5 ms·
Humans using the land for recreation are far more destructive to wetlands than occasional rocket launches. Canaveral and Vandenburg have become de-facto prote
by bryanlarsen 3y ago
Humans using the land for recreation are far more destructive to wetlands than occasional rocket launches. Canaveral and Vandenburg have become de-facto protected wildlife refuges because humans with guns keep other humans away from them.
I know that if I was a turtle at Boca Chica I would rather deal with the occasional rocket launch than the ATV's that also use the beach.
- gleenn 3y agoI was under the impression that regular use of rocket fuel made a lot of land extremely toxic.
- nickff 3y agoIt depends on the fuel, and the number of leaks (the latter usually being relatively high). Some fuels such as hydrazine and red fuming nitric acid are indeed quite dangerous, but Starship mostly uses methane and oxygen.
- cdchn 3y agoI figure it would depend on the rocket fuel. LOX and Liquid Hydrogen/Methane probably isn't so bad, stuff like hydrazine I could imagine wouldn't be great.
- dylan604 3y agoBut hydrazine makes for a great ingredient in bottled water! https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2023/10/05/real-water-contamination-case-liver-illnesses/71077761007/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2023/10/05/real-w...
- oittaa 3y agoWhy would you think that methane is toxic? I know the average american knows nothing about even 6th grade chemistry but these kind of comment pop up on every thread about rockets.
- elteto 3y ago> The average american... Ah, yes, as we all know, Americans are unique in the entire world for their lack of knowledge of chemistry.
- oittaa 3y agohttps://www.google.com/search?q=is+methane+toxic https://www.google.com/search?q=is+methane+toxic
- mensetmanusman 3y agoWe are unique in that we pay 10x as much to know as little as we do.
- wil421 3y ago>Two of six mice exposed to 70% methane in air died in 18 min, whereas mice exposed to 70% nitrogen in air developed only ataxia. Animals exposed to 50-90% methane in oxygen showed mild depression and a marked decrease in locomotion, but no ataxia. Thus, the toxic effect of methane is much greater than that of nitrogen when available oxygen is low, but methane has little effect when oxygen is readily available. It seems that the toxicity of methane should be discussed not alone, but rather with respect to the partial pressure of oxygen in the atmosphere in question. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK208285/#:~:text=Thus%2C%20the%20toxic%20effect%20of,when%20oxygen%20is%20readily%20available https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK208285/#:~:text=Thus%2....
- MikusR 3y agohttps://twitter.com/justsaysinmice https://twitter.com/justsaysinmice
- Someone 3y agoWhat is “70% nitrogen in air”? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmosphere_of_Earth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmosphere_of_Earth: “As of 2023, by mole fraction (i.e., by number of molecules), dry air contains 78.08% nitrogen, 20.95% oxygen, 0.93% argon, 0.04% carbon dioxide, and small amounts of other gases.” Did they take out nitrogen, added 7 parts nitrogen to 10 parts of air, use something else than mole fraction, …?
- elteto 3y agoWhich rocket fuel? There's so many different ones. Methalox engines produce water vapor. Kerolox engines use refined kerosene, so lots of soot and your regular fossil fuel combustion byproducts. And then there's the hypergols, which are indeed, incredibly toxic.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoThat'd require: 1) regular spills of fuel, that 2) aren't burnt up in the air before they hit the ground and 3) are liquid, not gaseous, and 4) are hypergolic. Boca Chica doesn't have any of those 4 requirements.
- jjk166 3y ago1) Fuel spills happen as a regular part of working with fuels (leaking pipes, loose fittings, safety purges, general clumsiness, etc) not just rocket explosions. 2) Even if a rocket explodes in the air it is unlikely all of its propellant will completely burn up (fuels aren't mixed, the ratios are optimized for a specific combustion conditions, and there are multiple tanks, etc), and there are many failure modes besides "massive explosion" 3) Just because the main component of a fuel will boil off eventually doesn't mean chemicals added to the propellant or produced in side reactions will 4) Hypergolic just means chemicals spontaneously combust on contact with one another; it has nothing to do with environmental risk.
- Dylan16807 3y ago> 3) Just because the main component of a fuel will boil off eventually doesn't mean chemicals added to the propellant or produced in side reactions will What do you have in mind that exists in quantities large enough to make things "extremely toxic"? > 4) Hypergolic just means chemicals spontaneously combust on contact with one another; it has nothing to do with environmental risk. Nothing except if you look at the actual list of rocket fuels that get used.
- jjk166 3y ago> What do you have in mind that exists in quantities large enough to make things "extremely toxic"? I don't know where you are quoting "extremely toxic" from but even small quantities of toxic chemicals can be cause for concern. > Nothing except if you look at the actual list of rocket fuels that get used. Just because a square's a rectangle doesn't make a rectangle a square. Hypergolics are toxic does not equal non-hypergolics are non-toxic. For example, hydrazine monopropellant.
- avmich 3y agoMethane is gas, liquified methane spills evaporate and go to atmosphere. Not perfect, but no land poisoning either. SpaceX does use hydrazine-related components in Dragon and Crew Dragon, but they don't launch from Boca Chica (and rather small by mass) - AFAIK Starship is planned to be 100% methane-oxygen vehicle, justification for Mars flight.
- dotnet00 3y agoThat's mainly a hypergolic fuel thing. The goal with Starship is to try to use Methalox everywhere so that's the only thing that needs to be resupplied. Long term this would be meaningful for ISRU, but short term this would be meaningful for in-space refueling and propellant depots. A more typical approach of using different fuel types for different things would create all sorts of restrictions on capabilities and would make in-space refueling more complicated.
- nwallin 3y agoDepends on the rocket fuel. Oxygen, methane, hydrogen are basically completely non-toxic. RP-1 is a pure form of kerosene and is non-toxic enough that it doesn't need special handling. Hydrazine, fuming nitric acid, nitrogen tetroxide... basically all hypergolic propellants are absurdly toxic. The SpaceX tests at Boca Chica have been almost entirely oxygen, methane, and RP-1.
- neonbjb 3y agoI don't think the plan is an occasionally rocket launch long term. I think the plan is to launch rockets as fast as humanly possible.
- soperj 3y agoNot from Boca. Boca is a testing grounds, since they aren't allowed to test elsewhere.
- pavon 3y agoBoca Chica is a test facility. SpaceX is only allowed 5 launches of the StarShip second stage, and 5 launches of the full stack each year (page 17 in [1]). More frequent launches will require a new environmental review. They plan production launches to occur out of Florida, and have already begun permitting and building of a launch site there. [1]https://www.faa.gov/sites/faa.gov/files/2022-06/PEA_for_SpaceX_Starship_Super_Heavy_at_Boca_Chica_FINAL.pdf https://www.faa.gov/sites/faa.gov/files/2022-06/PEA_for_Spac...
- greedo 3y agoThey've built Starbase there, with all the rocket assembly facilities and the new expansions. Unless they're planning on shipping all the rockets via barge, I think it's safe to assume they'll send them to Florida by launching from Boca Chica.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoWhy not ship by barge? It'll be far cheaper than the fees, costs and labour costs associated with a rocket launch. Both Brownsville and Cape Canaveral are well set up for barge shipping. Also, they're expanding their factory in Florida, so they could be built on site.
- cryptoz 3y agoThere's that protected-from-open-ocean barge lane (I forget what it's called?) that I think runs right from Brownsville to Cape Canaveral, or close enough, I think they plan on using that. Edit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intracoastal_Waterway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intracoastal_Waterway
- flandish 3y agoFar more? … <laughs in Union Carbide>
- avmich 3y agoQuick, name the date of the event? Without checking the sources? Not 9/11, right? Chernobyl also demonstrates this effect that humans avoiding the place are beneficial to the wildlife. While both Bhopal and Chernobyl events are pretty horrible, I think the GP has a point.
- HPsquared 3y agoLocals probably know the date.
- lamontcg 3y agoI got the year for Bhopal correct, I didn't bother trying to guess the day or month (mostly luck, but I remember that I was younger). I guessed 1989 for Chernobyl, at least I got the decade correct (remember it happened in either Jr High or High school for me). I was a year off for the Challenger disaster (I remember riding the school bus to high school when it happened which narrows it down to about 3 years).
- epivosism 3y agoMore generally, if our goal is to help a certain type of environment, let's do that. Let Musk buy up land a few miles away, convert it to more wetlands w/government help, permanently endow & protect it. The gov't could get 10x as much land protected as before - in exchange for giving up the few small acres near the launch facility. It seems like everyone wins this way! Musk & SpaceX can do their work, environmental protection of land for the future & birds etc. has improved locally and nationally on net. The only ones who don't win are the bureaucrats who have approval over other people's productive work. So... this type of deal rarely ever happens.
- bryanlarsen 3y ago1) There are a couple of minorly endangered species near the launch site, so EPA, FWS would be involved anyway. 2) the FAA's concern is protection of humans, and the FAA is the lead agency.
- nradov 3y agoWhen I took the tour of Kennedy Space Center at Cape Canaveral several years ago I was kind of shocked by the number of alligators there. It was a bit jarring to see a Space Shuttle on the launch pad and alligators all over the roads. Some armadillos and lots of birds as well.
- chasd00 3y agoI’ve noticed that too, it’s infested with alligators. They get under cars in the parking lot. Walking up to a deep hiss emanating from beneath your car is a bit unnerving.
- eichin 3y agoI recall an article that part of the prep work for shuttles landing in Florida included the usual "Foreign Object Debris" walk through to check the surface for things that might be a problem for the shuttle... but that this often included needing to wrangle alligators (sleeping in the sun on the nice warm tarmac :-)
- Teever 3y ago> I know that if I was a turtle at Boca Chica I would rather deal with the occasional rocket launch than the ATV's that also use the beach. If only it were that simple. If the occasional rocket launch is what causes that turtle's species to go extinct because it damages the shells of their eggs or the bright light disrupts their mating schedule or whatever that is all that matters to the turtle.
- agar 3y agoIf only there was some multi-year programmatic environmental assessment that could be performed by experts in the field to determine whether this would occur or what mitigations would ameliorate the concern...[1] Nah, that's crazy talk. Instead let's just speculate wildly. [1] https://www.faa.gov/sites/faa.gov/files/2022-06/PEA_for_SpaceX_Starship_Super_Heavy_at_Boca_Chica_FINAL.pdf https://www.faa.gov/sites/faa.gov/files/2022-06/PEA_for_Spac...