5 ms·
But is it still the most attractive SBC at its price point?
by amelius 3y ago
But is it still the most attractive SBC at its price point?
- pizza234 3y agoI haven't checked, but Odroid are/were more competitive AFAIR (RPi's have a better software support, though).
- justin66 3y agoIf you aren't buying a thousand of them, how much does "price point" really matter to you?
- dividedbyzero 3y agoLots of people buy these on a finite hobby budget.
- justin66 3y agoIs there some missing context here, like "...and they only have ten dollars to spend on hobbies during the entirety of 2023 due to the famine wracking their homeland?" I mean, when you're talking about things (items in your "finite hobby budget") that cost less than a hundred dollars, why are you going to fuss about the "price point?" I am intrigued by how much this appears to matter to people who comment on Raspberry Pi threads. Hobbyists spent, at times, thousands or even tens of thousands of dollars on microcomputers in the eighties, and that was real money back then. Even the quaint ZX whatevers that were sold in Europe were, in inflation-adjusted terms, much more expensive than a Pi. Perhaps that's why I find these recurring concerns about how much an inexpensive SBC costs to be a bit baffling, particularly in the case of a hobbiest who is only buying one of them.
- lagniappe 3y agoThere exists life outside of the first world where that 10 dollars is worth more
- timthorn 3y agoIf you're a child not earning your own money, price point matters enormously. I remember rarely ordering electronic components from Maplin because of the P&P charge which was massive compared to my pocket money. Though I did get a buzz from my first CASHTEL order: https://worldradiohistory.com/UK/Mapelin/Maplin%20Electronics%201983-06.pdf https://worldradiohistory.com/UK/Mapelin/Maplin%20Electronic...
- justin66 3y agoSo my missing context as to why people obsess over price differences on the order of $20 when talking about single-board computers in Raspberry Pi-related comment threads is... they're thinking of the children?
- timthorn 3y agoThat's the market RPi was initially established for
- justin66 3y agoAnd there is a much more powerful Raspberry Pi (model 3) available at the original price point of the Raspberry Pi. Or others like the zero that are even cheaper, and still more capable in some ways. I'm not sure having a new one available that is quite a bit more powerful and costs $25 more is hurting those kids.
- peppercat10 3y agoInexpensive isn't a fixed value. A hobbyist can be someone able to splurge thousands on tech because they find it fun, but they may as well just be someone who only has 50€ at the end of the month and wants to tinker with a microcomputer they read about online.
- edgyquant 3y agoThis is such an out of touch comment. Not every, definitely not a majority, hobbyist spend thousands of dollars on their hobby. You sound like a rich kid who doesn’t understand $8 milk is expensive.
- justin66 3y agoNo one is suggesting people ought to spend thousands of dollars on their hobby. The point is that the difference between an $80 computer and a $120 computer (for example) is not going to break any hobbiest in 2023. I'm trying to figure out why anyone wants to pretend that that kind of difference is a big deal, and why it always manifests in Raspberry Pi conversations. It's weird. > edgyquant Haha.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoHaving been a teenager and broke college student, I can assure you that $40 does in fact matter to some hobbyists.
- justin66 3y agoWhen I was a broke college student I would have just not bought the top of the line system, which is what we're talking about here.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoI think there is actually a point in there; I mostly subsisted on used equipment that I could get dirt cheap back then. OTOH I'm not sure I want that to be the only option.
- dividedbyzero 3y ago> I mean, when you're talking about things (items in your "finite hobby budget") that cost less than a hundred dollars, why are you going to fuss about the "price point?" I am intrigued by how much this appears to matter to people who comment on Raspberry Pi threads. Usually an SBC is just one item on a project's part list. If I can get one that's equally suitable and 20 Euro less, that's another bunch of sensors, or another smart light, or a few additional PCBs, or a spool of filament, or another display, or other peripheral, or another filter for my photography kit. > Is there some missing context here, like "...and they only have ten dollars to spend on hobbies during the entirety of 2023 due to the famine wracking their homeland?" People in that kind of situation will probably not be looking at a Pi 5 for a hobby project. A lot of people are better off than that and still not in a place where a hundred dollars here and there isn't even worth thinking about. I try to limit hobby expenses because that allows me to have more projects and play with more things without cutting into anything more important. > Hobbyists spent, at times, thousands or even tens of thousands of dollars on microcomputers in the eighties, and that was real money back then. Even the quaint ZX whatevers that were sold in Europe were, in inflation-adjusted terms, much more expensive than a Pi. At least for the things I do, that's a wildly inaccurate comparison. A Pi is more like a drop-in part like an electrical component would have been back in the 80s, and most hobbyists would not have paid thousands for a specialized diode or the like, and most wouldn't have bought another personal computer for a new project. The closest analog to a proper computer back then would be my laptop, and I did pay "real money" for that. I don't buy Pis as standalone personal computing devices, they're for automation that I can't or don't want to fit on a microcontroller. Two Pi 4s are running Home Assistant deployments, another (zero W) is driving an e-ink info screen, one Pi 3-something sits inside a half-assembled robotics kit, I had another 3-something running OctoPrint until recently. If I had to pay "real money" for any of those, I'd just do without.
- justin66 3y agoAll fair points, in isolation. It's the overall gestalt of the cost-related conversation surrounding the Pi that I still don't understand. I appreciate you sharing your thoughts. (thanks for not mentioning that you could just buy a used PC on ebay for less, har har har)
- radiojosh 3y agoSome people really don't have a lot of disposable income. Are you saying we should just stop thinking about making products accessible to those people? You seem to think that these rich "hobbyists" make up the entire population, but I'd bet there were at least ten families in the US who couldn't afford a computer for every "hobbyist" that bought one. What a bunch of elitist gate-keeping nonsense. These low-cost SBCs are often viewed as a gateway product for introducing people to technology they wouldn't otherwise have access to - a system that could be a serviceable PC or launchpad for hobby electronics. The hobbyists you mention, apparently flush with cash and not a care in the world, aren't the people who need the price break. It's low income families with kids that need access to resources that might lead to a better future. Not to mention that a Raspberry Pi is an embeddable system. It might be a small part of a much larger project, so even a low price might be hard to justify. But no, let's keep making everything expensive so that computers and technology careers are only accessible to families that already have wealth. We, the Hobbyists of lore, can strut about the city square in our wearable devices and augmented reality headsets while the dirty street urchins scramble behind us, hoping for a fallen scrap, a loose semiconductor or relay they can take home to their families so they might afford little Timmy's leg surgery...
- justin66 3y ago> while the dirty street urchins scramble behind us, hoping for a fallen scrap, a loose semiconductor or relay they can take home to their families so they might afford little Timmy's leg surgery... While you've misunderstood my comment so badly I am worried you might have suffered a recent head injury, and I'm not getting any closer to understanding the quirkiness of people who comment on Raspberry Pi related threads which is what I was really shooting for, believe me: I respect the effort here.
- bluGill 3y agoAs a software guy I make far more than average. Yet in this past year I have looked at and rejected buying for my hobbies many $$$ worth of toys because I cannot afford it. Well I could, but my family vacation took priority (this could be considered part of the hobby budget). Most years the total cost of things I want for my hobbies exceeds my annual pre-tax income, but this year made an effort to not look and I still came close. At least as someone who makes a lot of money I have plenty of good food and a dry roof over my head. However that doesn't mean I have infinite money in the hobby budget.
- rtpg 3y agoI dunno, as a kid if there was a $40 or a $80 thing, I would get the $40 one (both would involve negotiating with parents anyways, and there's an obvious big gap here). $40 is a lot of money for teens without income (which is the case for most teenagers across the world outside of the US). Most kids get money maybe once or twice a year and have to spread it out, and then negotiate for other hobby-based purchases when they can. There's a reason forums are filled with people discussing how to maintain sub-$100 Thinkpads!
- michaelt 3y ago> If you aren't buying a thousand of them, how much does "price point" really matter to you? A lot of recreational tinkerers are already giving up their free time, and accepting a slightly inferior product to the commercial options. To also spend more would be a step too far :) Getting my 20-year-old mono laser printer network-enabled with $20 of hardware: Smart, e-waste-reducing move, even if it only supports 300dpi. Doing the same thing with $100 of hardware: Why waste the time, when a brand new mono laser would cost less, offer better print quality, and have built in wifi? Setting up a DIY networked camera with $50 of hardware: Fun little hobby project, maybe more secure than the sketchy cloud options and cheap imports that never get firmware updates. Doing the same thing with $130 of hardware: Just buy from Axis or Pelco or whoever. They'll have figured out the waterproofing, and the night vision, and the PoE, and nobody will call you a dumbass for buying the "wRoNg tYpE oF mIcRoSdcArD"
- poulpy123 3y agoOnly very rich people can say the price point doesn't matter for them. For normal people, buying something is always a matter of balancing alternatives, not even talking about poor people for which it is even more dire
- pulse7 3y agoIf the community is part of the price you pay, then yes...
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoSadly, yes. You can buy whatever else you want, even cheaper and better today, and after three years, getting a modern supported OS will be a total pain, due to binary blobs, custom drivers, custom "design solutions" etc. RaspberryPi is currently the only SBC where you can take any revision of it and still get fully working(! yes, even wifi, bluetooth, etc.) software for it, even if it's not the newest and the greatest model.
- _cenw 3y agox86 based SBCs being the notable exception, since you're very likely going to get an Intel CPU that's in the lineage to Atom (and now E-Cores)
- MrBuddyCasino 3y agoThe first gen Pi Zero W isn't really supported anymore due to the outdated ISA. But other than that, you're right.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoIt's my understanding that https://www.armbian.com/ https://www.armbian.com/ has quite broad hardware support, and there are boards from Orange Pi and Pine64 that boast actual mainline kernel support, so this is more a case of a fragmented ecosystem than there being zero competitors that can meet or exceed pis.
- megous 3y agoThis is just nonsense. There are plenty of old (6-7 year old boards) very well supported in Linux. I've been using several such boards for that long. If anything, support gets better with time, usually.
- LeafItAlone 3y agoWhich SBCs are you referring to?
- megous 3y ago
- dtx1 3y agoYou have 3 choices: 1. Raspberry Pi 2. X86 System 3. Barely functioning SOCs with no mainline support and major software issues until eternity.
- imtringued 3y agoYeah. Just go with x86. If you like adventures go with the Raspberry Pi. If all you need is the cheapest CPU, then enjoy messing around with obsolete kernels I guess.
- dividedbyzero 3y agoI believe the Pi is also pretty much the only sensible choice for GPIO support on Linux.
- dividedbyzero 3y agoThere are so many subtly different smallish x86 systems though that finding one that's cheap, power-efficient, fast, extensible, reasonably quiet and well supported on Linux is pretty difficult. At least to me.
- dboreham 3y agoI have a bunch of these systems from the past few years related to my work building self-hosted decentralized systems. Most recent is this: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0BVLS7ZHP https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0BVLS7ZHP and so far it's working well. I'm running Ubuntu 22 and I have the stock internal SSD plus an externally attached 2T M.2 NVMe drive (via USB3.2 and this: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08RVC6F9Y https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08RVC6F9Y).
- glimshe 3y agox86 has the best cost/benefit nowadays, especially for server/desktop applications. Just a random example from Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/KAMRUI-Computer-Computers-Business-Recreation/dp/B0C6CYZL4J https://www.amazon.com/KAMRUI-Computer-Computers-Business-Re...
- 3y ago
- mschuster91 3y agoYes, I'd say that - RPi is, through its moat, the only player in town where you as an user (hobbyist, corporate, ODM) can be assured that there's reasonable build quality, availability of parts, and especially the tooling around it.
- bhouston 3y agoOrange PI 5 Plus is faster (10% faster single threaded, 200% faster multicore per Geekbench) and also supports up to 32GB of memory. It has decent support, but not anything like the Raspberry Pi ecosystem. So if you want a SBC that is fast for special well defined projects, go with Orange PI 5 Plus, but if you want one for arbitrary hobby projects with tons of support everywhere, go with the Raspberry Pi series.
- Havoc 3y agoI’ve never seen a 32gb for sale?
- bhouston 3y agoThey are available for pre-order via the official Orange Pi store on AliExpress right now, slated to ship in November. I know since I was about to pull the trigger on this one: https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005006119813607.html https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005006119813607.html
- eropple 3y agoI have both two OPi5's and an OPi5 Plus, and honestly? It's not a problem. Armbian support's there and is emphatically Good Enough for the 90%+ case. They're excellent boards. If you want to talk about bad support, let's talk about something like the NanoPi R5 series. Oof.
- rjsw 3y agoWhat is wrong with NanoPi? I was thinking of getting an R6C to use for RK3588 development.
- eropple 3y agoThe vendor OS is clunky and weird, Armbian doesn't have support (for the R5C at least), it doesn't have NVMe support (only a wireless m.2), flashing the eMMC is really weird...I wouldn't buy another NanoPi. I quite like the Orange Pi 5's for RK3588 boards though.
- contrarian1234 3y agoLibreComputer boards are some of the best supported ones that just run standards Debian/Ubuntu ARM builds
- esskay 3y agoTechnically yes but in most cases you dont need an sbc. An old Lenovo Thinkcentre or Dell OptiPlex Micro can end up being cheaper by the time you add all the additional expenses onto the pi (storage, power, case, etc). The micropc's are also infinately better performing and are upgradable.
- DrammBA 3y agoWhat about energy usage for the next few years?
- doubled112 3y agoHow much does a Raspberry Pi 4/5 use with some sort of external storage running? How much does one cost once you factor in a case, cooling, storage, and a power supply? I paid $195 NEW for a Beelink S12 Mini with 16GB RAM, 500GB NVMe, and an Intel N95 CPU I believe it is said to idle at about 8W. It's a powerful enough machine you could run a bunch of small VMs on it, assuming your workload didn't involve GPIO or other hardware things. I rolled a handful of RPis into VMs on one Orange Pi 5 because it has memory to do so and I wasn't using anything Pi specific.
- poulpy123 3y agoon their website the cheapest lenovo is 500€ and the cheapest dell is 600€ while a kit R5 is 150€, not at all the same price
- esskay 3y agoYeah I'm not referring to new ones. Ebay. Dirt cheap and even the ones several generations old are very power efficient and vastly outperform the pi on both performance and cost.