9 ms·
Scammers posing as customer service agents on X as companies leave platform
- tempodox 3y agoCrime abhors a vacuum.
- rtkwe 3y agoPlus the opening of the 'verified' tag to anyone and everyone lets anybody with a couple bucks get a boost of validity for people who haven't internalized the new normal of Twitter.
- atkailash 3y ago[dead]
- hn_throwaway_99 3y ago> boost of validity Except now the blue checkmark means the exact opposite to me: it's usually total randos who feel like they live half their life on Twitter, so now the blue checkmark to me means "people dumb enough to pay for something they think means 'status'".
- outworlder 3y agoWhich is why you have the option of hiding the blue checkmark now.
- bonton89 3y agoWait, why are people paying for it then?
- rtkwe 3y agoA lot use it for boosted visibility forcing their comments to the top even if they're bad. Also because it used to be a stamp of being somehow 'important' enough to garner the verification it was (and I suppose still is) considered a mark of status to some. The US right in particular seemed to have a particular fascination with verification/"blue checks" before Musk's purchase and the changes to the system. There's also the siren call of the monetization splits for the new blue check system though beyond some early large payouts my impression of it is that it was very disappointing. I'm not even 100% sure without looking if it's still happening or if it's been rolled back.
- JeremyNT 3y ago> A lot use it for boosted visibility forcing their comments to the top even if they're bad. Which is why it's important not to hide it for an end user - it helps you distinguish between organic posts (non-checked) and boosted ones (blue check). The blue check is mostly a negative signal at this point, except for the fact that people over certain follower numbers automatically are forced to have it. It's a really bizarre system.
- Someone1234 3y agoBlue no longer means "verified." It now means "X Premium Subscriber." Features listed here[0]. The Gold/Grey checkmark is now the old Blue "Verified" checkmark (Gold for orgs and Grey for Government/Elected Officials). In essence they redefined "Blue checkmark" from notable person/org to "gives us money" and then directly replaced it with something else. [0] https://help.twitter.com/en/using-x/x-premium https://help.twitter.com/en/using-x/x-premium
- SleepilyLimping 3y agoAlgorithm priority, potential of earning money, Tweetdeck, 2FA, other features.
- Balgair 3y agoThere are a few extensions for your browser that will hide blue checked people: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/blue-check-hider/jhkoihkndkemdikaiafkiolgidghjfkl https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/blue-check-hider/j... https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/blue-blocker/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/blue-blocker/ I've no idea how well these particular ones work, but there seem to be a lot of them going around. Caveat Emptor.
- bruceb 3y agoScammer pose as customer service agents for companies who are still on twitter as well.
- dewey 3y agoThat's not a new thing, just search for "password reset" or tweet something at a big company account about your account. You'll instantly see replies from fake agents funneling you to some IG account or group where they are apparently trying to help you recover access. Luckily for them this got a lot easier with the "verification" badge for everyone.
- wlesieutre 3y ago"Take a respected mark of quality and juice it for cash until it becomes meaningless" has been a staple move of companies since before I was born, but they really did a speed run with the Verified check mark.
- mcpackieh 3y agoThe twitter checkmark was a mark of authenticity, not quality.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 0ct4via 3y agoInitially, yes. It later came to be available for notable accounts, or ones Twitter deemed of public interest. That isn't a mark of authenticity, per se.
- sharkjacobs 3y ago> That isn't a mark of authenticity, per se. Do you mean that it became a mark of endorsement?
- libraryatnight 3y agoNone of the accounts I followed were blue checks for anything other than the purpose of verifying they statements made were legit from the source, which would be a mark of authenticity, what accounts were just given checks for whatever it is you're insinuating? (pre elon drama)
- sickofparadox 3y agoEven then it wasn't a reliable mark of authenticity as Twitter would often remove verification from authentic accounts as a form of punishment.
- sharkjacobs 3y ago
- readyplayernull 3y agoTextbook spiral of death, hat tip to Musk for creating an evident case of study for future enterpreneurs.
- brink 3y agoI think it's more due to general social media burnout and companies waking up to how much of a PR nightmare social media is, and that it might be doing more harm than good. No company wants to post online just to get relentlessly antagonized in the comments as most companies do.
- sangnoir 3y agoIt's likely KLM probably didn't think integrating Twitter with its customer support platform is worth the $40000[1] per month Musk was asking for. 1. Off the top of my head. May have been $50000 or in that ballpark. He seemed to overestimate the value of Twitter to corporates and transport agencies, and that the flow of value was in both directions. It's insane to think a quasi-governmental agency would spend tens of thousands to tell Twitter users the train or bus will be late; then again he probably doesn't know how much a banana costs, to steal from the Arrested Development trope.
- ethanbond 3y agoNo, it's not. It's due to Musk's personal product decisions and erratic behavior.
- z7 3y agoX caught in the act of spiraling to new heights of death! 'Death Spiral' just announced its world tour! 'I've been practicing my 'Death Spiral' all morning!'
- boeingUH60 3y agoI almost fell for this when I had issues with my banking app, until they asked for my pin...yeah no, the bank told be in that giant billboard that they'll never ask for my PIN, so I hurled insults at the person and blocked them.
- elitan 3y ago[flagged]
- ourmandave 3y agoThe Chase Visa guys are always reminding me to beware of phishing emails and to never click links. And then their card rewards side sends me emails with a link to auto enroll in upcoming discounts.
- mrguyorama 3y agoMy local credit union sent me a damn email from a DIFFERENT EMAIL ADDRESS to my private email that said I had "an important message" on my account that I had to click a link to go to a THIRD UNAFFILIATED WEBSITE I had never heard of before to get it. I emailed their support directly asking if I was being phished. They said I was not. I still didn't look at the "important message" Really glad my accounts with them are unimportant.
- tommek4077 3y agoEveryone bashing Twitter, no one is blaming the companies going to such a platform in the first place? This pinwall website was never a good place for customer support.
- rtkwe 3y agoIt was a convenient platform where a lot of people were. It's also where a lot of people went to complain if they were having issues with the regular support channels so of course companies would go there to perform damage control and act as a kind of level 2 support channel where issues with the normal support would be voiced. Also doing it in a quasi public channel is a bit of PR advertising "we look after our customers" even if it's only partially true given they had to take to twitter to start with.
- outworlder 3y agoNot sure I agree. We can see countless cases where people managed to solve their issues through Twitter while normal channels failed. You go where your customers are.
- bonton89 3y agoIsn't that his point? The normal channels (that the company directly controls) don't work, so everyone ended up using the twitter wall of shame out of desperation.
- taco_emoji 3y agoThe companies didn't go there first, that's where people were publicly complaining about their service. Companies quite obviously found it prudent to respond to those complaints by funneling them into their customer service pipeline.
- rsynnott 3y agoThing is, it basically worked fine for a lot of people for about a decade. If your risk model is “I can’t use anything that an idiot might buy and ruin”, that limits you. Like, in principle it can always happen, but there’s no great defense against it.
- itishappy 3y agoI think the bigger issue here is companies (ab)using social media for their services. How did anyone ever think this was a viable customer service solution? It's publicly visible, you do not control the platform, impersonation has always been a risk (Musk made things worse, but the flaws were already there), and at some point you're going to need to share personal info so you're going to need to funnel people to your actual platform anyway! Are these companies now planning to move customer service to Facebook and TikTok, or was this always insane?
- smt88 3y agoThis wasn't the companies' idea. You couldn't (and still can't) get customer support from Google and many other customer-hostile companies, so you had to just publicly blast them on Twitter. Their fear of bad PR outweighed their fear of spending money to support users.
- jazzyjackson 3y agoIt was the companies' idea to make it so convoluted to reach a human that the default became public shaming
- bonton89 3y agoYeah, I remember during one of Mojang's migrations I lost access to my Minecraft account. Nothing happened from my communications through support. The only reason I have a twitter account was to whine at a Mojang representative and it actually resulted in the problem being solved. I hate it.
- djbusby 3y agoOn Twitter today I noticed I was able to see tweets and profiles while not signed in - did the auth-wall get removed? Edit: seems only some profiles can be seen w/o auth.
- rsynnott 3y agoYou can see some profiles when not logged in, at random, but it’ll often show you posts from years ago. Whether this is a deliberate silly decision or a bug is somewhat unclear, like many things about Twitter today.
- bowsamic 3y agoWhat are they going to replace it with? They were on there for a reason after all
- ckbishop 3y agoSomething less shitty, I would imagine.
- add-sub-mul-div 3y agoPeople were on Craigslist, until they weren't. Twitter's downfall will be like that, gradual and with different replacements for different use cases. It won't be fast and one-to-one like MySpace to Facebook.
- nkozyra 3y ago> They were on there for a reason after all Frankly, because the risk of getting publicly shamed on one of the biggest networks was too high to ignore. As Twitter sheds users and usage[1] some companies are evaluating this differently. Also worth noting that you could, for a very reasonable price, make a few API queries a day before just to see who was complaining about your company and now to do so directly it costs $42,000 a month. Maybe if there was still a way to programmatically get your data then the calculation would go differently. [1] https://www.pcmag.com/news/twitter-traffic-on-downward-trend-since-elon-musks-takeover https://www.pcmag.com/news/twitter-traffic-on-downward-trend...
- rsynnott 3y agoI mean, they probably used to have a public fax number, too. Things change.
- janalsncm 3y agoMan I’m really just now starting to notice all of the auxiliary things Twitter was useful for that have become non-viable. Musk should’ve leaned into those. Add a fee to large companies for using it for customer support, but add features that make the experience better.
- permo-w 3y agoI don't think he ever wanted Twitter to succeed
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hristov 3y agoSo he just wanted to blow away 30 billion of his own money? He felt he had too much money but he did not want to give the money to the needy or anything woke like that he just wanted to waste it in an extravagant gesture? I think the answer is different. He wanted it to succeed he was sure it would succeed, but like many people blinded by previous success and personality worship he thought it would be easy and a bunch of half baked simple solutions would be sufficient. Fire most of your employees and increase fees for most of your users. Seems very simple, right? Guess not.
- janalsncm 3y agoVery little of what made Twitter successful was its engineering. Thats what he didn’t understand. It’s a social network. Network effects are the most important. People will use a second rate network if all of their friends are on it.
- permo-w 3y agowhat's $30bn to someone with $260bn? that's like the average person buying a mac, or maybe a cheap car, except less important because Elon Musk doesn't need the other 7/8 of his wealth to survive on I sincerely do not think Elon Musk is that stupid. you don't build Tesla, Paypal and SpaceX with the kinds of decisions that have been made at Twitter, and I think it's quite silly to take the basic assumption that no one ever buys a company to deliberately destroy them. why wouldn't that happen?
- 0ct4via 3y agoWhen a number of the very same companies that use X/Twitter have settings that ensure only Verified (i.e. Subscription) users can message them, it fails to be useful for regular customer support like it was. That aside, scammers and fakes have only gotten worse on the platform post-takeover.
- markx2 3y ago"X Customer Support" "X Assistant Support to Elon Musk" The possibilities.....
- sonofhans 3y agoOne of the most important reasons companies are no longer engaging via X is that their tools don’t work anymore: > Another change is that it is no longer always possible for companies to load questions asked via DM on the platform into their customer service systems. This is related to API access for the tools in question, I’d guess. So many businesses and ideas grew up around Twitter’s flexibility and relative openness. Many of those ideas don’t work at all in a monetized model. We’ve known this as a culture for a long time. It’s why we created and continue to use public utilities. Not everything needs to be a profit center.
- logifail 3y ago> So many businesses and ideas grew up around Twitter’s flexibility and relative openness. Many of those ideas don’t work at all in a monetized model Don't work at all, or don't work for free?
- smoldesu 3y agoIn business, you may find that the two are synonymous with each other when you want to make an attractive platform.
- richbell 3y agoWhy would they pay for users to send them DMs on Twitter when they can point people to their support site for free?
- logifail 3y agoWhy were they keen to provide better support to customers contacting them on Twitter than customers contacting them via email, phone or their own support site? (Spoiler: I think we all know that Social Media was one budget item and Customer Support was a different one, and executives were happy to "invest" in the former and wanted to spend as little as possible on the latter...)
- richbell 3y ago
- throwaway9274 3y agoGenerally I appreciate Elon Musk’s work a lot. He created two world-changing companies in SpaceX and Tesla. I wanted him to be good at running Twitter/X. It seemed like a good match. Staid company meets indefatigable executive. His early moves prompted a lot of pushback but were generally wise: Diversified away from ad revenue. Introduced breaking changes to accustom the user base to faster development. Cut costs they couldn’t afford by shuttering a data center. Shrunk a bloated team to die-hards via whaling-and-culling. Not least, open sourced some recommender system code, and largely solved the content moderation problem via Community Notes. Individually, all good steps. Sure, there were many misfires along the way: the verification system, launch of Twitter Blue, and erratic public ideation of potential features. But I am ready to declare the Musk&Twitter/X experiment a failure. The crux of the matter is this: Twitter exists as part of an ecosystem. Elon has alienated a large part of that ecosystem, both in terms of creators and advertisers. I don’t know whether the network effect will tip or the business will run out of cash first, but I am confident it will not grow enough to justify the investment. Maybe I’m wrong. Maybe alternate revenue streams and the value of Twitter’s data for AI training will be enough to keep it viable. But I’m just not seeing the path.
- agubelu 3y ago> Diversified away from ad revenue. He was forced to due to ad revenue plummeting as a reaction to his own actions and policies. >Introduced breaking changes to accustom the user base to faster development. What does faster development have to do with breaking almost a decade's worth of UX and muscular memory? You can ship _bad_ changes quickly. I lost track of the amount of times I tapped Reply instead of Retweet after they shifted all buttons right when they introduced viewcounts. > Shrunk a bloated team to die-hards via whaling-and-culling. I'd argue there's a reasonable middle ground between "a bloated team" and "just the die-hards". > largely solved the content moderation problem via Community Notes. Community notes existed before Musk, and their role is to dispute a claim or provide context. They don't moderate content in any way.
- throwaway9274 3y ago>He was forced to due to ad revenue plummeting as a reaction to his own actions and policies. That’s incorrect. The need to diversify away from ad revenue was a topic discussed with Jack prior to the acquisition. The rationale was that advertisers effective control content moderation policies due to the revenue which they provide. This is true. Whether it’s bad on or not depends on your viewpoint and ideological position. What advertisers want for now, e.g. with regard to social policy, may be aligned with what you or I want now. But there’s no guarantee that will be true in the future. >I’d argue there’s a reasonable middle ground between “a bloated team” and “just the die-hards. Layoffs are painful, and they were handled poorly. But there can be no doubt the prior company was massively overstaffed. If you’re going to cut, generally you want to cut deep to prevent future rounds. Arguably not increasing the size of the first layoffs led to the second, and more people could have been preserved in total. There’s very little virtue in “middle ground” in this context. > Community notes existed before Musk, and their role is to dispute a claim or provide context. They don’t moderate content in any way. It doesn’t moderate content in any way… except for placing large labels to “dispute a claim or provide context.” Sure, if you very narrowly constraint content moderation to the Trust and Safety definition of removing content and administering bans it doesn’t. Birdwatch existed, but the prominence of the feature and improved reliability of the feature weren’t launched until after acquisition. It solved the main edge cases for content moderation by only displaying labels when moderators who disagreed sufficiently on other issues agreed on that particular label. It has significantly impacted the disinformation at scale problem for the better.
- shmatt 3y agoKLM profits: about 1 Billion Euro per year HappyFox (Twitter integration into customer support tickets) $40-$100 per user per month Twitter: Unprofitable Maybe this wasn't sustainable all along, even pre-Musk implosion. Everyone was making money except Twitter. Yet they were completely dependent on Twitter
- akaitea 3y agoHad an experience recently where I tweeted at booking.com's profile @bookingcom only to be tweeted back by 5-6 different lookalike profiles all pretending to be customer support and asking for my personal information and a WhatsApp phone number to resolve my issue. All the accounts were something like @Bookingcomx @BookingCom_44 @BookingCom__4 I'm thinking how hard can it be to automatically block this from Twitter's end? They were all using the official booking's profile image and had something in their profile info indicating they were "booking". It's just a few simple checks and then at the very least require extra validation of the account before allowing them any further. You can go right now and look at everyone sending tweets to the official account, their replies will be full of scammers https://twitter.com/search?q=%40bookingcom&src=typeahead_click&f=live https://twitter.com/search?q=%40bookingcom&src=typeahead_cli...
- solarkraft 3y ago> how hard can it be Quite hard when you've fired everyone :-)
- solarkraft 3y ago1) Acquire Twitter 2) Decide that driving traffic to your platform will now cost a bajillion dollars rather than being free 3) A high number of entities that drive traffic to your platform decide to leave 4) ??? Business genius