6 ms·
Cleveland launches plan to provide cheap broadband
- spandextwins 3y agoWe need that! The Internet should actually be free given the value they all get from me.
- thelastgallon 3y ago> despite billions in tax breaks, regulatory favors, and subsidies, companies like AT&T have long refused to upgrade low-income and minority Cleveland neighborhoods to fiber. There is a very easy solution to this. Electric utilities should be required to lay fiber along with electric. They can choose to offer internet (better) or offer fiber with a choice of carriers. EPB in Chattanooga has been providing fiber to homes for decades.
- bombcar 3y agoIt's the obvious solution, so of course it won't be done. I now have four separate companies' fiber running through my property, of which I am connected to only one, but I could switch to two others anytime I wanted to, and then they'd run the "last connection" to my house. It's kinda silly. (The fourth is a business line, which I could connect to but that involves more work as it is older.)
- Spivak 3y agoI'm not saying it's right but I'm predicting the argument against will be that it will increase the cost of running electric which you think would be "who cares" but homeowners end up footing that bill and are more let's say more price-sensitive than governments. It's crazy we still haven't won the fight of "if you build a house the literally state controlled electric company has to hook you up" but here we are.
- tw04 3y agoElectric companies already run fiber with every new power line in most places. They simply use it as dark fiber for internal purposes. The cost to string a couple more strands for public use would be a rounding error for them.
- zrail 3y agoIf the municipality owns the poles and the power company this is comparatively easier. In places that own both, like Traverse City in Michigan, Chattanooga TN, or Longmont CO, this model can be incredibly effective. The problem, at least in my part of the world (Michigan) is that most municipalities do not own the poles or the power company. The power company is instead a large publicly traded corporation, albeit with strong regulation. Adding regulation to force power companies to run dark fiber on new runs only addresses part of the problem. You still have to deal with the millions of miles/kms of installed grid that sees proactive maintenance _maybe_ once a decade. Not to mention the state laws in dozens of states that place onerous rules on municipalities installing their own broadband service, or even outright forbid the practice entirely. These laws are often the result of ILECs lobbying state governments or using their lobbying groups to directly write "model legislation" that state governments subsequently adopt.
- arrosenberg 3y agoRarely does a situation so desperately cry out for the use of eminent domain.
- chasd00 3y agoisn't "pole ownership" and access to those poles what doomed google fiber? In some cases it's easy to run fiber yourself in other cases it's completely impossible.
- mfer 3y agoI would suspect access more than ownership. Lots of places legally limit access and Internet companies are excluded.
- gs17 3y agoIn some places they seem to be working around it. Here in Nashville they cut into every street/alley to run fiber (it isn't available at my apartment, but they did run it down our street, which is not a main street at all).
- mfer 3y ago
- nerdponx 3y agoImagine that: company gets free money from the government to do such-and-such thing but isn't strictly required to do it, then they take the free money and don't do the thing. It's almost like corporations are self-interested and un-altruistic.
- parineum 3y agoI don't know why you'd be railing against the company here for acting in it's best interest (exactly as you'd expect) rather than the state for giving away money with no strings attached. A private business sure as hell wouldn't be so foolish as to sign such a contract.
- dd36 3y agoIt is in a company’s best interest to make sure corruption is legal?
- dvdkon 3y agoI think you misread the parent comment, I'd say they are blaming the government for not covering their "investments" legally, same as you.
- bigstrat2003 3y agoOne can blame both parties. It was foolish (or corrupt, take your pick I guess) for the government to give out money without formal strings attached. It is unethical for the companies to take that money knowing it's intended for $thing, without ever intending to do $thing. Neither is good.
- parineum 3y agoThis is a classic example of the scorpion and the frog though. The government is ostensibly giving them money and saying, "We hope you choose to do the thing we want with this money but you don't have to, no pressure." Exactly what you'd expect happened, they took the money and did nothing. I honestly have a hard time finding that nearly as unethical as the government being incredibly irresponsible with our money, either through naivety or corruption.
- ourmandave 3y agoGiven the way things go, there'll be a line item charge on every bill: Connection to AT&T backbone surcharge..............................$39.99
- selimthegrim 3y agoCPP is city owned, doesn’t sound like anyone is stopping them.
- qup 3y ago"Cheap" to be determined
- gs17 3y agoIt's very likely to be cheaper and better than Comcast at least.
- qup 3y agoIf they're not aiming to clear that bar, I think we should bin it. I was actually really interested to hear what kinds of numbers they can pull off. I hate Comcast, and I hate my local provider even worse.
- rtkwe 3y agoIt's been much cheaper than the local mono/duopoly providers in all the other cities it's been done in so far your skepticism is unearned.
- qup 3y agoI'm not skeptical. I should have said "How cheap*..." Given that it's the whole goal of the project, you'd think they might have come up with a number.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jrgifford 3y agoIt'll be interesting to see if they can do this better than previous attempts. I remember in 2009 when OneCommunity tried[1], 2014 when OneCommunity launched everstream, their for-profit arm (and didn't change much)[2], or the 2018 Old Brooklyn/Ward 13 project[3]. Somewhere in there, there was an initiative (probably 2009 or so?) that included public wifi in Cleveland Heights along much of Cedar Road, where One Community had a wifi SSID "OneCommunityPublic" (or something similar). That got shut down quickly. [1] https://www.cleveland.com/business/2009/07/onecommunity_seeks_millions_in.html https://www.cleveland.com/business/2009/07/onecommunity_seek... [2] https://everstream.net/press-releases/onecommunity-launches-everstream/ https://everstream.net/press-releases/onecommunity-launches-... [3] https://connectyourcommunity.org/cdjc-program-four-points/free-city-wifi-for-all-cleveland-neighborhoods-what-you-need-to-know/ https://connectyourcommunity.org/cdjc-program-four-points/fr...
- BreadPants 3y agoI remember that and did contact Everstream for internet service. It was 1000/1000, but they wanted $500 for running the lines from across the street and then $500 per month after that. Insane.
- zdragnar 3y ago$500 for running the lines under a street isn't too far out of the ordinary (I paid $300 for a longer run, but there was nothing to go under, so the job was easy). That said, $500/month for service is insane.
- gottorf 3y agoThat sounds like pricing for a "business-class" Dedicated Internet Access service, with meaningful SLAs and no oversubscription.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- markofzen 3y ago
- ralph84 3y agoToo little too late. Comcast is running ads trying to scare people into not dropping their home internet service. That’s a pretty clear sign that a lot of people are doing just that and relying solely on mobile.
- gs17 3y agoI doubt it's so much "no one wants home internet anymore" but more "Comcast is so expensive and annoying that mobile is nicer".
- llsf 3y agoWould it make sense for the municipality to own the pipes that run in the city ? Like some cities own the sewer pipes. Could it be an infrastructure that the city builds, owns, maintains and rents to ISP ? The city would have a full control on how many houses are connected. That is the type of investments that a city is suited for (i.e. large upfront cost financed by bonds). AT&T, Charter, Comcast, they have no incentive to invest a lot upfront. And they might duplicate the infrastructure. At the end the customer pays for the piecemeal fiber deployment, and redundancy.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jpk 3y agoPart of me likes this approach, but another part of me is hesitant putting the local government in control of all of the network infrastructure. It could conceivably allow local officials to turn it all off during a protest or something; similar to what we saw during the Arab Spring events.
- xenospn 3y agoThey can already do that with ease by instructing the companies that own it to shut it down. I’d argue that having local officials in charge offers more transparency than a nameless corporation.
- gooseyman 3y agoCleveland has a public owned utility for power that does publish an annual. https://www.cpp.org/About/Annual-Reports https://www.cpp.org/About/Annual-Reports The non-Cleveland owned utility data is also available, it’s just not as “Cleveland specific”
- jpk 3y agoSure, but the company has an incentive to resist such an order. So there's a check there. I guess all I'm saying is there should be a check, and transparency about when that check is tested.
- sxg 3y agoI just moved back to Cleveland, and I signed up for Cleveland Broadband (clevelandbroadband.com), which is incredible! I pay $50/mo for 1 Gb/s download and upload speeds with no contract or temporary introductory pricing. The best part is the customer service, which I've only had to use twice while initially setting it up, but it's a direct line to a person who physically came to my place within an hour and was super knowledgeable! We had a lengthy discussion about Ubiquiti networking gear. I previously had Comcast/Xfinity, which was reliable, but felt absolutely scammy due to constantly changing pricing with multi-year contracts. Talking to a human for basic tasks like upgrading or canceling service was nearly impossible. Apparently their chatbot is capable of these tasks, but I could never get it to work.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 1-more 3y agoI had municipal broadband in a town I lived in and it was the same experience: you get the feeling that everyone involved really cared about it because it's our town, not just an account number somewhere.
- tshaddox 3y agoFor what it's worth, I have Frontier in Los Angeles County and I have the same positive experience, other than that my gigabit connection is $70/month (it's possible that's reasonable given overall cost of living differences).
- p1mrx 3y agoDo they provide an IPv4 address or CGNAT? An IPv6 prefix or sadface?
- beeburrt 3y agoI'm considering moving there. How are you liking it? How is the tech jobs market there?
- vineyardmike 3y ago
- taylorbuley 3y agoFor anyone who wishes this post was, in fact, about a plan by data guru William Cleveland, I'm with you.
- amiga386 3y agoIt's a post about Moses Cleveland, he's the guy who invented Cleveland YEAH! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ysmLA5TqbIY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ysmLA5TqbIY
- OnACoffeeBreak 3y agoI wish ARSTechnica would pick up this story and do a deep dive. They have done an amazing job keeping up with all of the shenanigans that incumbent telcos pulled in the case of the town/city of Wilson in North Carolina back in the day rolling out their Greenlight fiber muni broadband network: - https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2010/11/the-price-of-muni-broadband-eternal-war-with-time-warner-cable/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2010/11/the-price-of-mun... - https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2011/03/cable-backed-anti-muni-broadband-bill-advances-in-north-carolina/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2011/03/cable-backed-ant... - https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2015/02/fcc-overturns-state-laws-that-protect-isps-from-local-competition/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2015/02/fcc-o... - https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/09/muni-isp-forced-to-shut-off-fiber-to-the-home-internet-after-court-ruling/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/09/muni-... - https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/10/city-isp-makes-broadband-free-because-state-law-prohibits-selling-access/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/10/city-...
- doublerabbit 3y agoCool, goodluck.
- atdrummond 3y agoReally frustrating that this article focuses so much on the partisan attacks in the back half. When I lead the (successful) effort to build a city wide FTTH network in Quincy, IL, our most fervent supporters were all Republicans. We got far more support from the IL GOP than the IL Democratic Party. (The former helped us, at the federal level, secure additional funding for the local telco coop that runs Adams County’s fiber lines.) Despite this, I wouldn’t promote our success as the story of one party beating another and it really diminishes the hard work of people from both sides of the political divide.
- jrochkind1 3y agoI'd love it if Baltimore City could get it together. 90% of Baltimore has only one wired broadband provider, Cocmast -- who charges like 50% more for the same service than in markets with competition. (Some tiny portion of Baltimore has verizon fiber available. Some growing portion has the new T-mobile 5G wireless home internet; apparently not enough to get Comcast to reduce prices to what they charge in markets with competition)