic, and as the tree weakens, it becomes host to a variety of beetles whose grub larvae tunnel right into the trunk. Pulling down sick trees is sometimes the best thing you can do to help the rest.
- nateskulic 3y agoCould be. I saw more than 30+ massive logs and healthy piths in a back lot of the woods; stacked carefully before being removed; maple and oak. Given the level of local corruption, this forest management deserves the suspicion. The city and the locality was recently accused of cutting down too many trees for numerous reasons/projects. Unless you are adamant, they are quite aggressive about killing things in parkways. I think it would be better to leave things where they are in "Forest Preserves"... Maybe one day we'll have [unmanaged] old growth forests again.
- jdietrich 3y agoThis article was obsolete before it was written. The species commercially traded as Ipe (Handroanthus spp., Roseodendron spp. and Tabebuia spp.) were submitted by Columbia and Panama last year for inclusion in CITES Appendix II. This submission was accepted, meaning that the international trade in these woods will be subject to strict controls as of 25 November 2024. Any international trade must be accompanied by an export permit issued by a national Management Authority, certifying that the wood was harvested in a manner that is compatible with the long-term survival of the species. CITES enforcement is no joke and the listing of Ipe in Appendix II is likely to hugely reduce demand, due to the substantial bureaucratic burden and legal risk that importers will be exposed to. Guitarists will be all too familiar with the impact of CITES, following the listing of Rosewood in Appendix II in 2017. Until an exemption for musical instruments was negotiated in 2019, guitars with rosewood fingerboards practically disappeared from the market - the risks for importers and distributors were simply too great to reasonably manage. https://cites.org/sites/default/files/eng/cop/19/prop/as_received/E-Handroanthus_spp.pdf https://cites.org/sites/default/files/eng/cop/19/prop/as_rec... https://cites.org/eng/app/appendices.php https://cites.org/eng/app/appendices.php
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pvaldes 3y agoAs botanical footnote: All this trees called lapachos are in the Bignoniaceae family. Lapachos have huge ornamental value and hold the equivalent place as the cherry trees in the northern hemisphere. They are cultured in all the big cities that have the correct climate; by their fantastic bloom in bright yellow, pink or pure white and their role as a cultural symbol. This means that some lapacho wood can have legal origins also
- badosu 3y agoIpê trees are great to see in your city (I live in Brazil), I always get a big smile when my mom keeps getting amazed at them. You can have yellow, purple, white, a whole lot of colors.
- charles_f 3y ago> [as a consumer, ask] Where exactly does the wood come from? Is there documentation of the origin of the wood and its path through the production chain? Realistically no-one will tell you that the thing you want to buy is illegally harvested wood. Most sales people won't know, won't understand the question to begin with, and won't care enough to provide the information. And if they do know, incentives go against being honest and transparent. So I doubt this is very useful
- ziddoap 3y ago>So I doubt this is very useful It becomes useful if a big enough percentage of potential customers ask this question and if an insufficient answer is given decide to shop elsewhere (at a place that can provide a sufficient answer).
- remus 3y ago> Realistically no-one will tell you that the thing you want to buy is illegally harvested wood. They might tell you if it has been harvested legally though, as that is often a selling point. And if they don't know and can't find out then you could move on to a different supplier.
- frumper 3y agoIf no one will tell you it’s illegally harvested, they’ll always be happy to tell you it’s legally harvested.
- remus 3y agoIn which case they'd be lying and selling you something under false pretences. Obviously it can happen, but it's a risky thing and something a lot of businesses would want to avoid.
- frumper 3y agoif they're willing to sell illegally harvested wood, then I don't think they have the scruples to care about being inaccurate in their sales pitch
- m463 3y agoIf you walk through many of the mountains in the bay area, where redwoods dominate, you will notice a sad fact. After the earthquake in 1906 san francisco basically burned down. And that led to all the redwoods on all the bay area mountains being clear cut for wood and lime. In Henry Cowell state park (and others) you'll find some trees that survived. One that was cut down is shown in a cross section with the rings marked. Some rings are marked: - 1 Birth of Jesus/Modern Calendar Begins - 105 Chinese Invented Paper The redwoods you see now are still giants, hundreds of feet tall. But notice they are clustered in groups around a stump or an empty area where an old-grown redwood used to stand. it is sort of like walking in a graveyard.